26 Best American Restaurants near Fishers Island

Pequot Inn American • $$
775 Montauk Ave, Fishers Island

Customers` Favorites

Burger

“The Pequot is a very special place and Ian is a great manager“

3.8 Good14 Reviews
The Irons Restaurant and Bar American • $$
20 Coogan Blvd, Mystic - 9.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Smoked Beef Brisket Sandwich
Crispy Point Judith Calamari
Short Rib Grilled Cheese
New England Clam Chowder
Mystic Chicken Sandwich
Crispy Corned Beef Hash
Crispy Skin Salmon
Firecracker Shrimp
Fried Cheese Curds
Irons House Salad

“Our server Randi was very attentive and knowledgeable about the menu. She is a real p.lus for your business. The firecracker shrimp was amazing.“

4.8 Superb493 Reviews
Dog Watch Cafe American • $$
194 Water St, Stonington - 8.69 miles

Customers` Favorites

Brownie Rockslide & Vanilla Ice Cream
Fish and Chips with Coleslaw
Scallops Wrapped in Bacon
New England Clam Chowder
Truffled Scallop Risotto
Bacon Wrapped Scallops
Tuna Tartare Featured
Lobster Salad Roll
Whole Belly Clams
French Onion Soup

“02.12.25 'Big Al's Reel Reviews' dropped into a Spot located in the Town of Stonington called Dog Watch Cafe. I dropped in unannounced late this afternoon to find out if this spot is serving up Great food, great service with a great atmosphere. Absolutely everything about this place is amazingly Dope!! I absolutely loved the full experience from the service, the atmosphere and most importantly the delicious meal! Dog Watch Cafe is without a doubt a Top Notch restaurant! This place is Off The Hook!! 💣💣💣 Thank you Dog Watch Cafe 👍🏾 194 Water St. Town of Stonington, CT See you on the rebound, ☝🏾❤️- Big Al Mayo“

4.6 Superb443 Reviews
Whitecrest Eatery American • $$
22 Bayview Ave #14, Stonington - 9.01 miles

Customers` Favorites

Eggs Benedict with Scallops
Spiced Shrimp and Ceviche
Buffalo Brussel Sprouts
Oysters Crispy Potatoes
Fried Sole with Grits
Native Mystic Oysters
Grilled Flank Steak
Buffalo Brussels
Steak Frites
Local Burger

“Wonderful staff and amazing food! I’ve never had a bad experience. The use of local produce keeps the menu continually evolving, seasonal, and exciting.“

4.7 Superb74 Reviews
5

Red 36

Red 36 American • $$
2 Washington St, Mystic - 7.38 miles

Customers` Favorites

Seared Scallops with Truffles Mushroom Risotto
Lobster Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Lobster Roll Hot with Butter
Oysters on the Half Shell
Thai Peanut Calamari
Paella Style Risotto
Lobster Mac & Cheese
Lobster Cobb Salad
Bang Bang Shrimp
Hot Lobster Roll

“Food and Drinks Were amazing. Some entitled dude next to us said the drinks were “terrible” when closing out. Could not relate!“

4.3 Superb280 Reviews
Astin J's American • $
762 Long Hill Rd, Groton - 6.51 miles

Customers` Favorites

Double Cheeseburger with Mac Combo
Spicy Chicken Sandwich with Fries
Chicken Sandwich and Queso Dip
Spicy Garlic Parmesan Wings
Beef and Chicken Tacos
Wings and Fajitas
Garlic Parm Fries
Philly Cheesesteak
Garlic Parm Tots
Chicken Poppers

“Was really happy we decided to come here. The food great and we each enjoyed our meal thoroughly. We will absolutely be back in the future.“

4.6 Superb120 Reviews
Fords Black & Blue American • $$
65 Marsh Rd, Groton - 5.1 miles

Customers` Favorites

Lobster Avocado Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Panko Baked Cod and Pesto Risotto
Coconut Curry Mussels
Lobster Fettuccine
Fish and Chips
Noank Chowder
Shrimp Tacos
Lobster Bomb
Clam Chowder
Lobster Roll

“We visited here for the first time last night and we were not disappointed! The dining room is a bit dark, but it’s nice and tastefully decorated. Our server was Christina and she was great. Very friendly and personable. She was very genuine and not faking it for the job. The food was FANTASTIC! I ordered the famous Bisque Bomb, which was pricey, but worth every penny. My husband had a cup of bisque and the B&B tacos with shrimp, and he said both were very good. If you’re in the area this summer, give Ford’s Black and Blue a try. Great food and great staff.“

4.6 Superb115 Reviews
Captain Daniel Packer Inne American • $$
32 Water St, Mystic - 7.33 miles

Customers` Favorites

The Dpi Original Stuffed Portobello Mushroom
Beer Battered Fish and Chips
Lemon Peppered Chicken
Lobster Mac and Cheese
Lobster Mac 'N Cheese
Cold Lobster Roll Mkt
Lemon Pepper Chicken
Dpi Baked Onion Soup
Lobster Roll Lunch
Stuffed Mushroom

“Was very disappointed when we took friends of ours there and told them how good the bread was but when we ordered from Jack was told the bread now costs and yet we were there two weeks ago and bread was offered. Also we had to ask Jack what the specials were and he acted put out. What a change from two weeks ago with waiter Greg who was awesome“

4.5 Superb206 Reviews
Sneekers Cafe American • $
568 Poquonnock Rd, Groton - 6.19 miles

Customers` Favorites

Corn Beef Reuben with Onion Rings
Fried Sea Scallops-Fries-Slaw
Gorgonzola Garlic Bread
Fried Brussel Sprouts
Sneekers Garlic Bread
Panko Sea Scallops
Fried Bay Scallops
Sneekers Calamari
Haddock Nantucket
French Onion Soup

“Absolutely amazing food, i got the fish and chips but replaced fries with onion rings. I would reccomend this cafe to friends, family etc. The live band was amazing and the drinks were even better. I got a grapefruit martini that was a little too bitter. I didnt even complain about it, but the owner herself saw my face and immediately offered to replace the drink or add to it to my liking. The service was phenominal and the food was just as amazing. Whether you just want a drink or are hungry, its seriously one of the best places in the area.“

4.6 Superb62 Reviews
Kitchen Little American • $
36 Quarry Rd, Mystic - 6.54 miles

Customers` Favorites

Crab and Asparagus Eggs Benedict
Scrambled Eggs and Raisin Toast
Asparagus and Crab Omelette
Corned Beef Eggs Benedict
Grilled Blueberry Muffin
Chocolate Chip Pancakes
Lobster Eggs Benedict
Portuguese Benedict
Blueberry Pancakes
Crab Eggs Benedict

“We found this to be quaint little restaurant with water views. Our breakfast was delicious“

4.4 Superb175 Reviews
Buford's American • $
126 Poquonnock Rd, Groton - 6.69 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pecan Chocolate Carmel Brownie Pancakes
Breakfast & Benedict Special
Breakfast Nachos Supreme
Steak & Cheese Omelet
Oreo Cookie Pancakes
Breakfast Sandwiches
Blimp French Toast
Corned Beef Hash
Eggs Benedict
Hash Browns

“04.29.25- 'Big Al's Reel Reviews' Ep.90 💎Buford's Family Restaurant💎 126 Poquonnoc Rd. City of Groton, CT I am so glad that I was tipped off about this small spot by a fan because I have just discovered another 'Big Al's 💎 Gem Spot'. I walked into a warm welcome from the owner Margaret, who was also my server and she was such a sweet lady with a great personality. She was so friendly and great with all her customers and I sat there smiling the whole time. Buford's does not have a huge FB following with just over 1k followers but it is truly an Amazing Hidden 💎 Gem breakfast spot of Groton!❤️ I walked in the door ready to eat so I ordered and reviewed a couple popular menu items: 1. Western Omelet w/Home fries & wheat toast $13.00 💣 2. Buford's Big Breakfast w/pancakes $13.20 💣 The service and atmosphere of Buford's is very laid back, comfortable and when it comes to the food they don't disappoint! I started with the Western Omelet and I ate quite a bit of it because it was the bomb 💣 I knew that I couldn't finish all the food so I moved on to those fluffy delicious pancakes with two easy over eggs, Home fries, crispy bacon and sausage patty. It was all amazingly Dope and easily earned a bomb 💣 as well! I had an amazing experience at Buford's and I understand why the fans have shared great experiences dining there. You really need to get your a** down there right away and check out the latest 'Big Al's 💎 Gem Spot' for yourself. ❤️ Thank you Miss Margaret ❤️ 'See you on the Rebound, peace out!' ☝🏾❤️ -Big Al Mayo“

4.6 Superb35 Reviews
Engine Room American • $$
14 Holmes St, Mystic - 7.73 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chesapeake Bay Style Steamed Mussels
Chipotle Chicken Sandwich with Fries
Grassfed Blue Cheese Fondue Burger
Chicken Skins w Honey Hot Sauce
Fried Local Fish & Chips
Fried Chicken Sandwich
Randy's Double Stack
Mushroom Mae Burger
Mac and Cheese Side
Chicken and Waffles

“Went to the Engine room and sat outside on the front deck. Seating was comfortable & service was quick and very friendly. Everyone very much enjoyed their meals & left full and happy. Would definitely recommend and will plan on coming back soon.“

4.1 Good350 Reviews
Par Four Restaurant American • $
93 Plant St, Groton - 5.26 miles

Customers` Favorites

Penne Pasta with Our Own Meatballs or Sausage
Beer Battered Onion Rings
Firecracker Calamari
10 Pan Cheese Pizza
The Fisherman 8oz
Chicken Parmesan
Chicken Kickers
Soup of the Day
Pastrami Melt
Caesar Salad

“Sept 16 Par Four hosted the 45th Class Reunion of Fitch High School! The sunset & cool, breezy evening was matched only by the excellent wait staff and delicious buffet! We all had such a great time!“

4.5 Superb36 Reviews
Jealous Monk American • $$
27 Coogan Blvd, Mystic - 9.05 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pretzel Charcuterie Board
Buffalo Chicken Rangoon
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Charcuterie Pretzel
Griddled Cornbread
Chicken Sandwich
Chicken Wings
Fish & Chips
Soft Pretzel
Big a Pretzel

“MUST COME BACK! I have been many times, and it just never disappoints. There are no bad seats. Super social environment. Amazing rotating tap list. The food...! THE FOOOOOD! Never a dull moment at the Jealous Monk.“

4.3 Superb250 Reviews
Pop Over Eatery Salad • $
24 E Main St, Mystic - 7.64 miles

Customers` Favorites

1 Tuna Melt on a Popover and a Grilled Cheese Both We Great
Roasted Veggie Hash V GF
Freshly Baked Pastries
Loaded Breakfast Bowl
Popover Turkey Club
French Toast Plate
Classic Cheese Pop
Breakfast Burrito
Vegan Power Bowl
New Trendy Vegan

“Always great food and especially coffee“

4.3 Superb144 Reviews
Groton Townhouse Restaurant American • $
355 CT-12, Groton - 8.26 miles

Customers` Favorites

Two Eggs Any Style Served with Homefries and Toast
Golden Brown Blueberry Pancakes
Chocolate Chip Pancakes
Biscuits and Gravy
Kielbasa Breakfast
Breakfast Burrito
Eggs Florentine
Banana Pancakes
French Fries
Lobster Roll

“Great food. Friendly faces And service“

4.3 Superb142 Reviews
17

Noah's

Noah's American • $$
113 Water St, Stonington - 8.54 miles

Customers` Favorites

Dos Wild Blueberry Pancakes with Real Maple Syrup from Stonegate Farm Sugarhouse Conway MA
Eggs Any Style with Toast & Home Fries
Local Oysters on the Half Shell
Two Bulgogi Lettuce Wraps
Classic Eggs Benedict
Big Messy Dan Burger
Fettuccine Alfredo
Yogurt and Granola
Chicken Quesadilla
French Onion Soup

“Loved everything about this place from the moment I drove up and parked across from the entrance . Hope to be back again .“

4.3 Superb105 Reviews
The Shack American • $
441 Long Hill Rd, Groton - 7.01 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sausage Gravy Breakfast
Home Fries Well Done
Banana Walnut Waffle
Breakfast Burrito
Corned Beef Hash
Shack Corn Bread
Denver Omelette
Eggs Benedict
Hash Wrapper
Kitchen Sink

“The food was great. The staff were amazing and the atmosphere was remarkable. Will definitely be coming back again and again“

4.3 Superb85 Reviews
Market Cafe at Mitchell College American •
437 Montauk Ave, New London - 6.52 miles

“The gentleman who made my tuna grinder this morning did an amazing job! All the food is amazing. The staff is also friendly and kind! Highly recommend“

5 Superb4 Reviews
Grille 92 American • $
235 Lestertown Rd, Groton - 8.64 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Flank Steak with Chimichurri Sauce
Turkey Rachel
Souffle

“great food, reasonably priced...amazing staff 🤗“

5 Superb1 Reviews
Grill At Pequot American • $$
127 Wheeler Rd, Stonington - 10.76 miles

“Great local club. It’s been in great shape the last 2 years! Very good staff and lots of local members.“

5 Superb1 Reviews
The Shack American • $
131 Boston Post Rd #3, Waterford - 7.76 miles

Customers` Favorites

Hot Buttered Lobster Roll with Onion Rings
Eggs Hashbrowns Biscuits and Gravy Bacon
The Dish Is Named the Mess
Biscuits and Sausage Gravy
Our Famous Home-Style Pie
Western Omelette Special
Sausage Gravy Breakfast
Cinnamon Apple Pancakes
Banana Walnut Waffle
Sweet Potato Fries

“Always a great experience!“

4.2 Good93 Reviews
K's Kart Too American • $$
376 Boston Post Rd, Waterford - 9.56 miles
3 Average2 Reviews
Langley's American • $$
28 Lamphere Rd, Waterford - 7.13 miles

Customers` Favorites

Flatbread Pizza
Dessert Table
Salad Bar
Turkey

“We had the most wonderful experience with Langley’s for our small, intimate wedding reception. The customer service was great from start to finish. The event manager Brian was incredibly attentive and made sure every detail was taken care of, ensuring our day went smoothly. The food was fantastic and we received rave reviews from our guests. The team went above and beyond by setting up our decorations exactly as we envisioned, making the space look beautiful. They were also very accommodating and willing to work with us in case we needed to move our outdoor ceremony indoors, as well. We highly recommend this venue for anyone looking for a place to hold your event.“

4 Good30 Reviews
Spouter Tavern American • $$
Mystic - 8.19 miles

Customers` Favorites

Clam Chowder

“We love going to the Mystic seaport and this was a great pub! The food was terrific and the beer was great. You order inside of the counter and they bring it to your table outside. They also have indoor seating. Would recommend if you are going to see the historic village.

Kid-friendliness: Great for the kids because you sit outside.“

3.6 Good9 Reviews
The Spot Cafe American • $
11 Buddington Rd, Groton - 6.35 miles

Customers` Favorites

Apple Gorgonzola Salad
Lobster Mac and Cheese
Country Fried Chicken
Chicken Caesar Wrap
French Onion Soup
Mozzarella Sticks
Fish and Chips
Stuffed Shrimp
Cheese Burger
Fried Pickles

“We were traveling to Mystic and after a long journey needed comfort food. Mike delivered and more. We were impressed with excellent customer service and care.“

4.1 Good78 Reviews