50 Best Ice Cream Shops near Warren

“The property was outstanding for the location in a very ritzy area. The food was great. Ordered the special for 2 with two glasses of wine, an appetizer ?, and a main course dish that was shared for two. The waiter was a little anxious to rush the order in before 9 PM. Great service and the price was pretty high, but overall experience was great! Definitely will come back again!“

“I love Rita's no matter which location, however I need to leave a review for the staff here. Two young ladies, one with a ponytail and a huge smile who was so good with everyone she served. Funny and charming and legitimately enjoys her job.“

“Fun icecream flavors: Black Sesame Durian (limited by the pint only) Milk Tea Thai Tea Lychee Taro Ube“

“Thank you for being a part of our Easter day! Our Easter ice cream pie was amazing!!“

“Gaby was super helpful and attentive. I wasn’t sure which percent of dark chocolate I would like so she was able to explain the difference between 60,75 and 85% of dark chocolate. She also mentioned the loyalty program that no one had previously mentioned so I was able to join! Looking forward to coming back !“

“I had a really great experience visiting Egypt Oasis today with my two children. The staff was so friendly and attentive. And the owner Mo introduced himself and was clearly passionate about his business. I was waiting on by Ella and she spent the time talking to my son about his sports. The business is very clean and they have so many selections. We all had the rolled ice cream but I noticed people in the store getting boba tea. There is much variety to choose from in a really cool atmosphere with cards at the tables. We will definitely be back!!“

“What a scoop indeed!! 72 flavors! Creamy, delicious, super tasty. This is an amazing place with friendly, patient people and generous scoops at a great price.
Accessible ♿️, with a few tables inside. Family with lots of kids having a great time at lunch when we visited. We took our icecream to go, and just walked around the town. They had at least 6 different chocolate ice cream!! It was heavenly!“

“Today is Chocolate Milkshake Day! Wishing you a great day filled with sweet moments. 😊🥳😋“

“My family will often drive here from Madison and Madison has their own ice cream shop. The ice cream here is fresh and tasty. Large portions and you can sit outside and enjoy your ice cream. Friendly staff although they are often very busy. I like the Coffee Oreo and the Chocolate Thunder was really good.“

“Absolutely in love with the taste of the fresh creamy delicious ice cream. The owner hit the jackpot with their staff, they all provide a perfect scoop and just the right amount. Would definitely recommend anyone looking for a tasty treat.

Vegetarian options: Large selection of vegetarian options

Dietary restrictions: Many non dary options

Kid-friendliness: The staff was so nice to my kids“

“great ice cream so worth the wait“

“Love the place Great selection Great service“

“Thank you for making the BEST cake!! I came in a few hours before graduation and asked to decorate the cake on each side. The woman who decorated the cake did an amazing job!“

“We came past 10:30pm and they close at 10:30, they were super sweet, nice and attentive. They let us in and order everything we wanted, food was amazing, we had the mango crepe cake and drinks 10/10. Packaging is beautiful, reusable and well presented. Loved it, would recommend and will come back ???“

“McCool's is my family's go to for a wonderful cold treat and a relaxed and pleasant atmosphere. The flavors are absolutely delicious and consistently exciting, sure to please all taste buds. They are always coming up with innovative and delicious drinks, toppings and flavors! I would like to thank Paul the manager for always going above and beyond for my family. His service and kindness makes all the difference. He truly cares about each customers experience and ensures all leave happy! Thank you McCool's for making us feel like family.“

“Lots of flavor variety. Wish the sugar free/ NSA flavors were listed on the menu .“

“First of all, yum, secondly-they are so nice! The staff is super helpful and nice! Third of all-they have dog treats! Anytime I'm walking a dog by there and it's open I stop in to get the doggie a treat. Always, always, wonderful. Love this place!“

“It's not really summer until you get your dairy quick fix. If you like Magic Fountain however you want to negate the ridiculously long lines then here is your chance. I'm actually surprised this hasn't become a popular hot-spot among the summer ice cream devotees. Only a matter of time before the word gets out...“

“We have been enjoying this gem of an ice cream shop for decades. Nick and his family treat you like part of their family. The ice cream is homemade. The cones are homemade. The brownies are homemade. There is a theme here. You are in for a gastronomic desert delight! Get to Magic Fountain today! I promise you will want to come back again and again! So many flavors and so little time. Thank you Nick and family for keeping the tradition alive! God Bless America! God Bless Blue & Gold! Remember Everyone Deployed Everyday!“

“gelatis!! ☺️ are the best thing!“

“Great place! Friendly staff“

“Have yet to experience their food food but I had their ice and it was amazing. Brought my whole family there and I can easily see this being a new tradition to go there every time they make the new seasonal flavors because they got some wild flavors that pair perfectly.“

“They have the best lemon italian ice. Perfect balance between frozen and creamy texture. I make sure to come here whenever I am in town. Better than anything else I've tried on the east coast! **Cash Only!**

Dietary restrictions: Italian ices are dairy free.

Wheelchair accessibility: 100% accessible although YMMV for counter service height.“

“Karin was so helpful in coordinating a large cupcake order for my mom's birthday party. The cupcakes were both delicious and beautiful. We did not get a chance to get any pictures because people took them so fast! Karin's bakery also offers gluten free options which were also delicious. 10/10 and would go back!“

“I saw this place and wanted to try it out. I got the vanilla with peanut butter and caramel add in and graham cracker topping. You can have up to 5 toppings. The ice cream was pretty good. Once he was done it was pretty hard. I had to let it soften a little. I would recommend this place. I definitely want to go back.“

“Tiny location, packs a pearl.... comedy. ?I love their Thai Tea Boba and their waffles are amazing ?? whether you like croffles or their house made (?) batter. All smoothies I've had have been delicious as well as their Dolgona(hope I'm spelling that right) coffee boba! SUPPORT THIS BUSINESS??tons of parking btw!“

“love the bubble tea and general atmosphere“

“Amazing! I just found my favorite pizza shop! If you’re looking for traditional jersey pie, you’re going to be disappointed.“

“Ice cream - both hard & soft-serve, ice pops, and other frozen treats with all the trimmings and toppings. They also have an eclectic mix of candies and toys, plus a few trinkets and gift items. Prices are comparably reasonable. Located right on Hamilton Street with plenty of on site parking. The service is outside (thru windows), so they're not always open on the colder days. But it's a great place to hang out on one of the benches when the sun is warm. It feels good supporting local business, too.“

“If you’re craving Indian food that hits all the right notes, "Saffron" is the place to go!
Saffron special kofta was super delicious & wow .The dumplings were tender and filled with subtle spices. Paneer methi garlic is an absolute treat . Tandoori Malai Broccoli & Pani puri were outstanding.
But the real star of the night? The hot brownie with ice cream. It arrived sizzling, with the brownie perfectly gooey in the middle and crisp on the edges.
The service was top notch & the Staff was super helpful . Everything from the cleanliness to the beautifully plated dishes reflected attention to detail.
This restaurant has it all—flavors, hospitality, and even the perfect dessert to end the meal on a high note.

Vegetarian options: They have lots of Jain & Swaminarayan options.“

“Cute, dainty shop with your standard boba drinks. The workers were extremely friendly and patient! I got two refreshing fruity drinks. I like the star shaped chewy toppings — made the drink fun to consume. Perfect for a hot day!

Plenty of free parking out front.“

“This was my first time having a mochinut and it was absolutely delightful!!! Their taro mochinut has been my favorite flavor so far. The texture is sooo good. It's both chewy like mochi and doughy like a donut, the perfect mixture of both! Not too heavy and not too sweet. And their variety of flavors is amazing and unique! I can't wait to go back and have some more. I can tell the staff there work hard to pump out all these donuts and with such quality too! Please keep doing what you're doing!“

“Amazing ice cream, staff is super friendly“

“I have been coming here since I was a kid. The absolute best ice cream in the county. You won't be disappointed.“

“I was seen very quickly by the staff and they answered all of my questions about sizes and specials. Kyle happened to be the gentleman who helped me. He was quick and polite. A real pleasure. I felt really bad that I was unable to tip him or the great staff there using my card. Knowing that most don’t carry cash after Covid-19 (because let’s be honest, money was dirty before the pandemic) it seems unfair that the staff is unable to get tips via another method. People who work customer service jobs deserve to be able to receive tips for making sure the customers are taken care of. Thank you so much to the staff for always being polite and quick with every order we requested.“

“I arrived after 9:00pm on a Tuesday night and we live like 1 mile away and have been coming to this Rita's for years. The staff is always amazing, but tonight I was served by Abby (Abbie?), who after the transaction was completed asked "what is your name? It was very thoughtful coming from a young girl. She was so sweet. I wanted someone to know. We will continue to come back for the wonderful ice and custard.“

“This was my first time but not my last. The place is small but very nice. The ice cream was delicious and what I enjoy the most they had choco-banana which is banana cover in chocolate. A hispanic type of food. Delicious. Overall the workers where nice and very polite, I will definitely come back but I wish the outside had a better representation.“

“So my family ordered sundaes. We didn't realize how generous the portions were. The quality of the ingredients was very good. We took home what we couldn't finish. The young lady that took care of us was very quick and efficient. She definitely needs a raise.“

“This place has the best Lychee frozen yogurt I’ve had in my life. I dream about it. 5 stars if they keep it on the menu more cuz it’s been gone for a bit. It’s truly a transformative experience. ?

** update they have the Lychee 07/12 ??? SO GOOD“

“Always had great service and italian ice.“

“gelatis!! ☺️ are the best thing!“

“I highly recommend this store location. Keith was extremely helpful and knowledgeable with my order. I had it sent as a gift and it was a big hit!“

“There were 4 vegan flavors when I went (watermelon sorbet, mango sorbet, oatly vanilla, and oatly latte). I enjoyed all of them. For toppings, I got wet walnuts, which were very delicious, and oreo pieces. There used to be vegan cookie dough bites that I really enjoyed, but I didn't see them this time (there were cookie dough bites, but not labeled as vegan). I would like some more vegan flavors and toppings to make this place even better.“

“Place is very clean, food is absolutely delicious and their smoothies are amazing. I get this around 3-4 times per week and have only good things to say about this place. Food comes out fast and their delivery prep through Ubereats is very good as nothing is ever spilled

Parking: Parking is a bit tough as it is on a very busy street. If you go around the block towards supremo supermarket you’ll be able to find a wider variety of parking.“

“Rita has always been my favorite spot to eat frozen custards and ice creams, but recently, I discovered this Rita here in Berkeley Heights, and it is such a good spot. There is plenty of parking right in front of it so that you sit in a car and enjoy it. Service is quick and efficient, and ice creams are amazing as always.“

“I order ahead and pick up. My experiences have been pleasant, as it is usually ready by the time I walk in to pick-up. The staff is nice. I absolutely am a fan of the shroomburger and their fries. I mix mayo and ketchup 1:4 parts to dip my fries in. Highly recommended.“

“Went here this afternoon and the gentleman at the window was so nice, patient and accommodating. He even has dog biscuits at the window for your pup! I don’t have a dog but I appreciate the gesture. I’m thinking he might be the owner but I’m not sure. Definitely 10/10 Will return!“

“This place have some Amazing verity of flavors . They have so many verity of toppings also. Service is good . Price is average . They have some seating inside and outside of the store too. They also have a handful number of frozen yogurt too.“

“OMG! On an afternoon when it would have been TOTALLY OK to close up shop during a family/owner emergency, a sweetheart of a lady saw two 9-year olds sweaty and craving Rita’s as she was locking the doors to attend to an emergency. She unlocked the doors and showed me and my kids the heart we’re all hoping to see these days!! The registers were shut, doors locked, ice covered, etc. These gals couldn’t have been sweeter and I’m forever grateful for their selflessness. ????“

“So good, You will want to build a snowman. Maybe after a hard day of the office, grab a FROZEN delight. It's never a bad tIme to Let It Snow, Let it snow!We were impressed with service from a 19 year old with a great professional demeanor and a vocabulary to match. Groom this employee, he has the right stuff.“