26 Best Greek Restaurants near Amityville

“Food is delicious“

“The food was really delicious, and my family and I had a great time. The place has a nice, cozy vibe, and the decor is really well done. The service was friendly and attentive, which we appreciated. Overall, it was a really good experience and we’d definitely come back again!“

“Stopped in for a late dinner. The staff is super nice and welcoming. Ordered the lamb gyro, side Greek salad, chicken quesadilla and we even got on the house rice pudding! Everything was a 10/10. Highly recommend this place!!!!!“

“First time here today, what a great place with great people. We were a group of 4 and everything was amazing. Even got to talk with the owner Peter and his wife. Can’t wait to go back.“

“Fast, friendly service. Gyro Platter was enough for 2 meals. Excellent!“

“Last night I took my 95 yo dad with my family here, our Go-To Greek restaurant and as always we had another wonderful meal. The grilled octopus, coconut shrimp and the haloumi cheese were all delicious. I had the chicken santorini for the first time and it was amazing as it melted in my mouth. The food is always spot on and most of all we are treated like family. I would recommend "It's Greek to Me" without hesitation.“

“When I get Greek I always get gyros because I don't have Greek food enough that I'm ever bored of gyros. The sauce on the gyro had a kick to it and was unlike any other place I've ever been to. I wish it was closer to where I was because I would be back more often.“

“Stopped in after a wonderful recommendation from my good friend, Garrett. I thought I was in Greece, then I met the family. What a pleasure. Smiles everywhere. The atmosphere, the food and the wine was tops but the service was the best. I think there was a handsome model named Christian was working that night. Not only was he handsome but delightful as well. My daughter and my wife insisted we return.“

“Greek Cove Merrick’s lunch special is incredible. Ate the warm pita in the car on the way home! Grilled chicken with a salad and rice. One huge chicken cutlet over a generous portion of delicious rice and a tasty Greek salad- with a grape leaf and feta! I am a very picky eater but this chix was seasoned beautifully, so that if garlic, onion or rosemary(my triple threat) was used, it all blended together perfectly so that even I could not pick out the offensive spice. Amazingly, the yogurt sauce is also tasty( I hate yogurt sauce;usually throw it away). Forgot to tell them not to give it to me, so as not to waste it, but I’m glad I forgot! All of this, and a lot of smiling happy employees, for $12.99 cash. Wowza.“

“Very fresh food. Everything we ordered was delicious. Reasonably priced too. We will probably use their catering for our next party.“

“Just ordered the first time and it was delicious! Everything was fresh and the restaurant was nice and clean. The staff were friendly and helped me order. The owner was also very friendly and accommodating.“

“As a Diner waitress for my entire career, I was pleasantly surprised at how lovely this Diner is. Great breakfast service and great food.“

“First time dining here and overall a really solid experience. The food was enjoyable — the lemon orzo soup was comforting, the lamb gyro taco had great flavor, and the chicken kebab skewers was cooked well. Drinks were a standout, especially the dirty raspberry martini, which was excellent.

The vibe is casual and relaxed. There were a couple small service hiccups, but nothing that took away from the meal. Overall, we enjoyed it and would definitely come back again.“

“Delicious food. Loved the shrimp gyro“

“i live in bellmore where there is at least 6 greek places in the area. i always drive to massapequa to greek delight. The food is phenomenal 👌“

“first time 5-25-23. very disappointed. spent $15.20 and barely got any food.small scoop of white rice and chicken scraps in a pita. not worth my time going there.“

“This was the best Greek food . The take out food comes hot because they use these foil boxes. Spinach roll appetizer was amazing and chicken skewers with rice with twaztiki sauce amazing . Our new place to go to!“

“I happened to be in the area from out of town and stopped in for a bite to eat. The gyro, grape leaves and baklava were outstanding! Staff was very friendly. Highly recommend 10/10. Thank you!“

“I was here yesterday, ordered Chicken Karahi, Kebabs, Chicken Tikka with Naan. Everything was delicious and closer to the perfection. Raita and special Spicy Onions made things more delicious. I will definitely visit again to try other dishes. One more thing which i liked, there werr no mandatory service charges, you can tip whatever you want to. Beautiful small space with Quality Food. Please owners keep it like that. Thank You“

“Husband & I were in the area & decided to stop in for lunch today & glad we did. I had the Lamb Gyro, came w/french fries & Beef Barley soup. Soup was delicious. Gyro had plenty of meat (lamb) w/lettuce, tomatoes & onions. All very fresh. Husband had Falafel which he said was absolutely delicious. We had a great lunch. The staff were very nice and attentive & restaurant was cheerful & clean. We will definitely be coming back to try their dinner next time. Highly recommend Opa Grille.“

“This place does mainly a takeout business, there are 3 small tables to wait in if desired, but it is noisy and there is a lot of Doordash/uber eats activity in and out, and for good reason: the food is consistently excellent and the quantity served makes it a terrific value. The salads are terrific and we love that you can not only get chicken souvlaki chunks or chicken gyro meat on salads or platters and both are terrific. Tzatziki - amazing. If you're a fan of baklava, theirs is better than most bakeries around. Spanakopita is also excellent. Think of it is restaurant quality but in takeout form. We absolutely love the guys who run the place, very friendly, very gracious. There aren't that many Greek places in Nassau that hit it out of the park for us, but these guys do, every time. Go!“

“Beautiful, cozy spot. Food was delicious. Great cocktails, too! Great service. I highly recommend!“

“I went to check out the new location in Levittown after they closed their spot in Mineola. The new place looks great—clean, spacious, and welcoming.

I ordered my food to go, and it was ready by the time I got there. Everything was hot, freshly made, and delicious. I got the chicken souvlaki with grilled veggies, and it came with a small Greek salad. The portions are generous, and you definitely get your money’s worth.

The lamb gyro was also really good—tender, well-seasoned, and stuffed with meat. They definitely don’t skimp. The staff was super friendly, service was quick, and pickup was easy. Definitely worth the trip.“

“Very good food, very slow service on a busy day. They have a ton of seating to accommodate alot of people but that doesn't mean much if the kitchen can't keep up. We were seated for an hour before seeing an appetizer. I would come back but not on holiday weekends.“

“I honestly love a good chicken over rice platter and usually have to drive all the way to Hicksville which is pretty inconvenient. This spot is less than 10 minutes away from where I attend school so I had to try it out and I’m so glad I did! I stuck to the classic chicken over rice platter. It tasted fresh and the service was great too— nice people and I got my food in a matter of minutes! This place definitely just became my go to spot for gyro!“