10 Best Italian Restaurants in Madison

L'Allegria Restaurant Italian • $$$
11 Prospect St, Madison

Customers` Favorites

Zucchini Imbottiti - Stuffed Zucchini
Saverio's Lobster Bouillabaisse
Filet Mignon Tips Pan Seared
Filet of Salmon Procinciale
Spaghetti Alla Carbonara
Braised Beef Short Ribs
Soup of the Day
Figs Prosciutto
Burrata Arugula
Creamy Polenta

“My team had a lunch booked today and stepping into L’Allegria was a beautiful surprise. I booked the restaurant based on the menu and ratings, plus parking looked easy. Without planning it we had a private room where we could celebrate the departure of one of our colleagues. Alana took great care of us and the food was delicious and well executed. Temperatures were perfect on the food too. The zucchini blossoms and homemade gnocchi were the best I’ve had in YEARS. The chef and restaurant team are to be commended. I look forward to returning with my husband for dinner. Thank you!“

4.1 Good66 Reviews
Il Goccino Ristorante Italian • $$
33 Main St, Madison

Customers` Favorites

Tortellini Bolognese
Pollo Scarpariello
Mozzarella Caprese
Key Lime Pie
Pear Salad
Ravioli

“When we decided to make a reservation here I was concerned because the parking situation in Madison is difficult. IlGoccino has parking in the rear of the restaurant so it was fine. The staff were warm and welcoming and they honored our reservation on arrival. The food was excellent - the salmon cooked to perfection and the chicken was tender and delicious as well. We certainly will return.“

4.6 Superb40 Reviews
Il Mondo Vecchio Italian • $$$
72 Main St #1, Madison

Customers` Favorites

Lobster and Shrimp Arrabiata
Warm Apple Tart with Gelato
Portobello Mushrooms App
Spaghetti Seafood Dinner
Butternut Squash Ravioli
Porcini Mushroom Ravioli
Carpaccio Con Parmigiano
Antipasto Della Nonna
Shrimp Pasta Dinner
Chicken Parmigiano

“Cute decor with incredible food! All the staff is incredible in their hospitality and polite. They have the most amazing porcini mushroom ravioli!! I often stop by to pick it up to go when I happen to be in the area. It’s a bit pricey at $45 for a dinner portion, but I don’t mind paying a premium for good quality fresh ingredients.“

4.4 Superb54 Reviews
Firehouse Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria Italian • $$
15 Central Ave, Madison

Customers` Favorites

White Pie with Fresh Garlic
Pizza by the Slice
Sausage Pizza
Rice Balls
Penne Vodka
Firehouse
Zeppoles
Italian
Calamari
Nicky

“Love everything about it. Chicken Marsala is awesome“

4.3 Superb73 Reviews
Osteria Trevi Italian • $$
4 Park Ave, Madison

Customers` Favorites

Penne Bolognese
Cacio E Pepe

“Very good all around. I see the concern on portion size but I thought it was enough IMO. Meatballs were excellent. Definitely worth the hype. You need reservations on the weekend. BYOB. Yes, atmosphere is loud, but fun at the same time. They don’t rush you but also don’t come around too often. Overall, worth a visit and I’ll be back.“

4.2 Good42 Reviews
Baba's bakery Bakery • $
37 Kings Rd, Madison

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni and Cheese Croissant
Assorted Small Cookies
Chocolate Fudge Cake
Chocolate Croissant
Boston Creme Donut
Buttercream Cake
Emoji Cupcake
Carrot Cake
Cake Slices
Cream Puff

“Best connoli cake! The staff are great“

4.6 Superb34 Reviews
Formaggio's Pizzeria Pizza • $
36 Main St, Madison

Customers` Favorites

Sicilian Cheese Pizza
Chicken Scarpariello
Margherita Pizza
Chicken Parm
Pizza Kit
Sausage

“Best eggplant parm around!“

4.5 Superb67 Reviews
Tino’s Artisan Pizza Co. Pizza • $
6 Main St, Madison

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parm Sandwich
Tino's Marghertia
Margherita Pizza
Tino's Margherita
Mamma's Meatballs
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Bites
Caesar Salad
Caprese Salad
Bruschetta

“The pizza was delicious! They don’t use any artificial or super-processed ingredients, so even the Coke was Mexican Coke that uses agave sweetener versus corn syrup! Casual but feels upscale.“

4.5 Superb53 Reviews
Romanelli's Pizza & Italian Eatery Pizza • $
42 Lincoln Pl, Madison

Customers` Favorites

Pizza Slice
Greek Salad

“Best neighbor and classmate ever. Proud to have called him friend.“

4.1 Good32 Reviews
Italian Village Pizza Pizza • $
300 Main St, Madison

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana
Plain Cheese Pizza
Special Pizza
Sausage Roll
Garlic Knots
Penne Vodka
Caesar Salad
Cheesecake
Sicilian
Sauce

“Great food! Great staff! Best chicken parm dinner ever!!!“

4.1 Good46 Reviews

You May Also Like