Pizza Restaurants near Caledonia

“A little late, but want to thank all the folks that made our families Christmas Eve sheet pizza special! It was amazing! Best we have had from you folks so far! Great service“

“The lady who works in the morning bagged up fresh breakfast sandwiches and let me tell you, the yolks were perfect. I read the negative reviews and that has not been my experience whatsoever. It seems as though users Jake fromstatefarm, Cody Preston and Theresa Cirigliano who have only reviewed one business, ever, chose to hold grudges and drop one measly star and not even mention how spectacularly clean the bathrooms are, which is a lot to ask for because you know the grossest dumps ever get dropped in those bowls. I mean, it’s a gas station, workers from all around this area come here just to poop, and their diets are wretched. They eat gas station food so, you get it.“

“Finally went today after hearing amazing things about the gluten free menu. It did NOT disappoint! The only thing better than the food was the incredible staff who ensured everything was safe for my celiac girls and made them feel so comfortable and confident ordering! The portions were huge and so delicious- it was hard to believe they were gluten free! If you have the chance, get the cinnamon buns- they are beyond decadent. Yum!“

“The guys running the place are super friendly! The food is absolutely delicious and reasonably priced. 10/10 recommend!“

“Churchville Pontillos is always our go-to pizza place. They have AMAZING pizza, and are always friendly and accommodating.Tonight, though, they went above and beyond! I asked for a heart shaped pizza for Valentine's Day, and not only did they deliver, they even through in a Valentine on the inside of the box! Little things like this show how much they truly care and put their heart into these amazingly delicious pizzas! Not to mention, it was delicious as always!“

“Cheese and pepperoni pizza slices were good and the bread on my capicola sub was some of the best I had in a while. The style of the restaurant doesn't really match the small town pizza place vibe, it's more geared towards trying to be a trendy influencer haven. More barbie dream house than pizza shop ambiance.“

“Great freshly made pizza. Especially for jamming in the garage. Super nice staff and again, fantastic pizza!

Parking: Small entrance off Chili Ave in between the Colombini’s entrance and the Hair Court entrance.
Looking at Google Maps there looks to be a lot of parking available on both sides and double row in the back,but I only used the front and didn’t pay attention the the rest.“

“I’ve lived near scottsville for my entire life, and we order from marks probably twice a month, and the manager always grabs my pizza as soon as he sees me enter the door, doesn’t even need my name. Tonight I pulled into my spot and was responding to a text someone had sent me before getting out to go inside, when suddenly he was at my window with my pizza. Talk about curbside delivery! Always great customer service. Even in the big evening rushes I know I’m always taken care of as a regular.“

“we drove all the way from conesus bc I lost track of time and everything around closed at 8pm. man o man was this worth the drive! the wings were cooked to perfection and the pizza was amazingly delicious even after the 25 min ride home! you gained a new customers tonight! so worth the drive and the price even left me with gas money lol“

“I just have to say that the pizza I had tonight was the Best pizza from anywhere I’ve had in quite some time. Thank you very much !! Perfectly cooked !!“

“BREAD BOWL SALAD: Fresh, Delicious, and Enormous. Highly recommended!“

“We ordered a steak sub and a meatball sub. On this cold blistery day, both hot subs arrived hot. The steak sub was delicious as was the meatball sub. They didn't skip on the meat. It was seasoned to perfection. My new go to place.“

“Been patronizing this location for about 15 years. The Pizza is Always consistent as it’s the only thing we order. Haven’t tried any of the other menu options but they do look good. Dough is house made which makes it a real pie . The owner is Justin and he’s really nice. If you order the pizza no matter the toppings, you won’t be disappointed. Great flavor and filling. Pricing is avg. nothing out of the ordinary and worth it“

“Had an issue with the Honeoye fall Location tonight put in information they have my pizza delivered to the house, but their computer auto generated it to an old address went back-and-forth with the HFL store telling me I could have a pizza that was 40 minutes old and it was too late for them to make a new one they said my pizza was out for delivery to the wrong address that they had on file but my email says different and then I called the store 40 minutes after my pizza was out for delivery and they told me it was still sitting there. I could come pick it up. I asked them to remake it because I put my information incorrectly. They told me it was not Their problem and it falls on me and that there was nothing they were gonna do other than refund my money which they did.
I immediately called the Avon location and they went above and beyond staying open late past their time of operating hours to make me a fresh pizza as long as I could go there and pick it up. This store has earned a lot of respect from me as a customer they have on location did not have to do what they did but they went the extra mile and they made sure that I was taken care of as a customer. The food was excellent. It was fresh. It was hot, friendly conversation and stayed open past business hours just make sure customer is taken care of. I can’t say enough good things Thank you. To this location and the team members that you have there by far compared to what I’ve been dealing with an HFL, my business will only come to this store going forward“

“This is one of those mom and pop pizzerias that you grow up on, you have family dinners around, you celebrate with. You may have been born in or may have moved to Bergen (as I did) but you quickly realize why the residents are fast to talk about "their local pizza shop." [BONUS] If you have ever had a chance to talk with the owners, they honestly have hearts of gold! Ralph and Rosie's: Good food, good wings, GO BILLS! [try their "plate" it's really good]“

“Great employees! Service outstanding! Great pharmacy! I worked at Lyell four years. Wish I could have worked at Chili Paul instead. 😢 But It was a privilege to work for Wegmans at all. You opened many other doors for me. I go out of my way to come to Chili-Paul 2-3x a week. You take great care of your customers, and that is sooooo appreciated. Keep the Josh Allen Posters up! We were in last week and took pictures with “him”☺️☺️“

“This is a great place I definitely recommend trying there wings and waffle fries😮‍💨❤️“

“I had a GF sub and it was the BEST sub I have had since being diagnosed with a gluten allergy!! I will definitely be back! Also my cheese puff was out of this world delicious 😋 Thanks for being so careful with my food🥲“

“Food and service is excellent.“

“Gabby was very nice and assisted us with a welcoming smile, asking us if we needed anything else after completing our order. I never had the supreme pizza slice before but it was delicious! The new owner Alessio is doing a great job turning this place around!! Would highly recommend!!“

“Found my new favorite west side deli!“