50 Best Italian Restaurants near Tuckahoe

“Mamma Assunta Ristorante is a hidden gem that serves delicious traditional Italian dishes. The chicken cutlet pamagiana is a standout, tender and easy to cut. The penne hot and seeded bread salad are also popular choices. The restaurant has a bustling dining area, professional and attentive staff, and a friendly bartender who crafts excellent espresso martinis. With a short wait even without reservations, it's a great spot for a night out or special occasions like Easter.“

“Roma is an old-school Italian restaurant that has been around for nearly 100 years, offering a no-frills, family-friendly dining experience. The food is consistently great, with popular dishes like mussels marina, honey, vodka, lasagna, and penne vodka. The lasagna is particularly spectacular. The restaurant has a friendly and caring staff, with a warm and welcoming atmosphere. They offer vegetarian options, including pasta dishes and eggplant Parmesan, and are wheelchair accessible. Roma is a great spot for kids and large groups, with plenty of space to accommodate big families. With its delicious food, kind staff, and comfortable atmosphere, Roma is a reliable choice for a relaxing and enjoyable meal.“

“Angelina's is a fantastic place to get a quality meal. The new owners are updating the dining rooms, but the staff remains the same, ensuring excellent service. The food is still very good, and the combination of great food, friendly staff, and pleasant atmosphere make it a great spot for celebrations and everyday dining. The location is wonderful, with free parking nearby. The attention to detail and quality of food are top-notch, making it a popular choice for special occasions and regular meals. With its excellent service, atmosphere, and food, Angelina's is a great place to dine.“

“Zero Otto Nove is a restaurant that offers delicious dishes, with standouts including the caprese, beet salad, veal chop, and skirt steak. The bar staff is attentive, and the restaurant is a favorite among locals and out-of-towners alike. The clean and cozy atmosphere, along with good service, adds to its appeal. While alcohol prices are on the higher end, the food makes it a recommended spot. Parking is conveniently located in a paid lot in front of the station, which is free on certain days of the week.“

“San Fratello's Deli is a local Italian eatery known for its delicious sandwiches. During lunchtime, it can get quite busy, so calling in advance is recommended. The staff is friendly and helpful, often suggesting their popular options. Standouts on the menu include The Sicilian and The Al Pacino, both of which are generously portioned and flavorful. The chicken cutlet sandwich, in particular, is praised for its freshness and perfect texture. Other notable mentions are the prosciutto and mozzarella sandwich with balsamic glaze, which is a classic Italian delight. The bread is fresh, and the portions are substantial, making it a worthwhile visit for any sandwich lover.“

“Crestwood Pizza is known for its excellent pizza, service, and communication. Customers praise the fresh and tasty food, especially the pizza and garlic knots. Whether you're a lacrosse team or a local resident, the experience is seamless and worth the wait. The thin, crispy pizza and quality pasta keep customers coming back for more. If you're in the area, Crestwood Pizza is a must-try for a delicious meal.“

“Pasquale’s Deli is a beloved spot known for its fresh mozzarella, meatballs, and Italian specialties. The owner, Pasquale, takes pride in his food and community. The store offers a variety of imported goods, hot trays, and deli meats. Visitors can watch Pasquale make fresh mozzarella daily. The friendly staff, clean environment, and delicious food make it a must-visit for those craving authentic Italian flavors. Buon Appetito!“

“Roberto's offers great food and service in a relaxed atmosphere. The restaurant serves unique, high-quality dishes, including the popular veal sorrentino. The atmosphere is comfortable, with well-spaced tables and a great environment. The staff provides outstanding service, ensuring that any issues are promptly addressed. With its excellent food and service, Roberto's is considered one of the best Italian restaurants in the Bronx and Westchester County, making it a great spot to celebrate special occasions or enjoy a regular meal.“

“Vinatería is a renowned Italian restaurant in Harlem, praised for its exceptional food and atmosphere. The restaurant offers a variety of authentic Italian dishes, including its signature squid ink pasta and lamb chops, which are said to "melt in your mouth like butter". The decor is beautiful and classy, making it an ideal spot for both group gatherings and romantic dates. The staff is consistently friendly and attentive, ensuring a phenomenal dining experience. With its perfectly cooked pasta and rich, flavorful sauce, Vinatería is a must-visit for Italian food lovers.“

“Zero Otto Nove in the Bronx offers a memorable dining experience with its vibrant atmosphere and exceptional Italian cuisine. The Margherita pie with flavorful tomato sauce and fresh basil is a highlight, while the pasta fagioli soup is rich and hearty. The baked potato is fluffy and well-seasoned, and the La Cirlio pizza is a phenomenal choice with creamy butternut squash puree and fresh mozzarella. The restaurant's ambiance resembles a classic Italian trattoria, transporting diners to Italy with its charming decor and elegant waitstaff. The menu offers a variety of delicious options, from burrata and calamari to pasta and pollo dishes. With attentive service and generous portions, dining at Zero Otto Nove is a must-visit for those looking to enjoy fantastic Italian cuisine in the Bronx.“

“Fumo Harlem is a top-rated restaurant that consistently delivers great customer service, ambiance, and food. The menu offers a range of options, including lunch specials that are economical and delicious. Standout dishes include the spicy calamari, penne with mushroom and truffle, lobster spaghetti, and the popular "Roni" pizza. The Fried Mozz and Kale Caesar salad are also recommended as appetizers. While some reviewers have experienced slow service, the staff is generally helpful and friendly. With its great energy, consistent food quality, and reasonably priced drinks, Fumo Harlem is a go-to spot for a satisfying meal and a good time.“

“Kingsbridge Social Club offers a top-notch dining experience with delicious food and friendly service. The wrecking ball pizza with cherry peppers is a must-try, with perfect mozzarella, amazing pepperoni, and fresh cherry peppers on flavorful bread. The chicken parm and spaghetti are also highly recommended. The cocktails, like the tequila with lime and basil simple syrup, are a hit. The bar has a good selection of beers, and outdoor seating is available in warmer weather. The staff, including Lilivette, are attentive and create a welcoming atmosphere. Whether for lunch or dinner, this hidden gem in NYC is worth a visit for a memorable meal.“

“Sergio's is a highly recommended restaurant for a nice lunch or dinner. With its Old school Italian restaurant vibe, the atmosphere is cozy and inviting. The service is impeccable, with attentive staff that make guests feel like they're the most important person there. The cuisine is excellent, with dishes such as the sopressata/provolone appetizer and the Napoleon dessert being standouts. Whether celebrating a special occasion or just enjoying a meal with friends, Sergio's is a great choice.“

“Chazz Palminteri Italian Restaurant White Plains offers a consistently excellent dining experience. Friendly and attentive servers, such as Elson and Tommasso, provide top-notch service. The food is outstanding, with delicious dishes like eggplant parm, risotto balls, buccatini, chicken marsala, shrimp dish, lasagna, and Chicken Pizzaola.“

“25 North is a wonderful restaurant with great food and a friendly service team. The atmosphere is fun and lively, and the valet service is convenient. The staff, including waiters like John, are thorough, precise, and make guests feel like family. The restaurant is a standout in Westchester, offering superb food and exceptional service that makes it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.“

“Augustine's Salumeria e Pasta Joint is a small local spot run by a dynamic NYC duo. The chef creates confident dishes in the kitchen, while the sommelier wife covers the front of house and selects unique wines. The menu features dishes like steak tartar, pesto mussels, pasta with Sunday gravy, and grilled asparagus with crème freche balls. Octopus, saffron orecchiette, and pork chop are also highlights, with great flavors and perfect cooking. The service is polite and friendly, making for a wonderful dining experience. With great food, wine, and service, Augustine's is a must-visit spot.“

“The Cookery offers a lively atmosphere with delicious food, making it a great dining destination. The service is commendable, and the menu offers tasty options such as the pizza rustica. However, the outdoor dining area can get quite hot and the menu could benefit from more detailed descriptions to manage expectations. Additionally, the lack of menu options for brunch, particularly the prix-fix, might not suit everyone's preference. Despite these minor drawbacks, The Cookery is worth visiting for a delightful dining experience.“

“Verana offers amazing food, especially the pastas, with impeccable service and a welcoming atmosphere. The grilled pear salad and chicken Parmesan are must-tries. Despite being busy, the staff is patient and attentive. The restaurant has a variety of vegetarian options and a drink menu worth exploring. Everything, from the bread to the desserts, is made from scratch by a talented kitchen staff. The pasta is particularly outstanding, rivalling what you'd find in Italy. Verana provides a great dining experience that will leave you wanting to come back for more.“

“Piattini Café Bar Osteria on Arthur Ave offers a welcoming atmosphere and excellent service. The owner, Victor, ensures a personal touch, making guests feel like family. Customers enjoy well-made drinks like Aperol Spritz and Negronis. The food is top-notch, leaving visitors eager to try more dishes from the menu. Dining here feels like being at a friend's house, with friendly people and delicious food. A true gem worth revisiting for an unforgettable experience.“

“Zuppa Restaurant offers a dining experience that exceeds expectations. From the attentive staff and superior service to the mouthwatering dishes, such as the lamb chops and flourless lava cake, the restaurant provides a delightful and indulgent atmosphere. The free valet parking and accommodating team ensure a seamless visit, making guests feel like long-time friends.“

“Torcello Ristorante Italiano offers a delightful dining experience with an extensive menu featuring Italian specialties and other options. The service is excellent, with friendly and helpful staff. The atmosphere is elegant, with a muted decor that exudes sophistication. Popular dishes include the breast of duck over spinach, veal porcini, and lamb chops, served with sides. While some dishes may have minor imperfections, the restaurant strives to compensate with excellent service and a lovely atmosphere. With easy parking and a hidden location, Torcello Ristorante Italiano is a gem worth visiting.“

“Tra Di Noi is a highly recommended Italian restaurant that offers a scrumptious dining experience. The staff goes above and beyond to ensure customer satisfaction, providing excellent service from the moment guests are seated. The menu features a variety of delectable dishes, including the popular stuffed artichoke, gnocchi sorrentino special, and lasagna with bolognese sauce. Diners can also indulge in a selection of Italian beers and wines to complement their meal. The restaurant is known for its specials, which are consistently praised as delicious. Although reservations are recommended, the staff is accommodating and remembers regular customers, even those who live in other boroughs. The front entrance may be a tight fit for wheelchair users, but the restaurant is accessible. Overall, Tra Di Noi is an outstanding Italian dining destination in New York City.“

“Patricia's of Morris Park is a wonderful find, offering excellent southern Italian cuisine with a twist. The restaurant serves a range of outstanding dishes, including the sublime scallops over lentils and the delicious caccio e pepe. The setting is great, with a cool, old-school room and friendly service. While the noise level can be high, the restaurant's generous portions and tasty food make it a great choice. With options like fetticini alfredo, sausage and pepper calzone, and salads with chicken, there's something for everyone at Patricia's.“

“City Island Pizza Company offers great food, a relaxing ambiance, trendy decor, and friendly staff providing wonderful service. They have interesting locally sourced offerings, making their own bread and sausages. The Sunday dinner special includes pasta with Sunday red sauce, meatballs, and sausage, accompanied by a house salad and garlic bread. Generous portions, a nice selection of wines, and creative appetizers. A perfect spot for brunch and evening gatherings. Highly recommended.“

“Bistro House is a welcoming spot for a quick bite or a leisurely meal. The menu features "Masterpiece Sandwiches" and "coconut Shrimp" among other options, with a daily selection of specials. The food is fresh and delicious, with Italian dishes being a particular highlight. The atmosphere is unpretentious, and the owners are pleasant to interact with. BYOB adds to the restaurant's charm.“

“Da Franco & Tony serves mouthwateringly good food at fair prices. The service is generally good, although it can be spotty at times. Parking can be a challenge, but the excellent food and professional, friendly staff make it worth the effort. Try their fresh tagliatelle with veal ragu and homemade rice balls for a great meal.“

“Cafe Alaia is a breath of fresh air with impeccable service and delicious, creative food. The wait staff works together seamlessly, providing a welcoming and cordial experience. The ambience is great for a fancier night out, although prices can be a bit high. The crisp hen with vegetables is a favorite, along with the outstanding mussels and pasta dishes. The restaurant is adored by many for its attractive and peaceful setting, making it a go-to spot for special and yummy meals. The service is impeccable, ensuring that every detail is taken care of for a truly memorable dining experience.“

“Nonna Carola Ristorante and Bar is an Italian restaurant that offers delicious food and excellent service. The chicken parmigiana is a highlight of the menu, and the calamari appetizer is also highly recommended. The bar is lively, although this can lead to a higher noise level. Parking can be challenging on weekend nights. The manager is commended for their professionalism, friendliness, and accommodating nature. Overall, it is well worth a visit for a fantastic Italian dining experience.“

“Via Veroli, previously known as Calabria Mia, has been impressing diners with its delicious meals. The fried calamari stands out for its freshness and crispiness, while the chicken parm and pasta dishes are also popular choices. The pork chop scarp and branzino are must-tries, thanks to the chef's excellent cooking. The service, led by Sal, Walter, and Sergio, is commendable, contributing to an overall enjoyable dining experience. The clean and welcoming ambiance makes it a great place for various occasions.“

“Lena Trattoria offers an amazing dining experience with delicious Italian food that is rich in flavor and very filling. Though the scallops portion is small, the service is top notch, and the beautifully decorated place with great artwork adds to the ambiance. Consistently outstanding quality of food and service in the Bronx.“

“Briciola Harlem is a tiny Italian restaurant offering a delightful culinary experience with addicting, thin, and well-cooked pizzas, including gluten-free options. While it is pretty pricey, the authentic flavors make it worth it for amazing Italian food in Harlem. The supportive crust holds even with multiple meats, ensuring no sagging or dripping. This cozy spot provides a memorable dining experience for those willing to spend a bit more.“

“Tombolinos Ristorante is a welcoming restaurant with a comfortable atmosphere. The staff, including the owner, are friendly and great. The menu offers plenty of options, and the food is great, according to customers. Some dishes may take a few extra minutes to arrive, but the staff makes up for it with small gestures, such as offering rice balls. Parking can be limited, but street parking is available. The restaurant has a pleasant atmosphere and a good selection of music, making it a great place to have a relaxed dinner.“

“Pisticci is a fantastic Italian restaurant with a romantic flair, serving delicious food in large portions. The chef pays attention to detail, including high-quality bread and olive oil. The service is fast and attentive, with cozy ambiance. Must-try dishes include garlic bread with goat cheese, butternut squash soup, and rigatoni bolognese. The wine and tiramisu cake are also delicious. Be prepared for limited parking, better to take the subway or Uber. A great spot for a meal out.“

“P & M Classic Pizza and Restaurant is a humble and pleasant spot in west Harlem. The pizza is very good, and the staff members are kind and friendly. The meatball parm sub is a highlight, being plentiful and delicious, and the garlic knots with sauce are a special treat. This restaurant serves the best pizza in the community, with a crispy crust, amazing sauce, and a good amount of cheese. It's a great value, with quick and affordable options available.“

“Piccola Trattoria is a wonderful Italian restaurant with a spacious interior and attentive staff. The menu offers a variety of pasta dishes and other Italian meals, including perfectly cooked seafood options. Located near the Hudson River, it has a cozy pub-like atmosphere, especially on busy nights. Free parking is available after 6 PM.“

“Spadaro Roman Kitchen is a hidden gem serving up delicious Italian food. This small neighborhood restaurant impresses with its attention to detail, from the chef's careful preparation to the phenomenal service. The menu features traditional Italian dishes, each bite infused with love. Standout options include the pistachio eggplant, artichoke, and codfish with tom sauce, olives, and capers. The octopus and white tiramisu are also highly recommended. With a cozy ambiance and great music, Spadaro Roman Kitchen is a must-visit, where every bite is on point and the hospitality is exceptional.“

“Da Giorgio is a highly recommended Italian restaurant, known for its excellent and innovative food. The stuffed clams, eggplant burrata, and squid linguini are popular dishes. The cozy atmosphere is intimate and always filled with locals, making reservations essential. The service is attentive, and the pasta is widely praised as outstanding.“

“Wow, I gotta tell you, I had the most amazing experience at this place! I tried their upside down pizza and an Italian hero sandwich, and let me tell you, they were both absolutely fantastic. I couldn't believe how delicious everything was! I can't wait to go back there again, it was such a charming place.“

“Giulio's Restaurant offers an amazing dining experience with exceptional food and great service. The menu features a variety of dishes, including fettuccine with shrimp and a delicious prime ribeye steak. The restaurant caters well to both small parties and large groups, providing a wonderful atmosphere for any occasion.“

“Carlo's Pizza of Port Washington is a beloved local staple, serving classic and delicious regular slices and Italian staples. Their specialty pies, like the spinach artichoke, are highly praised. The friendly staff and timeless atmosphere make it a consistent favorite among locals. With fresh food and a welcoming environment, Carlo's is a must-visit for pizza lovers.“

“314 - pizza,pasta&cocktailbar is a restaurant located in Morningside Heights, known for its authentic Italian food and friendly Italian staff. The pizza and lasagna are highly recommended. It is a popular date spot and neighborhood favorite, offering a relaxed and chill atmosphere. The handmade pastas, including the bucatini, are highly praised. The cocktail menu features unique spins on classic favorites. Whether it's for a celebration or a casual meal, 314 is a destination restaurant.“

“Osteria Padre Pio offers an amazing dining experience with professional and attentive service. The authentic Italian cuisine is made with fresh and tasty ingredients, impressing even Italian-American diners. Standout dishes include the shrimp cocktail with spicy cocktail sauce and the exceptional Chicken Milanese with arugula, parmesan, and black olives. Don't miss the exquisite pistacchio mousse for dessert. This cozy restaurant's friendly staff makes you feel like family, making it a must-return destination.“

“La Lanterna Restaurant Wine & Beer Garden offers outstanding food, with highly recommended dishes such as chicken parm, spicy lobster & shrimp with pasta, and grilled branzino. The decor is perfect for photos, and the outdoor space is very cozy. While service can be improved, they were accommodating when a reservation needed to be pushed back. The drinks are satisfactory. Overall, it's a nice dining experience.“

“Frankie's Restaurant on Arthur Avenue is an excellent dining location, known for its warm and inviting atmosphere. The restaurant features a second dining room, where a fireman's retirement celebration was held, indicating the establishment's popularity for special occasions. The menu includes standout dishes such as fried calamari, buffalo wings, and cacio e Pepe, along with classic options like spaghetti and meatballs and chicken parm. The meatballs are particularly noteworthy for their tenderness, and the chicken parm offers a generous portion size. While the cacio e Pepe could benefit from a touch more sauce, the Calabrian red wine is a definite highlight. The service is superb, with attentive waitstaff. Overall, Frankie's Restaurant provides a delightful dining experience, surpassing the quality of nearby establishments like Enzo's.“

“Misto Restaurant and Bar offers a vibrant atmosphere and delightful cocktails, including the popular Lychee Martinis and Pistachios Martinis. The food is described as spectacular, and the staff, including the bartender and owner, provide excellent service and a welcoming vibe. This establishment is praised as a great spot for a romantic and fun night out.“

“DeCosta's is a top-notch Italian restaurant that offers delicious dishes. The calamari and cheese ravioli are must-tries, along with the fruit cake for dessert. The restaurant provides fresh and tasty meals, like the Clams Casino and Clams Oreganato, and pasta dishes such as capellini with crabmeat and shrimp in a creamy tomato sauce. The Seafood Pescatore with linguine is also a hit, with tender and fresh seafood like mussels, clams, calamari, and shrimp. To top off the meal, the creme brulee with blackberries and dragonfruit offers a perfect mix of creaminess and crunch. Whether it's a special occasion or a casual dining experience, DeCosta's in Yonkers is the ideal spot for authentic Italian cuisine that will leave customers satisfied with every bite.“

“Trattoria Vivolo is an exceptional Italian restaurant that serves authentic and fresh dishes, evoking the simplicity of Italy. The menu offers a wide range of options, including clams, salads, soup, shrimp & cannelloni, scamorza con carciofi, gnocchi, mixed grills, and veal martini, all of which are impeccably prepared. The staff is outstanding, providing excellent service, even for large parties. The restaurant is accommodating, allowing guests to order off the menu and even bring in a cake. The atmosphere is very cool, and the staff remain attentive and efficient, making it a highly recommended dining experience.“

“Mambo Italiano is a restaurant located in Irvington, known for its cozy atmosphere and delicious food made with fresh ingredients. The restaurant is female-owned and has received praise for its salmon, chicken with polenta, and burrata, which is described as the best ever tasted. The bolognese is also highly recommended. The owners, Dani and Ana, are noted for their friendliness and welcoming personalities. It is recommended to make reservations in advance as the restaurant can fill up quickly.“

“Dolce Vita offers an exceptional dining experience with amazing food at reasonable prices. The new ownership has brought a welcoming energy to the restaurant, where the friendly owner and skilled bartenders ensure a great time. Savor delicious dishes like wild mushroom ravioli, shrimp scampi, and scallops and shrimp pasta in a lively atmosphere. With great presentation and flavorful food, Dolce Vita is a wonderful addition to the Nyack restaurant scene, making it a must-visit spot.“

“Valentina's Ristorante is a hidden gem in Fleetwood, offering amazing Italian food like Chicken Francese and Veal Parm. The Chicken Martini is a must-try dish. The owner, Karen, and the staff are friendly and create a comfortable atmosphere. The food is always delicious and made to order. Prices are reasonable, and the service is excellent. It's a great place to enjoy a relaxing evening with friends or family. You won't be disappointed by the awesome food and welcoming staff at Valentina's.“