12 Best Pizza Restaurants near Homer

“Their crust tastes delicious, and they have so many options for toppings! Always ready within the time they say, always friendly staff, and just great all around pizza place!“

“Wow! Amazing chicken Caesar salad! Good price and ready quickly. So good. Highly recommend!👍“

“Great customer service, Wonderful serving Staff and Outstanding Food!!!“

“Excellent mushroom and onion pizza.. thank you!!“

“Ambiance... what is it ( look it up). Hollywood has the Best. Wait Staff - Hollywood has the Best. The food is Great and the Owners are Friendly and Visable. Not just the best in Cortland. The Best in CNY.“

“We ordered sandwiches and it made us so sick my husband had to reschedule surgery . They offered no apology or resolution

After the food poisoning incident from then we tried to give them a chance so we ordered again only for the food to be inedible as it had so much hot sauce on it . When I called to complain the sickly sweet manager told me the owner would never give a refund so she offered a $60 credit . Some weeks later I tried to redeem the credit by ordering some simple things only to be told there was no credit in my name / associated to my number .
Never order from this place you may get sick and if you ever complain you’ll never be reimbursed
Worst restaurant in Cortland don’t go there“

“I order from these guys ALL of the time, been with dominos since 2014 as I was a college student. I lived in Seneca and aside from those guys, this is one of the BEST dominos pizza spots that I have ever ordered. Pizza is always fresh, delivery drivers are cool, indoor staff is cool and they always deliver on time. Great location. Worth every penny!!“

“I ORDERED A SHEET PIZZA EXTRA CHEESE THE PIZZA WAS DELICIOUS! THE THICK-PUFFY !FRESHLY MADE CRUST WAS PERFECT! LIKE FRESHLY MADE HOMEMADE BREAD FROM SCRATCH! FLAVORFUL CHEESE THE PROPER AMOUNT OF OLIVE OIL! THE RIGHT AMOUNT OF SAUCE!!!!! PERFECTLY CUT!!!!! NO! PROBLEMS! WITH! SELF! SERVE! NOR! ANY! PROBLEMS! WITH! SERVE-SAFE!!!!! BRAVO TEAM!!!!! PERFECT-10!“

“We ordered a pizza to be delivered as we usually do. It was delivered in a decent amount of time as usual but it was so over cooked it was like chewing leather, absolutely horrible. I stopped down a few days later to let them know how bad the pizza was and to show pics of how horrible it was. They stepped to the plate and offered to made us a replacement pizza at no cost. For me this is a place that not only cares about their product but also their customers. With this "A Pizza & More" is still number one my book and the best pizza joint in Cortland County.“

“First off.. they have a bathroom, but it's out of order .. that's a problem if you bring your kids. The tables looked as if they needed a major cleaning. Food is ok. Not everything on the menu is available. The online ordering needs to be more user friendly.“

“Very cute bar in cortland. Was surprised it wasn't more busy to be honest. They have tables and a wrap around bar that you can order food at. I sat at the bar and got a pizza. Very good pizza considering the area. Its brick oven which helps a ton. Idk how often he works but if you get the chance to have the guy bartender w the manbun hes one of the best bartenders ive ever interacted with. Great combination of drink knowledge, humor, personality, and flare. Def would recommend chatting it up with him if he works when you go. Only real knock on this bar is the lack of ppl there tbh. Definitely enjoyed my time none the less“

“Pros: the pizza is very good, particularly for the area, and the prices seem fair.

Cons: Very limited menu compared to most pizzerias (literally just pizza, wings, salads and a couple sides) and I wasn't crazy about their garlic knots (last time I went they tasted to me like they used jarred garlic.)

If you're looking to get good pizza, I'd say to give this place a try. If you're looking for anything much more than pizza or wings, you might have to try another place.“