50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Brookhaven

“Had a bad cold and it was a rainy Monday so I was grateful to find Brook House open. Ordered a chicken caesar salad to take home and the staff kindly threw in some potato/leek soup to help cure me. All delicious and the kindness will not be forgotten.“

“Vincent and his team are top notch. Could not have asked for a better experience! The food was incredible and my guests were excited and super pleased. The interactions from Vincent and his staff made the party rock. Highly recommend for your next gathering, you won't be disappointed.“

“Rocco's Pizza is a 5/5. I have been going there 10 years+. My eldest son was the first fan of the Buffalo chicken and Marsala pizza slices when we first moved to Patchogue. Now my youngest son also loves the Buffalo chicken slices. The atmosphere is friendly and the employees greet you with a smile! The prices are affordable and the food is delicious. I definitely recommend Rocco's of Patchogue!“

“Picked up Three pies two hero’s the price is great. we ordered three different types deep dish. Thin. Crust and regular pie with meatballs five stars the meat balls really made the pie.“

“Dinner was excellent! Extensive menu. Ordered from the pasta section of the menu gnocchi a la vodka with melted mozzarella on top. It was delicious. There was an unprinted kids menu that included good items like spaghetti and meatballs, lasagna, chicken fingers with fries, pizza, etc on the night we went. Chose the spaghetti and meatballs and it came with a large bowl of spaghetti and two giant meatballs. My portion was huge too. They were all about service. Very friendly and attentive team members. The restaurant was very busy, but the food came out relatively quickly and very hot.

The only reason I gave the atmosphere four rather than five star rating is because the front door area was so crowded and congested when we arrived that we couldn't get through the dense and unorganized crowd to figure out where the hosts and hostesses were to request a table. We had never been there before so we had no idea if that was a line for a table or takeout. Appears the front door has a take out order counter or area there. There was a back side door that we ended up using and found some hosts in the middle of the restaurant to ask for a table. To our pleasant surprise there was table readily available for us on the patio!“

“My family and I went to them since they first opened.. and when I say there was NOTHING that they made that was anything below amazing, believe me! From their pizza to pasta, to rolls and salads.. even their garlic bread. The hospitality they all provided, especially Benny, was enough to make you remember them forever.. then you add on their food? Forget it. Nothing holds a candle to this place and the family. They are SORELY missed! I have yet to find a salad/vinaigrette, or a marina sauce, from any other place that comes close to this place. I dream of that antipasto!! Thank you for all your years of service to the community. You are so, so missed. I hope your family is enjoying retirement! Love always, Victoria “Bella” (Benny called me that ever since I was a baby!!), Alice, and Raymond ❤️“

“Every good service and great food“

“Simply the best pizza on Long Island!!!!“

“One of our favorite pizzerias. Love all the options. Pizzas and salads are the best around!“

“We are very happy with L'anatra. Love their pizza and we had them cater a party for us this weekend. They delivered to the door for free and the food and presentation was beautiful. The staff is always friendly and accommodating. I wish them much success and highly recommend. Will cater from them again!!“

“My favorite local pizza place! Pizza is always cooked perfectly and never had an issue here. Their sauce is delicious and it goes great with a calzone or garlic knot. The staff treats you like family and cares about the quality of their food. Will be coming back for years!“

“The BEST pizza in the world!“

“Everything AMAZING in one word!“

“All I'll say is.. Mama Mia !!“

“I just found great pizza in Suffolk County 8.4 had the Roman style. Unbelievable and white slice absolutely amazing with a grilled chicken Caesar slice the wife loved it keep doing what you doing and thank you.. see you soon!!!“

“Great atmosphere and friendly people“

“Delicious pizza!! Highly recommend to anyone who loves a good slice! Nelson and his staff make amazing food! Great service and always very friendly! May God continue to bless your business!!“

“I came in there over the summer with my wife and my grandson, Gerald. We were greeted by a young lady by the name of Brooke. Let me tell ya, she was a wonderful waitress to mi familia y yo! She brightened up out dinner experience and made the whole restaurant glow with positivity. I have never experienced such amazing service in my 73 years of life. I especially want to thank her for being nice to my grandson. he has severe autism and she was just a doll! She even sang him happy birthday (he was turnin 7). I tell ya what, if I hadn't lost so much money to these darn taxes, I would've left a $100 tip for this sweet girl. PLEASE give miss Brooke a nice raise. And give her my best wishes. Hugs & Kisses, -Rupert, Gerald and family <3“

“Awesome pizza! Friendly staff, quick service, affordable and delicious! Tony's Wife“

“We LOVE Alfie's. Food and service are always OUTSTANDING!“

“Second time I had Sicilian pizza and salad delivered. One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had on Long Island. I am definitely going to visit them to see what else they have to offer. Their salad was delicious too, and their dressing was outstanding.“

“Just Made the pizza from the Pizza Kit for The Harding Avenue Elementary School fundraiser, and it was delicious.“

“The absolute best !!! Catered food for my son’s graduation party 7/26 never disappoints!! Eggplant parm ,tortellini Alfredo , chicken parm , chicken Marsala all gone !!! Should have ordered more everyone was raving!! Bravo !!“

“Baked clams were so fresh and fulfilling. They have a full clam in each half shell for starters but the stuffing and sauce was so original and flavorful I can't wait to get another batch. The chicken Francese dinner was a beautiful thing as well. I highly suggest Sal Anthony's if you are looking for some authentic Italian/Sicilian food. Fresh bread and wonderful fresh salad with the works as well and a nice balsamic. Pricing was fair as well. I could go on but I'll let you decide. Get in there you won't regret it.“

“Sept 2025: 5 star review. sat down inside and was treated perfectly. It was three of us. The waitress was so nice. The food was absolutely perfect. The garlic knots were the best knots I’ve ever had. Cheesy and garlicky perfection. Would order these every single day. Ordered 16” Paulie’s pie with pepperoni. It did not come out burnt. The taste was perfect!!! Also order buffalo and garlic parm wings. The buffalo sauce was out of this world. The garlic parm was average but still tasty.
I have to say I would return.

August 2025: was a 4 star review. Ordered online and did a pick up. Pizza tasted yummy but lots of the pizza was burnt from the coal fired oven. We couldn’t eat the crust. Otherwise, great flavor“

“Food is amazing! You can have a little of everything which is a major plus for my family!“

“They are my go to for all my party meals... they are all friendly and personable, plus the food is awesome!!!“

“Amazing every time!! Your pizza is like a piece of GOLD!! Thank you for keeping it fresh!“

“I live local and my daughter's went there to have a slice for lunch and said we had to try it and we did and order at least once a week from them great food and beautifully decorated“

“great food , the staff are wonderful. would recommend it“

“We had a catered party yesterday, with several recommendations to use Tony's Pizza. The food was delivered and set up for us. It was piping hot, had very generous portions, and most importantly delicious! Luigi was super friendly at the pizzeria, and great to work with for the follow-up. Thank you guys, for helping my son's 21st birthday be a huge success! The Sitler Family.“

“Thank you for the spinach pinwheels, garlic knots, pepperoni knots, and vegetables with sausages. Your hospitality were great.“

“This is a wonderful place. We always get delicious food from them. The owner is very nice and professional. We are so glad to have a place that is so close to get great food from. Definitely give them a try and support a local family.“

“It’s Tuesday night I just left there speaking to Frank. My name is Thomas Kos. I’ve said this numerous times I believe since I moved to this area there’s no sense of even going anywhere else I’m a big pizza person the Sicilian in the regular or some of the best I’ve ever had the chicken bacon ranch is probably the best slice of pizza I ever had in my 56 years. The people are kind the workers are great it’s just no need to go anywhere else. Great deal on Tuesday and the slices are always huge, I’m shocked sometimes the size of a slice. Guys thank you for everything. Always great going in there.“

“I am the Executive Director at a local senior living community. Our residents have been requesting that we order takeout pizza to switch things up a bit for our dinner service. I placed a large order at the last minute and couldn't be more impressed with how kind and generous they were in the process. The pizza was delicious and our residents are now begging me to schedule another pizza night for them. Thank you Via Pizza for being a great local business that we are proud to support. I can't imagine we will be ordering pizza from anywhere else for the foreseeable future.“

“I order here every single week. Never a complaint. The gentlemen that work there are always super pleasant and smiling.“

“Visiting from South Carolina to celebrate my daughter‘s, sweet 16 and Bella Roma welcome our party of 20 to celebrate!! Their food and service was absolutely amazing!! Gabriella has got to be the best server we have ever had! Top notch service and hospitality!!she took care of our every need with a smile the entire time!! Thank you Bella Roma we will be back!!“

“The food here is quite good. The portions are big. Customer service is quite mixed. Some of the staff are exceptional,others are not. Offer a wide range of delivery options ranging from their free in house drivers,slice,Uber,door dash or grub hub.“

“Just had some amazing slices! 2 Grandma slices, 1 Chicken Marsala slice and 1 regular. Great taste and crust was cooked perfectly. Definitely recommend“

“Service was quick and efficient. We called them a half hour before they were going to close, and they did 2 large pies for us for a pick-up order.
I'm a NYC pizza guy, and this might be the best pizza on LI. It will give any NYC pizza a run for its money.
I was in the area because my sister in law lives down the block. We will be back every time the family gets together in Port Jeff.
We will try some of their dinners next time, but the pizza gets 4 stars, for sure.

Thank you Colosseo!“

“Joe and his crew at Nino’s are amazing. A lot of things stink in this world right now…..but ONE thing that doesn’t stink is Nino’s Pizza. Been going there for over 30 years, and not ONCE was there a bad dining experience. One of Patchogue’s finest.“

“Meatballs-tasted almost identical to when my Italian, childhood best friend’s grandma would slow simmer them ALL day long every Sunday!! The grilled chicken in the Greek salad was very moist and soft. Loved their 6 slice pizza too-great cheese and perfect amount of sauce that’s way less acidic than other local pizza, maybe partially because they use less sauce. Staff were very kind too. Highly recommend.“

“For 3 years, Oven Lovin’ has catered my son’s HS track invitational. From mac‘n’cheese to pulled pork, to heroes, to meatballs and chicken tenders - they have never disappointed! Always rave reviews!“

“A few years ago (before COVID) we placed an order and thought the food was great! Now years later we started having gatherings again, so we placed a catering order for our holiday party that we hosted yesterday & everything was delicious!!! Even better than I remember! The yummiest chicken franciese sauce I think I've ever had! Will 1000% order from here for all of our parties!“

“Great food! vegan options!!! I always eat vegan when I go out due to an allergy. everything was delicious and I ate safely. thanks! I'll be visiting again!“

“Best Sicilian slice around“

“pizza is great. Crust is super. eggplant chicken dishes are terrific. owners are there and extra friendly! Catering is super. very good catering menu available“

“Great food. Great experience overall. 👍🏼“

“they are the best. Tried about a dozen items and all were terrific. Very accomodating.“