16 Best Pizza Restaurants near Nags Head

“BEST GF/DF pizza I have ever had, amazing and now I want to move here just for the pizza!“

“5 out of 5 STARS….. We are here on Vacation and have ordered from Pizzazz 3 days out of the 4 days. Pizza was amazing and the sub and salad was also excellent. Will eat here again next visit to Nags Head“

“🍕⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️great pizza and service“

“Great pizza and great service!“

“The best cheesesteak I’ve had in Nags Head! Pizza is delicious too“

“Dare Friendz (Outer Banks Autism Society) absolutely loved the delicious pizza we got from Cosmo’s today! The girl out the counter was SO sweet too!! Thanks Cosmo’s Crew! ❤️“

“I have had pizza here two times on my stay in Kill Devil Hills. Outstanding online ordering, very efficient/quick preparation, extremely friendly staff, and great gluten free pizza !“

“From a Hometown Hotspot to a Nags Head knockout! If you're looking for a place with the freshest pizza around, look no further! Fresh dough made daily with the love and excellence we all look for! Gluten-free options to fit our dietary needs! They also have wings, mozzarella sticks, subs, and much more! I have not tried the subs yet, but I'll definitely be back! They have awesome weekly specials, extraordinary management, wait staff, and a super clean establishment. If you are in town and love the menu options, check them out, you will not be disappointed! Ask for Cheyenne, she's one of the managers , makes a mean pizza, and the sweetest person there! Thank you guys for the wonderful experience! Good Job!“

“Best cheese steak on the beach.“

“Great pizza but they weren’t great about calling names after the food was done. So our food sat ready in the hot box while we waited for 30 minutes. After telling us ready in 10. They were busy and moving constantly and the new young lady employee seemed to go above and beyond to help every area of the store. But yeah having to wait for food that was ready in the box was not ideal especially if you’re calling ahead in a hurry. Otherwise they are always busy and over worked so I get it.“

“Had their pizza delivered to our hotel in Kill Devil Hills after a long day of traveling 7-25-25. I have had a lot of different pizza in my life, let me tell ya, that was one of the best, if not the best. Their delivery guy was super nice and funny. A great experience“

“Straight from the pizza palaces of yesteryear is Garden Deli & Pizzaria. Delicious pizza, great wings, and perfect mozzarella sticks are a plenty here. There is also a sweet black cat outside; a sign of the kind and skilled people who operate the establishment.“

“Delicious pizza and the salads are the best!!! The best service ♥️“

“We were looking for pizza close to where we were staying, and this was it!! It was so good! The crust was crispy on the bottom, super soft on the inside. The sauce and toppings were also a hit. So so so good!“

“I want to commend the staff and management. Tonight I sat for a while waiting for my pizza and although it had been a very long day and it seemed like I constantly was being held up trying to get home, these workers were great. They were very friendly and kept their composure like they always do when I am in there and witness the impatient and rude behavior of others. Especially a group that seemed to think that just because there was 1 table there that it meant it was a sit down restaurant that should have been at their beck and call. Clearly allot of people get pizza there every night so it is hard to keep their warmer full. Personally I prefer getting it nice and hot:) Even with the rude mutterings not so quietly thrown their way they remained friendly and were constantly working and pleasant. So yet again I commend them and I am thankful for the military service of the owner and am glad they are able to post it proudly on their window.“