38 Best Bakeries near Fairport

“You have not had a cookie until you have had Maggie’s cookies! We are talking out of this world flavors, amazing consistency, huge size and just 10/10 taste. What ever her secret is, she’s killing it! She had a pop up tent sale this last weekend and I had to go and get a dozen to share with family and friends and keep some for myself. Not to mention she’s a hard working mom who finds time to balance all of this. Supporting Maggie’s business with your sweet tooth is the best kind of cookie decision you could possibly make!“

“Vinny is awesome. What a true pleasure to speak to a man like him. I am SO glad that my wife, daughter and grandkids got to experience what was so much more available to guys like myself years ago. This place is a gem and the food was great. A true unexpected pleasure in this day. Check it out for yourself because good things like this don't last forever. Italian bread is fantastic btw.“

“Thank you Amazing Grains for a delicious lunch! I stopped in for a loaf of Salty Bread...left with that and some Cucumber Dill Cream Cheese. Perfect addition to my Chicken Corn Chowder at home! Winter blues just melted away! ❤️“

“Every time I order a cake from Dianne it turns out perfect. Not to mention the price is always right. I send her a picture of what I want and every time it looks better than what I sent her. So, order from Holy Cannoli she is amazing and you will not be disappointed.“

“Sunday I picked up a loaf of bread, cannolis and an eclair for Palm Sunday dinner. Everything was AMAZING! ...and the cannolis were especially great! Thank you! Kathy & Tony“

“Best milk and eggnog there is!“

“Just stopped by here today and grabbed two loaves of focaccia. Not exaggerating, this is the BEST bread I’ve had in my life. Do yourself a favor and stop by here as soon as you can to grab some delicious home made bread. They also have a variety of local items as well and I picked up some dog treats and pies from crust.“

“Their sponsorship to bring treats a well deserving teachers is much appreciated!“

“The best pastry shop around! They’ve done my wedding shower, wedding, baby shower, gender reveals and more! I couldn’t recommend them more!“

“Best cheesecake I’ve ever had in my life it is so so soooooooo good it is almost orgasmic, just thinking about it I am drooling 🤤 a mist try if you are a cheesecake fan ! Also tried the banana bread it is really yummy and those ginger turmeric bar are also really yummy. The bread is different a little like a pumpernickel I really liked it ! Love this place it’s one of the hidden gems of ROC glad we tried it ❤️“

“I have been wanting to try the beef barley soup for a while now but I’m never in the area on the right day. Today I was and it was well worth the wait even on a hot day! Delicious!!“

“I ordered Blueberry scones multiple times. They exceed expectations every time with big blueberries in every bite. Great with morning coffee. I ordered classic sourdough that was perfect with soup. Crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside. The wheat loaf was gone before Monday! You will be thrilled with anything you purchase.“

“Lily is a wonderful woman, my husband has been helping her with some things around her bakery so he wanted to introduce her to our family which is why we were there. To thank him for his help she is always sending us some of her delicious baked goods. I highly recommend stopping in and checking out what she has.“

“Scratch has made quite a few different desserts for my family and they have gone above and beyond expectation every time. Just when you think their cakes are the best you’ve ever had, their cookies and fresh doughnuts enter the arena too. 🤣 I cannot stress enough about how great their treats and staff are. ❤️“

“Best chocolate babka ever. They do a wonderful job catering too. We used them for my son’s post-wedding breakfast and we heard nothing but great things about the food!“

“Jen and Christine, the owners of Bright Side Sweets, baked a gluten-free wedding cake for our daughter’s wedding. It was absolutely moist and delicious, and also beautifully presented. The customer service they provided was exemplary. I also purchased coffee cake and assorted muffins for other wedding activities. All were appreciated by the bride and groom and our wedding guests. Truth be told, if we hadn’t let folk know that the baked goods were gluten free, no one would have known the difference. Thank you Jen and Christine for making our wedding so special.“

“My favorite part of kiss me cookie is not only the fact they are right next store to our business but they constantly working on improving their recipes. Right now my favorite cookie by far is the sugar cookie with sprinkles! I’ve had to restrain myself some days cause I just want more!“

“Seriously everything in this place is vegan and it is all incredible. That said it's all a big sugar bomb but for the occasional treat this is incredible. A must to bring even your non-vegan friends as they would never know!! Updated from previous review on 2026-02-14“

“The absolute best customer service you could ask for! Kellie was amazing to work with, so kind and responsive. I wouldn't order my cakes from anywhere else!“

“I recommend everything!!“

“Love this place. Wonderful selection of tasty fresh breads, pies, cakes, and cookies. Get there early in the day for the best selection, or order ahead once you have seen their selections. Parking behind the building, often scant. The back door is no longer open so you have to thread your away around to the front door.“

“We ordered a set of 6 through Postmates and unfortunately didn’t get our cookie cutter that we ordered. Postmates has put us through if with supplying documentation l, sending a million pictures, etc… only to say our order isn’t eligible for a refund. On a whim I called in to ask about this and the GM was amazing. She just offered us a cookie cutter. Didn’t make it a hassle, was amazingly friendly, and made me feel a lot less crazy about the situation. 10/10 for crumble cookie 0/10 for Postmates ?“

“Exceptionally delicious cookies at great prices. Sweet spot in Webster!“

“The brunch is incredible and the sweets are delicious! 😋“

“Pretzels were ok, not the best I've ever had from auntie Anne's. The line was very long but moved extremely quickly, staff was fast, efficient, and friendly.

Though the pretzels were slightly overcooked and only like warm.

There was a big selection of different types of pretzels and other pretzel related food items.

I had pretzel nuggets and a frozen lemonade. The frozen lemonade is amazing!“

“Took a chance and ordered a Thanksgiving dinner. Could not have been better! And I can never say enough about their chocolate cake!“

“If I could give a TRILLION STARS I WOULD!!! THESE CUPCAKES ATE DOWNNNN!!! They were delicious point blank period and I don’t even eat cupcakes I just bought them for the kids for an event and my god!!!!!! I needed to buy more! They were amazing! Fantastic spot!!! Will always recommend!!! TOP NOTCH HIGH QUALITY CUPCAKE!! ALL OF THEM ARE DELICIOUS!! FOR REAL HANDS DOWN I had to leave a great review just because the cupcakes was that good!!! My favorite one is the carrot cake cupcake just because that’s my all time favorite type of cake and she had the flavor to make it into a cupcake and it was amazing!!“

“the store is absolutely amazing!“

“Good coffee. friendly workers. very clean environment. I will recommend to everyone.“

“we were greeted by Sam. he was so nice and very helpful and making our decisions. I was having that a great day and the minute I started talking to him it changed my day I thank you Sam..good excellent“

“I was just in the store across from Hoselton Chevrolet in Fairport NY. The girl who was at the window was great at the service she was providing. She was friendly, had a great attitude, acted like she loved her job and delivered quick service. I have been to many Tim Hortons and other drive thru windows she was by far a one of the best I have had serve me. My order was #262161501 in case you would like to reward her, I didn’t catch her name.“

“Good breakfast and nice seating outside“

“Shout out to Sophia at the Eastview location! Wonderful customer service!“

“Coffee is DELICIOUS! The donuts are good.“

“Big Red puts out a mean box. That is to say the manager (I think?) does a great job with his crew and getting the Ryan's breakfast box out and correctly. The crew has some great employees and they really seem to work together well and work hard.“

“Great place ‼️Like the food and the portions are great and I love the atmosphere.“