12 Best Pizza Restaurants in Amherst

“The pizza here is phenomenal! It’s a classic 'Buffalo' style with a generous amount of toppings and a perfect, slightly charred crust on the bottom. Truly delicious.
​The wings, however, were a bit of a mixed bag. While they were a great size and perfectly crispy, they had almost no sauce on them. We ordered Medium and Mild, but both tasted as if they hadn't been sauced at all. I’m hoping it was just a one-off mistake, as the quality of the chicken was great. I’ll definitely give them another shot!“

“The absolute BEST pizza we have ever had. Ordering and waiting did kinda feel like waiting in a gymnasium full of high school kids. They were busy yes, but there was a lot of just leaning and chatting too. The flavor and quality of the pizza made up for it.

Dietary restrictions: Best gluten free crust ever! However, on our salad , they weren't familiar with the ingredients of the dressing.“

“I have not eaten here in quite some time and I cannot state how the conditions of the restaurant were inside because I ordered ahead and someone else went in to get it. The food is usually good and the employees do the best they can to service you in a timely manner.“

“The absolute best pepperoni (well done double pep) pizza in the Buffalo area. Crust has fabulous texture and flavor. Sauce is good, not overwhelming. The pepperoni crisps up and isn't wafer thin.
I no longer live in the area but when there I take a few home with me.“

“Delicious Eggplant Parm but for 20 bucks or so it really should come with a salad or veggie side. Comes with an Olive Garden style bread stick. It also comes with a LOT of spaghetti!! 🍝 I got extra sauce for $3 because sauce!! I love their sauce. Sometimes I order a quart for $8 because it's delish and have it a couple of nights with my own pasta for dinner.“

“I ordered two party packs for a birthday in advance. Showed up on time and cooked perfectly. Pizza was excellent, especially for getting a sheet. Not doughy in the center. Wings were spot on, actually had sauce to lick off our fingers. Thank you all at La Nova for a great dinner for our gathering.“

“2025 Saturday October 25th around 1:30 pm
Everything was fantastic pizza was great breadsticks were super good if you guys can keep up this consistency I could see you bringing back the good name of Pizza Hut like back in the days of old.. establishment was nice and clean inside pearing back into the kitchen it looked clean. All the employees looked clean and well groomed. Was really really happy it's been a while since we've hit a good Pizza Hut so I was surprised when I came to leave a review and only seen 3.6 stars... keep up this consistency like what I had and make everybody's else's experience thebsame and hopefully you'll get back up to 4 plus stars..“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ THE CREW AT PAPA JOHN’S = STRAIGHT UP AWESOME 🍕🙌😄

I DoorDash here all the time, and these guys are ALWAYS on point. 💯
Every visit: big smiles, good vibes, and super helpful energy. 😁✨
They treat people with respect, they hustle, and they make the pickup process smooth every single time. 🚗💨📦

It’s rare to find a team that stays this friendly and consistent — especially with how busy it gets. 🔥👏
Seriously, shoutout to this whole crew. Y’all make my nights way easier, and I appreciate every one of you. 🙏🍕💛“

“wonderful!! Dominos on Niagara Falls Blvd is a beautiful restaurant“

“THANK YOU so much for your generous donation to Our Lady of Peace church’s Wines Around the World Event. We greatly appreciate your donation. With out your support we could not help the Breast Cancer Network, Sleep in Heavenly Peace and St. Lukes. Support Local Businesses!“

“I ordered from them for the first time, and I am very impressed. They delivered on time, and the spicy wantons and stinger sandwich were delicious! The prices are good, and the menu selection is vast, so I am curious to keep trying more items, I strongly recommend them, and the delivery hours are unbeatable.“