Custom Cakes near Garden City, NY

“This Coldstone creamery location is one of the best on Long Island. Though the wait time may seem long on a busy night it is well worth the wait. Every time I come into this location it smells like fresh waffles and the employees are always eager to help.“

“First time at Leonetti. Loved the place, the layout and open space of the sitting area, the way they have their cakes placed inside the fridge, not overcrowded and are able to appreciate the beauty of the cakes. Everything looked amazing and very clean. I really recommend Leonetti to anyone in the area or just passing by!“

“I had the pleasure of trying cakes from this bakery, and I was genuinely surprised by how delicious they were, especially considering they were eggless! I was introduced to this spot by a friend, and I’ll admit my expectations were low when I heard the cakes didn’t use eggs. But after one bite, I was completely won over. My absolute favorite is their butterscotch cake. It’s rich, flavorful, and perfectly moist. These cakes are so popular that slices often sell out quickly, so I highly recommend reserving ahead of time if you want to guarantee your pick.

Even their cookies are tasty, though I do think they’re a bit pricier for the quantity you get. Still, the cakes are definitely the star of the show and worth every penny.“

“You made me this cake for my birthday and it is absolutely delicious..chocolate cake with cookie dough filling..OMG so good you will be making more 4 me lol..this cake had to weigh 10lbs no joke...absolutely amazing I love it thank you so much for putting in such detail.“

“I just had a “Celebration of Life” for my mother in NY… I live out of state. This business is trustrustworthy and awesome… the items ordered were absolutely delicious( everyone was asking where I purchased from)…it was my pleasure to share my experience…they were so accommodating to my requests, delivery was perfect and on time…they even called to make sure I was satisfied. WOW doesn’t get any better than this! Thank you Nitas… you are the BEST!“

“Excellent baked goods. Delicious pastry and the CANOLI“

“We had the best experience ever with this bakery - the cake was included in our venue pricing through this bakery, and I can definitely see why! Working with Alison to schedule and have our tasting, which was just down right fun...(because of COVID we had to take our samples home... and she loaded us up with some extras to share with friends) to showing her our vision for the cake on the day of, and then actually SEEING and EATING it at our wedding was perfect all the way through. They really incorporated everything we asked for, and it was simply delicious!!! We even asked for an extra birthday cupcake for our nephew to have on the day of the wedding, and they made it sooo cute! (wish I could figure out how to add a picture here... It was SO pretty!!!)“

“Family bought the rainbow cookie cake for my birthday today! Was the best cake I have ever had! Everyone was obsessed with it!! Thank you Capri Bakery for making my birthday extra sweet!“

“They make an addictive challah, I nicknamed it the crack-cocaine challah. You need a twelve step program after having that or their incredible pastries once. Five stars is not enough for this bakery, at least 100 stars.“

“Thank you so much for the beautiful cupcakes for my daughters bridal shower! Everyone was Ravi g about them. Not only were they gorgeous but they were delicious ! I gave your name to a few of guests“

“I ordered a specialty cake for my mother and it was FABULOUS! The cake was unique, 2 - tier choc and vanilla with a hazelnut cream filling. It was covered in a lovely lavender frosting with lace flowers and unique lettering. It was fresh and special!“

“The Bellmore Carvel is very special. The amount of love and care put into my son's birthday cake exceeded my expectations. Amanda is so talented and you can tell she is passionate about designing cakes. She even called me personally to ask if she could alter the cake a bit from the image I provided. It came out a million times better than the image! Thank you, I will only be ordering from you guys in the future!“

“My husband and I were going to a different Cold Stone and figured we should try this one and we're glad we did! We've been here a few times now and it's always a good experience. We order online and go in to pick it up. The people we've spoken to have been great, our order is always accurate and tastes so delicious! This is now our place to go to end our date nights:)“

“Layers Bakeshop is hands down my favorite bakery. The first time I ever had Layers was actually in Pakistan, so it already held a special place for me. Later on, a close friend introduced me to the U.S. locations and fun fact, she and her brother actually own the franchise. They’ve truly done an amazing job with every store so far.

I’ve been to about three Layers locations, and while the Elmont Layers Bakeshop location is the smallest one, it’s also the closest to me, which makes it my go-to. The quality, presentation, and consistency are always on point.

Honestly, I love almost everything from this bakery, but right now my absolute favorite is anything Lotus-flavored you really can’t go wrong with it. The desserts are rich, balanced, and never disappoint.

I also noticed they’ve started making candles, which is such a smart and creative addition to the brand. It just shows how much thought they put into expanding beyond desserts while keeping the same aesthetic and quality.

If you haven’t tried Layers yet, you’re seriously missing out. Highly recommend stopping by especially the Elmont location if you’re nearby.“

“The best Carvel in the area ! What makes it the best is that they definitely have the friendliest staff. And they keep the place super clean. I take my daughter there at least once a week after her gymnastics class and on more than one occasion have been shown appreciation for our loyalty.“

“Rainbow cookies Cannolis Napoleon Cheesecake A MUST !! The bread… best in the world“

“The best everything is fresh , delicious , and there’s lots to choose from . Just amazing“

“Excellent desserts,bread and breakfast sandwiches & spotless!! The owner and employees are very friendly and accommodating. Once you walk in you will see an authentic Italian bakery with a warm home atmosphere, carrying a variety of italian and american desserts!“

“It’s incredibly difficult to find a bakery that can make a delicious gluten-free free cake, but Sisters has not only nailed the recipe they have also set a very high standard! Those of us who have to be GF constantly lower our expectations. That’s just how it is! My birthday cake was the most delicious cake I’ve ever had and it was gorgeous! Thank you so much for the attention to detail and for being such amazing bakers! ???“

“Everything is delicious and fresh! Cookies, pies, cakes, pound cakes, cheesecakes, and the pastries. Holidays are extra special. I only go here whenever I bring something when visiting and everyone loves it. I buy extra for myself too cant resist. Hands down the best bakery I travel from a few towns away.“

“I come here at least once a week and everytime I try a new flavor from the assortment of flavors in their store. The workers there are very ecstatic and always ask about my day. Great ice cream with different toppings. Everyone who gave a bad review is mid and obviously wrote their bad review on the wrong store. Keep up the great work!“

“Delicious cake, amazing staff - who dealt with my craziness on such short notice. Beautifully decorated and brought such a smile to my 16-year-old daughter's face (which isn't easy😉) Even the restaurant staff was impressed by the taste and texture of the cake. Can't wait to stop in again for a treat or to order another specialty cake.“

“Ordered a pull apart cupcake cake for my daughter's 1st bday. All the guests enjoyed. Tasted fresh and delicious. Thank you !!!“

“I used to live in Kew Gardens and would drive to Polito's just for their nut cake. I still remember how delicious everything tasted, and really miss going there. I wish they had mail order!“

“Uhhhh, it’s carvel, of course it’s amazing in every way!!! Love it there, yummy and the staff is great. The owner is such a nice person... we love him.“

“I come here some Wednesdays for the BOGO soft serve. The same two guys are always here and they are always very polite and helpful. Some days there are crowds of kids or families waiting to be served and they still provide good service. I love Carvel in general and this is a good location, very reliable. Parking can be iffy if there isn't anything open on the street but you may just need to find something residential or a block or so away and walk.“

“Buttercooky just made me a cake for my husbands graduation from the fdny academy and i cannot thank them enough ! He absolutely loved the cake and so did everybody else. They exceeded my expectations and were so helpful and kind during the process. I will 100% be coming back for more orders“

“I was walking down the street and my phone died, so I walked in here and asked to use a phone to call my mother, one of the servers let me use there phone and gave me a small cup of ice cream to cheer me up, I was having an awful day and this really helped :) thank you cold stone“

“Their ice cream cakes are great“

“It's so beneficial that this location is now always open until 1am. They are always kind to me when I visit this establishment. The vibes are always on point, just like the music;). The ice cream is always stacked high and even if the ice cream is low they will get it from the back with no issues. I highly recommend this ice cream spot to all looking for a late night snack, or just a snack whenever!“

“Peter helped me with a full rewiring of the house, which included adding new outlets and upgrading the panel.

The team was thorough and made sure to do everything in compliance with local building codes.

They completed the job on schedule and took extra care to keep everything neat.

I was especially impressed by how they cleaned up after each workday.
The house feels much safer now, and I can rest easy knowing I have a modern electrical system.“

“Outstanding customer service!!!
The staff were super friendly, actually trying to make conversations while making my order.

Freshest ice cream hands down, and boy they do go all in with toppings, like literally covered my entire cup.

I am never visiting any other Carvel.“