17 Best Italian Restaurants near Tuckerton

“Incredible food and service! This family business is the absolute best place to eat in Tuckerton. CLASSIC Italian food that is made with heart!Definitely try out their breads and cheese made fresh DAILY! Small warning, this business is cash only, but has an ATM outside of the shop for those with cards.Parking: Limited parking“

“The Grapevine has drastically improved!!Haven’t been here for quite a few years.Service was outstanding as was the food!!Food:Eggplant appetizer was excellent. The eggplant was crispy on the outside, tender on the inside. Mozzarella and tomato topping was flavorful. All around great app.Mozzarella sticks were fat and cheesy!!Dinners:Linguine with clams was delicious. Mixture of both whole and chopped.Chicken parm was equally as good. Big portions cooked perfectly.Chicken Murphy was excellent.You get a salad or soup with your meal.Prices are reasonable.Definitely going back now!!!“

“First time here. Very impressed! Very nice restaurant in a small strip mall. Excellent service as well as food. They have a small but varied menu. I ordered the Hanger steak and my wife had the chicken franchise. Delicious! We don't live in the area, but would love to return sometime.“

“Having grown up in Brooklyn I appreciated Neil and his great Neapolitan pizza-making. Eddie and the whole crew are a credit to Neil's legacy. All varieties and styles of pizza are A+ here. And they don't rat you out if you buy extra slices to eat on the way home. They even make a ❤-shaped pizza year round, if asked. All Manahawkin owes Anthony's a delicious, big thanks!“

“Had a really great dinner here this past Saturday. My wife and I both, my son had chicken with broccoli pasta in a white wine cream sauce. My daughter had rigatoni in oil and garlic. We also had a Cesar salad and their tomato tortellini soup. Everything was good, the soup was fantastic. Our waitress was also really great and attentive. I would definitely come back again.“

“Once again Isola did not disappoint! The food, service and ambiance were exceptional! If you have not tried the stuffed olives for an appetizer, they are a MUST! We also shared the fig pizza which was done to perfection! For dinner, my one cousin and I had the Spaghettini a la Arrabbiata ( a new item on the men) and was DELICIOUS! The rest of my family had the Branzino and short ribs which were out of this world! From entering the restaurant, my family and I were greeted enthusiastically ( and with a big smile!) by Bella at the front desk, we were seated promptly and our server Maureen, continued that warm and enthusiastic hospitality once we were seated and that same level of hospitality continued throughout our time dining. This is by far my favorite restaurant on the island! Thank you so much for another fabulous dining experience with exceptional food and service!! We will be back soon!“

“Just had a slice of Grandma's pie from Naples in Tuckerton. I'm 75 years old and have eaten a lot of pizza over the years including during the two years I was stationed in Naples, Italy. Their pie is absolutely the best pizza I have ever had both here in the States and in Italy.That's sayin' something.“

“Happy New Year!Enjoyable evening with friends and family for our second New Year's Eve. Robert and his family have always gone out of their way to make our dining experiences special and have had many celebrations at the restaurant. We plan to have many more.“

“This place is awesome! I went on Thursday, and they have a deal where two people get an appetizer, soup/salad, entree, and cannoli for only $40 (plus the warm, fresh bread they give you!). Such a deal! The food was awesome, and there was live music as well. I loved the atmosphere. It’s BYOB, so make sure you bring your favorite bottle of wine. Cheers!“

“It has been many years since we have been to Olive Garden. Let me tell you the experience we had last night was awesome. We had a server who was brand new so she was a little off, but she was very good. The food was fantastic. Really had a good time and a good celebration.Kid-friendliness: There is a high emphasis on kids. When we arrived, we asked real quickly for a mac & cheese and a spaghetti dinner for the two little ones and that came right away along with orange juice and lemonade. Plus they had some crayons and something to color right off the bat.“

“I recently got a cheesesteak from Slice of Heaven. This cheesesteak was absolutely amazing. I don't know who made it but I would consider giving them a raise. I ate half for dinner and then half for lunch and the quality both times was amazing. Thank you Slice of Heaven. I will be coming back to get another cheesesteak very soon.“

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐What can I say about this gem of a pizza place? From the moment you walk in, you're greeted with warmth and hospitality. ? The family-run atmosphere adds an extra layer of charm, and you can tell that every dish is made with love and care. The food? Absolutely delicious! ? Whether you're a fan of classic pies or adventurous toppings, they've got you covered.But what really sets this place apart is their dedication to supporting the community. ? It's evident in everything they do, from sourcing local ingredients to supporting fundraisers. It's rare to find a business that truly gives back like this.Overall, if you're looking for amazing pizza, a welcoming atmosphere, and a place that cares about its community, look no further. This place is a must-visit! ?2 amazing sisters ❤️“

“Made a reservation for a birthday, party of ten. They had us all set up in a big room with a server ready to go as soon as I got there. Wine glasses, ice buckets c water, etc. Emily was a gem! Service was perfect. We all ordered different items. Everyone loved their food. I had the shrimp francais. Best I ever had, and I'm picky because I cook a lot. Food was nice and hot . After dinner our plates were cleared and Emily wrapped all our leftovers for us. Highly recommend Pietros for your next dinner choice .“

“Some people love fast food, I love pizza! This place has been around forever and I always heard such great things. When my daughter was a senior during the pandemic they had an adopt a senior program and the senior I adopted wanted a Ray's pizza because he loved it. Finally I got a chance to try it out. I'm not going to lie it's a bit of a dive but clean.The people are extremely pleasant and it seemed to be a family run business.Straight out of the oven our delicious thin crusted pizza came out and we started to drool just a little. Compared to some thin crust pizza places I would consider this pizza to be medium in crust, they used real cheese because the pizza actually had oil coming off.A bunch of pizza places have got cheap using cheap mozzarella or adding provolone,this place used good cheese! The first slice I had was delicious but after that the second the sauce was a little sweet. I think I devoured my first slice. Overall this pizza place deserves a solid 4!!I would definitely go again.“

““Mama Maria’s Pizzeria is a delightful spot that locals cherish and visitors must try when in West Creek. The pizzeria delivers a cozy and welcoming atmosphere, perfect for family dinners or a casual hangout with friends. Their menu offers a variety of classic and innovative pizza options, each made with fresh, high-quality ingredients that bring out the authentic Italian flavors. The crust is cooked to perfection - crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. Whether you opt for a traditional cheese pizza or venture into their specialty pies, you won’t be disappointed. Beyond pizza, they also serve a range of appetizers, calzones, strombolis, and more, ensuring there’s something for everyone. With great food, friendly service, and a commitment to the community, Mama Maria’s stands out as a top choice for anyone craving a slice of comfort in West Creek.”“

“I had take out at Nicks pizza yesterday and everything was excellent! Marco the owner is friendly and very accommodating. Chicken franchise had so much flavor and delicious. Chicken parm and spaghetti was so good too! And the zeppolis!!! Sooo good! Thank you for the delicious food and great service. Definitely recommend“

“Really nice and friendly staff. We are from a place where pizza is king so I cannot be too hard on them. I think the food was all very good and above average for sure. It was not something I would run back for, but would eat again in a pinch. I'm happy we tried this place and sprinkled a little business their way. Pizza and sandwiches were just what we needed after a long day at the beach.“