12 Best Pizza Restaurants near Homer

“Mean Mommy - Bacon Pickle Ranch rules“

“Wow! Amazing chicken Caesar salad! Good price and ready quickly. So good. Highly recommend!👍“

“Great customer service, Wonderful serving Staff and Outstanding Food!!!“

“Excellent mushroom and onion pizza.. thank you!!“

“I order from these guys ALL of the time, been with dominos since 2014 as I was a college student. I lived in Seneca and aside from those guys, this is one of the BEST dominos pizza spots that I have ever ordered. Pizza is always fresh, delivery drivers are cool, indoor staff is cool and they always deliver on time. Great location. Worth every penny!!“

“Pontillos is our favorite pizza place. We go almost every Sunday and sometimes even during the week too. Everything we have ever eaten there has been great. The service and the people are great and very friendly. We highly recommend Pontillos and if you haven't tried it yet please do!“

“Ambiance... what is it ( look it up). Hollywood has the Best. Wait Staff - Hollywood has the Best. The food is Great and the Owners are Friendly and Visable. Not just the best in Cortland. The Best in CNY.“

“I ORDERED A SHEET PIZZA EXTRA CHEESE THE PIZZA WAS DELICIOUS! THE THICK-PUFFY !FRESHLY MADE CRUST WAS PERFECT! LIKE FRESHLY MADE HOMEMADE BREAD FROM SCRATCH! FLAVORFUL CHEESE THE PROPER AMOUNT OF OLIVE OIL! THE RIGHT AMOUNT OF SAUCE!!!!! PERFECTLY CUT!!!!! NO! PROBLEMS! WITH! SELF! SERVE! NOR! ANY! PROBLEMS! WITH! SERVE-SAFE!!!!! BRAVO TEAM!!!!! PERFECT-10!“

“We ordered a pizza to be delivered as we usually do. It was delivered in a decent amount of time as usual but it was so over cooked it was like chewing leather, absolutely horrible. I stopped down a few days later to let them know how bad the pizza was and to show pics of how horrible it was. They stepped to the plate and offered to made us a replacement pizza at no cost. For me this is a place that not only cares about their product but also their customers. With this "A Pizza & More" is still number one my book and the best pizza joint in Cortland County.“

“First off.. they have a bathroom, but it's out of order .. that's a problem if you bring your kids. The tables looked as if they needed a major cleaning. Food is ok. Not everything on the menu is available. The online ordering needs to be more user friendly.“

“I can’t say enough good things about Brix Pizza. From the moment you walk in, the atmosphere is welcoming and the staff treats you like family. The pizza is always fresh, loaded with flavor, and cooked perfectly every time. You can tell they take real pride in the quality of their ingredients and the consistency of their food.

Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or ordering for the whole family, they never disappoint. Cortland is lucky to have a spot like this — easily one of the best places around for pizza. Highly recommend!“

“My measure of quality pizza comes in how well a pizzaria performs the basics. Afterall, it is not the topping that makes the bite. The sauce, the crust, the cheese or lack thereof.

I ordered a medium, plain cheese pizza. No frills, no toppings.

On my scale I'd give my first bite a 9.7/13. A high score by my measure! The crust held up, the ends werent too floppy. The cheese was of good quality, not too greasy, nor tough. The sauce wasn't too acidic, nor too sweet, a near perfect blend. Exactly what I was looking for. The crust was crunchy, with a soft interior, perfect for dipping if that's your thing. All of the ingredients melded together in an exceptional example of a well-made pie. It also reheated very well the next day!

All in all I am left craving more. Well worth the buy.“