50 Best Burger Restaurants near Milltown

“Been going here for years with my family. Good food and friendly staff. I also belong to a Car Club and we go there on Friday nights during the car shows and Monday nights in the winter time. Allie is our Bartender. She's the best! 🍻
1/24/2026 Still going to Applebee's Friday night during the Car Show season and most Friday nights during the winter months. Alexa and Kait are our Top Notch Bartenders now 👍🍻. Allie left a while ago.
7/3/2026 Went to Applebee's tonight with my Car Buddies. The Car Show was canceled due to the extreme high temperatures. We had a good time eating at the Bar. Alexa and Meli were our Bartenders. Kait left for sunny Florida 🌞“

“I mean it's certainly no five star restaurant but for fast food it seems like the most fresh. I heard claims that the Wendy's on Ryders Lane it's cleaner but I rarely go inside because I'm a drive-through kind of person. At least Wendy's is a place where I rarely have to return to the drive-through because they always screw you in the Drive-Thru... Maybe not so much at this place“

“Our go to burger place, love their crispy chicken burger, look forward to their new milkshake flavors!“

“Great burger! And the service was great as well. Love the location also.“

“What a gem of creative deliciousness! Definitely make reservations is you go on the weekend.“

“I work there service with attitude“

“Absolutely the best burger period!! Great fries and drinks! MILKSHAKES Yum!!“

“Best place in town 🤔 no, best place in entire county“

“Was impressed with the decor, service and food. The BBQ burger was cooked perfectly! Made with fresh meat (not frozen formed patty) - not sure whst the English would be but I know it in Yiddish as “hockfleish.” The BBQ sauce added to the taste of the meat without being overpowering and the onion, pickle, lettuce and the challah bun were all extremely fresh. Looking forward to coming back snd trying the other choices!“

“Absolutely loved the Indian fusion pizzas here — super flavorful and perfectly made for vegetarian and Jain preferences. Tried their Kathi rolls and burgers too, and everything was delicious. Great taste, great quality, and really kind service. Highly recommend!“

“Good food and drinks and comfortable atmosphere“

“Happy with my burger.“

“Visited on Saturday,Dec20th. It was a great surprise the food was well presented , delicious and large portions, the service was extremely helpful and even the chef came to say hello and asked if we were satisfied with what wee ordered. We strongly recommend this small but great restaurant.“

“I really love the food and the way they care for customers . You definitely can tell that they are passionate about their food. Would definitely go back for more !!“

“I’m vegan and this restaurant offered so many plant based options that literally no other burger place/fast food restaurant does. I ordered the spicy vegan plant based chicken burger and it was so delicious. A very nice inclusive place that made me feel welcome.“

“wow..Great pleasure to spend time here..I strongly recommend this place..Food was very delicious..atmosphere was phenomenal...Home like taste with generous serving...“

“Great food and service, has been coming here almost daily lately! Definitely recommend the zinger sandwich 🙏🏻“

“Cool electic vibes. Busy but cozy as well. I randomly was in the area and was looking for a quick latte before a meeting. This was 4 minutes away, really glad I went. Will go back again, I tried nootropic latte. It's got a cool clever twist with emphasis on neuro/ nootropic/ well being mixins.“

“First time back since 1973! Even better than I remember it. California cheese burger, fries and a soda. Served up in about 3 or 4 minutes, hot and fresh. I will not wait another 50 years to go back! LOL“

“Omg! These burgers are soooo flipping good! They take 2 days to eat, moderately priced and the taste of these burgers literally makes my mouth water every time I think about it! Finding a place that can properly cook impossible meat is hard to find but they nailed it! I got the impossible 30 burger and all I can say is OUT of this WORLD good! Please add this place to your list of places to go when visiting, you won’t be disappointed.“

“I had such an amazing experience at Shake Shack thanks to Jack! He truly went above and beyond to make sure our order was perfect. He was incredibly patient, kind, attentive, and made us feel genuinely taken care of. Jack did everything he could to make our experience a great one, and his customer service really stood out. It’s employees like him who make you want to come back. Thank you, Jack, for turning our visit into such a positive experience! Shake Shack is lucky to have you! ❤🍔“

“Excellent pizza 🍕 and a abundance of choices to select from - new to the neighborhood and I think we found our new pizzeria“

“I was told about Made Kitchen through my cousin in Georgia as this was something he saw on IG. So I had to check this out especially working so close by on Easton Ave. I visited Made Kitchen on 4/26 and again 4/27 and both times didn’t disappointed were super delicious. I got the King Caesar the first visit and Big Jerk Cheesesteak on the second visit. Both sandwiches are great in portions and I couldn’t finish it in one sitting. The King Caesar was fav for sure. That chicken was tasty and the lettuce was fresh. The Big Jerk was tasty as well. Jerk seasoning had the right of kick. So you can’t go wrong with either sandwich. I’ll probably get The Heavyweight or the Chopped Cheese next visit. TBD. But definitely hit this spot up if you in the area.“

“As a truck driver passing through New Jersey I came across Freddy’s off of US 1 and I had to do a review! The food was made fresh and it was delicious! I will be returning whenever I am passing through! I especially want to acknowledge the staff that was preparing and serving the food! Thank you so much for an impeccable experience! You all rocked!!!!!“

“Food was tasty and well presented, staff was friendly and helpful. Lots of options for breakfast, lunch or dinner. The fresh squeezed orange juice was delicious. We'll definitely be back.“

“I stopped by Stewart’s recently, and wow what an experience! From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with friendly smiles and that classic, welcoming atmosphere. The menu had everything I could hope for, from delicious burgers to perfectly crispy fries, and don’t even get me started on their shakes they’re thick, creamy, and absolutely delicious! You can tell the ingredients are fresh, and each item feels like it’s made with care.

The service was quick, but nothing felt rushed, which I loved. It’s clear that Stewart’s isn’t just about fast food; they’re about good food and good vibes. Perfect for families, groups of friends, or anyone craving a quality meal without breaking the bank. I can’t wait to go back! Highly recommend!“

“Amazingly delicious food with beautiful presentation and top notch quality and quantity! Love the environment, attentive/knowledgable staff, wait is beyond worth the food! Second time having lunch there with Addy personally coming around to make sure all customers were satisfied!“

“This is by far my favorite burger place. Everything always tastes fresh and the quality is always good. You can tell they actually care about the food. Their milkshakes are so good too. My favorites are the Dubai Chocolate, S’mores, Cherry Blossom when they had it, and Cookies & Cream. Their crinkle-cut fries are really good too. I always end up coming back.“

“The food is good. very happy with service. chicken was delicious. plenty of parking at night“

“The restaurant has a lovely, comfortable atmosphere. The food overall tastes fantastic. Their fried chicken and hamburgers are absolutely delicious and easily the highlights of my order.
The only tiny downside is the barbecue wings; they would be even better if they were juicier.
I am happy to give this place a full five-star rating. I will definitely come back again in the future.“

“Best in Metuchen! Go! Now! You will not be sorry! Great meal, great service and of course you get to visit with the owner, Dario Barone. Nothing better.“

“Hotdog was very good, got the original Texas weiner. Place was very busy with only 1 server. She was trying her best but was overwhelmed. Atmosphere was loud and crowded. Well worth the trip for the weiner!!

Parking: Free street parking“

“Very good service. Had the Turkey burger with fries.“

“Every time I’ve visited 418 Burgers it’s been a happy experience. The food is fresh & delicious & the staff is very courteous. 100% would recommend.“

“We came in from a long day, none of us were in a great mood, and we were all starving. I complimented an employees (Khadijah’s) nails and we had a great conversation. She was so funny and I could see how she lifted everyone’s mood before we were even eating. Amazing place, would recommend.“

“We needed a place to get together after a game with a lot of people. The Colonial didn’t hesitate when I said 20 people. We came and they sat us in the back so we could all be together. Phil and Pedro were an amazing team. They organized our checks by family and all of our food came out hot, fast and delicious. So very thankful for this option in the area!“

“Me and my job recently attended for the whole month of December every week and every week we had to do a review for the following week everyone at my job reported phenomenal service. They enjoyed the food and everyone said they would go back so we wrote it down for the future to attend again thank you Jamesburg diner.“

“👍👍👍👍👍👍👍😁😁😁👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍“

“Yes, it was to meet my friends and have brunch. Everything was great but they do need to tell you that they need to mention any fruits that goes on your pancakes or the side that they come cold that is my only complaint you have to let them know that you would like your fruits warmed up“

“** Stopped in today while I was out running errands to pick up a slice of their delicious Sicilian to go. I have to say it's the first time that I'm disappointed. An elderly man was pulling the slice with his bare hands onto a plate to put in a bag and then took my cash and gave me change and bills back. I wish he would have worn gloves if he's going to be touching money and then touching the pizza I'm going to be eating.**
Everything is delish from the drinks, appetizers, dinners, desserts! The best bloody mary's, clams casino, appetizer and the prime rib entree melts like butter, the mashed potatoes and gravy are amazing, and I usually don't like mashed. The tortoni dessert is delish, and the cappuccino too ! And if you want pizza, I suggest the Sicilian slice it's great !“

“You get more food for your money here,and food is delicious and Nicky the bartender was great“

“I told the owner if he gave me extra sauce, I would leave a better review. Without the sauces, this is one of the best Arthur Treacher’s Fish and Chip’s I’ve had in many years. Clean, Fresh and cooked to order! I definitely recommend this place and hope the quality and service doesn’t change. The only thing I would ask for is a bigger serving of COLE SLAW!“

“It's a tasty burger and fries, but the fresh drink selection and two kinds of pickled peppers at the condiments bar put this place above the other posh burger attempts. Their lettuce wrapped burger and vegan options are also respectable. Even the fries can be replaced with less starchy sides like zucchini fries or a salad, and you won't run into that everywhere.

Every year I seem to see different folks working there, but in all cases they were so friendly I wanted to talk to them, and so I noticed when the faces changed. I never noticed when a Five Guys face changed, so I have to think they have abnormally friendly staff.“

“Great food, awesome service, perfect ambiance!“

“Best pizza in New Jersey! I’m honestly surprised Dave Portnoy hasn’t come to rate this place a 10. Their pizza is incredibly crispy, and the ingredients are simple but high quality. They’re always making different pies throughout the day, so there’s always something fresh and delicious coming out.

The customer service is impeccable. I’m not from New Jersey, but every time I walk in, they treat me like family. They also have a great lunch special—two slices of any kind. I usually go for the vodka cheese and a pepperoni slice, and it never disappoints. Oh, and you have to try the sugar-free cream soda—it’s so good!

100/10 would recommend!“

“I am an everyday satisfied customer, after a long day of work I come here to dine in, they have the absolute freshest food materials and the cleanest place ever, they are super respectful and friendly, they have a beautiful variety of choices you can make, they make they food 100% from scratch to the toppings, best restaurant I have been in they have great prices as well the best.
They also let you pick up or they give free delivery after a certain amount, they put so much effort in their food it’s so tasty, best restaurant on French st.
Do NOT FORGET TO TRY THEIR FRESH WATER/ Aguas frescas they have variety of flavors my top 4 favorite would be Horchata, Limon y pepino, Passion fruit and Pineapple, their drinks are all fresh and made the same day they never reuse from last night, they have 100% best service & food.“

“a melhor padaria e Lanchonete Brasileira dos Estados unidos com os mrlhores Salgado e Pratos feitos“

“I have been here a total of 3 times in the last month & they have messed up my order every time… either the wrong order completely or missing items… add that to the usual lunch hour wait & yes… they need to improve the customer experience..“

“Great food, excellent service. Marisela treats us like family“