7 Best Pizza Restaurants in Amherst

“The absolute BEST pizza we have ever had. Ordering and waiting did kinda feel like waiting in a gymnasium full of high school kids. They were busy yes, but there was a lot of just leaning and chatting too. The flavor and quality of the pizza made up for it.

Dietary restrictions: Best gluten free crust ever! However, on our salad , they weren't familiar with the ingredients of the dressing.“

“Tried Mattinas pizza for the first time ever and it was very good. We ordered a Chicken Finger Sub and also a Pizza. The chicken fingers were very thick and meaty and seemed as if they may have been made in house but definitely good quality chicken fingers and at the usual price. Their pizza was very good and almost was reminiscent of Boccis club pizza, which in my opinion is a great thing. Their sauce was flavorful, and they had generous portions of topping.(I wouldn't have minded extra sauce and cheese, but it was good how it was). You cannot dine in which I was not expecting but was fine. The staff were friendly and constantly cleaning/ scraping the ovens between each pizza. I definitely recommend trying them out if you have never. They are worth it.

Parking: Big parking lot

Kid-friendliness: Definitely kid friendly, but no seating so expect to have the kids standing“

“I asked for my pizza well done,but they already cut it in half. I asked if they could cook it some more but when they took it out of the oven a lot of toppings leaked out of the middle of the pie. When they put it in the box the pizza paddle stuck to the pizza and half of the toppings slid off the pizza and into the box. If I didn't already pay for it I would have walked out. I've been there about a dozen times and never had a problem. It's going to be a long time before I ever go back if I ever go back at all .“

“So we have gotten pizza from here twice. The first time a friend was visiting and he picked it up and we got the original pizza with hot and bbq grilled wings. Everything was very good, but I guess my wife found a strand of steel wool in her slice which was unfortunate. The second time we got meat pizza and bbq grilled wings and it was still very good. The other bad part is their website is abysmal and it took me 35min to figure out you can order online,and that they do deliver but not far at all only to their zipcode(im 6min away)“

“Ordered take out from her while visiting Niagara . It was very close to our Airbnb.

Viagarro Pizza-5/5 ( nice veg fresh, dough was fresh and so was the cheese) would have loved more veggies on them.

Carissa Pizza- 4/5.Chicken Pizza dough was also very fresh and the cheese was really good. Chicken protein was good. Would had loved more veggies.

Definitely worth visiting.“

“These are hands down the best BBQ wings in the city. The pizza is outstanding with quality ingredients. My #1 complaint would be the cost. I have been getting this food since the late 80's when I lived in an apartment on West Ferry. I was poor but could afford a pizza and wings every now and then, $65 for an order of double wings and 1 large pizza is a disgrace. You have always been a great product but go back to be affordable.“

“wonderful!! Dominos on Niagara Falls Blvd is a beautiful restaurant“