37 Best Bakeries near Farmingdale

“Delicious breads, pastries, cookies and coffee!“

“Angy’s Homemade Cakes are delicious. Fresh, moist, flavorful and beautiful. Norma was very accommodating, responsive and professional. Highly recommend. 😋“

“We received a box of goodies from Chocolate Carousel and they were delicious. Chocolate covered pretzels with M&Ms and peanut butter chips, cake pops and chocolate covered Oreos.😋“

“this place is the talk of the town. Nick’s croissant gave me déjà vu of when I went to Paris in April. A small but mighty, local business. Go when they open or you’ll miss the best bites. Easily five stars. It’s the best place in town.“

“My wife’s birthday was this past week. The only thing she asked for was a cake from Turquoise! And that’s what she got. The fluffiest, sweetest Red Velvet cake and Cream Cheese. Decorated to perfection! I’m trying to post a photo or two but the app won’t allow it. Oh well… take my word for it. Delicious.“

“The BEST Carrot Cake I’ve ever had! 🥕🍰“

“This is the absolute best crumb cake I’ve ever had!“

“A few years ago, I began the search to find a good cake/baking supply store. Michaels is OK for last minute items but I wanted a “Go To” place. When I went to the internet, Shore Cake Supply was the 1st one to pop up. I live in North Jersey so it’s an hour or so drive for me BUT I drove there and had a “me” shopping spree. I’ve taken a class or two and even suggested to Jennifer that I wouldn’t be opposed to her opening a second location in North Jersey 😉. All I can say is just go there. You WON’T be disappointed. They are friendly, kind, helpful and MOST importantly.. honest! Oh, and I would travel as far as needed to go there. ❤️“

“Great place for all types of desserts and pastries!“

“Their baked goods are out of this world! You must try their monkey bread!! It’s outstanding or their crumb cake.. to die for. Walter will get you everything you need Cheers“

“So many freshly-baked items, I had a hard time choosing. My students were thrilled that I went out of my way to shop here. While I bought 4 different items, I needed to get triple the amount of black and white cookies. I know now for next time. So many compliments and thank yous as students picked some of each item.“

“I have visited the Red Rose Bakery in Howell a number of times and loved everything I have tried. The apple turnovers were delicious, the selection of cupcakes was amazing, and it is wonderful to have the ability to buy just a portion of a cake when you don't have a large family. This morning I called with a last minute request for 20 cupcakes in 10 containers of two each for my dogs birthday! I wanted to bring them to his Saturday morning class with his doggie friends. I already had a cake for the dogs but had neglected their human partners. I was so pleased with the lovely selection and packaging on such short notice! Thank you Red Rose Bakery!“

“We just went for the first time today took a detour off our road trip to stop in. My kids were so excited that they could pick anything out we have a lot of allergies and it was so nice to see their faces light up and know that everything there was safe for them. The worker was so kind and sweet and it was overall an amazing experience. It’s a small front shop but so worth it to go in they had so many options to choose from we grabbed a little of everything we could. We will definitely be planning more detours the next time we drive near.“

“I just moved into the neighborhood and found this delicious gem not far from home. Fresh pastry, great coffee choices, and espresso on request. Staff are friendly. Highly recommend!“

“Stopped by Papa Ganache in Manasquan and didn’t realize it was a vegan bakery until we got there. I ordered the cake roll, s’mores bar, and an Americano. Everything was delicious! The flavors were really good, and even though the texture isn’t quite like a non-vegan baked good, the taste totally made up for it.“

“All their cookies and baked goods are delicious!!! We do not keep a Kosher home, but the cookies and baked goods are so so good and beautifully packaged! 😃“

“A friend of mine recommended Fancy Cakes & I'm so happy she did! Krystina made AMAZING cakes for my son & husbands birthdays in April & last week made a gorgeous cake for my sons communion, plus the most delicious mini chocolate chip cookies & brownies I & my guests ever had. Everything for both parties was perfection. I am beyond happy!“

“I recently hosted my baby shower in Belmar and came across this shop—so glad I did! Cali was incredibly helpful and made sure my vision came to life. Let me tell you, these were the BEST cupcakes I’ve ever had in my life! Everyone was raving about them, and they were absolutely beautiful too. If you’re planning a party, use this shop—you won’t be disappointed!“

“Sugar bakeshop provided the most beautiful baby shower cake for my daughters baby shower at Half moon point grill. Not only was it delicious, it was made with so much attention to the theme. Take a look at the photo, it’s absolutely gorgeous. Five stars, cake was fresh and moist and delicious. Great job, thank you. Update ; Sugar bake shop closed and new people took over the space. They did custom sugar cookies and baptism cake delivered to venue . The cookies were beautiful and cake delicious.“

“Lakewood Shmura Matzoh Bakery is one of those places that, the second you walk in, you feel like you just stepped straight into Erev Pesach in the old country — only with better lighting and a lot more Lakewood energy. 😄
First of all, the smell. That warm, toasty, fresh-off-the-fire shmura matzah smell hits you and suddenly you’re like, “Okay… I’m ready to say Kol chamira right now.” The whole operation has that serious Yiras Shamayim vibe — you can tell this isn’t some “matzah factory,” it’s a matzah avodah. Everyone’s moving with purpose, like it’s a well-rehearsed seder of zerizus.
And if you come at the right time and get to see the process? Wow. You’re watching people working quickly, carefully, focused — and you’re thinking, “This is not a bakery, this is basically a live shiur in Hilchos Matzah.” The heat, the timing, the coordination… it’s like a whole chaburah in action, except instead of arguing on a Tosafos, they’re making sure every second counts.
The matzos themselves? Geshmak. Crisp, fresh, and clearly made with pride. You take one bite and you already know your Pesach is going to be on a higher level — like your seder table just got an automatic upgrade. And yes, it’s shmura — but it also tastes like it was made by people who actually care that it should be delicious, not just technically kosher.
Also, the location inside Excel Park is classic Lakewood: from the outside it looks like a regular industrial spot, and inside it’s literally kedushas Pesach headquarters. Hidden gem vibes. (If you know, you know.)
Bottom line: If you want real Lakewood shmura matzah, made with care, zerizus, and a healthy dose of that pre-Pesach excitement — this is the place. Just don’t blame me when you start feeling like you need to do bedikas chametz the second you leave.“

“Our wedding cake came from Cameo. It was amazing! It was everything I wanted on our wedding day, beautiful, light and incredibly delicious! I highly recommend Cameo for anyone who is looking for a bakery for their wedding cake.“

“🥰enjoy sharing with friends and family!“

“If you’re in Lakewood and you have even a drop of a sweet tooth, Gelbstein’s is basically a ניסיונות station. You walk in “just to look,” and two minutes later you’re leaving with a box, a bag, and a third thing you don’t remember agreeing to… because the smell of fresh pastry makes you sign away your free will. 😄
First of all, everything is fresh. Not “fresh-ish.” I mean fresh fresh — like the danishes are still warm and the crumbs are already following you home. The rugelach/danish vibe is top-tier, the pastries are flaky in a way that makes you whisper “וואו” without realizing, and the challah is the kind that turns a regular Shabbos table into a whole simcha.
And it’s not just the classics — they’ve got fun stuff too (those cute cupcakes and seasonal things), so it’s perfect when you need:
a quick treat for the car (aka: “for later”),
something respectable to bring to a vort/Sheva Brachos,
or a Shabbos dessert that looks like you put in effort (בלי עין הרע).
Also, the place has a very heimish, local feel — you’ll bump into half of Lakewood in there, all pretending they’re “only buying one thing.” Sure. We all believe you.
Bottom line: delicious, consistent, and dangerous in the best way.
Highly recommend — just don’t come in hungry unless you’re okay with your wallet doing teshuvah afterward. 😄“

“Simona’s Bakery is amazing. She made a beautiful and delicious cake for my daughter’s 30th birthday. Along with the cake we enjoyed 4 dozen of her awesome mini cupcakes. Everyone loved it all. So much so that I didn’t even get a cupcake.lol. Heading to New Jersey in a few weeks and I have every intention of picking up my own order of cupcakes. Thanks Simona and staff for helping to make my daughter’s party a success.“

“We ordered a cake very late before an event, they were so nice and prompt about it. we told them that we wanted the cake to be tall and gold, gave them the flavors, and told them to design it however they wanted! the cake was decorated amazing! it’s gorgeous. and usually pretty cakes don’t taste good but it was so moist! we got the canoli, and chocolate fudge and the canoli is sooo good! chocolate was also good but we all liked canoli better! the cake was 80$ super affordable compared to other places, it fed about 16-20 people!! totally recommend!!“

“Had a catering order. Placed the order a week in advance. The morning if pickup, the order states that it was ready when it was not. Got to the store and told them i was there for a catering pickup. No one said anything and they started to scramble to package everything. We paid extra to get the cookies in individual boxes. Upon getting the order noticed that nothing was in individual boxes. Now I have to scramble before an event to package these things. Do not get a large order from here.

Edit: cookies were delicious and we still had to make the boxes and pack the cookies ourselves the morning of our event but the store did right by us and gave us a refund.“

“When I ordered a full sheet birthday cake (in person) the salesclerk was patient, professional and attentive to the details I requested. Great customer service! At pickup in Jan 2025, the large heavy cake was carried out to the car for me. It was beautifully decorated and exactly as expected. Again, great customer service! Best of all, at the party, many of our guests raved about the delicious cake. A fresh and moist chocolate cake filled with chocolate custard and iced with whipped cream. Excellent!“

“They made a smash cake for my niece's first birthday. It was DESTROYED- she loved it!! I took a nibble and I don't blame her- that cake was gooood!! I use Bruno's for almost all of my events. Can't recommend them enough!“

“Hi all! Thanks for your comments! Im the new owner and really was interesting reading all of your comments! Bread House is under new management since February 2022 . We are trying hard to make things better and keep customers happy and healthy! Please don’t hesitate to rich out and give us a call if u have any issues or complaints! I will be happy to hear you and make things better! Bread House is only authentic Georgean restaurant in the area so its very important to do the business right! Thanks again! Please come in and try us!“

“Absolutely the best store. If you're looking for a beautiful and delicious treat you must go here. The gift trays are beautifully wrapped and ready to go for any occasion. They have Cholov Yisroel and Parve chocolates and treats. Highly recommend to stop by and see their selection for yourself.“

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Crumbl Cookie in Ocean Township is always a hit! The cookies are fresh, warm, and packed with flavor every single time. The staff was super friendly and made the experience even better. Definitely one of my go-to dessert spots — highly recommend! 🍪🔥“

“I have had these Bundt cakes for many occasions and they are always delicious. The staff at the store is always pleasant and polite. The store is so cute and always clean and organized. Thank you making our events so special 😍“

“There's a new guy in charge! The guy with the glasses and does the cooking, he is legit and doesn't forget anything. He's very cool.

These bad reviews were from a year ago when they had different workers and yes, they were horrible.

But these new workers are awesome!“

“highly recommended!!!!!!!“