50 Best Ice Cream Shops near Belmar

“Can’t give 5 stars due to the subpar service and god awful ownership. Otherwise, this location is the only one worth visiting. The “lighthouse” ones are more like water ice. I highly recommend the peanut butter if they have it. Some flavors run out fast. Coconut hasn’t been on the menu in years since before they moved across the street. I can’t answer why and wouldn’t bother to ask. Amazing ice, cheap, but sadly cash only. The staff really could be better. The phone also never gets picked up to confirm hours. It’s all about luck and not confirmation they’re open.“

“I loved this place, it's a cute little shop with so many options. I got the salted caramel pretzel with cookie dough and it was delicious. The cookie dough was so soft, and very generously placed. The ice cream had the perfect amount of caramel, and the pretzels in it were such a nice touch. It really enhanced the flavor of the ice cream, and they were even covered in chocolate. The staff was also nice, and not greedy with the amount of ice cream they gave me. Overall it was one of the best ice creams I've ever had, and if you are in the area you HAVE to try it out.“

“It’s by Belmar Marina and across the street from the Windmill for burgers, hotdogs, chicken, and Ribeye Steak Sandwiches Dessert? DAIRY QUEEN can handle anything and save you dollars and cents to Boot!!!“

“Great place with a great view. The staff was friendly, the food was excellent and the shakes were the best!!“

“The Apple Pie Ice Cream was the best ìce cream I have ever tasted.“

“My boyfriend picked up my ice cream cake last weekend (March 2nd) and the cake was AMaZINg! It came out better than expected. The cake decorator did an incredible job at making his idea come to life! It was vanilla, with chocolate peanut butter and chocolate drizzled on the side. It tasted delicious! We will be back for future cakes. Thank you!“

“It is a fun place for some frozen yogurt.“

“You cannot complete the beach visit to OG without a treat at Days-the only problem will be what to have many creative and tried and true choices-soft serve custardy and tasty, hard ice cream fresh and varied for any fan of a true old fashioned ice cream stand-,simply the best“

“I don't...lousy service...manager that calls customers names....when she made the mistake. Unprofessional. WILL NOT GO THERE AGAIN!“

“The ice cream was very good!! Will be definitely going back!“

“I absolutely love this place!! and jasmine is the best her energy is so inviting and fun! Def will recommend this place to everyone!!!“

“I drive up every year from Florida to visit family .One of the must visit places is Hoffman's ! I look foward to seeing the looks on my grandchildrens face eating your fantastic ice creams thanks again. John very nice remodel on your shop !“

“So many years coming to the shore and tonight was our first time! Crazy :) The place was hopping, lots of people, families, kids getting a treat! Everyone working there was so nice! Super helpful and kept their cool. The line moved quickly. Flavors/toppings and specials are listed on black boards. Several people came to get icecream cakes!
Servings were generous.
Accessible ♿️ with plenty of parking. No place to side indoors, but there are benches outside.“

“Just visited Sweet N Joe and will definitely be returning. Yummy ice cream.“

“One of the best Ice Cream shops around. Great flavors that you can tell are homemade. They have a good variety of classic flavors and unique ones too. This location gets busy at certain times of the day so be prepared to wait. There's no real indoor seating either but plenty of parking.“

“Now this is a way better and more AWESOME!!! ice cream truck service, safety updated with an electric swing arm stop sign like on school buses which is extremely AWESOME , safe, clear, and recognizable because octagon means STOP whereas sideways trapezoid with rounded corners on the wide end and pointed corners on the narrow end means SLOW unlike some other ice cream truck services that still have the bad old outdated red trapezoid children slow crossing warning blades that word IF-SAFE STOP THEN-GO which is confusing.“

“Whenever we come to the beach (1.5-2 hrs away from us) this ice cream shop is a MUST. Our trip isn’t complete until we stop at Beach Plum. They have nice variety of ice cream, affordable prices, sweet employees. Have been craving it all winter but unfortunately they’re closed for the season I believe. Chocoholic is my personal fave flavor :). It is Cash only but there’s a Chase bank across the street.“

“We loved our ice cream sandwiches! Everything was delicious, portions big and prices fair“

“Best ice cream of the summer.“

“Great ice cream. Great variety.“

“Great experience!“

“Great custom made cake! Highly recommend! ❤️“

“Thank you so much. Monday September 13. I was driving by and a friend ( battling Cancer) had said how good root beer ice was. I asked at the counter and a very nice young woman said I just but the last in a cup in the freezer. I know she probably wanted it. But she gave it to me. Thank you so much. In haste I did not tip. I drive by I’ll be back Thank you so much. Love jersey shore help out attitude“

“These Frozen delicases are clearly a quality product. They are refreshing, and full of flavor. There are many varieties to choose from; one is sure to hit the spot no matter what mood you're in. Treat yourself once; and you'll be back for more!“

“Always yummy & of course we love the lighthouse shaped building!“

“Always yummy & of course we love the lighthouse shaped building!“

“I don’t remember the names of the ice creams we got… a Bourbon Coffee one and a Peanut Butter with Oreo (I mean, come on, that’s a dream combination). The ice cream was so dense and absurdly decadent. I have half a mind to go back a second time before we head home!“

“We have been going here for years and today for the first time the owner allowed my daughter to serve her own soft serve ! There was no one in the store so it was a friendly gesture he offered and it truly made her entire day. Thank you yellow brick for always being amazing !!“

“We only love two ice cream places. Sundaes is one of them. Great product and service always.“

“We only love two ice cream places. Sundaes is one of them. Great product and service always.“

“The Wayside students LOVED the Italian Ice from Bellalicious on Field Day! The staff was amazing, quick to respond and made the kids day extra special. Thanks so much!!“

“Best Carvel around!“

“My daughter and I absolutely love Rita's. Specifically this location. All the Employees that work here are always kind and always smiling. The owners son Michael is a great guy and boss from what I see and hear. Allways treating his Employees with respect and kindness.“

“So I have done fasting before, usually once a year for 3-6 days. So I'm used to going without food but this seemed to give me the same benefits and I didn't get hangry :) I combined my juice cleanse with my brand of CBD (Raw Botanics) and found that this greatly enhanced my experience. The CBD cut down on the anxiety of going without food, helped with my sleep which was an issue and I believe helped in the overall detox. I would 100% recommend Raw Generation paired with CBD. I did the cleanse by the book no food with the exception of 1 avocado on the first night. I cut out all other supplements and vitamins for the week. I did exercise but pretty lightly. Most of the weight for me came off on the first 3 days and it seemed to plateau by day 5. So next time I do this I may just do a 3 or 5 day. My total weight loss was 10 pounds and that was the goal. Once I went back to regular food 4 pounds came right back on but after a few weeks now I'm still better than before I did the cleanse. I plan to do a cleanse like this at least a few times a year. Other benefits I had was improved complexion, energy, and digestion, and my joint pain completely went away. Raw Generation is 100% worth the money.“

“I can't say enough good things about this place. First of all, the ice cream is homemade. I had a sundae made with 3 flavors of ice cream: tequila, coconut, and cheese (queso blanco). They have unique offerings (elote) and very creative concoctions (fruit with spicy chips). The owners were extremely friendly, gave us multiple samples without us even asking, and offered recommendations. The store was very clean and they were masked the whole time. The prices were reasonable and the quality was outstanding. I will happily return and probably make special trips to Bradley Beach just to visit this beautiful family-owned store again. Me encanta este lugar. Primero, todos los helados son hecho en casa. Tuve un sundae con 3 sabores de helado: tequila, coco, y queso blanco. Se tenga ofrendas únicas (elote) y concociones creativos (fruta con chips picantes). Los propietarios fueron extremadamente amables, nos dieron varias muestras sin siquiera pedirnos y nos ofrecieron recomendaciones. La tienda estaba muy limpia y estaban enmascarados todo el tiempo. Los precios eran razonables y la calidad excepcional. Volveré felizmente y probablemente hacer viajes en particular a Bradley Beach sólo para visitar esta hermosa tienda familiar otra vez.“

“The best employees and Louis thinks the vanilla custard is the tops!“

“The ice cream was delicious!!!“

“Walk up ice cream shop. So much to choose from. And vegan ice cream. I chose raspberry chip in a kids cup. Vegan, Very good. We’ve been here a few time. You must go. My friend had a monster mint. I think it’s called. Mint ice cream with huge chips.

Vegetarian options: Vegan options“

“The Ritas Italian ice in Neptune, New Jersey is on my way home from my gym. I visited for the first time after grueling workout not expecting much. I was honestly floored by the customer service experience I received and how well the team seem to gel together. One employee, Desiree, whose name I asked for specifically for this review, was particularly adapt to handling large orders and tedious requests coming from customers, Myself included. Despite the calamity of a busy summer, high traffic, ice cream shop, Desiree as well as the rest of the team Remain poised and courteous to all of the customers who were at the store. Yes, ice cream was good, but the customer service was better.“

“When visiting Ocean Grove, the Victorian Grill has come to my rescue more than once, as it's hard to find good eating places in the area that are open in September when I vacation in Ocean Grove. Lisa greeted me the second I walked in and was so accommodating and patient while I selected my choices. Tom the owner, is very congenial as well. Ordered a veggie burger, Madagascar vanilla gelato, plus a turkey club to go, to keep in my hotel fridge for dinner later. All were superb! You have a choice of indoor or outdoor dining. You won't regret giving this establishment a try!“

“On Sunday we stopped in to pick-up something to take over to my brother and sister in-laws house for dessert. What's better than Carvel. There was so much to choose from it all looked so good!!! I can remember as a kid Carvel commercials how can you forget Cookie Puss. After a long time on making a decision we chose the ice cream sandwiches Yummy. Upon arriving we told my brother in-law we got ice cream sandwiches his serious reply was he never meant a ice cream sandwich he didn't like. They were absolutely deliciousI want to say the woman running the shop was very professional and pleasant. She was extremely helpful and I would definitely recommend this location.“

“This is my absolute favorite place in Asbury. The shaved ice texture and flavors are delicious as well as the ice pops. I usually bring a cooler and take some home as well. The flavors are so fruity and fresh, I always stop by when I’m in the area. Great fair prices too.“

“i loved this place! i got an extra small coffee w chocolate sprinkles in a waffle cone and it was the best treat after a long day at the beach. the sprinkles were my favorite part - they’re smaller and crunchier than regular sprinkles and they seemed tastier too. will 100% be back next time we’re at the beach!“

“It was an amazing place , i always feel like home when i visit their shop, ice creams are out of this world, i had a chance to try ice creams in all of the Europe but this place just does it right , i would definitely recommend for both kids and adults“

“If I miraculously have any room left over after gorging myself at a nearby Asbury restaurant, this is always a stop. The ice cream is delicious, the flavors offered are varied/unique, and the additional products are excellent too. I'm very much a cup person when it comes to ice cream (I don't like the experience being marred by constant vigilance/paranoia over whether the ice cream is about to melt from the cone to my paw), but this is the one place I'm willing to go with the cone, both for superficial optics and because they're genuinely tasty. I had a Hawaiian Punch-flavored cone a few years ago I still think about from time to time.I stopped by this past Saturday afternoon with the Millennial Chum, on a toasty summer day that was absolutely teeming with people all over the beach and boardwalk. If you'd asked me to guess beforehand, I would have estimated this place would have a line out the door, but we got lucky - I'd say there were maybe three or four people in front of us, and (this part isn't luck) the line moved very quickly and efficiently. While we waited the two minutes or so to order, I gave the merch section to the side a hard look - there are some VERY legit-looking hoodies for sale that are only about $30 or $35 and would easily retail for twice that at a different establishment. I might come back for one.On this particular day, I went with a small cup (two scoops) of the birthday cake ice cream, and I THINK something Oreo/cookie related, which unfortunately I can't definitively confirm because it's conveniently hidden on top of the birthday cake in the accompanying picture. Both were excellent. I've mentioned this many times in prior ice cream reviews, but as long as it's a decent flavor and it's not freezer burned, it's hard for me to give anything other than a full-throated endorsement of it. The servings are huge too - the small is not particularly small, and the much better-behaved Millennial Chum actually went with a kiddie cup in the end.Definitely worth a stop if you have the time and appetite.“

“My kids & I luv the variety of tea drinks, shakes & wraps. We go there all the time since they’ve opened & never a complaint. The staff is awesome! Gina, Bella, Aggie & all of them are just great �“

“Such a cute friendly shop with amazing gelato and yummy assorted baked goods 10/10 will definitely be going back. Can’t wait“

“Plenty of seats available. Order kiosks available if you want to take your time to customize your order, but the counter service is friendly enough to get what you need. The açaí bowls were very delicious, and the Greek yogurt was a nice touch.Almost 20$ a bowl, but worth it as a treat for sure.“

“A great place for a delicious cocktail with an extra special personalization!“

“Thank you so much Kelly and Chrissy for a delicious cake! Not one piece is left! Creamy ice cream and awesome crunchies!!!“