10 Best Pizza Restaurants in Brockport

“first time getting food. ordered the Hawaiian pizza. the service was great and somehow the pizza was even better. Would say that it's easily the best pizza I've had in brockport. 10/10. would definitely recommend and will be my new go to for pizza for sure!“

“I believe this is the best pizza in Brockport, offering excellent quality and service. The pizza is consistently great, and the quality stands out when compared to other chains in Brockport which aren’t good like Domino's and Perris. I highly recommend visiting this location. I hope you continue to provide customers with such an exceptional experience and high-quality food. If you maintain these standards, customers will certainly take notice, as I did, and your business will thrive. Many businesses in Brockport are struggling due to a lack of focus on quality and customer service, but you’re doing excellent work. Keep it up!“

“They refused to do 1/4 just cheese on our pizza. I requested it for my daughter's who will only eat one piece each. What awful service. It is less work and cost less for you guys to put less pepperoni on my pizza. Lazy and very unprofessional. Pontillos was happy to make it the way we like it and now us and our kids are happy too. You've lost our business and our respect!“

“Great food great people! Glad they made the move to gates from brockport! Closer to Home for some amazing chicken parm!“

“Great service, yummy pizza. Subs are good calzones are bomb! Also, great workers :)“

“they got a nasty attitude whoever took my order around 7:02-7:12pm march 27th 2025 is extremely rude and I had him before and was rude then. if you got an attitude then don't work. he hung up on me twice and I called again cuz he didn't take my address for a delivery tonight and was like you didn't tell me delivery and I told him I told u 2 to 3 times“

“Amazing every time!! On point!! This is a gem. Pricey?? Maybe if you want it all. But the crust!! Best overall crust, Crispy, tasty, you just can’t stop!!“

“I order from this place a lot and never have any issues. Occasionally they run a little behind but its understandable because they do get busy quite a lot but the wait is worth it since their food is so good! I usually go at night and the crew always seems like they are having fun with what they're doing and they are very friendly towards me sometimes I enjoy coming here for the conversations.“

“Have ordered here many times but only ordered pizza so I can't speak on anything of the other food. But pizza have been spot on 99%of the time, one time it was kinda greazy and bland but that was only one time. Every other time it's been great, and as of right now this is my go to Pizzeria. Keep up the great work“

“We love our Brockport Wegmans. They are always knowledgeable, friendly, and helpful. They offer a variety of products, including an abundance of allergy friendly and special diet related items. I want to give a special shout out to the pharmacy staff. They work VERY hard, have excellent communication skills, always have a positive attitude...even when they are very busy. I appreciate their customer service and ability to fill prescriptions in such a timely fashion, even with little notice at times. Thank you for being such a great resource in our community.“