Custom Cakes near Milltown, NJ

“This is my happy place. I come here faithfully because they always provide me with great service. They made a mistake on an order once and they made it right. Thank you for always honoring my request for the chocolate devotion with no chocolate chips“

“I’ve ordered from this place three times for special family events in the always delivered. The cakes are awesome! I ordered cupcakes as well. This time for my grandson‘s birthday and they did not disappoint. I’m looking forward to using them to my go to for all my events.“

“I'm a regular customer and the cakes I get from them never disappoints! They're affordable compared to other bakeries around the area, and with a small household like ours we don't need a huge cake for celebrations. Their size and portions are just right for us. The weekend specials are such good deals so we always keep an eye on what they would be each month. Staff is always friendly and helpful. I'm pretty sure at this point they remember me considering how often I stop by lol.“

“Everything I got was so delicious! I'm very picky with chocolate chip cookies as I am an experienced baker myself, but the nutella filled cookie definitely hit the spot and passed my approval :) the brownie bar was super fudgy and not too sweet. I'll be a returning customer for sure!“

“I ordered a custom cake and it came out even better than i could have imagined! The cake matched the photo I sent in perfectly- actually even better! The icing was so smooth (not fondant, as requested), the handmade decoration and flowers were elegant and the intricate pipework was skillfully done. I am so impressed, I will only order cakes from Yelida Bakes from here forward. Bonus, this is a small owner run business, so I am supporting a small, local business.“

“My experience with this bakery was the most amazing amazing and very heartfelt as well as the very talented baker did an amazing cake for my grandmother, and also included a piece of my mom who recently passed a symbol of her. I highly recommend this bakery to everyone and anyone, she is absolutely talented. Amazing customer service and truly listens to exactly what you want and your vision you want she gets it on point. Not to mention everything was so fresh a delicious you couldn’t even tell it was for made for diabetic. I’m so happy definitely going back!!!Dietary restrictions: She can make a cake made with Splenda an Safe for diabetic's“

“Thank you for this beautiful cake. I was not getting any bakery to bake me a cake for my daughters birthday due to the holidays and everything being booked but Baker squared was able to do this beautiful and delicious cake last minute. Thank you so much everyone loved it especially myself. Definitely will be ordering again.“

“I ordered a custom sheet cake for my daughter’s birthday and the store did a great job. We had a design and swapped one of the flavors out from their originals. The additional costs were very reasonable and the cake looked great! We live a bit far so I couldn’t come in person to order it but was able to communicate with the owner via email and phone. We were super happy with it and would definitely order from them again.“

“- Lot of parking- This was my 2nd visit, clean store very colorful and appealing products- lot of options for vegetarian and eggless cakes, lot of variety of eggless cakes- Pricing is pretty steep high- They don’t allow you to taste, but since I am spending $70-$90 on your product you don’t allow to taste what if I don’t like, biggest drawback.“

“Great tiramisù, the cake foundation is very creative. Why La Bon and not Le Bon? La Bonne? Singular feminine La Bonne Patisserie, Boulongerie all feminine nouns?Mystery solved: "la bonbonnière", feminine noun, shortened to La Bon. Meaning candy dish or candy maker. (Not the adjective bon/bonne)“

“Selection is small (S. Plainfield location) but is ALWAYS delicious. Red velvet cheesecake is amazing. Get one every year for my birthday! The weekly and monthly specials are super affordable and we love them. Just wish that the pizza foccacia was year round, because that thing is BOMB. My go to place when the sweet tooth strikes!“

“This location-Morganville rocks! The ice cream is always so fresh and delicious. The people who work at this store is so friendly and knowledgeable. They are very aware of how to deal with Peanut and all nut allergies! Denise is awesome and truly goes above and beyond. Just made a custom cake and the way it was decorated was awesome.Dietary restrictions: All nuts allergy“

“Best icecream always; loved their new summer menu and overall collection of icecream. It is must try icecream whereever you find it's shop. This location has vsry curteous and understanding staff you can take your time to order. Good thing they had all ingredients and toppings.“

“It was my first time ever going to a Coldstone and after the experience I had, I plan on coming back to this one again. The worker (Gabby) was so nice and helpful when it came to making sure I got exactly what I wanted! She also made it super fun to watch how my ice cream combo was made! Definitely a 10/10 recommend.“