50 Best Italian Restaurants near Cinnaminson

“Georgettis catering made our party easy and amazing!!!“

“Went there with 2 of my friends for dinner the other night. We’ve never been there before, but have heard great things. Dinner was delicious, large portions, excellent server, and great atmosphere. Definitely will be back!!!“

“Best pizza around and the owners is Great“

“Everytime the taste and flavor is the same .never changes. The taste is unbelievably mouth watering. Wonderful. We couldn't find any good pizza for about 15 20 years then we moved from Philly to cinnaminson. OMG. FINNALLY We never order from anyone else. Just brick oven in cinnaminson. From 2008 and still today. Highly recomended.“

“I know some ppl have mixed fillings about this place since new owners but thier Mother's Day specials looked awesome...we had one and it was AMAZING 👌“

“Great food and even better customer service . Every thing we have ordered from them has been delicious . Great portions and great ratio with ingredients .“

“Primo is my family's #1 choice for superb, delicious hoagies- especially your Italian hoagie. The meats are fresh, the veggies are fresh, the rolls are always soft and the hoagie, itself, it is not assembled haphazardly. The potato salad is awesome- not overly-drenched in mayonnaise. I recommend Primo Hoagies for good eating.Adina“

“great pizza and decent pricing. whole family loves this place one of the best around“

“Pat’s has been a staple for our house for years. The #1 pick for both my wife and I are the Wally salads. I’m not a huge salad person but I would choose this any day. Everything tastes fresh.

The Chipotle chicken flatbread is also really great. That chipotle sauce drizzled over it takes it to the next level.

They also have great wraps. My favorite are the Southwest Chicken wrap and the Caesar Chicken Wrap.

I definitely don’t want to end this without mentioning their house-made chips. My wife and I had loved them since we started ordering and we’re excited that they’re finally available as a separate side.“

“This was one of our most memorable dinners of 2025 so far — everything we ordered was delicious.

We started with the marinated tomatoes with stracciatella and the focaccia, then had the Thai basil tagliatelle with crab and the breaded pork chop as mains, and finished with the corn brûlée and blueberry pâte à choux for dessert.

The marinated tomatoes with the focaccia were an excellent pairing, and the tagliatelle was a surprisingly delightful fusion — spicy, flavorful, and very well balanced. The pork chop was excellent too: juicy and flavorful, though slightly undercooked near the bone. The corn brûlée was fantastic, while the pâte à choux was the only dish that didn’t quite hit the mark.

Overall, the food was outstanding and the space was very cozy. Our only wish was for slightly better ventilation in the restaurant, but otherwise, it was an amazing dining experience.“

“Bravo! Dinner was delicious. This place is a gem.“

“We held an 80th birthday party at Verona. The service was top notch and owners beyond accommodating. The guests said they want to come back! The clams casino is my favorite. The outdoor seating is great.“

“This place was a true dining experience! The staff to the chefs was truly amazing. I recommend the tasting menu, it allows you to understand the authenticity and story of Tulip Pasta & Wine Bar through their food. My boyfriend and I enjoyed ourselves so much we plan to take our moms to experience the same enjoyment we did. Can’t wait to be back“

“My family had dinner at Albertinos today for my mom and husbands birthday. Because there was 9 of us they require a fix price meal for each person. This price includes an app, main, and dessert - anything on the menu. The service here is outstanding. The food is better than anywhere else in town, and for me- the best Italian I have ever had. Dinner for 9 of us took about three hours. To me, this is amazing. There was no rush. They made sure everything was perfect. We were able to relax and enjoy our time. We have been there two other times and have had the same waitress. The daughter of the owner (Jsut another plus). She is bubbly and kind and makes sure everyone has a great time. Thank you for a great evening.“

“Café Carmela is one of those places that just gets it right. From the moment we walked in, it felt comfortable and welcoming, the kind of spot where you can relax and actually enjoy your meal without feeling rushed.

Everything we ordered was so good. The meatballs were amazing — tender, flavorful, and clearly homemade. And the sauce!!! Soooo good!! The eggplant parmigiano was comforting in the best way, perfectly cooked and full of flavor without being heavy. And the Don Cheech cheesesteak was honestly outstanding. Packed with flavor, cooked just right, and easily one of the best cheesesteaks we’ve had in a long time.

And of course, every place must have fries and they do. Crunchy, hot, and exactly what you want alongside a great sandwich.

What really stood out, though, was how kind and helpful the staff was. Everyone was friendly, patient and made great recommendations, and made the whole experience feel easy and relaxed.

The atmosphere is cozy and laid-back, making it a great place to enjoy a casual meal, or just sit and enjoy really good food. Nothing feels overdone or pretentious — it’s simply a place that serves great food and treats people well. Oh and we live the decor and interesting signs. Feels like a throw back to a different time.

Café Carmela is definitely a spot we’ll keep coming back to. It’s the kind of place you’re happy to have in your neighborhood and excited to recommend to others. Definitely worth it. Check them out!“

“Fantastic dining experience our server Sean Martin was amazing.“

“Lovely atmosphere, very good food and our Waiter Nick was wonderful!“

“Excellent food & service , been here many times, Love it ❤️👍“

“Highly recommend this local Fishtown family owned establishment. The grocery selection is fabulously curated and don’t get me started on the hoagies 🤤🤤🤤🤤🤤🤤. Love to love this place. All the vibes. ♥️✌️“

“We had our son’s rehearsal dinner here, everything was great . We Had Taylor , who did everything, she was by herself, due to someone calling out . She severed over 30 people from Appetizers to dessert all with a smile . She helped set everything up and was amazing . Great food and atmosphere! A super special shout out to Taylor , she’s an absolute ROCKSTAR!“

“Excellent Bolognese and Tiramisu!“

“Amazing food and service. Top notch“

“Hidden gem, such a cute place and very clean. Food was amazing everything from the calamari to the cappuccino. Waiter was really nice and attentive. Definitely going back“

“It was a new place, so we decided to give it a try. The staff was friendly and sandwiches were so good. I got The Guido and tried a bite of my mom's Nonna's Special. The fact the ingredients are fresh certainly helps. I'll definitely order from here again. I dug their vanilla cream soda as well.“

“I had a delicious lunch meal with my family. The bread was a great start to the meal. All of the dishes were delicious and so was the dessert. Highly recommend this restaurant!“

“I’m a SJ native and have been going to Scotto with my girlfriend for about 5 years. It is hands down the best pizza around. We will drive well out of our way to get it. It’s a travesty that all of these “best pizza” lists don’t choose it as it should be better known. Look at the reviews.

If you want brick oven pizza or a fancy sit down, yes that is not here. But Scotto is the place to get the best pizza.“

“I had the pleasure of dining at Nunzio’s this evening for a work gathering. Every course was excellent! I cannot wait to bring my family back. The food was fresh and delicious.“

“Love the Spiedino de mare, I get all scallops. Thanks Carrabbas for the birthday tiramisu....yummm“

“This past spring my family and I took a roadtrip out east and after spending a day in Philadelphia watching the Union (MLS) we ventured into NJ in search of some local Italian eateries. It was a Sunday evening and not many establishments were open however we were fortunate Vitale's Italian Bistro was the exception. Warm welcoming staff greeted us, prompt and attentive wait service, and delicious food in abundance! It was a wonderful evening and a fine way in capping off our 10 day east coast road trip!“

“Giumarello’s Restaurant was delicious! The martinis were great. Appetizers: crab stack with mango salsa and avocado or saffron mussels with shrimp, Yumo! Entrees: Miso glazed sea bass or filet with stuffed lobster tail both Devine! Dessert: Chocolate heaven flourless cake and salted carmel creme brulee were heavenly 😋 Our waiter Griffin was wonderful and very knowledgeable, especially since we needed gluten free options. Highly recommend and will be going back!!“

“Wonderful service - outstanding food (the Penne Arribratta was one of the BEST pasta dishes I’ve ever had anywhere). Friendly owners - we can’t wait to go again!“

“Great dinner and great service. I had the crab cakes and my partner had the Rib-eye special both were outstanding. Worth every cent and we can’t wait to go back!“

“My sister and I dined here for Christmas din er. It was absolutely amazing. Your restaurant is beautiful and the food was phenomenal. The wait staff were amazing. I will recommend your restaurant and will definitely be dining here again. Thank you for a wonderful dining experience.“

“Excellent food, excellent service. Our favorite restaurant in Medford. The food is always fresh and delicious.“

“I ordered a Johnzarotti with extra cheese extra sausage extra green peppers Iforgotthe onions. But still excellent very tasty hats off to the Chef who has been there since I was a child in the late 70s early 80s. Back when they wr near the location of the current bank in the shopping center see picture below johns bought it from a family who used to sell burgers. Every time I have a Johnzarotti it brings me back to simpler times what a great comfort food ty for continuing to serve our community.“

“The food is always amazing. They do a great job handling larger groups too, so it is a favorite amongst our fraternity alumni club members.“

“Finally decent pizza in Collingswood! After shopping on the avenue, we stopped in for lunch. Honey got a gourmet “Chicken Marco Polo” pizza and I opted for a Sports salad, loaded with fresh grilled chicken and really enough for two people. We have been to the Montegrillo’s in Pennsauken but this is closer to home with the same great menu“

“We have come to La Strada many times... This time was by far the worst experience we have ever had. Sadly, the server was a bit overwhelmed I think. He came over to us and then let us sit for about 15 mins before he came back. Glad it is BYOB or else we probably would have been waiting for drinks also. After he finally took our order, which we knew by the sounds of other tables comments, it prob would come out wrong, we finally got our soup and salad and then another waitress that works there came over with the pork chop special to give us... Um, no that is not by any chance close to what we ordered. She walks away. Our server never came over to tell us what happened. About 20 mins or so later, we received our order.... BUT LO and BEHOLD, my husband's dinner which was Pollo Gamberi was missing ALL of the shrimp. This is a staple of this dish. I am really not sure what happened. But he comped our soup, gave us 2 pieces of dessert to take home, even though we said no and I also heard the ppl next to us never got their app. And he comped that. The owner is sadly gonna keep losing money if the server doesn't step up his game. From now on, when we go in , we will ask for the servers we have had and we recognize.“

“Carollo’s little Italy is awesome everything we have ever gotten there is great. All the chicken, pasta and seafood dishes are great. We Also love the mussels in red sauce and the bruschetta was the best we ever had. The staff is so nice and friendly and do an awesome job.“

“Good food and great people“

“Friendly atmosphere, great customer service, delicious food 🤤😋“

“Ate at the Philmont location last night. We had the Margherita pizza, cheesesteak, and truffle fries. Everything was delicious and our waitress, Katie, was the best. Ran into some friends that were also really enjoying themselves. Great spot.“

“Everything about my daughter’s bridal shower was perfect! The venue looked beautiful, the food was delicious, and the staff was excellent- so nice and friendly. Our guests were impressed with the venue and I’m sure they will recommend it to others, as will I. Thank you to Jackie and all the staff for making our experience exceptional.“

“They make their food the way you suggest it to them! I asked for my pizza well done and I love it! The pie was perfectly done right! Their chicken Caesar wrap made with wheat tortillas was fantastic too!“

“Very friendly people. Very good authentic Italian food. Best Italian Roast Pork sandwich around. So glad they opened back up. You won’t be disappointed!“

“Great, tasty food. Wonderful service. Great drinks.“

“We just had our 50th Wedding Anniversary Celebration at Marco's. Can't say enough about Lexi, who coordinated our event. She was so attentive to all our needs and made things so easy for us. The food was fantastic and I asked my guests and everyone raved about the food. Joe and his waitstaff were "The Best". Everything went so smoothly. Check them out. You won't be disappointed! Linda B.“

“My niece had her law school graduation party here the other night and the entire family, 21 of us, cannot say enough about the excellent food and service that we received. My elderly mother and I were early when they were still setting up, and they welcomed us with open arms and got us some coffee because it was so rainy and cold. The food was excellent. We had many courses, and my sister-in-law said that they were extremely accommodating and offered many choices at a good price for the menu. The owner was lovely to work with. I cannot say enough about how excellent the food was as was the superb service that we received from the entire team. They were on every need amidst a very busy restaurant while navigating around walkers and people like absolute pros... with a smile on their face the entire time. I sincerely hope that the owner and staff see this review.“

“Enjoyed everything the table ordered.
Arugula and Fire roasted peach salad.
Pasta Fra Diavolo with clams mussels shrimp and lump crab.
Crab cake on top of mashed potatoes and spinach.
Dessert was Fire roasted peaches with cannoli cream.“

“The staff are cheerful and on their toes. My veal parm was a gargantuan portion. All our dishes were authentic and savory. Our bartender, Angelo, has a warm and fun personality - very helpful.“