48 Best American Restaurants near Croton Falls

“Went to dinner with friends last night.When we got there it was not crowded yet, so the initial drink and appetizer service seemed a bit slow.My wife got the Jalapeño Margarita, really nice.I ordered the Reuben Eggrolls, a bit disappointed, the cheese overpowered the corned beef, I knew the neat was there, but there was no flavor in it, pastrami would be a better meat choice for that, also the sauerkraut had no flavor. The Russian dressing was meh.We all had the Pistachio Crusted Salmon - ABSOLUTELY DYNAMITE!!!Will order that again, though I do want to try the Hot Honey Fried Chicken Sandwich first.Three of us had decaf cappuccin, those were dreamy, whomever made the foam for those, it was like silk.“

“The most delicious food I have had in a long time! Everything is good and fresh & anything you order is amazing!The Owners are so nice & personable. I had a delightful time dining with my bestie from Florida!I will be a frequent patron and if you have not tried it, you are missing out!?? Beth WhippleVegetarian options: Salads,Rice bowls wraps, sandwichesHot food…Dietary restrictions: Had beautiful vegetarian choices and the food is delicious!Parking: Right across from Croton Falls Train station!“

“Amazing restaurant !!!best service !!best food!!Rack of Lamb off the charts!!drinks are delish!!10 stars!!definitely my new favorite!!!cozy and friendly ..like being with family!!only better!!“

“I could not speak more highly of this establishment. Service is always excellent. It is a clean environment. We are seated right away, food comes out so quick, and everything is always delicious. Coffee is always hot. Prices are hard to beat. Always my go to for breakfast. I Georges place.“

“We hadn't been to this restaurant in years and were pleasantly surprised. I had the burrata and the chicken thighs and my husband had a salad and the salmon. Everything was delicious and the server was very pleasant and attentive. We'll definitely be back soon.“

“Great Food. Friendly service. One of a kind. Definitely going back!“

“We CAN'T BELIEVE we haven't dined here in all these years. With one meal, Traditions has risen to the top. Service was professional and eager to serve. Dinner was tasty, hot, and nicely presented. My wife and I met with the owner Lisa on our way out. Lovely lady!!! We can't wait to come back!! I had the Veal Chop and my wife had the Shrimp with pasta. Dessert was sinfully delicious!!!!“

“Such an adorable place and the food was so delicious! Great ambiance! Lovely hostess and waitstaff“

“There was some construction right outside today (not the restaurant's fault obviously) but the staff was very nice and made sure we sat in a place that was further away from the noise :) The food was really good! And the wait time on the food was not that bad. Would definitely recommend and come back again!“

“Our party of 4 thoroughly enjoyed a Friday night at the Gramercy. The staff welcomed the early arrivers and offered beverages and comfortable couch seating in the invitingly-decorated space. Lauren, our bartender, made an excellent dirty martini as requested. Every staff member we interacted with was friendly, skilled and knowledgeable in an upbeat, "happy to see you there" kind of way. All entrees (the angel hair with shrimp and the special pounded breaded pork shop parmesan) were generously portioned, prepared and presented perfectly, and our two desserts pleased all. The super star of the evening was the paella for two. It was OUTSTANDING with an abundance of fish & chorizo over the most delicious tomato saffron rice foundation. We will go back just to have the paella again, it was THAT memorable!“

“I ordered the wrong thing and though I didn’t expect them to refund me, they gave me a massive discount on the food I intended to order. Very kind of them. I’ve gone here a lot and the food and service is always exceptional. Great for dine in and take out.“

“Countryside Kitchen was a nice place to go for a great Mother's Day breakfast. The staff were all very pleasant, and the food was luscious. They have a large variety of dishes to choose from, and plates were overflowing with an abundance of wonderful food ?!! If you haven't been there, give them a try, and I'm sure you won't be disappointed.“

“Wonderful service and atmosphere!“

“Food is AMAZING!! I am a vegetarian & my husband is a pescatarian. We love their vegan food, the seitan reuben, chunk steak, seitan parm, club sandwich, everything is delicious!! Head chef & owner is so sweet. Also beautiful view & gorgeous interior.“

“Food was delicious I got the chicken roasted pepper panini with cheddar cheese came with cole slaw fries and a pickle my cousin got the chicken souvlaki wrap which also came with fries cole slaw and a pickle for takeout. We got a cheddar cheeseburger deluxe from my cousins birthday dinner and I ordered a quart of chicken noodle soup since it's very cold but our waitress was very nice great Service will definitely be coming back“

“Service here is phenomenal. Sometimes it gets a little slow but trust me the food is worth it. It's just a small diner, they do a bunch of homemade baking and it's always a hit. Love the Biscuits and Gravy and the cheddar chive scone is to die for. Everyone's always happy and the two owners really make the experience so get there before 2!“

“Char is a great place to eat. Incredible attention to detail, service is great even at a busy time. Great cocktails - Fizzy Peach! Not in the menu any more but they’ll still make it. You’ll see the man who runs the place everywhere shaping everything that’s happening all the time. Runs a tight ship but staffed properly so they have the time to do a good job. Men’s room is in perfect condition always - looks and smells new. You know that if that is so right then all the things you can’t see must be perfect too.“

“My daughter invited us to this resturant for hubby birthday on Sunday I’ve never been there before but let me tell you we got seated right away girl who sat us very sweet but overall our waiter Tommy was amazing food was delicious hot and fresh we had the wings flatbread Greek burgers my favorite burger with one desk maybe it wasn’t the heaviest but the best can’t wait to go back tommmy u deserve all the stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️?“

“Amazing. Service was A1, food was amazing but don't come expecting large portions, this place is the definition of quality over quantity. No complaints and experience was most definitely 5 star worthy! Agim was very lovely and made the experience 100 times better!“

“My partner and our 3 children just love coming to burger barn! What a tasty treat this place is! The service is always friendly and prompt. The burgers are out of this world, very creative and juicy. Would definitely recommend to anyone that’s craving a burger“

“Awesome date night spot with amazing food and super lively vibe. Cool bar scene and main dining area has a fireplace. Our group shared a bunch of appetizers and starters (oysters and lobster cocktail). The Clam Chowder was great and refreshingly had an appropriate portion of clams. The Big Eye Tuna, which also has spicy shrimp over vegetable fried rice was incredible and cooked perfectly. No question I'll be back. Highly recommend.“

“Awesome, my sister has been telling me how great Tasty Table is, finally I was able to visit. It was really an excellent experience. The place has a great vibe, the food is great !!!! The service was kind and very knowledgeable. The owner is a sweetheart, very hard-working and very pleasant, she really shows such a passion for her restaurant. We went without a reservation , the place was packed, so we waited a bit, which is totally expected when a place is as popular as tasty table. This place really has it going on !! The mimosa flights, coffee flights, avocado toast, cauliflower, breakfast pizza all delish.. this will be me and my sisters go to place when I visit..“

“Well let me say that out of the many burgers I’ve had, this was the best one in a WHILE! My cousin and I were out and hungry, and on a whim I searched for “burgers near me” and came across POW! Burger. When we walked in, the staff immediately greeted us, and our service was very good.I got the double POW! Burger with jalapeños added in and my cousin ordered the double Cheese Burger, and it didn’t even take 10 minutes, they came and left our order at our table, and we were SHOOK!These burgers are a hybrid via smash burger size but loaded burger presentation (see photo). We took our first bites, and the flavors just hit us like a semi-truck. The patties are made and cooked right in front of you, the vegetables tasted fresh, and their aioli sauce was on point. All in all, 8/10 grade, very good! I have had 10/10 burgers before from places that really push the limits of creativity and flavor, but there’s nothing wrong with going the tried and true way, classic always works!The ambience itself is good, they have a lot of seating, and it did get busy so you know people like the food. However, the grill is out in the open near some of the seating, which is fine, restaurants want to show you that they make your food fresh, but the quality and taste of your food should prove that on its own. Nonetheless, very good experience, I will definitely be coming back here soon!“

“I have nothing but fabulous things to say about Mobile Pie Truck. The food is absolutely wonderful. Authentic wood-fired pizza that rivals NY and CT pies, which are already some of the best. All of our guests couldn't stop talking about how delicious it was. Frank and all of the staff were so warm, friendly, and helpful. Looking for a good excuse to book them again!“

“Hubby and I came here to meet our friend for brunch. It's a spacious, cozy, pleasant cafe with enough room for small and big groups. Alexa was our server. She's fast and attentive. Good! We'll eat slowly. We ordered mussels for appetizer. Then I had a wild fish taco, Hubby had a Village burger, and our friend had a duck quesadilla; I am not kidding; it's a duck quesadilla! Of course, I had my hot green tea! I love my hot tea during brunch or lunch. The mussel was phenomenal! The food was exceptional! We loved everything that we ordered. The homemade creamy sauce that they used on top of my taco was fantastic. I don't usually like creamy sauce or anything with my food, but I definitely enjoyed this one. We want to come back and check out more dishes. Everything's excellent! Thanks!“

“I was just at the Muscoot Tavern lastnight and the food was sooooo good. The Service was great. I highly recommend the Muscoot Tavern!!!“

“I can honestly say this restaurant, is by far, our favorite place to dine. From the intimacy of the dining areas, the attentive staff and incredible cuisine. Many time you go out to eat where one of the courses is good. Here EVERYTHING is amazing. From appetizer to dessert it's all delicious. The hardest decision is what to order. My favorite is the cheese soufflé as a starter then the Beef Wellington and finish with their amazing chocolate soufflé. Our go to for special occasions or just a night out to spoil one self. This is a "don't miss"!“

“Great Food at very reasonable prices. Also. Great quiet atmosphere..Our family had wonderful time.“

“Everything was great, but I would recommend the place knock down the smell of their floor cleaner. I found it overwhelming throughout the place. Some people like me are sensitive to chemical scents and it conflicts with the aroma of the food and drink.“

“If you haven't been to this local slot, do stop in! Monday is Jam Night where area musicians play together. It's a showcase of the talent in and around Mahopac and the Hudson Valley.The food is elevated bar food with burgers served on brioche and homemade potato salad.Vegetarian options: Veggie burger“

“Awesome place to gather up.Good food, music, & environment.The dining area is situated in its own area, while the bar offers plenty of room.I frequent this restaurant and my only complaint if you will is where the pool ? table is situated.It's frustrating when you have to use a short stick v regular cue.Not the biggest deal in the world, but I am a pool player. Which btw so is the owner ... beware! He's good ? lol.Parking: Plentiful & easy.Kid-friendliness: The outdoor patio will keep them occupied..Yes kid friendly.Wheelchair accessibility: Stairs both sides of the entry. The trick to avoid is go in from rear entrance where the out door patio is. Right side of building when facing it.“

“So-so....Not very impressed. My wife had the pastrami sandwich w/ sweet potato fries. Pastrami: Not that great, but the sweet potato fries she liked. My mom had the Belgian waffle. She said she enjoyed it. I had the Blueberry pancakes w/ patty sausages they were ok. I just wished they would have had real maple syrup instead of just high fructose stuff. Since there's a lot of local farms in upstate New York, I think it'll be a good idea to support farms that sell real maple syrup. I will say though, that the waitress and staff were very nice and friendly. Very accommodating! A few years ago I had a cheeseburger and fries and it was pretty good! I would give them another shot again.“

“Such a great dining experience and at a time when they were insanely busy! Wonderful staff, delicious food and excellent service! Ask for Annie A. She was our awesome server!!! I highly recommend this place. Tatiana is very personable and welcoming!Vegetarian options: So much to choose from it's hard to decide! I had the veggie grilled cheese with tomato soup. It was delicious! Will try the eggplant sandwich with vodka sauce next time. The deserts and milkshakes look spectacular and delicious too!“

“These guys go above and beyond. I live in Phoenix az and they packaged my order so I could take it home on the plane and then when I ordered for my family for valentine's day they separated the portions to go to 2 different places for me. They are great and the chicken francese is just awesome. Thank you guys can't wait to get back there, you're my 1st stop for dinner. ❤️ ?“

“First time here and everything was great. Friendly, timely service. Nice ambience - background music was just at the right level and not loud so conversation was easy. Sat by the window for a nice view of the grounds. Bonus was it happened to be restaurant week which i didn't realize when I made the reservation. Food was delicious and plated nicely. Prices were reasonable, quality food. Great time and definitely returning. I imagine it's probably more busy in the evenings, weekends, nicer weather. There are regular, high top tables and bar seating. Reservations recommended. Really no complaints“

“Nice place, excellent service. The scallops were awesome, the baked lobster tails were very good and only a little over-done. They did have trouble not overcooking the snapper, but they were very gracious and accommodating when it didn't work out. Will try this Eatery “

“This local gem offers well-priced and generously portioned meals. The combination of value and portion sizes ensures a satisfying dining experience without breaking the bank. A go-to spot for delicious food that won't disappoint your taste buds or your wallet.“

“We have been going here for years, and have always had great food and above par service. We’ve tried many of the items on the menu and have never had a meal we didn’t love. It’s great for a special occasion, or for burgers and pizza!Vegetarian options: Pizza, bean burgers, pasta, etcDietary restrictions: One of us is gluten free, the other a vegetarian. There are plenty of options on the menu for both of us!“

“When I left a message to determine if this venue was right for my 70th birthday, Nelson the owner forwarded to me an exceptional menu which met my goals. He and his team were very flexible as I came by numerous times checking table materials and possible table setups. The venue including Nelson, his wife Christine and famy met and exceeded all my expectations Nelson was very patient and accommodating. I had a cocktail hour inside because it was too humid outside. Nelson 's team set up the tables and they were able to deliver an exceptional dessert table. The outside was coiffured beyond beautiful! All in all we were certainly return for other functions!“

“Food was good. Service was quick the location is nice but it's a little small. I only had typical El Salvadorian pupusas. They were very good. I would go back for those again but seems like a lot of people came for the soups. Which I didn't try. It gets busy but mostly take out. I would order the Spanish food since everyone there is Spanish. I don't think the Italian side of the kitchen will be as good as the el Salvadorian one since there is not Italians cooking it.“

“Great food. No matter what we choose to eat it is always very tasty. Have not had a bad meal here yet. Decent selection of beers from the tap. Place definitely gets packed on weekends so make sure you go early if you're going to sit down and eat if you want to have a somewhat quiet experience.“

“I love the Horse and Hound Inn. I grew up 1mile from it. they have great people working here. Sue Val’s the owner is a mother to me/friend. i highly recommend the Horse and Hound Inn!!!“

“Lunch with 4 other adults on Friday afternoon. We sat in the bar and it was not busy. Food was excellent. Only two of us ordered appetizers; French onion soup and pretzel bread. I had tuna on quinoa which included a sautéed spinach and mango salsa. I asked for the tuna to be well done, and it was. Another had the burger special-whiskey burger?- and said it was delicious. Two others had panninis and one had grilled chicken on salad. Everyone really enjoyed the lunch. The bartender was also the waiter, server and bus boy. He had a great personality but I think he could have used some help. Beverages included 2 "near beers", 2 beers, iced tea, a margarita, ( that was the only thing that was not good at all!) and 2 diet cokes. Plus 2 coffees. Total bill including tip was $245. Probably would have been reasonable without alcohol. Five different dishes and each one of us thought the food was delicious. Would recommend.“

“We've ordered for pickup up twice and both times the food was phenomenal. So far we have had the Cuban sandwich, Ox Tail Stew, and Chicharron de Cerdo. The food was fresh and seasoned excellently. Finger licking good. They are priced fairly and they are generous with the portions. Very pleased with Tavern on 52. We are making them out go to spot and would highly recommend them to everyone.“

“Visited One Twenty Three Restaurant after a tennis match. The exceptional waiter made our experience memorable. Indulged in delightful chocolate martinis and savored a delicious filet mignon. Special mention to the accommodating staff for promptly fulfilling my daughter's request for a second serving of pasta.“

“This is the second time I've gotten food here and honestly it's fantastic! The service is kind and timely. And the food is amazing. They give you a good amount of food, I would always love more onion rings, but no problem here they give you so much meat in the Gyro and they definitely don't skimp out. I would definitely, come here again and actually sit down and eat one day.“

“Great food at great prices. A creative menu not normally found in Putnam County NY. Whatever I have ordered has been fresh and delicious. The portions are large and usually cant be finished in one sitting. Hamburgers are superb and not made from frozen meat. Salads are especially fantastic and great for lunch or diner. Soups are madefresh and dont taste commercial. This has become my go to eatery.“

“Kelly’s Corner is a classic bar-inspired restaurant in the heart of Brewster. Family friendly, Kelly’s has a lot of classic meals—burgers, wings, beer, common appetizers and sandwich-like items. While not “amazing,” you can rely on Kelly’s to give you good service and serve you a decent cocktail.I’ve had a few items from their menu including their Pulled Pork Sandwich, A Classic Cheeseburger, French Onion Soup, and various cocktails. Their food is good, but not necessarily “great.” Items could use a tad more seasoning and the food is meant to be simple, nothing fancy.For being a simplistic, hometown “bar,” the prices at Kelly’s could be better. A dozen wings are $13.99 and I paid I recently paid over $20 for a burger and a cocktail, with no add-ons. While not “unreasonable,” I’d rather pay a few dollars extra for an upgraded meal.“