18 Best Ice Cream Shops in Cary

“best ice cream I've ever had in my life. no kidding, it is that good!!!!!!“

“Kulfi milk tea are amazing ! A must try !“

“owners were very welcoming and friendly to us out of staters. He let us tate a sample prior to making our selections. I highly recommend.“

“First time visit and it was great. Different flavors of milkshakes and I wanted to try the new pumpkin pie shake. That first sip was phenomenal. Tasted like a solid pumpkin pie slice, but after getting halfway thru, there was something that was very overpowering. Almost as if it went from pumpkin pie to ginger snaps. Which isn’t bad, but I’m more of a pumpkin pie guy. Staff was friendly and engaging. And the strawberry shortcake sundae…great! Fresh strawberries, pieces of fluffy cake and ice cream. Would definitely head back.“

“This place is an absolute hidden gem! I was curious how Indian ice cream, boba, and pizza could all exist under one roof — but somehow they pull it off perfectly.

The Indian ice cream (kulfi) is rich, creamy, and full of authentic flavor — I tried the pistachio and mango, and both tasted just like the ones I’ve had in India. You can tell they use real ingredients and not artificial syrupy stuff.

The boba tea is also top-tier — chewy pearls, not too sweet, and a great selection of both classic and creative flavors. I got a rose chai milk tea with brown sugar boba and it blew my mind.

And the pizza? Surprisingly amazing. The paneer tikka pizza is next-level — the crust is perfectly crispy and they’re generous with toppings. It’s not your usual pizza spot — it’s got personality and flavor.

The place is clean, the staff is super friendly, and the menu is full of cool surprises. Whether you’re in the mood for something savory, sweet, or refreshing, you’ll find something to love here.

Highly recommend — I’ll definitely be back (probably too often 😅)!“

“best ice cream I've ever had in my life. no kidding, it is that good!!!!!!“

“This place has the best ice cream. Unfortunately, it does not have the best employees. Every single time I’ve been there in the last two years, my order has been wrong. Stopped by and ordered two sundaes tonight. Both of them had the wrong flavors in them. Like, not even close. We ended up throwing them away. Was going to complain but the kid that made them was running the register so I figured what’s the point. So, great ice cream when you get what you order. I’ve kind of forgotten what that’s like but I’m still recommending them.“

“We've been going since they first opened. We got to know the owner and are so happy for the success of the business. Not only is the service top notch, but the variety of flavors and quality of offerings are out of this world! Definitely a must for your dessert list!!!“

“first time trying goodberrys -- everyone was super friendly! i got the almond delight sundae. it was delicious, super cold despite the heat, and overall wonderful. not too sweet. parking is a bit of a beast if you're unfamiliar and in a larger vehicle; but relatively easy.“

“Ordered a drink that came out wrong, explained it so I could order something different as it wasn't tasting right at all. Still get charged for the old drink, infact my drink points I redeemed didn't even get accounted for. Terrible service. They won't remake your drink either, even if it's clearly wrong. don't recommend cary location its only gotten worse.“

“Without a doubt, FentonNC, made the area safer, more enjoyable, and great for the community.“

“Highly Recommend For Any Sweet Tooth Fix! Have been a patron since they opened! Favorite Flavor: Strawberry Butter Favorite Rolled Ice Cream: Bannana, Peanut Butter, Chocolate Syrup with whipped cream and cherries“

“Yes I recommend this Dunkin' Donuts and Baskin-Robbins. Many years ago I used to work in Cary and I came here a lot the service was wonderful then too! I drove here twice today from Durham. To get a special coffee that I like. I couldn't get it in Morrisville and two Dunkin' Donuts in Durham. I think this is a bigger and more popular location because they're always busy. The staff is very friendly and kind and even though this is not anywhere near my house it's worth the trip out there and I'm trying to work it into my daily routine. They get my order correct too everytime.I had two wonderful service experiences today and I plan to go back many more times. This location has never disappointed me past or present. Thank you!!!“

“There is always a good selection of flavors with some new flavors rotated in periodically. There is also a rich assortment of toppings available. The frozen yogurt is self serve unless you buy some pre-packaged cups out of the freezer. The toppings are not self serve. There are not a lot of tables inside though they have never been full when I was there. There are additional tables outside but no shade and they overlook the parking lot.“

“I’m not sure where everyone gets their prices from because I can usually fill my cup up above the top and the price will be $10-$12. Anyways the froyo tastes delicious and there’s a good amount of toppings, although I usually don’t get any because the froyo is enough. The staff is very friendly and attentive despite it being self serve. Great place, even in the winter!“

“1st time - fast and tasty“

“This was some of the best frozen custard I have ever had! The service was also amazing, especially Shane who took our order! He was kind, helpful, funny, and patient. The prices were not too expensive, the quality was impeccable, and the cleanliness and service were top notch. Definitely recommend getting a sweet treat here!“

“I did not think anything could beat Goodberrys until I went to Kilwins. Best ice cream I ever had. The store feels very fresh and clean. The server was a little off: attractive 20-something, clearly intelligent, probably under-employed, autism spectrum?, but she did thank me.“