9 Best Pizza Restaurants near Elmira Heights

“Chris is an amazing general manager . He is always eager to help out when need be and plus more . He’s very kind to not just customers but to his staff . Anytime something is wrong he will go out of his way to make sure the customer has the right item and will call the customer to resolve the issue .“

“This place is our favorite in the area. It is, from my experience, the best value around. We have easily fed a group of 5 (3 adults; 2 kids), including dessert, and kept it within a VERY reasonable price range, all while getting some yummy food!“

“There food is very good, service was fast. We will be back! You must try the pork belly...it was awesome, the chicken bacon ranch pizza was so good. The only thing I didn't care about was the crab cakes, they were more breading than crab and a little on the soggy side.Parking: It's a small lot that shares with a mattress store.“

“I am originally from the Southern Tier but left thirty years ago. While home for the holidays I asked who was serving up the best wings these days, Elbow Room or Bernie Murrays, I was surprised to hear both places have fallen and are hit or miss at best. A friend said, its a drive but try the Town Tavern so my wife and I went and found the pub, the atmosphere was ok, lots of people having fun. There was a GREAT BAND playing called Major Big Time and they really rocked the house and had people dancing and drinking up.We came for the wings and ordered, I got dozen with the house sauce and my wife was tempted by the Bacon Double Burger. After a short wait the food arrived and oh... my.... gawd..... the wings were absolutely HUGE and meaty (the Cincinnati area could learn a lesson or two here) and cooked to crispy perfection, the house sauce was amazingly good, not too sweet, not too hot but they found the spot right in the middle and it was absolutely delicious. My wife loved the double bacon burger, saying the patties were perfectly cooked and the bacon was exceptional.I highly recommend the Town Tavern, it is absolutely delicious food served with a smile. On my next trip to visit family, I know where I am going for a plate of wings.“

“Well hot damn! Finally! Haven't been able to find a good pizza since coming back a few months ago until now! It was perfect. Not one thing needed on either of my slices, EVEN SALT! Atmosphere was completely chill, laid back but, quick and on point.“

“Totally decent pizza just a few yards off of 17/86. If you like thin crust NY/NJ/style pizza, this independent, hard-working place is worth your stop. Apologies for the crappy picture... I was starving and dug right in before I realized to snap an image. I enjoyed the meat, lovers and broccoli/tomato/garlic slices.“

“The food at Guiseppi’s is always fresh and delicious. I have to admit that the bread loaves and rolls they were making prior to them changing management was far superior to the rolls they are currently using. I’m sure they are probably utilizing the old Light’s Bakery they now own, but the rolls for subs and especially the cheesesteaks are as delicious as the other homemade rolls and breads they previously made. I realize everyone has had to cut costs; but quality shouldn’t suffer and in this case it has. Their sauces, pizza’s and pasta dishes are excellent. Prices have gone up, but considering the cost of food that’s understandable. The remodel looks great and we visit their establishment regularly. I’m sure we are not the only ones that miss their larger dinner loaves and sub rolls. Still, one of the best Italian-American restaurants in our area.“

“Grabbed a party pack to share with the "moving crew". Everyone loved the pizza, 1/2 sheet bacon & 1/2 pepperoni + meatsauce. Medium Wings good too, but would've like a better drummie ratio. Staff gave us plenty of plates, napkins & cups since everything was packed!! It powered us through the day & night!!“

“Delicious food and a great atmosphere inside the restaurant. The staff is always polite and treat you with respect and serve your food in a timely manner. Their food is always our family's go to. My favorite is their lobster Mac & Cheese and their chicken wings.“