50 Best American Restaurants near West Milford

“Charming Atmosphere, Delicious Food, and Top-Notch Service at Country Cottage!

I recently had the pleasure of dining at Country Cottage, I was charmed by the warm, cozy atmosphere. The décor set the perfect tone for a relaxing meal.

The service was outstanding—attentive, friendly, and efficient without being overbearing. It’s clear that the staff takes pride in making sure guests have a wonderful dining experience.

I’m already looking forward to my next visit!“

“Had lunch there with my wife my cheese burger platter was excellent. Marlene had a dog all way and onion rings excellent. Coffee was good. Nice place .going return soon.“

“Love this place the food the service the atmosphere!“

“Practicing social distancing and offering car service!! Support responsible local businesses; they need us now more than ever!!“

“Some of the best wings I've ever eaten, with some stellar service.“

“Sunrise Family Restaurant is hands down one of my favorite places to eat! I’ve been going there for a while now and it never disappoints. I like to call it a hidden treasure in the neighborhood. The minute you walk in, you feel like part of the family — the staff is so warm, welcoming, and truly wonderful. The menu is HUGE, the food is always delicious, and the prices are more than fair. If you’re looking for a new go-to spot, this is it! Do yourself a favor and stop in — you’ll feel right at home and leave with a full belly and a big smile!“

“I recently had the pleasure of dining at this place, and I must say, it was an extraordinary experience from the start to finish. The ambiance was warm and inviting, with a perfect cozy charm. The staff were incredibly attentive and made us feel right at home. Each dish was a masterpiece, bursting with freshness and flavors. Highly recommended this place. ?????“

“We love this place❤️ coming here for years and the food and cocktails never disappoint. Sad to hear about Sam’s passing. We loved chatting w her. Great food and company❤️“

“You going to get a consistent meal at the Lantern. I usually will order ahead and pick up through the drive through. Today, we ate in, and can I just say the staff was amazing. Queen DD was so sweet and the gentleman whose name I forgot to ask, but assume is management of some sort, was SO KIND. Absolutely fantastic experience with them today. Thank you so much for your patience and kindness towards us! Yall made my little girl’s day with that itty bitty ice cream cone.“

“Great place. Food and service are awesome .“

“:Absolutely love The Grill in Greenwood Lake! The father-daughter team running the place couldn't be friendlier or more welcoming. The food is always delicious and consistently good, and the prices are just right. Highly recommend stopping by for a great meal!“

“We have Alexander as our server and he was so pleasant and helpful. The food was served at a reasonable time and great pricing for what we ordered. The lava cake was 10/10. I noticed the restaurant itself is very clean which I truly appreciate. They were also decorated for the holidays which was nice to see!“

“Both times I have taken my elderly handicapped mother here for lunch with family they were absolutely amazing to all of us,amazing staff and the food is always delicious and fresh,having the option to sit outside is lovely,and they are so so friendly and accommodating,thank you all for being so wonderful, a gem in Warwick for sure with great prices on fantastic food, the brioche rolls,the rueban,the burgers,the chicken wraps A++++++++ Everything you want in a hometown“

“Take out is absolutely amazing!“

“One of the best and most memorable breakfasts I have ever had. I can’t wait to return“

“Excellent cuisine, attentive staff and an overall cozy atmosphere in every room. This is fine dining without the pretentiousness that usually comes with it. The Old Stone House is, in my opinion, the finest dining experience in the entire county. 10 out of 10.“

“This is the best food in Vernon served by the friendliest stuff at the best prices , t The Place is Amazing ,if you are new in the area or just visiting Vernon just stop by because there is no better place for breakfast lunch and dinner at the writing of this post. You don't have to trust me ( I traveled all in jersey and upstate NY for the last 6 years In a way I know as traveler and restaurant visitor) but don't take my word . Just go and see it for yourself ,"The feelings and the value is in the plates" as they say in the restaurant industry, You will be surprised, Be your own judge :)“

“Great burger and fries great server definitely coming back with the girls“

“We can’t thank the Farm at Glenwood Mountain enough for how special they made our wedding day! Everything was absolutely perfect. The farm property is gorgeous and the barn’s cathedral ceiling is breathtaking. The food was incredible and is still being talked about, months after our wedding. Steve, Candice, and Stacy communicated with us every step of the way and made us feel so comfortable in our decisions, especially the few months and weeks leading up to the big day. We would recommend this venue to ANYONE and EVERYONE that is looking for a quality venue with staff and owners that care so deeply for their clients. We are eternally grateful for the opportunity they gave us to share such an important day with our closest family and friends, and are thrilled to have become part of the Farm Family! Highly recommend 100%!!!“

“Taco Tuesday is real real tasty , I love the pork and the shrimp tacos. the burgers are delicious , they cook them just the way you like them , onion rings yum yum , Thursdays is prime rib night … cooked to perfection, different sides to choose from , I always get the baked potatoe and the salad it comes with … is real good also , ya gotta try it. Oh I forgot Greg is a great bartender.“

“The Penne alla Vodka with chicken cutlet is fantastic a few times over now. 👍👍“

“I just discovered this place. Great Chicken.“

“Finally made it to the new location today with hubby. We sat at the bar and spoke with John. I have to say what a beautiful place John has built here. Beers were cold and the burger was delicious. Spacious indoors and beautiful wrap around porch with seating. Definitely will be visiting again. Oh and plenty of parking. 🍻👏🍔“

“My husband and I went for the first time last night & can't say enough good things about this place. It's fun and welcoming, with inexpensive food & drinks, and open LATE (and we're night owls). The music playlist is terrific, and the whole atmosphere just transported us back to the dive bars we'd hang out at in the city in the '90s & '00s (except cleaner). It's 20 minutes from our house, but it's 100% our new local.“

“Great dogs. And friendly too Support this business!“

“I had the Yucca Pizza wow it was delicious!!! I 10/10 recommend!!!“

“The personnel/staff amazing ! The decor and grounds are stunning. The food delicious it’s a 10 !!!“

“😋 We eat at this restaurant whenever we travel from VA. to RI. Every meal is delicious! Everyone is friendly. We love this place!😎“

“Very pleased with variety of catered trays for Birthday/Mother’s Day celebration. Excellent food, excellent service. 5 ⭐️’s!“

“Great carribean food like nowhere else, and the host of a great Wednesday jam that’s been going on for over 20 years.“

“Stop in soon and see the renovations, beautiful, and the food, yummy and the staff, friendly and the wait time, almost none, and the prices great, the portions ginormas, and the parking, tons of it. Chris, Gerry and the staff are terriffic. Come in a sit a few and chat with them and enjoy a meal. Breakfast, lunch or dinner, you won't regret it!!“

“Dining at the bar. Love the coziness and interacting with bar tenders“

“First time here been to the liquor store .The food was amazing the service was great . The atmosphere was great real friendly vibe . We will definitely be back !“

“Beautiful venue, amazing drinks made drinks, delicious food and great people.“

“We went to Beer Pockets BBQ for lunch this Saturday and the food was out of this world! Donielle and John made the best suggestions! We can’t wait to come back! Thank you!“

“We chose to have a small wedding at Tree Tavern! We planned for months as we loved the set up of the outside. We came and tried food and drinks, and every person we encountered were extremely nice and helpful. They helped us every step of the way. The options we had for the food was amazing. We got to customize it to how we wanted and then pick a very nice drink package. The pricing was outstanding. They helped with the set up and take down of the wedding and honestly helped us with every little detail. We couldn’t have asked for a better wedding day or a better venue for our special day. If we could do it over again we wouldn’t change a thing. Thank you to Mike, the wonderful owner. Joyce who helped us plan everything and Vicky who helped us pick out all our drinks. Tree Tavern is a place we will come to again and again. The atmosphere is beautiful and the people are great. They helped make our wedding day magical. This place is definitely deserves more than 5 stars!“

“This is my favorite place for great home-cooked food! Everything they make us top drawer and the staff is always attentive, warm and welcoming! It's everything you could ask for! Always looking for a reason to go back here and relax...“

“A Great night at the Cove Castle last night. My girlfriend and I attended the History of Greenwood Lake event at the Cove and it was very enjoyable. Bob, Andrea, Chuck and the entire crew made the experience exceptional. The setting and view of the lake from the second floor dinning room was beautiful. The food was delicious and the presentation was excellent. Drinks were large and reasonably priced. In Bob's 5 years at the Cove Castle he has transformed the place into a fine place to dine, drink and enjoy top notch entertainment. Can't wait to return to "The place to go" on Greenwood Lake.“

“First time ordering take out. I’m picky about my fries. I like fresh cut natural type fries and that’s what they have. Ordered a Reuben and they made it the correct way, not like a lot of places who make that open face slop. My sister ordered the meatloaf dinner and she liked it a lot as well.“

“great atmosphere, drinks and food!“

“Good food. Attentive server. Good value.“

“Great sandwiches! Delicious bread and they are big!! Highly recommend them“

“Great food in a comfy, friendly atmosphere! If you LOVE a good dog “All the Way”,Mc Cobbs is a MUST!“

“The best chicken pot pies in New Jersey and New York.The food is quality and large portions.The staff is friendly and accommodating. The other thing is the price for what you get is incredible.“

“Amazing experience at kink great food. The chicken and waffles are amazing.“

“The best veggie burger ever! love this place! I will be back! The staff are so friendly, great atmosphere! thankyou“

“I'm impressed! It was easy and pretty quick and the girl running the register was kind and patient and walked us through the menu like a pro. We waited at some of the tables and admired the To-Go lockers that make it really easy to order ahead and pick things up. They have a TV for sports and another TV to show you the upcoming orders. I like that because you know they haven't forgotten about you! They also have a reward program with points and stuff. We brought our wings home and loved them. They pack them in great boxes with air holes and clear tops so you can see what everything is and they gave us plenty of napkins and wipes. The wings travelled very well and were great! The fries weren't the best, but maybe they don't travel as well. We will definitely be back to try some of the other food on the menu too!“

“What a wonderful experience! The food was amazing, I even had the eggplant which I haven’t touched in years. Great atmosphere. Polite wait staff and the owner was a sweetheart! They really try hard to make your meal memorable. I don’t normally write reviews but I had to for Cypress Tavern. All of our guests had a great things to say about the meal and the service.“

“We loved the Wienerschnitzel and beer. Service was excellent! Friendly staff! Thank you Tracy!“