23 Best American Restaurants near Caledonia

“Amazing experience here tonight. They were very honest about the times and how long dinner would take, but absolutely made up for that! The staff was the nicest I've ever experienced. We recently moved to the area and will definitely be back. Thank you Caledonia Inn for a wonderful experience.“

“Wonderful, cozy little diner. The name fits it perfectly. We ordered just eggs and homemade toast. But the homemade toast was delicious. Especially the raspberry bread. Loaded with raspberry jam. The waitress was a bit snarky and not that friendly. Maybe she just had an off day. Hopefully next time , that won't be the case. I still would highly recommend this diner for it's delicious food and cozy atmosphere!!“

“This was a wonderful experience! Best breakfast place I have ever had and definitely will be going back again! The food was cooked to perfection, Brandy the morning server was phenomonal. The atmosphere was awesome! I love the 50s style and the music playing over the speakers. There were plenty of regulars and first timers in the joint by 930 am on a Sunday.Thank you so much for the best breakfast experience I have had! I usually loathe going out to eat breakfast but I am excited to come back! The Waffle with Walnuts was just delightful.“

“Looking for a different place for breakfast on my often trip from Buffalo, NY to Rochester, NY. I did a search on Yelp and Bergen Farm Market came up with good reviews. So why not? Turned out to be a great choice. Busy with Sunday morning locals coffee came fast and so did my order. Bacon, eggs and home fries fill the plate. The eggs cooked perfectly and the best home fries I ever had. Looks like often visits to the Bergen Farm Market are in store.“

“Many items on menu looked great. My daughter and I both had the Onion Burger. AWESOME burger cooked, but still pink inside. If you want it medium well you will need to ask, but I don't recommend that. I have crispy fries and she had potato salad.“

“Love this little diner. Food is awesome, service is fast and this place is always crowded. We tried to get here by nine and it was packed at that time. We did get a table and if you'd like, you can sit at the 'bar,' a long line of stools attached to a long table kind of like at a bar. They take cash or credit, phone orders for pick up. Cozy, nice atmosphere, kind of loud at times. I had the Mediterranean omelet, my kids had different variations of eggs, bacon or sandwiches and my husband had an Irish Eggs Benedict.“

“This is the best family restaurant around. Food is always great, owners are clearly community members who love what they do. Place is always packed but I've never waited more than 15 minutes. Great parking. Friendly bartenders and staff.“

“I’ve been here several times. I’ve never been disappointed. The food and drinks are always good. The staff have always been friendly and very helpful. Cozy atmosphere with kinda of a NYC vibe, which I love. I’ve eaten both inside and out. Highly recommend“

“We walked into Dirty Dave's not knowing what to expect, we got our menus and the first thing g that struck me were the prices, so far good start. We ordered our drinks then our food, I ordered the New York strip, with fries and mac salad. My wife ordered the fish fry, my nephew got the Buffalo chicken wrap with onion rings.I'll start with the steak. The flavor was out of this world, savory delicious, the steak was so tender I didn't need a knife to cut it. I'd call it perfect, found no fault there, the Mac salad was some of the best I've ever had, the fries also perfect. Crispy outside, tender and fluffy inside. My nephew loved his onion rings and wrap, and my wife's fish fry was so big she had to take some with her. All in all, we had just about the perfect experience at Dirty Daves.I highly recommend it to anyone looking for great food, great prices and great service.The worst thing Dirty Dave's could do is fire their cook. We will be going back.“

“D&R is definitely aimed more towards the older generations in the atmosphere and some recipes, but that's what adds to the charm, and the charm is what makes D&R, D&R!Besides recommending the Mac and Cheese, I also ✨️HIGHLY✨️ recommend the french onion soup & to grab a slice of their strawberry cheesecake. I promise, you'll thank me later ;)“

“My husband and I are soooo glad we stopped here. Tripadvisor reviews showed this place has great service; and they were not wrong. Great service, with personable staff - which makes a place all worth it! The food was really good as well. I do recommend the burgers (as mine was cooked perfectly to my liking). Overall, I'm thrilled with this little pub and would stop here again and again were I in the area. And really, chat up the hosts...such great ppl!“

“We stopped at Puppy’s on our way through town because we thought they might be dog-friendly— we were right. It may not be an official policy, but the staff was very accommodating getting us set up outside with our pup. Great food, better people. So glad we visited!“

“Great old style hamburger joint. Full of color and positive energy. Food menu was full of choices to satisfy every tastebud. The original and walhburger are still my favorites. Before you go make sure to check out the great coupon offers (simple Google search) you will happy at what you find. The meat sauce has its own special taste, not too hot and not too sweet, just the perfect blend of flavor to add to your burger or dip your fries into.“

“We couldn't have asked for a better meal or experience. We brought my father-in-law out for a belated Christmas gift meal, and it was everything I hoped for. We had filet mignon with scallops, the seafood platter and veal parmesan. Everything was delicious and perfectly cooked. We also got dessert: peanut butter pie, Snicker bar pie and key lime pie. Amazing again and Dad thought the key lime pie was the perfect ending to a perfect meal. The service was excellent and the staff fun and attentive. Will definitely recommend and return.“

“We just found this place tonight. What a great place for dinner , Food was great and the waitress she was so nice we love it hear and definitely will be back. The guy that runs the bowling alley is nice & very helpful. Going back in a couple of weeks to do a bowling party with friends. It's a restaurant on one side & bowling alley one the other side. You can eat play in one place.“

“What a beautiful little gem to find in the middle of Leroy, the food was outstanding. We even stayed the night there one of their sweets very very accommodating ultra clean very classy place to go. I would highly recommend this place to anybody.“

“I had a glass of white zinfandel, he had the Roger's hound dog scotch ale (three of them). We shared the 'Q for Two' with coleslaw and garlic potatoes. The amount of food was generous, and the price was very reasonable.Second visit: I had the Black & Bleu burger, medium, with garlic fries and a glass of reisling. The burger was so flavorful, I could taste the juicy beef without it being hidden by the Bleu cheese and bacon. The reisling was pleasant, lightly sweet with a dry finish. And the FRIES! OMG! Crispy and delicious even after they sat for a while waiting for me to finish my burger. My server, Sydney, was attentive without being underfoot and very friendly. Another 5-star experience!“

“While we didn't eat any food, the bowling was a lot of fun. We went on a Saturday around 1p and it wasn't too busy. They have 8 lanes so you might want to call before going. It was kind of pricy for bowling. They charged $5 a game, per person. Shoe rental was the usual $3. They had some really good music playing and they have a bar. We would definitely go back when visiting the area.“

“Unexpectedly wide selection is the Minnehan's thing. From turkey with stuffing to standard burger fare, there are great choices. The wait can be a little long, but that's the price you have to expect to pay when your food is cooked for you.“

“First timer at this spot, as I had a $50 gift card to use up. We ordered quite a bit of food on a Saturday night around 5pm but everything was ready to go in 15 mins. My sister and I ordered the Mediterranean salad with chicken and Buffalo chicken finger salad. Both were very good and filling but my ONLY complaint was that they used iceberg lettuce instead of romaine. They would have been so much more satisfying if they opted for the nicer lettuce. The chicken on the Mediterranean salad was super flavorful and juicy, we both loved it. We also ordered a side of fries and Mac salad. Fries were perfectly crispy and Mac salad had tons of flavor but needed a little more mayo. The girl at the counter was very friendly too. I would definitely come back and try other things!“

“Really disappointed in our order tonight. Chicken fingers had a stale chemical taste. Hot meat sauce made my cheeseburger plate inedible as it was strikingly hot from previous experiences on plates. Bacon burger also had an odd taste. Not sure what the deal is as this is not the norm for our experience there.“

“I'll be kind. Food had pretty good flavor. Service was very slow. The dining area was very hot, humid & smelled like fish. It was busy prior to us but slowed down, as did the waiting staff. There was only 3 families in the dining room and people who came in after us had their food served first. Staff was very kind. It's is a "Family Restaurant" so be sure you have time to sit and visit and enjoy your meal.Parking: Plenty of parking available.Kid-friendliness: Yes very. Huge coloring book section and they have high chairs & booster seats available.Wheelchair accessibility: It's a tight fit coming in the door a couple of very tight 90° turns to get in plus holding open doors.“

“Great food and Great service! AND to Michele Rogers (IDIOT) who offered a Google review previously…I hope it makes you feel awesome (IDIOT)referring to the young lady at the counter as a “Blonde Bimbo.” She is a very smart and beautiful 11th Grade High School Student you IDIOT! How cruel to post something like that. IDIOT!“