50 Best Sandwich Shops near Cresskill

“To whom it may concern, I am a student at Cresskill Middle School and a member of the Aerospace Engineering Club. We are in need of a sponsor for the American Rocketry Challenge to provide us funds. If you side with us, your club will be presented with publicity at the challenge, increasing your funds and fame. The entire nation will be aware that this little shop made it to the finals of a big time competiton, and whenever someone walks into your store, they will be aware of the success you made. Additionally, once we win the challenge, rocketry challenges across the globe will discover you and the fame you felt once, will be amplified throughout your entire life, increasing funds forevermore, and increasing your partnership with the rocketry field. Lastly, you are also helping out your local school, meaning the entire town will be in your debt and they will continue to buy sandwiches forevermore. Also, we can add fundraisers, if needed, and since Jersey Mike's is very popular, the amount of funds are sure to increase. Please side with the Aerospace team!“

“Everything was so fresh and delicious“

“I was truly impressed by the food - every bite felt like a perfect balance of flavor and texture. The presentation was stunning, and the ingredients tasted so fresh. You can tell the chef cooks with passion. I'll definitely be coming back for more!“

“Great lunches very accommodating for small lunch gatherings. Friendly atmosphere and staff. Delicious home cooked food and Italian specialties“

“Drove by this spot a couple of times and was intrigued by their decor. Decided today I was going to try it and I was really happy with the atmosphere and the sandwich was excellent! I had the “Lady Lover” cuz you know… I loved it!“

“This week I had the best sandwich at this place! The flavors are fantastic, and each bite is packed with freshness. The ingredients are fresh , and you can really taste the quality. Whether you're into classic combinations or something more adventurous, there’s something for everyone. If you’re looking for a delicious meal, you definitely need to try their sandwiches!“

“They have the most beautiful chip display of any Subway I’ve ever been to - it’s just so perfect & organized & it made my OCD brain happy when I walked in. My boyfriend always gets the nachos and they’re (surprisingly) really good.“

“Eggty8 offers a standout dining experience by masterfully blending creative Western brunch with traditional Eastern flavors. The special blueberry pancakes provide a light and inventive sweetness, while the Nova Benedict delivers a refined, perfectly poached classic for seafood enthusiasts. Complementing these is the authentic Malaysian curry noodle, which features a rich, fragrant broth and genuine spice, making the restaurant a rare destination where inventive sweets and bold, traditional comfort food coexist beautifully. You should try.“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ COMPTON’S is the kind of neighborhood gem you want everyone to know about — but secretly hope stays just yours. The sandwiches are massive, flavor‑packed, and clearly made with care. From the turkey hero with lime aioli to the Jaclyn with eggplant, every bite hits that perfect bread‑to‑filling ratio. The Reuben is a must‑try, and their chop cheese deserves all the hype.

What really sets COMPTON’S apart is the vibe: the owners make you feel welcome the second you walk in, and the service is as good as the food. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite at the counter or settling in at one of the few tables, you’ll leave full and happy.“

“Thank you for your generous support of Eastbrook’s class of 2021! Amazing spread of sandwiches, fixings & even gluten free options!“

“Second time there and I’m hooked.. I would recommend this place to everyone. And the staff there are very friendly and helpful…..“

“Friendly crew behind the counter, fast service too. Oh, and pretty good sandwiches too. 👍🏻“

“Great customer service! Tell Missy we said Hi.“

“Delicious sandwiches! The kind you’d travel from afar for just one more taste. All Boar’s Head Products. Fresh toppings and the Best Submarine Bread all combine for that taste of perfection. Best subs I’ve had in all of Jersey.“

“Theresa and Matty provided absolutely outstanding service! I came in for lunch around 11:40 AM, and even with a line of 8 customers plus online orders coming in—and being the only two there—they handled everything with efficiency and care. Each customer was served in a timely manner, and they never lost their friendly, kind attitude. By 12 PM, every customer had been served and left happy!! It’s rare to see that level of consistency under pressure. They both truly deserve praise and recognition!“

“This is far and away my favorite location. The entire staff is always so nice and efficient and their sandwiches actually look like the picture and the ingredients are always the freshest. I live a couple of blocks away from the subway on East Tremont, but this is totally worth the drive. I come here every time. Thank you for always making my lunch perfect!“

“If you want that sandwich you know Subway is the only fresh place to get it! My kids love going to this location especially because of the clean , nice environment and the attentive staff who are friendly and get it right how we like it.
Even when we pick up food to take home they always make sure it's made neatly and never leaking or exploding . This location is a a favorite quick lunch for my kids and family!“

“😀 hey serving sarges now“

“Excellent salad bar and cold food section. Vast selection of beverages, chips and snacks. Hot and cold roll or hero sandwiches made to order, as well as hot food dishes. Staff isn't very friendly, but they are efficient. The deli is next to a medical office building, so parking is tough.

Vegetarian options: Excellent salad bar options.“

“I had a wonderful experience at this local subway the customer service was truly excellent i was served by Shravya who made my meal with such care also Peter at check out was fast friendly and courteous!! Excellent customer service at this “

“Nice and friendly atmosphere and I recommend The Jibarito with Steak on fried Plantain..it’s my Fav!“

“Good good best chicken cheese steak“

“great service. awesome chicken cheese steak 😊😊😊😊“

“Madre Mía! This place is amazing! Simply spectacular! Anthony and his wife are so kind ! Food is delicious. Chef Jose Manuel is a very professional guy. Ambience is so relaxed and traditional. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED! I will definitely come back and much more often. Original Spanish Taste. You won’t get a great place like this in the area.“

“yum yum....nom nom.... two tries. two salads. both awesome. i'll be back again and again :)))“

“The presentation transforms good food into something special. Their kitchen delivers excellence and their team always shows care. The staff displays sincere hospitality. The positive facial expressions create a pleasant environment. I've stated the essentials.“

“Must share that the people who run this subway are top tier. So nice every single time I come in. Today I was helped by Pria who told me all about how I can save if I’m coming to subway often. Every other time I come in I’m greeted with a smile and prompt service and always leave feeling like I was cared for at A Subway! Great job tuckahoe Subway“

“I’ve been going here for years and absolutely love the fresh food. My go-to as of lately is the turkey- Italian spinach wrap. The veggies are so good too, it’s a great value for what you get and there are 2 people that work there who are amazingly kind, professional and wonderful customer service.

Vegetarian options: They have watercress!!! Amazing.

Dietary restrictions: I remember asking about the ingredients from the wrap last year and the woman easily shared with me.“

“Excellent sandwich, very courteous and knowledgeable staff. I was there to get a sandwich but I also picked up nice reasonably priced greeting cards and balloons too for my nephew. The place is bright and clean. This will be my go to stop when I am in the area making deliveries. Huge parking lot to park my truck, easy in and out.Also I saw they had a sign that say Buy 2 get 1 Free pizza. Next time I should try the Subway pizza too.“

“Amazing deli and a bunch of groceries“

“I like this subway sandwich because it’s a clean place and I like how the customers are very nice to you and they give you extra napkins if you need some other subway customers they just don’t care and don’t give you any napkins or just forget your order that what I don’t like but this subway sandwich is more better I rate it at 5 stars.“

“Great place! The guy behind the counter was very chill and made a pretty good Mr. Beast Burger for me and my friend. Burger was 7.5/10 in my opinion - definitely something I would buy again. Their entire menu looks delicious and plan on heading back to try more. Their fries are definitely 9.5/10 - some of the best fries I've had in a while. Highly recommend you stop by and try a burger from this place ?“

“Very good Philly Cheese 🧀 Steaks 🥩.“

“The best! They brought back the Landy Sandwich and it’s addicting!🤤“

“Mr Jarmar R Williams an employee there excellent customer service to us.My partner & myself frequent Jersey Mikes in Fort Lee NJ & Mr.Jamar addressed our issues immediatey.My personal opinion he def needs to manage that particular store his customer service is ova the top..💪“

“I stopped at our local Jersey Mikes when I just did not feel like cooking. Talk about hitting the spot. I ordered the Mini Italian sub and it was more than enough for dinner. They really load the meat and veggies inside the sub.\n\nThe only problem was that the girl put mayo on my sandwich before I could stop here. It was still good but tasted weird with the oil and vinegar that I also had put on top. Still I really enjoyed the sandwich and the meal and will be back.“

“The brick and mortar location is only open during the winter months, but the sandwiches are unique, fresh, and expertly crafted from the finest Italian ingredients. Westchester’s version of Italy & NYC’s world famous All'antico Vinaio.“

“Literally the best Subway I’ve ever went to. I used to live in a smaller city in California and pretty much all of the subways there had bad customer service and the owners were not that great but this Subway they are so nice. My sandwiches always taste delicious. I highly recommend ordering from here. I’ve been coming here for years.“

“One of the employees at this location made (my) perfect jersey mikes sandwich order and I am about to call the store and ask for his name because I wanna thank him by name but I didn’t wanna wait to leave this review. I come to this location a lot since I work in the area and they are always good, no complaints. This one employee was so nice too, even tho he had a line and very mean people in front of us, gave us a smile… cool. He finished with “the juice” and asked me if that was good and I said “perfect 👍🏼” because I felt it. I took my sandwich and got stuck in traffic… if you’re a sandwich connoisseur you know what that means. Yup, soggy sandwich. TO MY SURPRISE… I got to my destination and the sandwich was intact, perfect. I finished my sandwich a little while ago and I’m still thinking of this interaction because it made my long tired day feel so much better. 💙❤️“

“Loved the food and the team“

“soups are delicious, sandwiches yummy & bakery items mmmmmmm“

“I brought 2 blimpies best sandwiches. I was so happy when I realized there is a blimpies 2 minutes from Montefiore hospital. I haven't had my favorite sandwich in years. Blimpies seems to be housed in other stores. Before this time, I found it in a twin donut on 161st and it was 16 dollars. The one on Gunhill and Bainbridge Avenue is in a store named Tasty Picks and was the normal 13 dollars.“

“Awesome Subway and convenience store in a strip mall next to Laundromat. It has Subway, Alka Hydro alkaline water, Greeting cards, helium party balloons, chips, soda beverages, Slushies, Coffee, Hot chocolate and cappuccino machine, Candies, Gum and NJ lottery and ICEs

Vegetarian options: Veggie Burger and veggie delight

Parking: Strip center with tons of parking

Kid-friendliness: Birthday balloons, get wellballoons, party ballons,“

“Cons: Price can be slightly lower, I'm always surprised by the total.Pros: Clean place, quick service and quality food.Never long lines and just a solid place.Cons: Price can be slightly lower, I'm always surprised by the total.Had: Italian (recommend cold options) , Cheesesteak (alright)“

“Everything I have ordered from there is always delicious the grilled chicken salad especially it's the best I've ever had!“

“This deli functions and operates beautifully 😍 I love coming in here the employees are great from the deli guys to the counter guys THEY ARE ALL GREAT,NICE SERVICES AND NICE EXPERIENCE...“

“Shout to the Blimpie in Teaneck. Its been years since I've had a Blimpie sandwich. It brought back so many memories. The young lady behind the counter made my birthday stop a good one. Sandwich made as I requested. She even wrapped one specifically for me to eat while stuck in traffic(we had an 1hr and 20 minute drive back home during rush hour). Yay, superstar ✨️ 😎!“

“Went in Oct 2023. Great service and food was delicious. My toddler didn’t finish her meal and I walked over to ask for a to-go container and person theresaw me walking and grabbed to-go container and bag and handed to me before I had to even ask. A first at a fast food place for me.“