50 Best Sandwich Shops near Millburn

“Everything they make is amazing. The sandwiches are bountiful. Fresh ingredients. My fav place“

“Stopped in Saturday for the first time. We had to incredibly good subs and Potato salad. The owner is very nice, the place is immaculate and we will definitely be back!“

“The Great Wazu is the reason small businesses are the HEART of a community. I am a soon-to-be small business owner myself. I walked in this place tonight like I do every 1-2 weeks to get dinner. Sara behind the counter has gotten to know me and ALWAYS remembers my order. Tonight, she asked me what was new, and I told her I had been upset all day worrying about all the stuff I have on my plate right now getting my business ready to open. She was the sweetest. When I reached for my credit card, she told me my order was on her and gave me a hug and said, "You got this." It was one of the most human experiences I've ever had, and I just want everyone to know how special this place is. It's not just the sandwiches. It's the kindness.“

“Subway, Is truly the best place to come in and gets a snack or sandwich. I love it and the Service is even better I would definitely recommend coming here and get yourself something to eat come stop by and get yourself something yummy to fill your stomach“

“The pastrami is really good“

“OMG! I enjoyed such a fresh sandwich! So excited this sandwich cafe has been created in my area!“

“Truly the best Eggplant sandwich I have ever had. SO tasty and SO filling.“

“Holy crap the sandwich was good it was bursting with flavor and everything in between. The guy helping me gave me 70 free bags of chips and free cookies, of course. My life has been changed forever. The sandwich was so good, for a second I thought my dad returned.“

“Super service and delicious food. We are lucky to have you in our neighborhood and Westfield! The picnic tables are even better especially when the weather is so nice. Gracias! 5 stars!“

“I love Jersey Mike’s sandwiches—they’re really filling and always taste super fresh. I usually order in-store because I find it better than using the app. The staff is nice, though sometimes the music can be a little loud. There can be a bit of a wait at times, but it’s never too long. It can get expensive if you’re ordering for a big family, but I still think it’s worth it overall.“

“Excellent sub being the best prices in the area.“

“Great subs!!! Ribeye was fantastic!!!“

“I called my order of loaded fries no chipotle mayo. Came in paid and left. I got to my destination ready to eat and there’s chipotle mayo all over. I went back and spoke to the young lady at the counter with the cooper hair. I told her I wanted a refund because I called in my order and it was wrong she did offer to make me another but I refused due to the fact that if my order was messed up to begin with instead of letting me leave with it, the young man and young lady with the braids knew it was wrong but still bagged it as if everything was correct. They didn’t even offer an apology for their mistakes. I understand that mistakes happen but it should’ve been corrected before I even got there. Time and gas wasted because of laziness.

Update. I would like to make an update to my pervious review. First I would like to say the manager Alejandro is the only reason I’m updating my review. He was very attentive with resolving the issue and making sure I had a better experience than better. His attentiveness and care for the customer is something that isn’t found with a lot of businesses. His customer service was excellent.“

“great food and the people are usually pretty respectful but no matter how many times i tell them im just a man with long hair they still call me a woman
like just give me my sandwich i don’t care that you’ve never seen a man with long hair jesus christ
show me one woman named marshall im actually begging you at this point“

“Fantastic little spot with amazing food. It's a great foodie spot, and who doesn't love a tasty grilled cheese! Very plentiful with vegetarian options. It's a very small spot in a parking lot next to a park with trails and a small pond. Gentlemen, listen up. On a nIce day, this is a perfect spot to bring your partner for a date. You'll thank me later 😉

Kid-friendliness: Park right next doot“

“Subs are delicious, bread is always fresh and meats cut to order, roast beef, turkey and the Italian are favorites. Great options like Beeferella, the Eggplant and chicken Tikka cheesesteak were tasty too. Peter and his staff provide excellent service! Highly recommend“

“Everything they make is amazing. The sandwiches are bountiful. Fresh ingredients. My fav place“

“I love this place because every one is so welcoming. One thing though they need to better season their cutlet and maybe make them a bit thinner so they don’t dry out. They’re a bit thick and flavorless. The steak sandwich I had I really liked though“

“10/10! Found this gem on DoorDash. The Fries are crispy and shoe string like love! The Mac salad is too fire it’s absolutely delicious. And my sub (I’m a plain Jane girly) just good old ham, cheese, s&p, mayo, o&v just how I like it definitely will be ordering from here again. Next on my list is the cheesesteak“

“BIG SHOUT OUT TO PARSIPPANY JERSEY MIKES!!!! Can’t thank you enough for feeding 100 healthcare workers (at your own expense!) during these uncertain times..... YOU GUYS ARE AMAZING 😊😊♥️👍🏻🙏🏻 #peoplehelpingpeoplehelpingpeople #covid19wontwin“

“Tony Boys has amazing sandwiches but also generous and kind owners who give back to the community and schools. Their salads are good too but their hot sandwiches are phenomenal!“

“One of my favorite places to order better than Blimpie sandwiches, Roberto’s, nice and clean. The owner is the worker and the greatest sandwich maker ever I don’t say this about most places but if you’re looking for a great and tasty sandwich, this is the place to go.“

“very polite good customer service and The Sloppy Sub was awesome definitely a spot i will be coming back 🥪“

“Jersey Mike’s is a must. Very fresh.“

“Who’s ever idea It was to hire a bunch of Spanish ladies ready to work deserves a raise. I’ve been to this location more than once and everytime I go it’s always clean the ladies are very professional and attentive.
Constantly move around working. Sandwiches are good as well.“

“By FAR the best place to get a sub. Freshly sliced cold cuts, awesome service, and one of the friendliest places around !!“

“First time here and new to the area. I had no wait time. Smoke turkey and provolone sub was perfection. Soft fresh roll and all the veggies and meat was freshly sliced. I asked for specific items and they made it exactly like I asked.

Now the guy working that day can use some people skills (greet people, smile, saying thank you) but he did make an amazing hoagie. Someone just please tell him it’s ok to smile at paying customers 😁

The establishment has street parking, wide sidewalks and easy to see awning. Inside needs some cleaning, paint and new tiles. Nothing much to look more welcoming but the food is amazing, still.

No inside dining or bathroom. Some seats while you wait.

I also love the clear glass to see your sandwich being made. That’s so classic!

Will be back because summer is definitely for nice chilled subs.

They have hot food too!“

“I recommend all sandwiches but my favorite one is the chicken Caesar ciabatta sandwich. A salad but sandwich style. It’s so good it’s a must get. Workers there are friendly. I come here often for the corn muffins there the best I’ve ever had.“

“I had a honey turkey with yellow cheese mayo on both sides n everything on it seasonings included just forgot to add onions but not too much (next time ;-) oh yes and oil and vinegar on the side ...also do not forget the onion and garlic Wise chips 😋, let me not forget to shout out the JOE TEA (they have all flavors btw) on the side, and let me tell you I have to say the best sandwich I have had in a while and very tasty for sure!“

“Exxxcellent food, including ample portion size, all for very reasonable cost!“

“BEST FOOD AROUND! A++++++“

“Not up to Jersey Mike’s standards. Did not have chicken salad, got tuna sub that was poorly made. Over stuffed with tuna, mushy bread. Only ate half.

Update March 2026: Been back 3 times since bad experience. They must have had a bad day then. Each time now food is good, well prepared, and staff is friendly and efficient. Thank you 🙏 for improvements!“

“5 STARS First time there . Ate half of a half & very large portions Tuna w/Swiss let tom, onions peppers oil & vinegar. Best in a long time. Very friendly staff & place very clean. Would deffinitly recommend.Jersey Mikes. I think they also deliver!“

“I order from Subslingers often, whether it’s for lunch or to cater for a party, I’ve never been disappointed. I recommend the Destroyer Cold Sub. The ingredients are fresh, the bread is fluffy and the sandwich is always filled with lots of meat.“

“the hour n something minute trip is well worth it! I got myself a pizza bag to keep my food hot for the trip home! I'll make a few calls for orders for friends on my way home! The whole ensemble is perfect! nice n juicy peppers, onions and enough potatoes for that little side snack, a little extra grease to make the bread just right, not dry and dogs cooked to perfection! when you make the trip be sure to call friends to take their order! you know they're homesick and sure could use a great memory!“

“I needed to order a very nice lunch platter for a friend’s Shiva and the owner Jackie and her son went above and beyond to make it happen for my friend’s and me. They not only accommodated my request on a holiday weekend but were genuinely happy to help me. I heard the sandwiches were fantastic and beautifully presented. Thank you again, Jackie, and the staff at this wonderful deli! I will forever be grateful for your “can-do” attitude and service.“

“Come to this old fashioned place and you will have the best breakfast- home made style attended personally by the owner. Come and have great coffee and the best is…..the inexpensive price for a lot of food. Try the French toasts, omelettes, chicken parm over spaghetti. You will love it!!!!“

“I went to Jersey Mike’s today cause I haven’t had it in a while. The last time I had it I had a complaint this time I have it. I have another complaint first of all tuna fish is not supposed to be wet. I paid $10 for this sandwich and the most I got out of it was lettuce, tomatoes, and onions. I’m not trying to compare, but I was in North Carolina last month and got a Jersey Mike’s sandwich and I couldn’t even eat it all cause it was too much for me here I gotta eat the whole thing in order to taste it. It’s more bread than tuna second, I saw a young man in there behind the counter, grab condiments in his hand and walk to the back that to me was unsatisfactory because this is a restaurant a full restaurant and you walking away with condiments in your hand, going to the back how does that look for a customer? I don’t care if he was bringing it for his own or whatever I don’t know that’s just it. That’s why he shouldn’t have done that then the other man he’s steady constantly talking over your food. They don’t change their gloves unless you ask them, he dealt with a customer that was getting jalapeños all of this hot stuff and then gonna ask me man. What do you want in your sandwich? I want you to change your gloves. I just think that there should be some kind of a supervision when you at these restaurants Totally disappointed with this wet, tuna, fish sandwich, and it’s not even enough tuna fish on this bread. It’s more bread, lettuce, and tomatoes and onions than anything so nobody to do better.“

“I’ve been going to Bangiola’s for decades, but not so much lately. I was afraid that it might have gone downhill. I’m delighted to report that they’re still a great place to get a top-notch sloppy joe that beats them all at a much lower price. And I’ve tried them all! \n\nBangiola’s is located next to a gas station on Route 202 North between 10 and 46. There’s plenty of parking in the rear if the handful of spaces in front are occupied. There’s no place to eat inside. Their usual customers are the corporate types in the area during the week. You can pick up your lottery tickets, many off the beaten path beverages including Ensure, if you can believe it. Black and White cookies, too. It’s a nice old-fashioned NJ type deli, sandwich shop.\n\nGive it a try!\n\nPS - This software is really hard to work with.“

“I was doing a job out of town and stopped in on a wimb. 100% recommend stopping in if you are in the area. Food is delicious service is fantastic.“

“Exxxcellent food, including ample portion size, all for very reasonable cost!“

“This was such a nostalgic trip. I was so happy they were open and available. If you are looking for a good sandwich, head over to this Blimpie. The team that was working on Sunday November 3, 2024 mid day was excellent. There was so much love in my sandwich. It smiled at me when I opened it. That is what food is supposed to do when made appropriately. Will definitely be back sooner rather than later. I recommend the Blimp sandwich.“

“I been to subway alots of time first time i go to the online Elizabeth Ave and I ask for italian sub the 2 girls working there look at each other like what what is this guy talking about well finally my italian sub they whant it to put roast beef fist and last I go there again“

“Popped into Henry's Fine Foods to get take out sandwiches for my sister and I to get sandwiches to bring to my Mom's place. The have a descent sized seating area and a large we selection of convenience items.

We ordered BLTs and Grilled Cheese. Sandwiches were great and the 2 Team Members were wonderful !!!

They have a parking lot on Bloomfield Avenue which is a HUGE BONUS !!!“

“Asked for the "Kim" Salade... Its garden salad topped with one scoop each of egg, tuna and chicken salads! Add red onions, olives, carrots (shreaded in garden salade). Add what other ingredients you desire and enjoy. I personally like french dressing, sorry?

Alsooo, almost forgotten! Be prepared to take a nap! ?“

“Nana's is my go to place for sandwiches, back yard parties, and I hade my 78th birthday party in the new beautiful room. Jason and his staff did an outstanding job. The room is beautiful. The food was (of course) delicious, and the service provided by the staff was excellent. Needless to say I LOVE NANA'S“

“This was my first time visiting this establishment. Additionally, this was the first time I had a hot pastrami sandwich. I am so glad I went here for that experience. The portion size was nice, the people there helped guide me on how to customize my sandwich, and the sandwich was flavorful. I will definitely go back to check out the rest of their menu.“

“This place is a classic@ It's clean and everything is fresh. The cheesesteak and pastrami and cheese looked outstanding. I was thinking po' boy when I ordered the fried clams. This isn't New Orleans and I goofed.\nI strongly recommend Sandwiches Unlimited@“