10 Best Ice Cream Shops in Buffalo

Sweet Jenny's Chocolates & Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $$
56 E Spring St, Buffalo

Customers` Favorites

Orange Chocolate Ice Cream
Cake Batter Ice Cream Cone
Double Chocolate Ice Cream
Salted Caramel Truffle
Bubblegum Ice Cream
Mint Chocolate Chip
Cinnamon Nutmeg
Black Raspberry
Oreo Cheesecake
Ice Cream Cake

“Sweet Jenny’s is a staple for our family. We never have a holiday table without chocolate from here. Teacher gifts are a must. Summer ice cream trips making memories! Everything here is amazing, including the owners. If your visiting the Buffalo area this place is a must see, we always bring out of towners here! Thanks for being such an awesome part of our community!“

4.6 Superb223 Reviews
Lake Effect Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
1900 Hertel Ave, Buffalo

Customers` Favorites

Happy Birthday to Me Artisan Sundae
Black Raspberry Truffle
Flight of Five Sampler
Flight Sampler Platter
Peanut Butter Epiphany
Toasted Smore Sundae
Chocolate Ice Cream
Coconut Ice Cream
S’Mores Sundae
Ice Cream Flight

“I would love to give a very positive review but as of right now I cannot every time I go to the hertel location there always out of milk . the regular ice cream is great but I only do milkshakes cause I drive alot please fix y'all's problem of running out of milk.“

4.6 Superb134 Reviews
Hanna's Frosty Treats Ice Cream Shop • $
140 Taunton Pl, Buffalo

Customers` Favorites

Small Vanilla Cone with Rainbow Sprinkles
Vanilla Soft Serve with Chocolate
Chocolate Ice Cream

“Very Cute Local Neighborhood Ice Cream Shop with very reasonable prices and nice sitting area to enjoy“

4.5 Superb72 Reviews
Anderson's Frozen Custard Ice Cream Shop • $
2634 Delaware Ave, Buffalo

Customers` Favorites

Pistachio Soft Serve
Brownie Overboard
Curly Que Fries
Frozen Custard
Ice Cream Cone
Beef on Weck
Banana Split
Curly Fries
Kimmelweck
Lemon Ice

“Very good food. Lots to choose from and the frozen custard is so yummy!“

4.3 Superb104 Reviews
Sweet Emilia's Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
543 W Klein Rd, Buffalo

“Best ice cream I’ve ever had!“

4.3 Superb53 Reviews
Pam's Custard Corner Ice Cream Shop • $
2190 South Park Ave, Buffalo

Customers` Favorites

Cotton Candy Maple Walnut Peanut Butter Chip Cannoli
Chocolate Ice Cream
Strawberry Sundae
Ice Cream Sundaes
Ice Cream Cone
Banana Split
Bubble Gum
Hot Fudge
Custards

“Best Raspberry Custard that I have ever had.“

4.1 Good58 Reviews
Crumbl - Williamsville Dessert • $$
5205 Transit Rd, Buffalo

Customers` Favorites

Triple Berry Cobbler Peppermint Brownie Cake Batter Blondie PB Featuring Butterfinger
Sugar Cookie Strawberry Shortcake Chocolate Chip Cookie Birthday Cake
Churro Rocky Road Cookie Dough Blueberry Cheesecake
Single 8 Oz Pouch
Key Lime Cookie
Cookie Cutter
Mini 12-Pack
Mini 3-Pack
Party Box
Cookies

“I had an excellent experience at the Crumbl Cookies location in Williamsville! From the moment I walked in, everything was clean, organized, and welcoming. The cookies were fresh, warm, and absolutely delicious- definitely lived up to the hype.

A special shoutout to Josh, who was especially helpful and went above and beyond to make sure my order was perfect. Great customer service like that really makes a difference.

Highly recommend this location if you’re looking for amazing cookies and friendly service. I’ll definitely be back!“

4.6 Superb299 Reviews
Bryce's Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
1 Naval, Marina Park S, Buffalo

“the absolute best place to get ice cream fast friendly and reasonably priced they also serve fresh squeezed lemonade and shaved ice in a variety of flavors“

3.9 Good7 Reviews
Golden Hour Treats & Things Dessert • $$
735 Sycamore St, Buffalo

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Chip Cookie
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Scoop of Ice Cream
Banana Pudding
Carrot Cake
Red Velvet
Brownies
Crepes
Fruit

“Learned about Golden Hour Treats on Grubhub when I typed in ice cream. Oh boy! I had a banana split which was the best I've ever had. The boys had the cotton candy ice cream and were very happy. I then went back in 2 days and had the banana pudding. I intended to eat a few bites and save the rest...well that didn't happen! Delicious!! Atmosphere is clean and the staff are nice if a little slow. It's definitely worth a trip.“

4.7 Superb100 Reviews
Watson's Chocolates Ice Cream • $$
738 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo

Customers` Favorites

Sponge Candy
Bakery

“Watson's has become a go-to part of my weekly self-care routine. Cashier James is the picture of customer service, warmth, and generosity. Large ice cream portions, delicious chocolates (available by the piece or pound), great hours, and affordable pre-Elmwood-surge pricing. I couldn't recommend Watsons more!“

4.6 Superb55 Reviews

You May Also Like