17 Best American Restaurants in Batavia

Terry Hills Golf Course, Restaurant and Banquet Facility American • $$$
5122 Clinton Street Rd, Batavia

“My husband and I just got married there on Saturday, and he loves golfing there. The course is in great shape, but thanks to Danielle the day was absolutely perfect. Food was amazing, venue was beautiful, clean, staff was so kind. I wish we could repeat the day over and over and over again. Thank you Terry hills!!“

4.7 Superb35 Reviews
Homestretch Grill American • $
8315 Park Rd, Batavia

“Went to the Burnin' Barrel BBQ (Homestretch Grill) at Batavia Downs with Dad and Mom. Tried the Half-rack of Smoked Ribs while my parents had the Pulled Piggy (no bun) & onion strings. Absolutely delicious. Portions were generous and the BBQ sauce was amazing! Very beautiful mural in the dining area too!“

4.5 Superb2 Reviews
Fortune's Italian Steakhouse American • $$
8315 Park Rd, Batavia

Customers` Favorites

Cedar Plank Salmon w Wild Rice Pilaf
Grilled Chicken Basil Alfredo
Prime Rib & Shrimp Cocktail
Seafood Stuffed Haddock
Eggplant Parmigiana
Alfredo Ravioli
Chicken Marsala
Sea Food Medley
Seafood Chowder
Fish and Chips

“My husband and I have eaten at Fortunes on two occasions now and have found it to be an extremely enjoyable experience. The atmosphere is quiet and relaxing and the staff are very friendly and efficient. There is a nice variety of menu items to choose from as well. We have never been disappointed in our meals and will continue to frequent this restaurant. I would have to rate it as one of the top dining experiences in the Batavia area.“

4 Good229 Reviews
Sport Of Kings Family Restaurant Family • $
419 W Main St, Batavia

Customers` Favorites

French Toast with Whip Cream and Strawberries
Western Omelette w Cheesy Potato Casserole
Cajun Chicken Broccoli Alfredo
American Scrambler with Bagel
French Toast Breakfast Plate
French Toast Eggs and Ham
Hot Turkey Sandwich With
Chicken Souvlaki Wrap
Traditional Breakfast
All American Scramble

“Arrived at 7:55 unaware that this establishment closes @8 pm. I asked what time they close and the owner said 8 pm. I went to leave and he said wait where are going. We close at 8 but as long as you sit before you have time. Waitress was friendly and wasn't acting as we bothered her. Even the other waitresses were talking to us and joking around! phenomenal service Definitely do not find this hospitality or customer service now days! Sport of Kings you are top notch in our book. We appreciate and thank you so much!“

4.7 Superb90 Reviews
Miss Batavia Diner Diner • $
566 E Main St, Batavia

Customers` Favorites

Eggs over Medium Rye Toast Sausage Home Fries
Corn Beef Hash with over Easy Eggs
Sausage Patties and Scrambled Eggs
Chicken Fingers and French Fries
Eggs with Cheese and Sausage
Chicken Parmesan w Spaghetti
Home Fries Hash Browns
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Strawberry Pancakes
Breakfast Sandwich

“I was looking for a good baked haddock, and I found it. it was delicious, no fishy taste, moist and a nice size. they did an amazing job.“

4.6 Superb67 Reviews
Settler's Family Restaurant Family • $
353 W Main St, Batavia

Customers` Favorites

Hungry Man Breakfast Dine in: Yes Takeout: Yes
Hungry Man Breakfast & Side of Pancakes
Reese's Peanut Butter Pie
Souvlaki Breakfast
Southern Benedict
Southern Omelette
With Home Fries
Scrambled Eggs
Club Sandwich
French Toast

“Food was very good, portion sizes were generous, and the service was great. It was obviously a placed favored by locals. If you are in the area and looking for a good meal at a fair price, I recommend this diner.

A note on the atmosphere - the place hasn't been updated in a while but it's not run down. The atmosphere is friendly, not fancy. I was fine with that.“

4.4 Superb161 Reviews
O'Lacy's Bar • $
5 School St, Batavia

Customers` Favorites

Fish and Chips with Chowder
Reuben Sandwich to Die For
Guinness Stout w Shamrock
Uncle Louie Sandwich
Bowl Mashed Potatoes
Chicken Sandwich
O'Lacys Burger
Shepherd's Pie
Delish Reuben
Shepard's Pie

“Great little place off the beaten path of main street. Easy open parking and seating while limited will be worth the effort to get in.

The seating is limited but also have a out door area weather permitting. The atmosphere was very nice. TONS of classic fun stuff to look at to make converstation about. The seating and bar is a classic relaxing feel to it.. I would say max 4 to

The food was equally amazing. The Ruben was very good. I give it an 8 out of 10, as I am super picky about the best ruben around. The meat was or is shreded, so you won't get get a huge chunk of meat all at once. The taste was spot on, and so was the toasty-ness of the bread.

Presentation was good. Someone took the time to actually look at what they are serving and ensured it looked as good as it could be.. I would say 4 person group max would be ideal for this place.

Service was good. Friendly. No issues with payment or the bill.

If you love the TV Cheers feel type place well worth the visit..“

4.5 Superb72 Reviews
Jen's Joint American • $
4974 Ellicott Street Rd, Batavia

Customers` Favorites

Philly Cheese Steak Omelette with Homefries
Open Beef Sandwich with Fries and Gravy
Maple Bacon Cheeseburger and Fries
Broccoli and Cheese Quiche
Sausage and Wheat Toast
Chicken and Biscuits
Taco Quesadilla
Cubano Sandwich
Beef on Weck
Jen

“I'm a nut about garbage plates and there are no good ones here in batavia until today.... i tried jens and OMG SOOOOO GOOD! I'm so excited to not have to go to rochester for one.“

4.6 Superb47 Reviews
Tully's Good Times Batavia Family • $
522 E Main St, Batavia

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Dijon Chicken Sandwich
Nirii Mile High Ice Cream Pie
Freshly Squeezed Lemonade
Chicken Tenders and Fries
Tully's Tenders Appetizer
New York Grilled Reuben
Mountain Melt Burger
Homemade Cheesecake
Baked Potato Soup
French Onion Soup

“Comfort food galore! You can't beat Tully's. I'm not a chain restaurant patron, but Tully's is different, see for yourself. You won't be disappointed.
I did remove a star for two very fixable issues.
First, the popcorn machine was broken, kids were looking forward toi t.
Second, they have great coleslaw, however they are only giving us a salad dressing cup full instead of the small bowl we used to receive.
Again, both are fixable and I hope they do soon.
Hopefully they're not turning into a regular chain restaurant.“

4.3 Superb173 Reviews
Bourbon & Burger Co. Hamburger • $
9 Jackson St, Batavia

Customers` Favorites

Everything Is Bigger in Texas Burger
Kentucky Bourbon Company Burger
Bubba Gump Shrimp Burger
Kansas Breakfast Burger
Sweet Potato Fries
Bourbon Selection
Different Burgers
Bourbon Burger
Cowboy Burger
Chicken Wing

“What a gem of a place! We tried it for the first time and will definitely be back! The burgers were excellent and the bourbon drinks were delicious and well balanced. The cherry on the top was the waitress we had (Tess). She went above and beyond to make our dining experience extremely enjoyable! We will be back!“

4.3 Superb105 Reviews
Main Street Pizza Company Pizza • $
206 E Main St, Batavia

Customers` Favorites

Homemade Fried Mozzarella Wedges
Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza
Veal Parm with Spaghetti
Create-Your-Own Calzone
Deep Dish Cheese Pizza
Dry Rub Chicken Wings
Build Your Own Pizza
The Main Street
Deep Dish Pizza
Boneless Wings

“Great food & great service!“

4.3 Superb93 Reviews
Town & Country Restaurant Diner • $
5025 E Main Street Rd, Batavia

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Jourlake over Rice Gresk Salad
Scrambled Eggs Bacon Hash Browns Toat
Sloppy Joe with Mashed Potatoes
Mushroom and Cheese Omelet
Corned Beef Hash & Two Eggs
Corned Beef and Cabbage
Corn Beef Eggs Benedict
Silver Dollar Pancakes
Crab Salad Cold Plate
Country Eggs Benedict

“This place has that home-cooked meal feeling. Food is ALWAYS good. And the prices are very reasonable. Highly recommend 🥰“

4.3 Superb81 Reviews
T F Brown's Restaurant Italian • $
214 E Main St, Batavia

Customers` Favorites

Homemade Mozzarella Sticks
Birthday Wings Before
Roast Beef Sandwich
French Onion Soup
Chicken Wing Dip
Chicken Tenders
Chicken Wings
Buffalo Wings
Beef on Wick
Nachos

“Stopped here on the way to a show in Niagara Falls. Reasonable prices, good food.“

4.3 Superb61 Reviews
Copperhead Creek Bar Bar & Grill • $
345 W Main St, Batavia

Customers` Favorites

Pretzel Buger and Fries
Chicken Fingers w Fries
Bavarian Pretzel Sticks
Jumbo Chicken Wings
Mozzarella Sticks
Thin Crust Pizza
Soft Shell Taco
Pepperoni Pizza
Loaded Fries
Chicken Salad

“Great place for music. A lot of fun was gad!“

4.1 Good38 Reviews
Alex's Place Steak House • $$
8322 Park Rd, Batavia

Customers` Favorites

Alex's Famous BBQ Baby Back Pork Ribs
2 Meat Special Ribs and Pulled Pork
Quarter Rack Baby Back Ribs
Reserve 20oz Bone in Ribeye
Twin 4 Oz Lobster Tails
Full Rack of Ribs
Danish Onion Soup
Half Rack of Ribs
Mashed Potatoes
Fish Fry Dinner

“Waitress was very courteous and very attentive. Her name was Carrisa. She was thoughtful to our needs, thank you some much for a wonderful experience, my wife and I will be back.“

4.1 Good181 Reviews
Club Bud Light at 34 Rush Sports Bar • $
8315 Park Rd, Batavia

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Wings
Sandwich
Burger

“Had fun at the casino drinks were good but not as advertised. We were promised 416 ounce drafts in the glass they put it in was 12 ounces. The plastic glass did say 16 ounces on the bottom but my 12 ounce bottle of beer just fit in it. I questioned the bartender. She rolled her eyes in disgust and said oh well but had a fun other than that.“

3.8 Good15 Reviews
Center Street Smoke House Barbecue • $$
20 Center St, Batavia

Customers` Favorites

Pulled Pork and Beef Brisket with Mac & Cheese Smashed Potatoes
MA's Macaroni and Cheese with Brisket
Corn Bread with Maple Butter
Texas BBQ Beef Brisket
Carolina Pulled Pork
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Baked Sweet Potato
Grilled Vegetables
Rotisserie Chicken
Sweet Potato Fries

“the food is amazing. I went in for a to go order and sam at the bar was amazing. I just found out my sister passed away and was low in spirit but he helped put a smile on my face and blessed me with a meal. I thank him from the bottom of my heart and I want to say people like him make me believe in Angels answering prayers. thanks“

4 Good55 Reviews

You May Also Like