13 Best Italian Restaurants in Mamaroneck

Osteria Padre Pio Italian • $$$
501 Halstead Ave, Mamaroneck

Customers` Favorites

Fresh Cannoli with Fresh Ricotta and Chocolate Chips
Complimentary Bread and Eggplant Dip
Homemade Fresh Ravioli Any Sauce
Pennette Alla Boscaiola
Calamari Shrimps Salad
Spaghettoni Padre Pio
Chicken Scarpariello
Linguine with Clams
Fresh Seafood Salad
Classic Caesar Salad

“Outstanding food at this cozy, rustic restaurant in Mamaroneck! Wide choices in every category. Everything is impeccably fresh, and beautifully presented by chef-owner Andrea!“

4.5 Superb111 Reviews
Augustine’s Salumeria e Pasta Joint Italian • $$$
213 Halstead Ave, Mamaroneck

Customers` Favorites

Salad with Candied Walnut
Sunday Pasta Bolognese
Meat and Cheese Board
Long Horn Burger
Lobster Corndogs
Brussels Sprouts
Mushroom Tempura
Broccoli Rabe
Chocolate Tart
Bread Pudding

“By far the best new restaurant in Mamaroneck in years! great food and service.“

4.4 Superb313 Reviews
25 North Italian • $$
974 E Boston Post Rd, Mamaroneck

Customers` Favorites

Fresh Whipped Cream Napoleon
Layered Eggplant Parma
Veal Chop Parmigiana
Veal Chop Valdostana
Italian Cheeseecake
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken Scarpiello
Paccheri Porcini
Chicken Milanese
Veal Parmigiana

“We finally made it to this Gem 💎 Italian restaurant. The authentic Italian food was a true delight Rich in flavor. Special thank you to Nicholas, who made our first experience top-notch, attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable service.  TyJason Michael for the great recommendation. “

4.7 Superb267 Reviews
Nonna Carola Ristorante and Bar Italian • $$$
211 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck

Customers` Favorites

Home Made Pasta and Lamb Ragu
Sticky Toffee Pudding Cake
Homemade Mushroom Ravioli
Nutella Fried Oreos
Chicken Parmigiana
Beef Cheek Risotto
Risotto Al Funghi
Nonna's Meatballs
Calamari D'Orati
Mushroom Risotto

“Great service and great food ! Beautiful outdoor space w fireplace“

4.6 Superb238 Reviews
Alessia's Trattoria Italian • $$
551 Halstead Ave, Mamaroneck

Customers` Favorites

Orecchiette Broccoli Rabe & Sausage
Castorani Montepulciano GLS
Garlic Bread w Mozzarella
Endive & Gorgonzola Salad
Broccoli in Garlic & Oil
Baked Ziti Sorrentino
Fettuccine Primavera
Chicken Saltimbocca
Mediterranean Salad
Eggplant Rollatini

“We love this place! We started going to Antoninos years ago so we were hesitant to try it just being a creature of habit. And just like Antoninos,Alessias DID NOT disappoint! Our server Marco and Host Melissa are always top notch, so welcoming and friendly! The food is beyond amazing 🤩“

4.6 Superb141 Reviews
Mercurio Fresh Pasta Italian • $$$
363 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck
4.9 Superb14 Reviews
Rosa Cucina Italiana Italian • $$$
410 W Boston Post Rd, Mamaroneck

Customers` Favorites

Maine Lobster Ravioli
Shrimp Alia Rosa
Tiramisu
Lasagne

“Old fashioned Italian cuisine.“

4.5 Superb36 Reviews
Modern on the Rails Italian • $$$
1 Station Plaza, Mamaroneck

Customers` Favorites

Blackened Scallops over Mushroom Risotto
Stuffed Mushrooms and Caesar Salad
Chipotle Fried Calamari
Chicken Scarpariello
Black Truffle Trofie
Chocolate Lava Cake
Rails Chopped Salad
Rigatoni Italiano
Steak Portavino
Lobster Ravioli

“Modern on the Rails is a solid dinner spot. It’s a great location and the ambiance/decor is a total vibe. It’s definitely got an upscale feel, while also not being stuffy or fancy. You could easily go here for dinner in jeans and not feel out of place, but also if you wanted to dress up for a date night or special occasion, it would also be appropriate.

The space is also really nice and is a good option if you were having a larger group or wanted to do a celebratory meal.

The staff is friendly and attentive.

The food is solid and the price is reasonable for what you are getting. They brought over bread to start and the bread was nice and warm. We started with the burrata app which weirdly came with 3 pieces of medium bread (same as the basket, but toasted or grilled). It felt like it should have been smaller crostini type bread and also more pieces given the app, but it didn’t matter because we had the warm bread basket. The app itself was nice, but not overly special.

For dinner we had the burger and the squid ink pasta with salmon. The burger was good, but the sweet potato fries needed any kind of seasoning, even salt. The pasta was the best dish of the night. The salmon was cooked perfectly, the sauce was delicious and the pasta was great.

Overall, I would definitely come back here again. It’s a nice spot with reasonable prices, great ambiance and service, and the food is solid.“

4.4 Superb112 Reviews
Frankie & Fanucci's Italian • $$
301 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Lava Cake
Tuesday Pizza-Fixe
Gluten Free Pizza
Fried Calamari
Balsamic Wings
Lemon Arancini
Chicken Cutlet
Garlic Bread
Chicken Wings
Chicken Parm

“Love the food. The service And the wait staff“

4.3 Superb97 Reviews
Enzo’s Restaurant Italian • $$$
451 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck

Customers` Favorites

Roasted Potatoes and Broccoli Dine in: Yes Outdoor seating: Yes Takeout: Yes Delivery: Yes
Littleneck Clams in a Light Garlic and Fresh Tomato Sauce
Fettuccine Bolognese Lunch
Shrimp Scampi over Rice
Chicken Scarpariello
Linguine Clam Sauce
Chicken Vesuvio
Veal Scallopine
Zuppa Fantasia
Broccoli Rabe

“Delicious food, and friendly staff“

4.2 Good60 Reviews
Piccolo Mulino Italian Restaurant Italian • $$$
136 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck

Customers` Favorites

Sauteed Broccoli Rabe
Chicken Scarpariello
Chicken Marsala
Chicken Piccata
Homemade Cannoli
Fried Calamari

“We had a great experience at Piccolo Mulino Italian Restaurant! Our waiter, Hugo, was incredibly friendly and attentive—he made us feel right at home. The food was delicious, with fresh ingredients and rich flavors. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, perfect for a relaxing meal. We’ll definitely be coming back. Highly recommend!“

4.1 Good60 Reviews
Pizza Gourmet Restaurant Pizza • $$
599 E Boston Post Rd, Mamaroneck

Customers` Favorites

Sausage with Broccoli Rabe
Phil's Special Salad
Spaghetti Carbonara
Chicken Noodle Soup
Margherita Pizza
Veal Saltimbocca
Chicken Marsala
Chicken Francese
Margarita Pizza
Mandarin Salad

“awesome food,great portions and prices wonderful owners go there you wont regret it“

4.5 Superb92 Reviews
Cosmo & Alex Pisano Bros Deli • $
252 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck

Customers` Favorites

Maple Honey Turkey
House Special
Fresh Pasta
Prosciutto
Sopressata
Bologna

“Ordered online for pickup. The sandwiches were ready very quickly and pickup was super easy; my son was able to hop out and grab the food without needing to park.

The food was incredible! Loads of meat on the Italian combo and healthy amount of prosciutto and eggplant on the Juice Special.“

4.3 Superb37 Reviews

You May Also Like