10 Best American Restaurants in Madison

“First time trying out this quaint little cafe’ and I can’t say enough about our experience. It was great. Tommy, our gentleman of a waiter, was excellent. He was attentive, funny, & personable. The food was fantastic! GET! THE! FRIED! TOMATOES! Soooo yum!“

“I have always loved Jason's Deli and I was saddened when the Ridgeland location closed. Lately when I am in the area, I frequent the Jason's Deli location in Madison and each encounter has been a pleasant one. The manager..James...is always hospitable and accommodating. I am so glad Jason's Deli has returned! Good food and customer service.“

“Love it , definitely will be returning 🥰🥰“

“I had heard that the mermaid cafe was a nice little restaurant for the Lake Caroline neighborhood where you could get a nice hamburger. I was pleasantly surprised at my culinary experience. I had some of the best red fish that I have ever had and my friend said the same about the fillet. The only thing that exceeded the food was the courtesy from the staff. Highly recommend it“

“Definitely recommend...this place is awesome!“

“On line website needs to be updated. Veggies on line not same as in restaurant. Would have done phone order differently if known daily available veggies. Was told no more creamed spinach which was listed and no more squash casserole, used to be favorite all the time! Phone order cornbread got rolls. One hamburger steak everything as listed other nothing but gravy. Was given very generous gift card to use !“

“Dickeys has a variety of different bbq options and free ice cream with your meal. They are at their best every bit of ok. I generally the few times I dealt with Dickeys was having them out of a pure wish for bbq on a bbq holiday but unfortunately I had to work so we decided to get Dickeys as they were the only bbq place nearby and open. I can say truthfully though the bbq was not terrible it was not great either as a matter of fact I'll say the ice cream was the best part of the meal. Prices are acceptable. Atmosphere is okay and customer service was good.“

“Great experience- the food is always pretty good there. Very rarely do they get it wrong. The service is always great! Chef's kiss to our server Gloria. I tried the O-M-Gosh cheeseburger. Great concept. I enjoyed it. However, the fries were not so good. If you've ever tried to reheat fries in a microwave, that's how they were. Not fresh - kind of cardboard feel. I think it's because the fries are cooking twice. Once originally and a second time on the hot skillet with the cheese. Next time I will request my fries on a separate plate.“

“It was nice for I and my wife and baby to get out. Service was good , food not bad but I've had better at other Chili's locations. The bluemoon beer was going bad , was barely drinkable with the orange slice. Bluemoon gets sour the older it gets. It's just not cheap to eat out these days. 1 beer , 1 appetizer , 1 trio fajitas $48 before tip. Also if you do go out to eat here , make sure to tip at least 15% or more. They only get paid $2.13/hour which is crazy.“

“I gave 5 stars for Ms.Abby at the entrance, I was greeted and thanked for my patience. She was very professional and held a smile that lights up a dark room. I was coming in for a pick up order, and I watched her greet customers in a timely manner with grace and kindness. The young lady behind the bar was kind also, a little overwhelmed it seems. But I’m all for giving grace when days are a bit hectic.“