19 Best Pizza Restaurants near Horseheads

“Fratello’s Pizza Company in Horseheads, NY, offers an exceptional dining experience that stands out in the local culinary scene. Their pizzas are crafted with a generous amount of delicious cheese and a perfectly seasoned sauce, all atop a crust that achieves an ideal balance of crispness and flavor. 

Beyond their signature pizzas, Fratello’s provides a diverse menu catering to various dietary preferences, including vegetarian and gluten-free options. Their fresh salads, accompanied by a divine Italian dressing, and irresistible garlic knots are noteworthy additions that enhance the meal. 

The establishment is known for its excellent customer service, with a friendly and attentive staff that contributes to a welcoming atmosphere. The restaurant is also wheelchair accessible, ensuring a comfortable experience for all patrons. 

Fratello’s Pizza Company has garnered high praise from its customers, with many considering it the best pizza they’ve ever had. The combination of high-quality ingredients, diverse menu options, and outstanding service makes Fratello’s a must-visit destination for pizza enthusiasts in the Horseheads area. “

“We pre-ordered our food from the online ordering system. There were a lot of coupons and specials this way. We arrived early and the pizza came out piping hot at the alocated time.
There is plenty of parking here, seating and bathroom if you need it. The food was very good. We would order from here again.“

“I had a couple of slices of pizza. Good recipe. Delicious crust and sauce. I think it would help your business during this time to set up a few tables with red umbrellas.“

“Rico’s is a fantastic place for delicious food and great service! The menu offers a variety of flavorful options, all made with fresh ingredients. The staff is friendly, attentive, and always ensures a great dining experience. The restaurant is clean and well-maintained, creating a comfortable and welcoming atmosphere. Whether you're craving pizza, pasta, or a hearty sub, Rico’s never disappoints. Highly recommended for quality food, excellent service, and a spotless dining environment!“

“We had a family dinner for Father’s Day at Giuseppe’s. Our meal was excellent and we had an awesome server. Thanks for a great experience.“

“Some more wings ? they were really really good we placed a order over the phone to eat there so all together it was probably a 30 or 45 min wait witch is usual 2 peanut butter cookies and sprite with pink lemonade the guy got the right combination of the pink lemonade and sprite oh the wings were very good we ordered 2 dozen hot wings and they were hot really good I recommend all you chicken wing lovers“

“Been craving chicken wings and onion rings. Found my new favorite place to get them!“

“Pretty sad Pizza place twice now we have ordered pizza from this place and twice have been told allegedly we called Horseheads clearly we called your 562 7000 number as it states on Google but avail no pizza..very rude man behind counter denying I called that store almost to the point of yelling no you called Horseheads when I did not. Get your s×!t together and maybe clean your alleged store!! will never be going back! plus side I called Horseheads and she was very friendly and denied ever receiving our call verifying that it was Big Flats and they do it alot! Proof in the pudding that it was your pizza place called! Thanks for making my kids go without dinner till 730 because I had to call aniellios and wait another 30 mins for dinner!!!“

“We love Pudgie's! Best pizza hands down. The staff is always friendly and helpful. Pizza is made really fast and fresh. The truck drivers are alwsys in and out and they are a little loud and demanding but the staff handles them so well and always has smiles.“

“Amazing Customer service, excellent selection along with monthly discount special. Their menu items are consistent and reasonably priced! I highly recommend, you will not be disappointed!“

“First time coming to Elmira New York. We had no idea the food was so delicious here. We stopped in to this cute little mom and pop shop pizza place and everything looked so good that we couldn't choose just one thing. The owner treated us like family and made these out of owners feel like they were home. The mozerrela sticks were the best we've ever had, thick, ooey gooey cheese, perfectly crispy and fresh delicious dipping sauce. We couldn't decide if we liked the garlic, sausage, or Supreme pizza better. Just get them all! The hot wings and BBQ wings were 💣! We feel like we made a lifelong friend and new favorite spot to bring the family. The owner you can tell truly loves the people that come in and puts love into his food as well.“

“First I’ll start by saying I lay in bed at night and think about the giant pretzels. If they are ever taken off the menu I will be devastated. I’m so glad this bar/restaurant is now a staple in our community, in a building refurbished. I grew up in Elmira, moved away for 20 years and just moved back and luckily live right up the road. When anyone asks for a place for lunch or dinner this is my suggestion. In addition to the good food and atmosphere, for my place of work, I worked with Barb recently - planning a small business event and she was incredible to work with. Our event turned out so nice, the food was delicious, the bartenders we had went above and beyond taking care of us that evening - so much that we are planning another small event in January. I highly recommend Ill Eagle for lunch, dinner or special events. And special thanks to Barb for being so great to work with on those special events. ✨“

“Chris is an amazing general manager . He is always eager to help out when need be and plus more . He’s very kind to not just customers but to his staff . Anytime something is wrong he will go out of his way to make sure the customer has the right item and will call the customer to resolve the issue .“

“We have found this to be one of the best. Friendly staff, orders done efficiently, and quickly, and extra care to a quality pizza, along with specials and reasonable prices.“

“Went for the fish fry. Got the beer battered which was super crispy and delicious. Piping hot too. Great sides as well. Bartender was doing tables and gave us great service. Highly recommended! Get there early if you want fish. Sold out just after we got ours.“

“Great food and fantastic music this Wednesday night. I'll be back!“

“Called late on a Friday night, went to place order on phone and was told that it was 50% off online. Got delivery promptly, and pizza was still hot. All of the sauces I ordered came with it too. Great service good salesperson good food, and great delivery driver. Good job Domino's Maple Ave in Elmira!!“

“An amazing store I can’t wait to shop here very friendly staff as well“