31 Best Pizza Restaurants near Macedon

“Always delicious 11/10!!!“

“I don't often recommend a pizza place, but this small town place is outstanding. Generous portions, rotating $10 deals, quiet, clean establishment, and quite a variety.

It is pizza from THIS area and Culture which I find is about halfway between thin crust of NYC and deep dish of Chicago.

I grew up on this style pizza, and it's well cooked without being overdone, overoiley, or over cakey.

They have the knack!

Good teas, too!
Lots of parking in the back.
Great example of small business.
Nice people, too.“

“Traveled from Southwest Pa to vacation with friends from Wyoming County and Fish Lake Erie. Two Veterans, 1 Marine and 1 Army and their wives. Saw the posts online about this Legion and gave the Fish Fry a try. It was the right choice. Gets an excellent rating from us on food and service. Very nice enviroment as well.“

“Picked up a delicious pizza tonight, and bought a container of Italian cookies….the BEST I’ve ever had.“

“The food was the closest thing to my dear old Italian grandmother's. I commented to our server how the food tasted so authentic and learned the owner/chef is from the same small town in Italy as my grandmother. You could taste it in the food! The service was as good as the food. We left there feeling like we were just at a family dinner. It was our first time here and it's a 1.5 hour drive, but we will be back often. Highly recommend!“

“They have consistently good pizza! They took my order right before closing and accommodated me. Thank you ♥️“

“Food is excellent, service awesome Great place to go! Highly recommend it if you're in the Victor NY area“

“This is the best pizza in Western New York. I've been going there for 46 years and never been disappointed! Tony & Mike are amazing and I always look forward to the time w/ them. Prices are beyond reasonable.“

“Marks in Walworth is always Great!I wish I was out there more often.I recommend anyone to stop in and see Ken Strang for all your needs! I have known Ken for over 20 years and he prides himself on having a great consistent product.Thanks Ken!“

“The staff Friday at 5 was awesome. Polite, friendly and helpful. My 7 y/o son like to contribute and ordered our pizza. Great service for such a young team. Manager did a great job organizing her team!“

“As a longtime satisfied customer of Mark’s in Fairport, I didn’t think I could be more pleased with their service, but I was wrong. Tonight I placed an order online for delivery. After an hour I called because it never takes that long for a delivery. It turns out I messed up and did the online order for pickup, rather than delivery. I drove to the store and was greeted by the manager who informed me she was making me a new pizza because she didn’t want me leaving with a cold pizza. When I told her it was my fault and that wasn’t necessary she insisted I was getting a fresh, hot pizza. I was blown away!! In an age of horrible customer service, this young lady decided to go above and beyond to satisfy a customer even though the mistake was clearly my fault! I have been a customer of Mark’s for quite some time and this just proved to me why! Their slogan is “we treat you like family” and, as it turns out, this is not just a slogan but reality! Kudos to this young lady for what she did for me. It will not be forgotten and I will continue to patronize Mark’s as I always have. Thank you so much for your kindness!“

“Quality of this Nima’s location is SO MUCH better than the Newark one.The pizza quality is just 10x better. They season and flavour the dough/crust and the cheese is actually fresh instead of rubbery chew from Newark’s.Service is also amazing here. The lovely lady is always so nice to me.“

“Great little open flame pizzaria! A little pricey but the craft pizza options are delicious and they have a wide varietys of dough, sauce, and toppings options! Your pizzas are baked in an open fire rotating stone which is cool for the kids to watch.

Dietary restrictions: They have gluten free dough and toppings are added according to your preference including cheese type.

Kid-friendliness: They have small pie sizes that can be out quick for kids.“

“Stopped in for lunch and had the crazy slice of the week. This week it was Blueberry Waffle Pizza. It was a take on breakfast pizza, served with syrup and while I was a bit hesitant, it tasted amazing! The staff were all super friendly and helpful. Looking forward to picking up another crazy slice next time i’m in town.“

“The BBQ is always excellent. The BBQ Cuban is my fav. Beer is great and the vibe is always welcoming. Hot wings were a hit too. Thanks!“

“Great people doing an awesome job. Got a sheet pizza and wings. Alwsys love the food and down the road from my work. Keep up the great work“

“Ordered egg plant parm w/spaghetti, garlic bread, tossed salad to go. Absolutely delicious..“

“First time going here because I was recommended by a friend. And dang I see why they recommended it. The breakfast pizza I ordered was absolutely perfect all the way to the crust. I could have eaten 3 of these easily. Great bang for your buck I will be recommending this place as much as I can. Great job and please keep up the great work. ????“

“Staff was quick and nice. Definitely a 95% takeout only as not really set up for dine in customers. But besides that I got buffalo pizza came out on time and not exactly my kind of pizza ,crust was thick and good a crunch. No flop,and sauce has a good flavor. Plenty of yummy cheese. Over all good flavor and enjoyed the pizza. Totally have it again“

“Their pizza is amazing!! Perfect crust and not greasy at all!!!“

“I’ve worked here since highschool, going to college on and off. The staff are great and all friendly, they welcome you with open arms and treat you like family. When I don’t work for a while due to college, I am always welcomed back with open arms and a place for me to work. I am lucky to be a salvatore’s employee!“

“Really good Hawaiian pizza!! Fast delivery too! (Marion location)“

“We had a paranormal film crew at our museums and Marks was awesome and donated 2 sheet pizzas and 3 different add ons! They were amazingly fast and very accommodating! We highly recommend them to all of visitors when they are done touring the museums! Thanks for all you do in our community!“

“I just love it when I'm traveling and find a new eating establishment that piques my interest.
It had been many many moons ago that I moved out of the NY area. And I've been hankering for some authentic NY style ? ever since.
That's why when my sister, my nephew and I searched and came across Salvatore's. It was a no brainer. And we are so happy with our decision.
The atmosphere of the restaurant was very laid back and comfortable with ample seating indoors and out. The staff was exceptionally welcoming and friendly. We got a brief history of how and who opened the pizzeria. Very interesting information.
And when it came down to ordering, my sis went with Ham Calzone, my nephew went with wings and I, a couple classic pepperoni slices. And we could not have been happier with our orders. Everything was superbly presented and tasted great. The vibe was beautiful and we thoroughly enjoyed ourselves.
I highly recommend anyone needing their pizza fix to stop into Salvatore's. You won't be disappointed.“

“fantastic dinner last night, the ravioli was the best I've ever had. Noah is a fantastic waiter and we certainly adore our Rachel.“

“Pizza is fantastic and the people are even better. The staff have always engaged my kids when we pick up. My five year old got home and said “best day ever” and my 7 year old was raving about the pizza. It’s also a favorite of the parents.

Kid-friendliness: Staff was great with my 5 and 7 year old while picking up the pizza we ordered.“

“Fabulous food. I've been eating my way around the menu and delighted with every dish. My only complaint is the older woman bartender who won't give you eye contact. Wait up to 20 min.“

“Good food, large portions. $1 upcharge for a teeny tiny bit of hot sauce was unexpected and annoying.Good lettuce greens, not iceberg. We didn't get pizza, got the fish dinner and it was hot and crispy and large. Also salad which was above average in size.“

“Wegmans family has built a gem and we love the store, but it was not a pleasant experience for this Christmas. To much virus what if drama, which the stores use to raise goods so high for the working class. No one is giving the working class huge government food voucher. So, does that give you the right to charge $45.00 a pound for scallops, or the high Cheese prices, meat?....There is no shortage.... The huge greed and "virus" drama only hurts the WORKER! How many people do you think makes $45.00 a hour to buy the scallops? So, ...this is the first time our family has went without the splurge of treats from your store. Yet, the government fed eat like a King!...'what a racket".! And your pocket is full.... And the Worker juggles and walks away from the treats! We greatly appreciate the store staying neutral on the "face diaper"!....No haphazard bin's to dispose the "germ" masks in?.... Sun kills it, remember?.....We all need to breath, especially when working!... Sincerely.....A worker“

“I had it delivered- it arrived in I swear like 10 min from when I ordered & so delish! Who ever made that meatball sub? You are my new hero! IT WAS AWESOME! It was so filling I could only eat half-stuffed & smiling. Now I have the leftovers in fridge & am excited to have it for lunch or dinner tomorrow- THANK YOU.“

“Everything you hope to expect when you go out for lunch or dinner. A fun menu with lots of options, a friendly staff and a nice atmosphere. Not your average nachos. Nice twist and definitely worth trying!

Kid-friendliness: Absolutely.

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes“