15 Best Italian Restaurants in Flemington

“Delicious food, great service and nice ambience!“

“Always great food and excellent service highly recommended! Never a bad meal love the sweet and sour calamari !!!“

“excellent and quick service, Delicious food and a great atmosphere !! The owner is very nice and attentive to every customer making sure they are having a good time while eating the delicious food.“

“Angelo’s never disappoints food fresh & yummy.“

“Best tacos in flemington!!!“

“Really good food and service. We really miss going but moved to Pennsylvania. However this spring we will be in more frequently.“

“This place catered one of our company's Xmas partys and it was absolutely delicious! So much so, that I ordered several dishes Saturday for the weekend. When I picked up the food they offered me a bottle of wine, and wished me a merry xmas! (How nice was that??) I got an order of Nonna's meatballs (I'm sure there's an Italian Grandma in that kitchen stirring a big pot of homemade meatballs in marinara. No lie.) Broccali Rabe w/sausage (fantastic), garlic loaf with cheese (try adding a meatball on a slice, with that incredible sauce-🤯), a ginormous burger (tonight's dinner, but I know it'll be great) and the star of the show... the Eggplant Rollatini. (Just WOW!) Several huge slices of eggplant, crammed full of ricotta, rolled up in a pasta blanket to keep it all tucked in, swimming in a sea of incredible marinara and penne, coated with globs of melty mozzarella. [THIS dish alone should have you heading out the door immediately, to get you some!😉] I don't know HOW they can give such big portions of incredible, high quality foods for much less they you'd expect to pay, and not only stay in business, but also give away cases upon cases of free wine to their customers. My eggplant was only $23. (I swear it alone weighed 5lbs.) So far Ive gotten 3 meals out of that 1 dish and there's STILL 2 servings left. You're not finding a better value on delicious homemade food, and will not be disappointed!“

“Just stopped in on a whim and it turned out to be our new favorite spot. This pizza is better than the best i've had in NYC and is phenomenal. The options are endless and their buffalo chicken garlic knot is a must eat. It's a beautiful shop and the owner is so kind and awesome. Brooklyn pizza has arrived in Flemington and it's 5 stars all around. We can't wait to try everything !“

“All .. salad pizza is my favorite“

“Excellent food and better people. Food is very tasty, fresh, and great 'inventions'. Love Angelo, Lorenzo, and Emilio. They treat you like family. You will find homemade scones made by Angelo which are very good. No one makes a better white pizza than Angelo. All the pizza is very good, the bacon chicken ranch one of my favorites. And the dinners, Jim loves the seafood, are always very delicious. No better server than Lorenzo. He knows you and will recommend for what you might like. Love the hugs. Couldn't ask for a better gem in Flemington. It is my happy place, which is what is saved on my phone.“

“Rose and Joe run a top notch bakery. All of their stuff is fresh and delicious. If you want bread get there early though! It sells out quick! ❤️“

“Love their food one problem they always deliver to my house on a Sunday I called up ordering for delivery the guy told me that they don’t deliver to my area Told him your boss told me you do he asked his boss he then said oh well we’re backed up so why don’t you order from the Hillsboro one the Hillsboro one is further away from me then Flemington location I will give them another shot because I like their food but I’m making it clear I’m unhappy with their staff and the way I was treated when all I wanted was a pizza Sunday night“

“Absolutely wonderful! I ordered Mamma’s Tomato Sauce with pasta and it hit the spot! Tasty and amazing!! Couldn’t recommend more and I will definitely order again or stop in next time!“

“Got 6 pizzas from gabbys for a bounce city birthday party. My son has a severe egg allergy and they promised to mark a pie and take extra care with it. He was able to eat it without any issue and we all enjoyed the pizza a lot. Thank you Gabby’s!“

“Went there with the family (10 people), the food was good, service was correct (the waitress was nice and got pretty much everything right), could have checked up on us more often (probably short-staffed). Nothing special about the atmosphere.
I would go back there.“