22 Best Pizza Restaurants near Elmira Heights

“Chris is an amazing general manager . He is always eager to help out when need be and plus more . He’s very kind to not just customers but to his staff . Anytime something is wrong he will go out of his way to make sure the customer has the right item and will call the customer to resolve the issue .“

“Fratello’s Pizza Company in Horseheads, NY, offers an exceptional dining experience that stands out in the local culinary scene. Their pizzas are crafted with a generous amount of delicious cheese and a perfectly seasoned sauce, all atop a crust that achieves an ideal balance of crispness and flavor. 

Beyond their signature pizzas, Fratello’s provides a diverse menu catering to various dietary preferences, including vegetarian and gluten-free options. Their fresh salads, accompanied by a divine Italian dressing, and irresistible garlic knots are noteworthy additions that enhance the meal. 

The establishment is known for its excellent customer service, with a friendly and attentive staff that contributes to a welcoming atmosphere. The restaurant is also wheelchair accessible, ensuring a comfortable experience for all patrons. 

Fratello’s Pizza Company has garnered high praise from its customers, with many considering it the best pizza they’ve ever had. The combination of high-quality ingredients, diverse menu options, and outstanding service makes Fratello’s a must-visit destination for pizza enthusiasts in the Horseheads area. “

“So good!!! the tiramasu is amazing, and so are the entrees. our go-to spot for takeout! Dine local ♡♡♡♡“

“Pretty sad Pizza place twice now we have ordered pizza from this place and twice have been told allegedly we called Horseheads clearly we called your 562 7000 number as it states on Google but avail no pizza..very rude man behind counter denying I called that store almost to the point of yelling no you called Horseheads when I did not. Get your s×!t together and maybe clean your alleged store!! will never be going back! plus side I called Horseheads and she was very friendly and denied ever receiving our call verifying that it was Big Flats and they do it alot! Proof in the pudding that it was your pizza place called! Thanks for making my kids go without dinner till 730 because I had to call aniellios and wait another 30 mins for dinner!!!“

“We love Pudgie's! Best pizza hands down. The staff is always friendly and helpful. Pizza is made really fast and fresh. The truck drivers are alwsys in and out and they are a little loud and demanding but the staff handles them so well and always has smiles.“

“I almost passed it by and went to the national sub chain where I know what I’ll get. So glad I changed my mind! I ordered a single slice and a roast beef hoagie. Everything was spectacular, but the hoagie really took top bill for me! It was perfectly dressed, perfectly warm and toasted, and I seriously wondered if Jesus himself had baked the bread that day! It was THAT good! I’ll definitely come back just for that! Staff was very friendly and welcoming also! Great Job!“

“Amazing Customer service, excellent selection along with monthly discount special. Their menu items are consistent and reasonably priced! I highly recommend, you will not be disappointed!“

“Very busy, Ling wait, but definitely worth it! So glad they back in our area!

Vegetarian options: Vegetarian and create your own

Kid-friendliness: I'd keep kids in my car or go through drive through

Parking: Lots of parking available“

“This is your typical Papa John's - the same as any chain pizza place. Their pizza is predictable, which is nice. They have delicious garlic sauce to dip in, which is so good. They run good specials where you can get a lot of pizza for a decent price. They've always been quick when we've ordered. All in all, if you want cheap pizza that tastes decent quickly, I'd stop here. If you want authentic, homemade pizza, head somewhere else.

Vegetarian options: There are plenty of toppings you can add to your pizza that would cater to a vegetarian diet

Parking: Plenty of parking in shopping center lot“

“Great place to hang with friends, grab a drink, and listen to some of the best music! I always enjoy their food as well. Highly recommend Ill Eagle!“

“Lovely people. If I had a choice to order from somewhere the rest of my life it would be this place and maybe somewhere that sells mozzarella sticks, but this place is tasty. And don't get me started on how wonderful those delivery drivers are.“

“I had a couple of slices of pizza. Good recipe. Delicious crust and sauce. I think it would help your business during this time to set up a few tables with red umbrellas.“

“Called late on a Friday night, went to place order on phone and was told that it was 50% off online. Got delivery promptly, and pizza was still hot. All of the sauces I ordered came with it too. Great service good salesperson good food, and great delivery driver. Good job Domino's Maple Ave in Elmira!!“

“Went for the fish fry. Got the beer battered which was super crispy and delicious. Piping hot too. Great sides as well. Bartender was doing tables and gave us great service. Highly recommended! Get there early if you want fish. Sold out just after we got ours.“

“I've been driving by this place and always stop for gas and fast food, 1/2 a dozen 4 or 5 times a year for probably 15+ years and never stopped. I wish I did. Now that I live out this way, I've been to this location twice an Market St. once. Pizza is very good. Love the crust and the staff is always very friendly.“

“Great food & great service!“

“An amazing store I can’t wait to shop here very friendly staff as well“

“I ordered an extra large pepperoni pizza last night and it was one of the best tasting pizzas that I have had in a long time. The place is clean and their employees are very friendly. Ordering online was very easy too and the pizza was ready at the time they stated. I highly recommend Paesanos Pizza!“

“always had good food here, however went with friends few nights ago, ordered a dressed cheese steak. pretty lame, nothing but a huge hoagie roll with barely any meat or cheese, $13 for a roll with lettuce.“

“This Pizza Hut isn't one where you can sit down to eat. It's just a take-out location. That said, we ordered pizza from here. My kids all got personal size pizzas and my husband and I got a pie. The pizza wasn't too bad, but it wasn't amazing. The cost has gone up a lot though for what you're getting. I can easily go to a local pizza place and get more pizza for less money.“

“Some more wings ? they were really really good we placed a order over the phone to eat there so all together it was probably a 30 or 45 min wait witch is usual 2 peanut butter cookies and sprite with pink lemonade the guy got the right combination of the pink lemonade and sprite oh the wings were very good we ordered 2 dozen hot wings and they were hot really good I recommend all you chicken wing lovers“