Jamaican Restaurants near Central Islip, NY

Nyam Sum Jamaican Cuisine Jamaican • $
70 W Suffolk Ave, Central Islip

Customers` Favorites

Jamaican Coco Bread
Jamaican Beef Patty
Jerk Chicken Small
Paella Valenciana
Steamed Cabbage
Buttered Shrimp
Curried Chicken
Fried Plantain
Curried Shrimp
Rice and Peas

“Fount the restaurant recently & its been a new everyday spot for me ever since. Always treats me well has a family atmosphere. The food always hits the right spot & gets me coming back. Highly recommended for any culture its a quality spot for “

4 Good113 Reviews
Willie's Delight Jamaican • $
831 Long Island Ave, Deer Park - 6.64 miles

Customers` Favorites

Jerk Chicken with Steamed Vegetables and Plantain
Sweet Fried Plantains
Brown Stew Chicken
Ackee & Saltfish
Curried Chicken
Curried Goat
Fry Dumpling
Garden Salad
Rasta Pasta

“Willies delight has some of the best food on Long Island. My husband and I drove 30+ minutes to come get the food. It’s always a hit each time. With that being said the customer service needs to improve. The older woman who works there always is pleasant and inviting and we love when she’s there but some of the younger employees aren’t as friendly. Also because we drive from across the island we like to call ahead to make sure someone is there and our favorite dishes are available. They never answer the phone and this past weekend we drove out there just for them to have closed earlier than their business hours indicate on Google. We love them but want better service.“

4 Good64 Reviews
Island Jerk Jamaican • $
1350 Deer Pk Ave, North Babylon - 7.16 miles

Customers` Favorites

Brown Stew Chicken with Roti
Fried Chicken Meal
Curry Shrimp Meal
Goat Head Soup
Stew Pork Meal
Cow Foot Soup
Chicken Soup
Curried Goat
Beef Patty
Fish

“Ordered via GH, and food came on time. If you're asking, what's this Asian girl know about Jamaican food? Well, my cousins are half Jamaican, and I've sampled plenty of Caribbean dishes. That's why! Here's our order along with feedback! 1. Beef Patty with cheese in coco bread: Beef Patty was mild tasting, so anyfirst-timee tryers can absolutely enjoy. Personally, I like a lot of spices but was still delicious. It came hot and bread was warm, cheese was stretchy. 2. Curry goat with roti: curry flavor was on point, a good amount of goat pieces and it came with a side of steamed cabbage. Roti was huge so, no need to get an extra order. 3. Jerk chicken with rice and beans with cabbage: chicken was spiced up and you can definitely taste the flavors and heat. It might be because food was prepared earlier, but chicken itself was dry, which is a shame because the seasoning was good. Rice and beans was actually really good! There were some claims of food poisoning and I really hope those diners are okay. My first time experience, we had hot, cooked through food. We also ordered some Jamaican dumplings but I guess they ran out but they quickly submitted a refund for that. Great service and 4/5 stars on food. Is it the best I've had? Probably not but much better than expected.“

3.3 Good49 Reviews
Big Taste Jamaican • $
1048 Islip Ave Unit B, Brentwood

Customers` Favorites

Stewed Chicken
Jerk Chicken

“It's definitely not the best food I've ever had as a brooklynite i use to several restaurants making great jamaican food. I try my best to support local, especially black owned businesses. However, this place just ain't it.I've learned to only purchase certain things here. Their soup, porridge, and breafast are pretty good. But their food ? Let's start with brown stew chicken. Why is the color of the gravy so black? It's called brown stew chicken, not black stew chicken, they put too much browning. Curry chicken was overcooked fish over fried. Beef patty lord, that's not only meat. it's mixed with something else. Plus, they skimp on everything. The new restaurant on suffolk is a bit better but not by much“

2.2 Poor13 Reviews

Enjoy Similar Cuisines In Central Islip