35 Best Sandwich Shops near Islandia

“I often go to the subway in Islandia, NY. There is a gentleman that works there Yatin. He is the nicest, friendliest person ever! I feel like he is always there & always in a happy & cheerful mood. He also makes great sandwiches. Subway is lucky to have such a terrific employee.“

“Great food, amazing lunch specials, and the best iced tea and spices in town“

“Great place to eat. Food is fantastic“

“Excellent place. The staff and manager greeted my family and I with a smile. They also followed up with us while we were eating to be sure we were pleased with the food and service. I would highly recommend it. Two thumbs up and a 10 star rating.“

“Best heroes on Long Island“

“Outstanding Service and Fresh, Tasty Subs!
I stopped by Blimpie at Hauppauge recently and had a fantastic experience — not just because of the delicious sub, but because of the amazing service!
From the moment I walked in, the staff made me feel welcome. They greeted me with a smile, were incredibly patient while I looked over the menu, and answered all my questions without rushing me. You could tell they really cared about making sure I got exactly what I wanted. The sandwich artist took the time to carefully build my sub just the way I asked, and even offered suggestions to make it better — which it absolutely was! It’s rare to find fast food places where the employees seem genuinely happy to be there and go out of their way to provide great customer service, but that’s exactly what I experienced here. Friendly, efficient, and professional from start to finish. On top of that, the sub was fresh, packed with flavor, and made to perfection. I’ll definitely be returning — not just for the food, but because the great service made the visit that much better.“

“Subway is a reliable choice for quick and customizable meals. With a wide variety of fresh ingredients and options, their sandwiches are always satisfying. The service is efficient, making it a go-to spot for a delicious and convenient bite.“

“I've been trying to keep to strict social distancing due to my son's grandparents that he has interaction with due to his father being an "essential" worker. I am healthy and at minimal risk but my worry for others has kept me home for most of this. But, my poor son had a serious case of cabin fever and has been begging for Jersey Mike's so we ventured out. Thankfully your online ordering is painless and I was able to pay online which limited the contact ✔. When I got there, I left my teenage son in the car to limit his contact and I didn't think I'd need help running in and out, as the order was already ready. 👍I was greeted by the same friendly faces in this particular building (I'll drive extra to go to this shop because friendliness and courtesy are a very big deal to me). 😃 I had ordered drinks and on instinct I reached in the bag to grab them..with the gloves I had worn to go inside. I stood there for a half second in slight panic when I heard the gentleman behind the counter. He offered to replace the cups because he had seen my reaction. He insisted even though I tried to deny the offer because it was my own silly fault. I got my son's favorite root beer (one of the other reasons my son loves Jersey Mike's lol) and practically sped all the way home. While this all seems trivial on a normal day...the kindness and awareness that gentleman showed helped me through my anxiety through the situation. Normal is no longer "normal" and his job is stressful I'm sure...But he still paid attention to his guests, he quickly addressed an issue before I could even register it was one fully, and he made my day. I couldn't give him a hug, and nobody wants to see a random lady crying in the middle of a sandwich shop...but I wanted to make sure the store got the recognition it deserved. Thank you for making my stress a little less stressful and for being a place I can trust in the midst of this insanity.“

“Enjoy w ELISA for dinner !!“

“I live in Los Angeles now, but I think about La Saka’s teriyaki chicken and green beans everyday ? So good and they’re not stingy at all with servings, if you ever have the chance to go try this place out you definitely should

Parking: Mall parking lot“

“I had a experience at this subway today.
The staff was friendly, my order was made quickly and everything is taste and fresh. The bread was soft and also vegetables is fresh and the sandwich was exactly how I wanted it.
Definitely one of my favorite spot for a quick and healthy meal!“

“This was my first time ordering from Joe's. Im sorry i didn't order sooner! i ordered the All American Hero with a side of Onion Rings. Holy cow, the size of this hero was massive! I could only handle half of it. It was delicious! I went for this place because it allowed special requests and I didn't want cheese but wanted extra mayo. They fulfilled my request accurately. It was dinner time when I ordered and yet still arrived timely and hot, and Im not that close as I live in Centereach. I devoured all the onion rings, they were too good to leave behind. definitely recommend and definitely will order again!“

“The meal was an absolute delight. Each dish was exquisitely prepared, offering a symphony of flavors that danced on the palate. It was evident that every ingredient was meticulously sourced at the peak of its freshness, from the crisp, garden-picked vegetables to the succulent, high-quality proteins.“

“This Jersey Mike’s hands down is the absolute cleanest and best one that I’ve been to!! The staff is always smiling and happy to help! Very consistent and everything is always fresh!! The staff take pride in what they do and they’re always busting there butts to make it and even better experience to buy lunch!!! So I personally thank the entire staff!!! See you at lunchtime lol“

“I have been going to this Subway since the day they opened in 2003 when Alper first acquired the business. The food is good, it’s always fresh and the staff is friendly. One thing I look for in any business is how well the owner(s) treat their employees. Al treats his staff well.

I recommend this Subway as one of their very first customers who still frequents over 20 years later.“

“Best philly steak around 😋🤗 can't beat the price“

“The staff here are rockstars. They are always friendly and fast when preparing the food and it's always delicious.

I highly recommend any of the breakfast options as well as the deli sandwiches- they're always packed and I never leave hungry (:“

“Had a steak melt hero (Manhattan) solidly packed with meat and not too much cheese - was pretty hungry as was a 3pm lunch. Hit the spot just right. Good value for money + Friendly staff as well. Would definitely come back next time I am around the area.“

“Good staff, young folks Working hard! Good to see!“

“I am astonished with this subway the sandwich was really good The food actually smells appetizing too, like I would go to the subway and stick to it. The employee is really sweet and kind I was not expecting a gas station Subway to taste this good but this Subway tastes so good. Like a luxury. I recommend you guys to come and take a bite of this Subway“

“Convenient location in a small strip mall off major roadway, easy in and out access. Well established. Keeps up with corporation "specials", has good foot traffic. Ingredients are fresh but the "fresh baked bread" sometimes is not "right out of the oven" and can get a little hard after being "toasted."“

“We went here on 4th of July because many of the other stores and restaurants in the area were closed. We were looking for something to take out and bring on a boat and Jersey Mike's subs definitely hit the spot! I was surprised to read some negative reviews because the workers there that day were extremely friendly & helpful. We got the #9 giant hero and a bag of chips (no onions/pickles), all the toppings including hot peppers ? and we had it on the rosemary parm bread . The sub was fresh and was delicious, much better than we expected. The perfect takeout food for beach, picnic or boat. This fed two adults for both lunch and dinner. For about $20. Definitely recommend!“

“The Stickball sandwich is phenomenal. I always add turkey to it. The combo of provolone, salami, ham and turkey ooff ahh. My only gripe is the price for added turkey $6 😂! The place is clean and the smell of bacon cooking as you walk in is amazing.“

“This was my first time to this Subway. I've been to bad ones before where I've gotten sick so I stopped eating it for awhile but I had a random craving for Subway today. I came in around 11:30 am. There was one man ahead of me. The clerk finished with him much faster than I expected. I noticed the store was very clean. The atmosphere was comfortable. I happened for some reason to look at their prepping boards and they were pure white which actually calmed my fear about getting sick. I ordered a philly cheesesteak with provolone cheese, lettuce, onions, sweet peppers, pickles, black olives and jalapeno (like I said random craving) He made a joke when he rung up my order and said $125.40 instead of $12.54 I laughed and asked him his name. He told me his name is Rocky. He printed my receipt and said if I do the survey on the receipt I could get a free cookie. I went on the website right then and there and answered the questions. Rocky even helped me and I got a free cookie. Rocky had great customer service. He made me feel welcomed. Oh and the sanidwich? was awesome! Perfect amount of toppings to complement the steak. I recommend it. Thanks Rocky! Would definitely come back.“

“I was shopping in Walmart and was super hungry after so I decided to grab a bite to eat. The first thing I noticed was that it was very clean and well kept. The person taking my order was super friendly and helpful with the menu. The food was made fresh and everything I ate was delicious. I had a wonderful experience and would recommend to come here!“

“Obviously everything in the mall is expensive, it's rare to see places like Subway located in the mall. This Subway is the only affordable place to go to eat compared to the other stores. The sandwich artist is always there with a smile and gives a good vibe to customers“

“The manager is so nice. I called a few weeks ago about an error that I thought was made and was told to ask for him on my next visit. Well, my next visit was today. He was so great, he remembered my call and explained everything so well and I realized it was my error and apologized. He offered me a discount for the confusion, he didn’t have to do that, that was amazing. I appreciate his patience and great communication, this was excellent service and I appreciate it. THANK YOU!!!“

“I got the original philly cheesesteak and it was amazingggg exactly how i wanted it to be with the perfect sautee onions the melted cheese sauce meat was cooked perfectly tender and soft and the roll perfectly soft. Ive been trying cheesesteaks from everywhere lately and havnt had luck until today with charlies cheesesteaks sandwich. I never post reviews but i felt i had to because i just enjoyed my lunch so much thank you i will be ordering from you guys a lot
Now“

“Frank the owner runs the best subway I've ever been 2 period.“

“Anna and her team put together a large order for my company’s event today and everything was perfect from start to finish. The sandwiches were delicious, great selection of sodas and chips and a timely delivery. Thank you so much for Anna and the hauppauge Jersey Mike’s location for a great luncheon.“

“Awesome subs. Good tasting subs, fresh meats.“

“Visited the Bohemia location for the first time. I pulled up and panicked that they were closed. Relieved to find that it was open and was greeted by an amazing associate that I came to title “Mr Jersey Mike “ as he was a rockstar! He looked like a very young Michael J Fox ! As I said it was my first time and I was accompanied by 2 disabled gentleman that I was treating for dinner. It was Saturday early evening June 1st and I’m hoping you can check your payroll records and give recognition to this incredible helpful knowledgeable and polite dude ! He knew his stuff and made recommendations that were fabulous! The staff working with him were a great team and I left a good tip. Please acknowledge these young men. Their work ethic and professionalism with disabled adults is really worthy of notating! The world hasn’t really had a great work ethic since Covid and these dudes are changing that ! We will be back real soon !“

“They Prepare an excellent sub with the price you can’t beat it“

“Fire service, fire quality food, clean clean clean atmosphere. I always come here with no issues. I just left the subway on Main Street in bay shore because they were so rude and disgusting but here??!! I come here all the time and they never let me down. Always kind and sweet and get me in and out in no time. Highly recommend this location.“

“Used the phone app for the first time. It took a little while to get use to. Once I figured out how to use it it was simple and everything I ordered was the way I ordered it. If you like a certain sandwich you can add it to your favorites list. I will definitely use it again.“