Sammy's Fish Box

$$$ • Seafood

41 City Island Ave, Bronx
(718) 885-0920


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Sammy's Fish Box

I have been going to Sammys for many years. Yesterday was the first time I went since Covid. The food lacked the taste I had so become accustomed to. We ordered shrimp scampi, piri piri snapper and virgin piña colada's. The piña colada must've been a powdered mix of some sort. Everything was very bland. I understand restaurants are doing their best to keep up and stay in business however with the prices they charge I would expect the food to be properly seasoned. I will full review
Came to visit tonight with my family (haven't been to city island in 5 years). I'm sure they mean well but the system of taking names without any true sense of how long it will take to be seated was frustrating. None the less we eventually sat down after much nagging. The server was overwhelmed with the number of tables he had to service which is not his fault. As far as the food, my parents ordered piña colada's which were heavy on alcohol (no complaints) and my sister full review
Today July 11 we went to Sammys to celebrate a graduation. Just the 2 of us. We had no alcohol just soda, but the bread & cheese & calamari... we were full. Our food came but our eyes were bigger than our stomach. We took EVERYTHING home. Our server Grace was soft spoken, patient & polite. Service was prompt. We sat in the booth,It was roomy & comfortable. All the staff wore masks. I appreciated that. It felt good to come out after being home more than a year. Sammys you full review

More Reviews(395)


Monday 11AM - 11PM
Tuesday 11AM - 11PM
Wednesday 11AM - 11PM
Thursday 11AM - 11PM
Friday 11AM - 11PM
Saturday 11AM - 11PM
Sunday 11AM - 11PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.