Custom Cakes near Bethpage, NY

“The best Carvel in the area ! What makes it the best is that they definitely have the friendliest staff. And they keep the place super clean. I take my daughter there at least once a week after her gymnastics class and on more than one occasion have been shown appreciation for our loyalty.“

“Delicious sfogliatelle, cannolis, napoleons, and Italian bread 🥖“

“Angela was friendly and very easy to work with. She baked an amazing gluten free cake for my birthday. Thank you Angela! 🎂“

“This place is amazing been going here since I was a kid I'm 50 now wouldn't get ice cream any other place got to check this place out“

“She did it again! This is my second time working with Nita for a milestone birthday, and she exceeded expectations once again. She is so professional and such a pleasure to work with. Her pastries are not only beautiful but absolutely delicious—this time I ordered cakes, tarts, and cake pops. She copied my inspiration cake to perfection! I will definitely be recommending her again and again.“

“Amazing cakes, and it’s not just about looks, the cake tasted amazing!!! Will def use again and already have him booked for my sons birthday party. 10 STARS“

“Delicious, tasty, and flavored eggless cakes. My family and I have been getting birthday cakes from bread in oven for the past two years and it has been getting better and better
I recommended this to my friends and my family.We and they enjoy it.“

“Amazing experience here! Ordered a cake last minute for our engagement photos… Wanted something vintagey and sweet. They went above and beyond and it looked PERFECT and tasted just as good! The staff were SO nice and accommodating. The shop is beautiful and clean. I will 100% be back for future events. Honest people that do great work. I HIGHLY recommend them!“

“Family bought the rainbow cookie cake for my birthday today! Was the best cake I have ever had! Everyone was obsessed with it!! Thank you Capri Bakery for making my birthday extra sweet!“

“Ashley and her team created the cakes for both my gender reveal and baby shower, and they exceeded all of my expectations! Not only were the cakes absolutely delicious, but the designs were so beautiful. Ashley was wonderful to work with, and the quality and attention to detail were exceptional. I'll definitely be using Vin's Bake House again for future events and highly recommend them to anyone looking for custom cakes!“

“I highly recommend Baked by Emily Rose! They made a beautiful cake for my mom’s special birthday. Mom loved it. Very delicious!“

“The Bellmore Carvel is very special. The amount of love and care put into my son's birthday cake exceeded my expectations. Amanda is so talented and you can tell she is passionate about designing cakes. She even called me personally to ask if she could alter the cake a bit from the image I provided. It came out a million times better than the image! Thank you, I will only be ordering from you guys in the future!“

“Owner is really friendly! I ordered a birthday cake and emailed him a jpg to put on the top (a cartoon image with my kid's name on it). He had great suggestions for the color of the icing to complement the graphic. Easy and smooth transaction, clean business, and the cake came out perfect!“

“this was a while ago but i love ben and jerrys! such a classic brand. i got the strawberry in a small cup and it was just enough. it was very good! the staff is super nice. the only thing i will say is the air wasn't working right and i wish the AC was on. but other than that it was a nice visit. i knocked over my cup before i could eat it because it was one of those days!!! and he gave me another one no charge. such a sweet cashier.“

“They are Best. Everything they make is delicious. The staff is great. Every time I go in for one thing I come out with half the store!!! They still have the famous pac-man cookies !! Cheesecake is off the cart. I would recommend them very highly!!“

“The best everything is fresh , delicious , and there’s lots to choose from . Just amazing“

“Combine two different birthdays, a wine bottle and an Amazon box into one cake and it was wow looking but not only that it tasted phenomenal. I recommend the vanilla cake with the fudge beyond delicious! Next month, I’m ordering the golf bag cake because this cake was beyond expectations. Perfection amazing“

“Rainbow cookies Cannolis Napoleon Cheesecake A MUST !! The bread… best in the world“

“Rin and Mariana gave amazing service from this beautiful bakery!!! Thank you both!“

“Great Kids Party… Highly recommend for children,“

“Great place on a warm summer night for an array of cold, frozen treats. Don't forget that Wednesday's are bogo free ice cream sundaes. Very clean, great, quick and happy staff. Highly recommend!“

“Brian designed our dream cake for our October Friday the 13th wedding. We went in with some ideas, bits and pieces from multiple photos and what was created blew our minds. Everyone was speechless when it came out. Aside from the delicious taste of the cake itself the details and time that was poured into it is one that we truly appreciate and love. We been to the shop multiple times before the wedding just to grab some goodies because everything is tasty and above the typical/traditional desserts you’d expect. Highly recommended bakery for sure.“

“This crazy story is true. I ordered a special order cake and due to a family emergency, I forgot to pick it up. It was for my son's birthday in HOBOKEN NJ. When I realized I got to Hoboken without the cake, my family all agreed to chip in for an Uber to pick up the cake and bring it to us ($90 mistake for us). When the cake arrived, it was someone else's cake. Maybe we had the same last name, not sure. I spoke with Mike, the manager, and he personally drove the cake to Hoboken, NJ at no charge. That would be 3 1/2 hours round trip. He refused a tip, too. I am still so blown away by this level of care that I wish I could eat carvel every week. Thank you Carvel Oyster Bay. We believe in kindness, humanity and always support local business because of you. P.S. The cake was beautiful.“

“Some of the kindest, most understanding people work here.

It's a Coldstone Creamery, you know what you're getting into.

But the staff is exceptional, we'd been here more than a few times and always had great ice-cream. My keys stopped working and me and my fiancé were locked out of our car late at night in sub 20 below weather. The manager attempted to help us open the car, gave us shelter, and was so kind and supportive. They moved a bench inside for us, checked in and offered so much. They took care of us in more ways than not after an already long and hard day.

Outside of being a good place to get ice cream, I think any locals should support these people as much as possible.“

“it's Carvel, nuff said 🙂🍦🍦🍦🙂“

“Their ice cream cakes are great“

“I had the pleasure of working with Josie’s Cakes for my law school graduation party. From the first conversation I had with them, I knew I was in for something special. Having had my aunt use them for many birthday celebrations, I knew the cakes were amazing. They made sure I received exactly what I wanted. Not only was the cake perfectly crafted, it tasted INCREDIBLE. My guests were satisfied with it and have been inquiring. I thoroughly enjoyed working with them and will continue to do so in the future. Thank you so much for everything! May God continue to bless your business!“

“This is my go to spot. The staff here is really friendly, service is really fast. I usually hang out here for a bit. I just really wish that there was a TV to watch sports. I love the area and the vibe here, it’s just missing some entertainment. Hopefully this place could get a TV soon.“