Restaurants in Brewster

“This is my fifth time ordering from them, and I have not been disappointed. It’s really nice to finally have a pizza place in Brewster that serves good food and cares about the quality.”

“Great Dining experience. Delicious entrees, service and family.”

“we had an incredible meal and chatted with the owners who were wonderful”

“we had a party here and thanks to Helen and staff, it was amazing and affordable! Highly recommend!”

“Great food and service! Beautiful decor. Private room was perfect for our chamber dinner.”

“Everything coming of the griddle looked great. My basic plate of eggs, bacon, and home fries was perfect. Tom behind the counter was friendly and quick. Definitely will come back.”

“We came here as a detour while driving out of town. Place is amazing and authentic (we are from LI). Only issue is it's definitely an eat-in place. We ate in the parking lot since we had our pets with us and there wasn't a garbage can nearby.

Food was so delicious and great portions. Mole with enchiladas wasnt too greasy and had the right amount of sweet. Guacamole was some of the best we have had. Chicken quesadilla and birria tacos were A+. Highly recommend making the trip to come here!”

“absolutely delicious food! Great atmosphere and super nice staff. I go here almost everyday for lunch now. go there, you will not be dissapointed!”

“Have had dinner at The Arch previously each time everything was tasty and prepared well. My wife who's very particular was more than satisfied. In June my wife and I had our wedding at The Arch. We Highly Recommend , Zennel and his staff are professional. The chef definitely knows his way around the kitchen. The food, from appetizers, to desert, everything, was delicious. The entrees were perfect, the short ribs were to die for, no knife necessary. Our chocolate on chocolate wedding cake was incredible.”

“I went to Froggys today for the first time and was blown away by the guy at the register greeting. (Second to none). He wasn’t too busy to speak and didn’t seem as if he didn’t want to be there. His smile, his greeting and attentiveness showed me something I have yet to see at any deli I’ve ever eaten at. And the sandwich (#13) was amazing too. I will most certainly be back.”

“The best Sicilian in Putnam County. Crunchy bottom, soft and tasty inside. My husband and I get a whole pie, it’s the best fresh out of the oven, we eat two or three slices in the restaurant and take home the rest, freeze for lunches. Bring a devoted Sicilian slice customer I ventured out to a salad, not any salad, their Asian salad. Cold crisp romaine lettuce, crispy chow mein noodles, sliced almonds and mandarin oranges, and the best Asian dressing. Really a very enjoyable salad. A great place for good food and great staff.”

“Mezzaluna restaurant is a great place to visit. I live in South Carolina and when my wife and I travel to NY we always visit Mezzaluna several times a week. The food and service is always excellent as is our usual waiter, Nick. He is great at his job, very friendly, observant, attentive and knowledgeable about the menu. The owner who we recently spoke with on the phone is very friendly and makes you feel welcome and special. If you are looking for a great place to dine in I highly recommend Mezzaluna Restaurant”

“Great every time ! Ice cream is the best there !”

“muy bonito el lugar alejado un poco del ruido de New York, lo recomiendo es muy latino y más nosotros que llegamos de europa nos gusta mucho la tranquilidad y allí es el lugar indicado”

“Great daiquiris. My cousins like the food too.”

“I’ve been going here since late last year, and I haven’t had anything they’ve made that I didn’t love. If I had to choose, the Paris-Brest pastries are ridiculously good and the carrot cake is the best one I’ve ever had, hands down.”

“I've passed by this place several times and never thought to go in—thank God I finally did. This is a true Italian deli. My mother, who is full Italian, was in awe of the items they had—it brought back memories of her childhood. I ordered a chicken cutlet sandwich, and it was fantastic—one of the best I've ever had. The owner was incredibly sweet and accommodating. If you're looking for authentic Italian specialties like pasta, sauces, sweets, or just an amazing deli sandwich, this is the place to go.”

“Everything I’ve gotten from here is amazing. I especially recommend the almond croissants! Love seeing them at the farmer’s market but their bread and pastries are always worth a trip to Brewster”

“Ordered through DoorDash. The food came quickly and hot as well as correct. We ordered the hibachi noodles, shrimp and vegetable tempura, beef negimaki and sweet potato rolls. The beef negimaki and sweet potato rolls were very good. The hibachi noodles were a bit gummy but ok tasting and the tempura lacked favor. All in all they were good portions and reasonably priced. Would definitely order from here again.”

“fast and friendly service. great authentic food!”

“You can always get a nice lunch at North Brewster Deli”

“Food was very very tasty. The lobster ravioli were esp delicious and the honey glazed pork belly was sweet and crispy.”

“The food is always delicious. Whenever I order from the place I get so excited. The wings are delicious surprise or delicious although the mozzarella sticks the cheese is a little dry. Everything else is really good. Most of the time they’re on, but the longest they’ve been late is like 20 minutes. I recommend going here.”

“Best cheesesteak wrap and service was wonderful.”

“Amazing food..especially Sunday raw bar!”

“Food is delicious, service is a bit slow but it’s worth the wait I promise. Lots of yummy opinions and prices are good. They also have a buffet style service if you are in a hurry on you want something quick to go. Bread is yummy, they have conchas and a lot of sweet bread that you can get. Love that this is local and I can have a yummy cheap meal anytime.”

“I picked out the shrimp Lo main and I wanted to write a review, I had a shrimp to two shrimp with EVERY BITE, this hole in the wall will make sure you are full. They don't hold back. "You get your money's worth"!”

“I recently left a negative review. I immediately received a phone call regarding my review which welcomed me to let them know if I was unhappy with my food as well as a credit. I thought that was excellent customer service, not too often found anymore. I went this evening and not only received my credit but an additional pizza as well. The pizzas were much better, so that and that the review was acknowledged go very far, a big thank you to Tony's Pizza!”

“Placed a large order for my daughters birthday last minute. Was very impressed with the service and the food was fresh, authentic and delicious. So glad we found this spot in Brewster!”

“Good service nice food friendly service”

“My husband and I wanted to find a local place to watch the knicks VS Celtics game. We called and confirmed with John that they will be showing it on one of the many TV’s. And they did.

We had server named Isabella V, who was wonderful. Very attentive and sweet. Will return and request her for any future dinings at this establishment.”

“Thank you guys for been so sweet and staying open for 2 more minutes since I called and said I was on my way. You guys made my boys night. That's a great way yo end our day.”

“Fast & friendly service. Prices reasonable”

“This is a really nice DD, very clean, nice atmosphere. I had a sourdough breakfast sandwich that exceeded expectations and price point. We needed to stop to feed and change the kiddos and this was a great choice.”

“Has the best pizza out of the city. Chicken parm is awesome and if your not intending on getting to close to anyone, the garlic and tomato is out of this world. Will def come back again when I’m up here”

“The renovation looks great, clean, organized & great service. The only complaint I have is the door dash orders. Went twice to pick up orders and they weren't ready.”

“We came here for our anniversary tonight. The food was exceptional!! We got the eat like a chef and had sssooo much food. Everything was well seasoned and perfectly cooked, we especially loved the polenta mushroom appetizer and the scallops and risotto entree, and the cheese cake for dessert were all amazing. A lot of the food is all from their local farm in Sherman CT which is incredible too!!

Super friendly staff, beautiful location, we will def be coming back. Thank you so much!!”

“From the call to order, thru pickup. Horrible. Lady Linda that answered the phone was rude as can be. Food was cold. The sauces are “in the bag”. Well that was a lie. Tried to run my card, and she kept jamming it into the machine. Never one apology, let’s make things right etc. been going here for years. But after tonight, my family and all the friends I’ve told, won’t either. Shame, this used to be the go to place where the old owners were there.”

“lo mejor en cafés, todo previamente, recién hecho, y con mucha higiene y rapidez,,bgs D,D y mucho más. el mejor lugar para compartir .”

“The food is delicious, love their chicken parm dinner, pasta figoili, well, everything they serve. The employees are the best, friendly and always happy to see you! Don't pass this restaurant up. They are the best!”

“The vegan chicken club sandwich was my favorite and will be what I get next time. Bring cash because they have diff prices if you pay with credit vs cash. 2 sandwiches and a giant matcha came to $43 which is a lot but it was good.”

“It was great … the food was very tasty”