11 Best Italian Restaurants in Caldwell

“The best thin Sicilian pizza I have ever had in my 56 years of life. Recommended 100%.“

“Beautiful authentic Ristorante - Don't pass this place up, Reserve your table - BYOB - Chef / Owner Mario is proud and honored to have you as his guest - Hostes Linda, waiter Franco - warm, knowledgeable & welcoming - Food is expertly prepared - fine ingredients - delicious - I honestly never had a better pasta with marinara sauce - Eggplant Parm is 5 Star - my Bronzino was suculent, tasty & cooked to perfection - Gelato topped it off to much better than 5 Stars..“

“There’s a consistency to Casa Nostra Bistro that’s increasingly rare—every visit feels deliberate, not accidental. The food is thoughtful without being overworked, rooted in classic Italian flavors but executed with a level of care that shows in each dish. Service strikes the right balance: attentive, knowledgeable, and never intrusive. And the atmosphere manages to feel both polished and genuinely comfortable, which is harder to achieve than it looks.

It’s the kind of place you return to not out of habit, but because it reliably delivers. Looking forward to going back.“

“been coming here since 2008. great food and atmosphere.“

“We had a 40th Birthday Party in the private room on Saturday night. It was absolutely fantastic. The room is beautiful ,they had it set up as we discussed. The service was exemplary. FOOD was amazing. We have been enjoying Forte since they opened. I would highly recommend this venue for any private party.“

“Amazing cookies and pastries... delicious cakes but for some reason the 3 cupcakes I purchased today did not taste as fresh as they normally do... not sure why, it was unusual but I forgive them!
You really can't go wrong here, yes they are more expensive than the other guys but you cannot beat the quality.“

“Excellent food as always. Sangria is one of our favorites. Love the homemade meatballs. Also one of our favorites. Afterwards, we ALWAYS visit the bakery for amazing pastries. Always look forward to visiting our favorite place. Glad it's so close to home!!!!!!“

“Great food and customer service“

“The man is an artist. The thin, thin pie .👍“

“Wonderful customer service and the FOOD, wow it is absolutely amazing. From pizza to salads, hummus to gyros, fat sandwiches and everything in between.. there is not one item that isn't good. Owner is very nice and accommodating as well - 5 stars plus!“

“What an incredible experience! We chose Calandra’s Italian Village to create our wedding cake after receiving a recommendation from a friend, and from the very beginning, they exceeded every expectation.

The moment we visited for our cake tasting, we were absolutely blown away. The selection was delicious and beautifully presented — it truly felt like an experience in itself. From there, we continued to be impressed by every aspect of Calandra’s Italian Village bakery, deli, and pizza.

Every visit was met with warm smiles and outstanding hospitality, and we especially want to thank Chef Henry, who kept us coming back time and time again for his amazing breakfast and lunch sandwiches — including the delicious lunch we enjoyed before the wedding festivities began.

The quality of the food is exceptional, the atmosphere is warm and inviting, and the staff genuinely makes you feel like family. We are so grateful to the entire team for being part of such a special time in our lives. We could not recommend Calandra’s Italian Village more highly!“