50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Hightstown

“Hands down, one of the best pizza shops in central Jersey 🙌🏽 If you’re looking for a fresh tomato pie or a plain slice, this is a must.“

“From out of town but visit once a month for work. I stumbled upon this place just driving around looking for food and was very pleased with the food and the service. I have had both the pollo and asada tacos-both fantastic. The fresh tortillas make a huge difference. The pizza was also very delicious. Usually eat the tacos in and pizza to go. As for the comments regarding discrimination- White male here who's been several times and have never had an issue. Also fast, kind and courteous service for me.“

“This was my first time trying mediterranean food and I loved every single thing I ordered. Plus, the service was easily one of the best I’ve ever had at any restaurant. Simply loved it.“

“Food was so absolutely incredible it might have ruined all other Italian food for me. Great customer service, staff were very friendly. The bread was an incredible base for the butter along with the marinara dip. Then there was the spaghetti with meatballs that came with a salad. The salad was great on its own. The pasta was incredible, and the meatballs balls were so tender that they just crumbled in your mouth. Overall the place was great. 10/10 would come again.“

“Excellent pizza 🍕 and a abundance of choices to select from - new to the neighborhood and I think we found our new pizzeria“

“What’s not to like great food in“

“The food here never fails to impress. It’s fresh, tasty, and expertly made. The staff are friendly, attentive, and work really hard to make your dining experience ( inside or takeout/delivery) an enjoyable one. We visit a couple of times a week!!“

“Great“

“Last week, we ordered 200 boxed lunches during the Staff Appreciation Week for High school North. Carlos delivered it personally and paid attention to details. Everyone enjoyed the lunch thoroughly.“

“Best 2 guys around❤️❤️ Antonio and Alex treat you like family. They are friendly and aim to please. Best 🍕 pizza around.“

“My daughter and I were in the area for an appt. and we came across Tino’s and I have to admit this is by far THE BEST Pizza we have ever tasted in our life!!!!! If you have not gone there- please do!!! They have excellent food and will not disappoint. Cheers!!!!“

“I was searching online for good Italian to send to my family who were gathering for lunch before my favorite Aunt Harriets funeral. Trying to do this as a surprise for my family, I was calling from Colorado not knowing true reputations. I not only found good Italian, I found fantastic and authentic! Sal's genuine care for my phone order was beyond words. I ordered trays of eggplant rollatini, chicken parmesan, lasagna, fresh vegetables and garlic knots which was fresh, hot and delivered on time. Can't say THANK YOU enough for helping me feel present with my family when I couldn't actually be present. Someday during my travels back east, I'll find my way there and experience your cooking first hand. Thanks again Sal and keep doing (ministering in a way) what your doing. Diann R. Longmont, CO“

“Thanks for the great dinners. This is definitely my goto Italian take out or dine-in. BYOB is perfect too as I can bring exactly what I want to drink. Capisci! 😎“

“food was outstanding! Service was impeccable! Everyone on out party had to taste each other's food because we all raved about how delicious it was! Can't wait to go back!“

“What an amazing restaurant and owners they are! We have ordered twice from the restaurant and our second order was incorrect but we gladly ate it since everything we’ve had is delicious! We didn’t even voice our concerns because it was so good and to our surprise we get a delivery with the correct salad! Top notch service and quality!“

“the food is amazing! beautiful presentation, delicious food andcvery helpful servers who explained all the different dishes and patiently answered our questioms“

“The owners and staff there always make us feel at home. We recently had a gathering there, the food was plentiful, and delicious. They were so accommodating to our time and request.“

“Attended a birthday party and the atmosphere and food were amazing! Will definitely be back.“

“The owner Sal very pleasant , the food is great , I recommend it to anyone who enjoy good food , the service is great , no matter what time is , lunch or dinner .“

“Contes pizza is one the best in the Mercer/Bucks county area. I give it a 8.99. Service was fantastic, the people are friendly and pleasant. I highly recommend going to Contes. I know we’re going back.“

“The food and service are awesome! We booked their pizza truck for an upcoming party. Soooo excited!“

“D’Angelo’s Italian Market has such a warm, welcoming vibe, and it’s the kind of place you look forward to visiting. Their homemade mozzarella alone is worth the trip... Pair that with their outstanding selection of imported pastas, and you’ve got everything you need to create an authentic Italian meal at home.

Feel like eating out instead? Well, D’Angelo’s has that covered, too. From their artisan sandwiches to their homemade sauces, delicious prepared foods, and amazing pastries, they’ve got it all. The store is well organized, and the customer service is consistently outstanding. Special shout out to Joe for always going above and beyond.“

“They are the very best around! Never miss. Great for catering too. Get a slice, get a sandwich, a pie or a dinner, it's always great. I love the owners!“

“Jimmy out did himself tonight. A large pepperoni, mushroom, and onion pizza was what was for dinner. The crust was absolutely delicious-crispy yet fluffy. One of the best pizza’s I’ve had in a long time!“

“Pizza is Best we’ve had in Jersey and Staten Island! Crispy underneath and perfect thickness. Sauce terrific hint of sweetness . Seafood app in a brothish white Sauce with Tender Calamari,Shrimp and Mussels. Took the broth home to dunk next day! Tks Chef and Servers.Great stuff!“

“Best buffalo chicken pizza EVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!“

“I order from this place everyday. And, I mean that literally. The food is good the Maximo is good and the pizza and the Strumbolis are good. The delivery guy is super friendly. I've ordered here more than anyone else in NJ and I've never had an issue. They also have great broccoli and garlic“

“great family owned business with good food and interesting weekend specials“

“Celebrated my husband's 94th birthday at Antonio's yesterday, December 16, 2025. Also, had his 90th birthday celebration there in their private room. Food, service, and value are always top notch. In addition, Tuesdays, Wednesdays, and Thursdays are buy one meal and get one free, (cash only) in different categories of food. Love their house salad, outstanding! Can always depend on a delicious meal there.“

“Cranbury Pizza always has great food, and their garlic knots are seriously delicious!“

“The best restaurant in town Italian food and 🍕 my fever meatball Parmesan“

“Had family birthday dinner and as usual a world class meal. Fabulous veal dish, penne vodka among other dishes! Calamari appetizer and meatball appetizer! I highly recommend Albivi!! World class food and matching service!!“

“Grate customer service, quick and delicious. We Love it!“

“My family and friends very recently had a Celebration of Life memorial dinner there and they could not have been more accommodating. The food was great and the staff were there attending to all our needs. I highly recommend Romeo’s for any occasion. You won’t be disappointed!!!“

“Stopped for lunch with hubs and friends. We we're looking to share a pizza, this is NOT that place. Yes, personal size for dine in. We opted for sandwiches. 2 ordered the roast pork, broccoli rabe, sharp provolone and both finished and raved how delicious 😋 Other 2 of us ordered the cheesesteak with LTO, red wine vinegar and olive oil, I added light mayo. The rolls these sandwiches were served were fantastic 😋 The sammies were NOT "packed" with fillings like a cheesesteak joint. Nicely presented with homemade potato chips. Quality of ingredients is huge because I can't eat a lot. The red wine vinegar and olive oil was top notch. I use red wine vinegar almost daily 😋 I would definitely go back for the same meal, about 1hr from my home and worth the trip 😋“

“Last week, we ordered 200 boxed lunches during the Staff Appreciation Week for High school North. Carlos delivered it personally and paid attention to details. Everyone enjoyed the lunch thoroughly.“

“Oh man that was good. Thanks !!“

“Haven't set foot inside Docks since 2004 for no other reason than it's a little out of the way from home and I'm not much of a drinker. I've been working in the area again for about a year and wanted to find a local spot to go with some coworkers and figured since it was close, why not try Docks. I happened across a picture of one of their burgers and had to try one since having my gallbladder removed and being able to once again enjoy the occasional bacon cheeseburger. Stopped there tonight with a coworker, got the Houston Burger and let me tell you... it was incredible. Burger was well seasoned and juicy (even though I always order well done) and the bacon was top quality. The prices were fantastic and my coworker said they had one of the best Guinness draughts he's had in a long time. Definitely see it turning into a to-do after work more often.“

“Great daily specials for 25.00 can’t beat the amount of food they give you enough for a family of 3 to have 2 meals !! Give them a try you will NOT be disappointed“

“We ordered a Sicilian pie with onion & sausage and a Chicken lemon w capers dinner. The dinner came with a nice salad and hot bread. The dinner was magnificent . Oh that pie was to die for. Delicious 😋⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“With Covid and other contagions on the rise for this coming fall, PF , Whitehorse Ave, Hamilton NJ leads the pack in Gym cleanliness. Management shows it cares about its members.“

“We just had a Brooklyn Pizza delivered from them. It was fantastic! Highly recommend!“

“I’ve thought about ordering here for years but just never did. Tonight I took a chance and I had to give myself a pat on the back. The tomato pie was everything. It was absolutely amazing and blew away my expectations. If you’re looking for a cheese pizza go else where they specialize in Trenton tomato pies please do some research before giving someone a bad review before you even know what you are ordering.

The service from the staff was different from other pizza places near by someone was actually happy to take my order. Classico is going to be in my rotation from now on and as a person who has eaten at every significant pizza place in New Jersey. This 5 star rating can’t justify my experience and most importantly that perfectly cooked tomato pie.

Keep up the good work. You guys deserve a round of applause.“

“The food is incredible - highly recommend“

“amazing food !! Marcelo always makes you feel like home I love their fresh pizza“

“friendliness price tastiness“

“Celebrated my wife's birthday last weekend. Food was delicious, service was excellent...we will be back!!“

“They have the BEST fresh made Minestrone soup i've ever had. I judge other restaurants quality by comparing to Valentino's. It takes a moment to heat up....as they include more fresh vegetables at time of ordering. Unbelievable! Oh, and their salad bar I also find impressive.Can't comment on pizza.“

“Great guys and excellent customer service! Always a warm welcome with a smile!!“

“the pizza was disgusting and cold 🥶 my dog wouldn't eat it and either would i in the trash waste of money“