50 Best Italian Restaurants near Peapack

“Delicious food! Great staff!“

“Had a fantastic Valentine’s dinner at Bistro Seven Three in Bernardsville last night! Food was unbelievable and the service was friendly and really attentive! Thanks! We’ll be back!“

“Food and service consistantly great. Daily specials are varied and well presented. Sweet and spicey calamari is best ever. Our server Niti was outstanding.“

“Food is excellent. Nice Place to eat.“

“Always fantastic !! Private party rooms or romantic dining room or patio or bar tv seating … always fun delicious and warm lovely staff and cocktails“

“Beautiful alfresco dining weather permitting. Dinner never disappoints all selections excellemt. Best mussels ever. It’s not about the mussels but about the sauce which is FABULOUS.“

“This place is great. You have got to try the million dollar bacon.“

“Food is Delicious. Nice Place.“

“bensi is my favorite restaurant. the staff is always welcoming and the food is absolutely amazing“

“We've been ordering here for a while now. It's one of the better NY/NJ style pizzas in the area without being too specialized.Their pasta and meat menu items are where they are best - looking at you Chicken Puicinella and Cavatelli with Broccoli.For appetizers, they have great wings which are crispy, the way I like them. Also, the fried calamari uses a very light batter, so it's not too heavy.We've ordered trays from them twice for parties and we weren't disappointed in the quantity provided and they were affordable.“

“I agree that the food and service are superb but while dining out with friends it is very rude to rush us out while still eating dessert and coffee. Cleaning off the table and bringing the bill while we were still eating to move us along. We had a reservation just like the people waiting to get in.“

“Absolutely delicious food and great service. Always a great date night out with hubby. Adrian makes it a point to greet, visit your table & watch over all details start to finish. Wonderful owner. Our go to place.“

“Excellent food, great Chef!!!!!“

“Very Good Italian Food. Always Delicious.“

“Food is great. Friendly staff. Love their cappuccino!“

“Buen servicio, excelente dinner y aperitivos, mi familia todos contentos y en especial mi esposa la del cumpleaños. Gracias.“

“best vodka sauce i’ve ever had
family owned establishment that takes pride in their service!

highly recommend and will definitely be going back soon

Vegetarian options: they are very very accommodating!“

“Food was amazing … Fast and delicious“

“Freddy's Pizza is REALLY good! We also love their garlic knots, calamari, chicken francese and more! If you haven't tried this place yet, you should.“

“Loved the warm atmosphere, food was delicious, and service impeccable.“

“Staff is very welcoming & attentive. Food is amazing!“

“Great restaurant. The food is unbelievable and the people are super nice“

“Beautiful and charming. Attentive staff and great food. My salmon was a little dry however. When we entered we were hit with a blast of very loud conversations. My husband and I couldn't hold a conversation and had a stressful experience. Very loud restaurant experience.“

“Was there for the first time last night, what a wonderful experience! The service was great, Franchesca was very friendly and attentive and the food was absolutely delicious. One of the best Italian food I’ve ever had. If you are looking for great food and service, definitely visit this place!“

“Stopped here for lunch. Food was excellent and very much enjoyed the antipasto bar. Place was very clean and welcoming and service was great. The only thing we didn't like was the boardwalk pizza- zero flavor so that was a little disappointing. If we are in the area again, we would definitely stop here for lunch or dinner for their delicious meals, salads and antipasto bar!“

“Everything we have ordered from DaNapolis has been excellent...pizza, Chicken Francese, Shrimp Scampi, etc., everything is perfect. By far the best in the area.“

“Love the vibe in this restaurant. Black ink pasta was amazing.“

“Best wings in the area. I always get the slammin hot and ask them to add some sauteed garlic to the sauce. It's a game changer. Great family restaurant and bar. I've had drinks with adults and had wonderful family meals with my toddlers. Great service and the prices are reasonable.“

“We have been here couple of times and we love the lunch menu

We tried these dishes and all we had were 5/5

- Breadsticks
- Minestrone Soup
- House Salad
- Eggplant Parmesan
- Chocolate Lasagna“

“Benito's is on my list a favs. I have never had a bad meal and the service is always great!“

“We had dinner here recently and loved it! My son and his best friend had the meatballs and clams as appetizers. My son had the pasta carbonara + loved it. I had the cavatelli with broccoli rabe, The pasta tasted homemade and the broccoli rabe was prepared perfectly. I'm vegetarian so they left out the sauage for me. Our friend got a pizza and loved it. Our cocktails were great too! Cynthia who acted as both our bartender and server really took great care of us!“

“Best food ever I loved it“

“This was my first time here and everything was great! Sandwiches, stuffed peppers, potato salad and the sausage wheel with provolone.“

“Thank you Sapori for the amazing food you made for my family Father's Day party! The Baked ziti was so cheesy good, the green salad fresh & crisp, bruschetta was crunchy & lots of topping, & shrimp scampi garlic yum! the service was so friendly! Many Blessings to your family from Ken & JoAnne Betz xo“

“Gio's came with recommendations, used them to cater my Mom's 85th birthday party. Everything was ready on time and the food was delicious!!!! I will be using in the future for sure! Thank you ..Mom loved it and was so happy and surprised!“

“Great Food. Nice outdoor area to dine.“

“This HAD to be one of the best pizza I had in a long time. Rumors have it in the pizza world, is you ever wanna try a places best pizza always order a personal pie, that will tell you how they really are. So I ordered a personal Mushroom, Plain and a specialty one. Let me tell you this, IF you like a good crunch pizza..... On every bite.... Good flavor that stands tall..... This is the place to go.... ABSOLUTELY, so far, one of the best around.... This hole in a wall will surprise the s#$& out of you. Next time I will go for a full size pie and tell you how that goes....It will be interesting... I have been in places where I love there personal size and didn't like there full size....and let me add..... It was so good that I ate the personal Mushroom before I got home and I love down the road in Morristown... That's how good this wasI AM TELLING YOU if you like a crunch to your pizza, and you eat the whole slice.... This places personal pie is just for you....The two guys behind the counter was extremely nice... One had to be the owner, a bigger guy great personality and knew his stuff.... And the counter guy was just as nice and eager to help....So I have no dog in this fight.... Did I get lucky, maybe maybe not.... I will go back and order the large and definitely a person for the ride home.... It will be interesting.... But this is a true review.... Thanks to the guys who made the pies....“

“Lots of pizza places to choose from in Long Valley, but this is our go-to. Love their pizza! And staff so friendly. For the 3rd year in a row, they let the middle school play have their cast party there. The kids run around on the grass and pizza and drink soda. Pizza has long been consumed, but they let us stay and celebrate and eat cake long after they have closed. Very supportive of kids and the community. I'm happy to recommend them!“

“Highly recommend the Calabria (eggplant/roasted peppers) pizza. Moved away to MD and love a chance to stop at Lenny’s when we are back in town.“

“We ordered chicken in lemon sauce and chicken with mushrooms. Alongside this, we were served a vegetable salad and pasta (at our request). It was possible to order another supplement. The place is intimate and gives a family Italian atmosphere. Highly recommend this place ❤️❤️❤️

Parking: We arrived at 15:30 and there was parking available on the street in front of the restaurant. There was no problem finding parking“

“Excellent food and service. Our staff holiday luncheon has been held there for years. The staff gets a choice - and their choice every years is to continue to go there!“

“Best sandwich I have ever had! I highly suggest the Grilled Chicken with Fresh Mozz and Roasted Peppers. Cute and cozy place with friendly staff and great prices. I will definity be back!“

“It is a cozy space, where they make you feel welcome, the food is delicious and the prices are fair.

Wheelchair accessibility: There is perfect handicap access; In fact, one of my companions was in a wheelchair; Our waiter placed us where he would be comfortable, in addition to not being in anyone's way.“

“Searching around the area for pizza 2 places came up I decided to stop here . I was met by the owner on her own making pizza , garlic knots and a few more things . What a hard working woman. The pizza was amazing , the garlic knots amazing . My coworkers loved their meals . She chatted with us for a little bit , gave a little history , and how she takes pride in what she does and what comes out that kitchen and oven . Definitely recommend this place . Keep doing a great job and thanks for the great customer service . See you soon !!!“

“My boyfriend and I visited from out of town. We really enjoyed their pizza. Our favorite was the buffalo chicken and bbq chicken pizza. The men in there were friendly. We'd go back. :)“

“Pizza was amazing and calamari was out of this world“

“This is 5:00 p.m. on a Sunday afternoon that my wife and I visited this restaurant an older gentleman waited on us took our order for a flatbread pizza and two sodas does sodas were served 20 oz size bottles with ice. The pizza came out quickly and we ate everything but two pieces. Quality was excellent. Service was a little slow and I had to ask another person to get our check cuz we had to pick up somebody at 6:00. I recommend the food as the wood fire smell and quality was great.“

“Visiting from Virginia. 5 Star from us! If you’re looking for a good pizza pie this is the place!“

“Looks like a regular pizzeria but offers a variety of Italian fair; we have come here for many years and food and service is always excellent.

Vegetarian options: Ask for the waiter to prepare the pasta the way you prefer it.“

“Pizza always great!!! Love the Sicilian“