Maggie McFly's | Albany
$$ • American, Bars, New American
Hours:
Crossgates Mall, 1 Crossgates Mall Rd, Albany
(518) 608-5647
About Maggie McFly's | Albany
Customers' Favorites
Maggie McFly's | Albany Reviews
Share your opinion about Maggie McFly's | Albany
Took my son for his birthday. We waited probably 20 minutes just to get a soda after being sat. Our calamari was over 15$ a small portion and was so over cooked and so tough you couldn’t chew it. My plate came (not by my waitress) and I had ordered sweet potato fries. Didn’t get that and when I asked for it the young woman was hesitant to offer the correct selection. The servers messed up the order for the people next to me and the older woman gaslit tf out of the gentleman...read full review
We had a party of 8 at two separate tables. The place was not very busy. We were seated at two adjoining tables right away. One of the tables hadn’t been wiped down from the previous guests. We asked the waitress to wipe it, and she proceeded to brush the crumbs off with a cocktail napkin. We had to ask for it to be cleaned. A steak knife was requested and a dirty one was delivered. One of the orders was incorrect. They agreed to make a new one correctly. It took about...read full review
We can’t say enough about this place! My boyfriend and I had our first date here so it’s very special to us. We had a gender reveal here back in November and they brought out ice cream with blue sprinkles and sang to us.
I went there yesterday; bought a slice of cheesecake and asked if they could put a candle in it and bring it out as a surprise for mine and my boyfriends 1 year anniversary. Not only did they do this but they also gave us an “anniversary” discount....read full review
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 11PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 11PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 11PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 11PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 12AM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 12AM |
| Sunday | 10AM - 11PM |
People in Albany Also Viewed
Based on six reviews, Maggie McFly’s offers a mixed experience. The atmosphere is nice with plenty of seating options like booths, counters, and tables, and the energy works for any event, from date nights to family meals. Service can be phenomenal, with specific praise for a waitress named Kayla who was absolutely great, punctual, and welcoming. However, service can also be less than adequate, with one coffee order never coming.
The food quality varies greatly. Appetizers like chicken pot stickers, garlic pizza bread, and potato skins are all fabulous, and the ahi nachos are highly recommended. The fish and chips are loved, and the carrot cake is delicious. However, some entrees disappoint. One Reuben was fatty and dried out, and the brisket was super thick, tough, and chewy, described as a massive portion of inedible fat. A garbage burger was bland and could use seasoning, and the orange chicken felt like a healthy lite calorie version. Despite these issues, many reviewers still recommend giving the restaurant a try.