Custom Cakes near Amityville, NY

Browse menus, reviews and photos of Custom Cakes near Amityville.

Showing 22 of 22 restaurants

  • Pure Sugar, Inc 5 Broadway, Amityville Patisserie/Cake Shop · $$

    1 Pure Sugar, Inc

    4.9 Superb 68 Reviews

    5 Broadway, Amityville

    Customers’ favorites

    • Birthday Cake
    • Wedding Cake
    • Unicorn Cake

    “Amazing cakes, and it’s not just about looks, the cake tasted amazing!!! Will def use again and already have him booked for my sons birthday party. 10 STARS”

  • Bake Me a Cake! by Angela (made to order custom cakes) 12 Grossman Street, Melville Custom Cakes · $$

    2 Bake Me a Cake! by Angela (made to order custom cakes)

    4.8 Superb 77 Reviews

    12 Grossman Street, Melville · 7.69 miles

    Customers’ favorites

    • Chocolate Covered Strawberries
    • Small Custom Cake
    • Birthday Cake
    • Wedding Cake

    “Angela was friendly and very easy to work with. She baked an amazing gluten free cake for my birthday. Thank you Angela! 🎂”

  • Old Fashioned Ice Cream 1025 Straight Path, West Babylon Ice Cream Shop · $

    3 Old Fashioned Ice Cream

    4.7 Superb 250 Reviews

    1025 Straight Path, West Babylon · 3.79 miles

    • Take-Out

    Customers’ favorites

    • Pistachio Soft Serve with Wet Walnuts
    • Chocolate Chocolate Chip Single Scoop
    • Holy Cannoli w Blueberry Soft Serve
    • Fudge & Biscotti Ice Cream Pie

    “This place is amazing been going here since I was a kid I'm 50 now wouldn't get ice cream any other place got to check this place out”

  • Capri Bakery 3434 Merrick Road, Seaford Bakery · $$

    4 Capri Bakery

    4.7 Superb 165 Reviews

    3434 Merrick Road, Seaford · 4.64 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Pistachio Cannoli Chocolate Chip Cannoli
    • Chocolate Pudding Eclair
    • Black and White Cookies
    • Chocolate Pudding Tarts

    “Family bought the rainbow cookie cake for my birthday today! Was the best cake I have ever had! Everyone was obsessed with it!! Thank you Capri Bakery for making my birthday extra sweet!”

  • Bread in Oven 13 West Marie Street, Hicksville Bakery · $

    5 Bread in Oven

    4.8 Superb 97 Reviews

    13 West Marie Street, Hicksville · 8.24 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Anniversary Cake with Fresh Fruits
    • Tower Wedding Cake with Fresh
    • Fresh Flower Wedding Cake
    • Customized Birthday Cake

    “Delicious, tasty, and flavored eggless cakes. My family and I have been getting birthday cakes from bread in oven for the past two years and it has been getting better and better I recommended this to my friends and my family.We and they enjoy it.”

  • Carvel 392-A N Wantagh Avenue, Bethpage Ice Cream Shop · $

    6 Carvel

    4.8 Superb 68 Reviews

    392-A N Wantagh Avenue, Bethpage · 5.66 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Birthday Cake

    “The best Carvel in the area ! What makes it the best is that they definitely have the friendliest staff. And they keep the place super clean. I take my daughter there at least once a week after her gymnastics class and on more than one occasion have been shown appreciation for our loyalty.”

  • Baked by Emily Rose 518 Broadway Ste B, Massapequa Bakery

    7 Baked by Emily Rose

    5.0 Superb 35 Reviews

    518 Broadway Ste B, Massapequa · 2.77 miles

    • Take-Out

    Customers’ favorites

    • Gift Basket

    “I highly recommend Baked by Emily Rose! They made a beautiful cake for my mom’s special birthday. Mom loved it. Very delicious!”

  • Moscato Bakery & Cafe 546 Stewart Avenue, Bethpage Bakery · $$

    8 Moscato Bakery & Cafe

    4.6 Superb 132 Reviews

    546 Stewart Avenue, Bethpage · 5.54 miles

    Customers’ favorites

    • Birthday Cake
    • Lobster Tails
    • Cheesecake
    • Cupcake

    “Delicious sfogliatelle, cannolis, napoleons, and Italian bread 🥖”

  • The Chocolate Duck 310 Main Street, Farmingdale Custom Cakes · $$

    9 The Chocolate Duck

    4.6 Superb 76 Reviews

    310 Main Street, Farmingdale · 3.96 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    “Great Kids Party… Highly recommend for children,”

  • Vin’s Bake House 1030 Park Boulevard, Massapequa Park Bakery · $

    10 Vin’s Bake House

    4.5 Superb 150 Reviews

    1030 Park Boulevard, Massapequa Park · 2.04 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Black and White Cookie
    • Italian Cookies
    • Birthday Cake
    • Cookie House

    “Working with Ashley to make a cake for our engagement party was so wonderful and smooth. She was able to educate us on the options and give reasons why things that we wanted had to be done differently for the stability of the cake. Even to this day, people are still telling us how beautiful and delicious the cake was! I sent her so many pictures because I really wasn’t sure what I wanted, and she took the inspiration photos and was able to combine them into her own creation beautifully! The night we got back we had some extra and happily ate it out of the Tupperware! It was so good that even though we had it a few hours earlier, that we wanted it again!”

  • Carvel 301A Bedford Avenue, Bellmore Ice Cream Shop · $

    11 Carvel

    4.6 Superb 64 Reviews

    301A Bedford Avenue, Bellmore · 5.84 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Reese's Peanut Butter Sundae Dasher
    • Square Ice Cream Celebration Cake
    • Mint KitKat Duos Sundae Dasher
    • Cookie Butter Sundae Dasher

    “The Bellmore Carvel is very special. The amount of love and care put into my son's birthday cake exceeded my expectations. Amanda is so talented and you can tell she is passionate about designing cakes. She even called me personally to ask if she could alter the cake a bit from the image I provided. It came out a million times better than the image! Thank you, I will only be ordering from you guys in the future!”

  • Spiga Bakery 2680 Merrick Road, Bellmore Bakery · $

    12 Spiga Bakery

    4.4 Superb 210 Reviews

    2680 Merrick Road, Bellmore · 5.82 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Great Tasting over the Top Flavored Doughnuts
    • Cheesecake with Fresh Fruit
    • Sausage & Pepper Roll
    • Assortment of Cookies

    “The best everything is fresh , delicious , and there’s lots to choose from . Just amazing”

  • Zio’s casa di dolce 3649 Merrick Road, Seaford Bakery · $

    13 Zio’s casa di dolce

    4.4 Superb 107 Reviews

    3649 Merrick Road, Seaford · 4.24 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Assorted Italian Cookie Tray
    • Lemon Meringue Pie
    • Rainbow Cookies
    • Almond Biscotti

    “They are Best. Everything they make is delicious. The staff is great. Every time I go in for one thing I come out with half the store!!! They still have the famous pac-man cookies !! Cheesecake is off the cart. I would recommend them very highly!!”

  • Carvel 188 Howells Road, Bay Shore Ice Cream Shop · $

    14 Carvel

    4.3 Superb 83 Reviews

    188 Howells Road, Bay Shore · 8.33 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery
    • Drive-Through

    Customers’ favorites

    • Soft Serve Ice Cream
    • Ice Cream Sundae
    • Birthday Cake

    “Went to get some ice-cream after dinner. The staff greeted us as we walked in the door. They were quick and efficient. They double checked that certain ice-cream were okay to have with my food allergy. They have a freezer full of premade ice-creams and cakes or you can pick from different size cones or cups. They have different flavors of soft serve or hard ice-cream and many different toppings to choose from. They don't have any seating so we had to take it to go. I was so intent on eating my ice-cream I forgot to take pictures.”

  • Sweet Karma Desserts 136 Manetto Hill Road, Plainview Custom Cakes · $

    15 Sweet Karma Desserts

    4.2 Good 116 Reviews

    136 Manetto Hill Road, Plainview · 7.71 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Gluten Free Funfetti Cupcakes
    • GF Funfetti Cupcakes
    • Birthday Cake
    • Wedding Cake

    “Brian designed our dream cake for our October Friday the 13th wedding. We went in with some ideas, bits and pieces from multiple photos and what was created blew our minds. Everyone was speechless when it came out. Aside from the delicious taste of the cake itself the details and time that was poured into it is one that we truly appreciate and love. We been to the shop multiple times before the wedding just to grab some goodies because everything is tasty and above the typical/traditional desserts you’d expect. Highly recommended bakery for sure.”

  • The Ultimate Bakery (A&G) 1350 Deer Park Avenue Suite 26, North Babylon Bakery · $

    16 The Ultimate Bakery (A&G)

    4.2 Good 162 Reviews

    1350 Deer Park Avenue Suite 26, North Babylon · 6.62 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Red Velvet Square
    • Chocolate Cake
    • Eclairs Pastry
    • Wedding Cake

    “I really do like this bakery and it has been our go to for 20 plus years but $15 for the Philly fluff is absolutely outrageous now. I understand increasing costs but this is like double what it used to be not that long ago . Guess no more Philly fluff for me 🤷🏻‍♀”

  • Cold Stone Creamery 297 N Broadway, Jericho Ice Cream Shop · $$

    17 Cold Stone Creamery

    3.9 Good 107 Reviews

    297 N Broadway, Jericho · 9.11 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Ice Cream Cupcake Variety 6-Pack - Ready Now
    • Founder's Favorite - Freezer
    • Peanut Butter Cup Perfection
    • Create Your Own Shake

    “Some of the kindest, most understanding people work here. It's a Coldstone Creamery, you know what you're getting into. But the staff is exceptional, we'd been here more than a few times and always had great ice-cream. My keys stopped working and me and my fiancé were locked out of our car late at night in sub 20 below weather. The manager attempted to help us open the car, gave us shelter, and was so kind and supportive. They moved a bench inside for us, checked in and offered so much. They took care of us in more ways than not after an already long and hard day. Outside of being a good place to get ice cream, I think any locals should support these people as much as possible.”

  • Carvel Merrick Mall &, 2144 Johnston Place, Merrick Ice Cream Shop · $

    18 Carvel

    3.6 Good 61 Reviews

    Merrick Mall &, 2144 Johnston Place, Merrick · 7.12 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery
    • Drive-Through

    “Their ice cream cakes are great”

  • Josie's Cakes 1635 Great Neck Road Ste 2, Copiague Custom Cakes · $$$$

    19 Josie's Cakes

    3.7 Good 102 Reviews

    1635 Great Neck Road Ste 2, Copiague · 0.93 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Baby Shower Cake
    • Birthday Cake
    • Wedding Cake

    “I had the pleasure of working with Josie’s Cakes for my law school graduation party. From the first conversation I had with them, I knew I was in for something special. Having had my aunt use them for many birthday celebrations, I knew the cakes were amazing. They made sure I received exactly what I wanted. Not only was the cake perfectly crafted, it tasted INCREDIBLE. My guests were satisfied with it and have been inquiring. I thoroughly enjoyed working with them and will continue to do so in the future. Thank you so much for everything! May God continue to bless your business!”

  • Cold Stone Creamery 255 Deer Park Avenue, Babylon Ice Cream Shop · $$

    20 Cold Stone Creamery

    3.7 Good 162 Reviews

    255 Deer Park Avenue, Babylon · 5.17 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Cold Stone Creamery Creation in Hand
    • Mix and Go Create Your Own Creation
    • Cookie Dough Delirium - Ready Now
    • Cake Batter Confetti - Ready Now

    “They keep a pretty large staff on hand. And they still get busy with a line to or past the door. Come at a smart time and your in and out. The ice cream is great and the workers put the effort in. All the cold stones are good but I keep coming to this one”

  • Dortoni Bakery and Cafe 11 Vanderbilt Motor Parkway, Commack Bakery · $$

    21 Dortoni Bakery and Cafe

    3.7 Good 269 Reviews

    11 Vanderbilt Motor Parkway, Commack · 11.57 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Bakery Cakes Pastries Cookies
    • Cannoli Birthday Cake
    • Assorted Mini Cakes
    • Black Forest Cake

    “We used Dortoni's to cater dessert for our wedding - Hands down the best bakery on Long Island!”

  • Cold Stone Creamery 3535 Hempstead Turnpike, Levittown Ice Cream Shop · $$

    22 Cold Stone Creamery

    3.4 Good 135 Reviews

    3535 Hempstead Turnpike, Levittown · 5.65 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    “This is my go to spot. The staff here is really friendly, service is really fast. I usually hang out here for a bit. I just really wish that there was a TV to watch sports. I love the area and the vibe here, it’s just missing some entertainment. Hopefully this place could get a TV soon.”

Custom Cakes Nearby