50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Tuckahoe

“Crestwood Pizza is known for its excellent pizza, service, and communication. Customers praise the fresh and tasty food, especially the pizza and garlic knots. Whether you're a lacrosse team or a local resident, the experience is seamless and worth the wait. The thin, crispy pizza and quality pasta keep customers coming back for more. If you're in the area, Crestwood Pizza is a must-try for a delicious meal.“

“Villaggio Pizzeria is a popular restaurant known for its pizza, with many customers praising it as the best in the area. The chicken, bacon ranch pizza is particularly enjoyed. However, some have noted that the plain slice has an overpowering amount of garlic. The restaurant has a variety of options on the menu, including delicious salads and pastas. The service is professional and friendly, with staff ensuring that the food they serve is delicious. The restaurant has a good reputation, with some customers having visited for around 10 years and highly recommending it.“

“Roma is an old-school Italian restaurant that has been around for nearly 100 years, offering a no-frills, family-friendly dining experience. The food is consistently great, with popular dishes like mussels marina, honey, vodka, lasagna, and penne vodka. The lasagna is particularly spectacular. The restaurant has a friendly and caring staff, with a warm and welcoming atmosphere. They offer vegetarian options, including pasta dishes and eggplant Parmesan, and are wheelchair accessible. Roma is a great spot for kids and large groups, with plenty of space to accommodate big families. With its delicious food, kind staff, and comfortable atmosphere, Roma is a reliable choice for a relaxing and enjoyable meal.“

“Angelina's is a fantastic place to get a quality meal. The new owners are updating the dining rooms, but the staff remains the same, ensuring excellent service. The food is still very good, and the combination of great food, friendly staff, and pleasant atmosphere make it a great spot for celebrations and everyday dining. The location is wonderful, with free parking nearby. The attention to detail and quality of food are top-notch, making it a popular choice for special occasions and regular meals. With its excellent service, atmosphere, and food, Angelina's is a great place to dine.“

“BURRATA offers fresh and delicious food in a friendly atmosphere. The pizzas like "Burrata" and "Tartufo" are a must-try, along with the "Budino al caramello" dessert. Customers feel welcomed by the polite staff, making it a cozy spot for pizza and pasta lovers. The J Sexton pizza and pappardelle are highly recommended dishes. Make weekend reservations due to its popularity.“

“Kingsbridge Social Club offers a top-notch dining experience with delicious food and friendly service. The wrecking ball pizza with cherry peppers is a must-try, with perfect mozzarella, amazing pepperoni, and fresh cherry peppers on flavorful bread. The chicken parm and spaghetti are also highly recommended. The cocktails, like the tequila with lime and basil simple syrup, are a hit. The bar has a good selection of beers, and outdoor seating is available in warmer weather. The staff, including Lilivette, are attentive and create a welcoming atmosphere. Whether for lunch or dinner, this hidden gem in NYC is worth a visit for a memorable meal.“

“Pizza Fenice is a highly-recommended pizzeria that serves exceptional pizza. The owner, John, is known for his craftsmanship and passion for his craft. The pizzas are cooked to perfection, with flavors that are out of this world. Reviewers have praised the sauce, saying it's the best they've ever tasted. The pizzas come in a variety of flavors, including Margherita, Spicy Vodka, and Pepperoni. The owner is not only skilled in his craft but also provides excellent hospitality, making customers feel welcome. With a focus on quality and customer service, Pizza Fenice is a must-visit destination for pizza lovers.“

“Beekman Ale House is a popular spot with a focus on delicious food and great beer selection. Their pizzas are a highlight, with options that are fresh and crunchy. The owners are passionate about their business, and the atmosphere is lively with 90's rock music. With a good selection of beers and friendly service, this restaurant is a great choice for a night out.“

“Ivana's Pizzeria is a cozy Italian eatery in Little Italy, offering authentic flavors and warm hospitality. Friendly service, great pizza, and pasta dishes are served in a charming atmosphere reminiscent of Italy. The owners are approachable and enthusiastic, while the food, including true slices of pizza, is made with quality ingredients.“

“Pizzeria La Rosa is a hidden gem in Westchester that serves amazing pies, salads, and broccolini. Their wood-fired thin crust pizzas are crispy and come in 14-inch personal pans. The restaurant offers a great selection of wines by the glass and has a cozy atmosphere with a big wooden bar, spacious booths, and a visible pizza kitchen. The service is laid-back and cool, making it a neighborhood favorite. The menu features a range of options, including the delicious Margherita pizza, bolognese pasta, and arancini, all made with fresh and flavorful ingredients. Whether dining in or ordering delivery, Pizzeria La Rosa is a must-try.“

“Hollywood North Pizza & Pasta is a classic New York-style pizzeria with huge, delicious slices. They also offer cookies, ice cream, and water ice. The kind ownership and staff provide a warm welcome, making you feel at home. Try their mouthwatering penne Alfredo, a culinary delight. With lunch specials starting at $10.95, it's an amazing deal. This charming shop offers a cozy atmosphere, perfect for unwinding. With its lovely staff and tasty food, it's a must-visit spot in Sleepy Hollow.“

“Pelham Pizza is a restaurant that offers high-quality food with generous portions at reasonable prices. Despite its plain exterior, it stands out with friendly service, even packing leftovers for customers. The fettuccine carbonara is a must-try, being a difficult dish to perfect, but Pelham Pizza has managed to execute it excellently. The eggplant and spinach pizzas are also highly recommended, staying fresh and delicious for up to a week. With affordable pricing and convenient on-street parking paid through the Passport app, Pelham Pizza is a great find for anyone looking for delicious Italian dishes.“

“Bob's Thin Crust Pizza is a must-visit spot for pizza lovers. As soon as you walk in, you're greeted with the aroma of freshly baked dough and savory toppings. The thin crust is perfectly crispy, providing the ideal base for their mouthwatering creations. The friendly staff ensures a pleasant dining experience, whether you're sitting inside or outside under the sun. Their pizzas are crafted with care and attention to detail, offering a range of options to satisfy every palate. With delicious and authentic "plain" slices, Bob's has earned its spot as one of the best pizza joints in town.“

“Casaletto Pizzeria offers the best pizza around, loved by both kids and adults. The service is fantastic, and the chicken Marsala entree is always a hit. Customers enjoy the yummy slices, especially the square ones. The owner is fair and hospitable, making it a solid choice for a delicious meal.“

“Louie & Ernie's Pizza is a cozy spot that feels like visiting a favorite uncle's house. The plain and crispy pizza is a standout, with vegetarian options available. The owners and service are warm and welcoming, with perfect slices and a great crust. The sausage topping is a must-try, with big, juicy chunks of pork sausage. This cash-only spot is worth the trip, with incredible crust, sauce, and cheese.“

“Duha Cafe & Pizza is a hidden gem serving delicious food and drinks. Their egg, cheese, and Turkish sausage on a croissant is a must-try, paired with a perfectly made coffee. The baked spaghetti is also a highlight, and the baklava is a sweet treat. The cafe boasts attentive and kind workers, a cozy ambiance, and a great overall experience.“

“Bubbles Posh Pizza offers superb food, a chilled and social atmosphere, and fast, courteous service. The restaurant serves delicious pizza, with generous portions at reasonable prices. The staff is extremely pleasant, making it a popular spot for those looking to unwind and enjoy good food.“

“Mario's Metro Pizza & Pasta is a neighborhood favorite with amazing food and great service. The owners, Mario and Paul, are friendly and down-to-earth. They offer delicious pizza slices like Sicilian, Meat, and Regular, as well as Chicken Francese. Don't miss out on their tasty desserts like Tiramisu and Creme Brule Cheese Cake. With quick service and a welcoming atmosphere, this place is a must-visit in New Ro. Cheers to many more delicious slices to come!“

“Mercato Roman Pizza is a charming restaurant with a cozy atmosphere and limited but innovative menu. The wood-burning oven adds warmth to the space, making it a lovely dining experience. The pizzas are made on thin, crispy sourdough crusts with unique toppings like truffle potato and shrimp scampi. The Veal and Ricotta Meatballs are light and fluffy, served in a savory tomato sauce. The Prosciutto di Parma pizza is a favorite, with aged meat, fresh mozzarella, and arugula. The truffle honey pizza is a must-try, with delicious toppings. The owner, Stephanie, is welcoming, and the service is impeccable. Whether you're looking for a casual lunch or a special dinner, Mercato Roman Pizza offers a delightful culinary experience that will leave you satisfied and planning your next visit.“

“Original Joe's Pizzeria is a popular spot in the Bronx, offering delicious food and great service. The restaurant has a clean and welcoming atmosphere with a variety of vegetarian options and kid-friendly amenities. Friendly staff provide excellent service, making it a must-visit spot.“

“Dado's Pizza and Taproom Harlem is a great neighborhood spot for a slice and a drink. They offer a fantastic selection of beers, ciders, and beverages. The team provides excellent service, going above and beyond to ensure customer satisfaction. Their pizzas, like the Classics Pepperoni, are made with quality ingredients and arrive quickly in perfect condition. Recommended for a quick meal or mix-and-match beverages to go.“

“Zero Otto Nove in the Bronx offers a memorable dining experience with its vibrant atmosphere and exceptional Italian cuisine. The Margherita pie with flavorful tomato sauce and fresh basil is a highlight, while the pasta fagioli soup is rich and hearty. The baked potato is fluffy and well-seasoned, and the La Cirlio pizza is a phenomenal choice with creamy butternut squash puree and fresh mozzarella. The restaurant's ambiance resembles a classic Italian trattoria, transporting diners to Italy with its charming decor and elegant waitstaff. The menu offers a variety of delicious options, from burrata and calamari to pasta and pollo dishes. With attentive service and generous portions, dining at Zero Otto Nove is a must-visit for those looking to enjoy fantastic Italian cuisine in the Bronx.“

“Fortini Pizza Romana offers a unique dining experience with its signature fortini slice, featuring burrata cheese, panchetta, rosemary, and truffle oil. The pizzeria's friendly staff and cozy atmosphere, including upstairs seating, make it a standout. The menu boasts thick, chewy crusts and flavorful toppings, setting it apart from traditional NY-style pizza.“

“Fumo Harlem is a top-rated restaurant that consistently delivers great customer service, ambiance, and food. The menu offers a range of options, including lunch specials that are economical and delicious. Standout dishes include the spicy calamari, penne with mushroom and truffle, lobster spaghetti, and the popular "Roni" pizza. The Fried Mozz and Kale Caesar salad are also recommended as appetizers. While some reviewers have experienced slow service, the staff is generally helpful and friendly. With its great energy, consistent food quality, and reasonably priced drinks, Fumo Harlem is a go-to spot for a satisfying meal and a good time.“

“Raceway is a family-friendly restaurant with a cozy environment. The service is excellent, and the atmosphere is nice and quiet. Customers enjoyed delicious and amazing food, such as spaghetti and meatballs, ice cream, pizza, chicken parm, and chicken franchise. The owner is very friendly, and the restaurant and restroom are clean. A great place for a meal with the family, and customers are likely to return for more.“

“Pizzarelli's Pizza & Pasta offers excellent pizzas, including personalized options and a delicious pepperoni mushroom pizza, all prepared fresh and quickly by their friendly staff. The restaurant also serves tasty chicken cutlets with vodka sauce, as well as renowned focaccia pizza and garlic knots. While the plain cheese pizza can be inconsistent, the above-average cannolis are a must-try secret menu item.“

“Patsy's Pizzeria of New Rochelle is a local favorite, known for its delicious food and friendly service. The menu offers a variety of options, from pizzas to chicken dishes like Chicken Martini and Chicken Bolognese. The restaurant has a cozy and relaxing atmosphere, making it a great spot for both casual visits and parties. The staff is attentive and welcoming, providing a personalized service to each customer. The portions are generous, and the ingredients are fresh. The bread is a highlight for many visitors. The restaurant offers a view of boats and pretty homes, adding to its charming ambiance. Overall, Patsy's Pizzeria of New Rochelle is a must-visit for anyone in the area.“

“Michelangelo's Pizza offers a delightful dining experience with delicious food and fantastic service. The pizza is perfectly cooked, with a flaky crust that customers enjoy. Customers can take advantage of 10 minutes of free parking, and the restaurant is wheelchair accessible. Reviewers praise the establishment's consistency and the friendly staff, making it a top-tier dining destination. Overall, Michelangelo's Pizza is an incredible establishment that leaves customers eager to return.“

“Turiello's Pizza House offers a great atmosphere with a perfect amount of seating and no wait time. The menu includes a variety of options, including gelato. Known for the best tasting and reasonably priced pizza in the area, their specialty slices like buffalo chicken and grandma margarita are a hit. The staff is friendly and laid back, creating a pleasant dining experience. Customers have described the pizza as life-changing, with rich flavors that make it hard to enjoy any other type of pizza afterward.“

“Salvatore's restaurant serves delicious coal oven-fired pizzas with thin, crispy crusts and perfectly melty cheese. The Greek salad is a highlight, and baked pasta dishes are reminiscent of homemade cooking. While chicken on pizza can be dry, the restaurant's old-school decor and decent service make it a great spot for pizza enthusiasts. Orders are typically ready in 20-30 minutes, making it a must-try on Long Island.“

“Fresco's Pizzeria is a must-visit destination for pizza lovers. Their pizza is "absolutely majestic" and worth traveling for. The restaurant has improved over the years, serving high-quality and delicious food. Their plain slices are a classic NYC-style pizza, with a perfect balance of cheese, sauce, and crust. The vodka slice is a standout, and a must-try when available. Fresco's has become synonymous with great NYC pizza, and is a top choice for those seeking an authentic pizza experience.“

“Broadway Pizzeria of White Plains serves delicious food with consistent quality and friendly staff. They offer a variety of individual slices, including pepperoni, sausage, chicken, and more, as well as entrees at fair prices. It's a great spot to grab a quick bite, with a cute interior and a 10/10 rating from satisfied customers.“

“Joe's Fleetwood Pizzeria is a family-run business in Mount Vernon, known for its delicious pizza. A pizza snob from Little Italy praises the pizzeria's dishes, particularly the pizza. The restaurant has a warm and friendly atmosphere, serving a variety of options including Sicilian pizza, minestrone soup, pastas, calzones, salads, and hero sandwiches. Vegetarian options are available, and the pizzeria accommodates dietary restrictions, such as gluten-free pizza. Parking and wheelchair accessibility are also convenient.“

“Dante's is a highly-recommended restaurant serving top-notch pizza, including the popular "Drunken Grandma Pie". The management is kind, generous, and helpful, providing great service. The menu is fairly priced and thoughtfully put together, offering quality ingredients and a variety of options. Whether you're looking for delivery, catering, or dining in, Dante's is a great choice, with efficient and attentive service from the staff.“

“Utica Pie Co. in White Plains offers a unique pizza experience. Their pies feature a Sicilian-style crust with the sauce and toppings placed below the cheese, cut into squares. The pizza has a distinctive flavor due to the placement of the toppings, resulting in a more identifiable taste. The restaurant offers a variety of toppings, and the cheese stands out in each slice. The establishment has a welcoming atmosphere, with a friendly owner who provides reheating instructions for leftovers. The menu includes options such as Caesar salad, wings, and local beers. Utica Pie Co. also offers gluten-free options, which are highly appreciated by customers with dietary restrictions. Overall, Utica Pie Co. provides a different pizza experience, with its unique style and topping arrangement, making it a memorable visit for any pizza lover.“

“Victor's Pizza & Restaurant in Tarrytown is a hidden gem with delicious, top-notch pizza. The large mushroom pizza with truffle oil is a must-try, with a great undercarriage. The chef, Chris, uses the freshest ingredients and creates amazing recipes. The owner is welcoming and accommodating, making the dining experience fantastic. Highly recommended for a slice or other tasty menu items.“

“Roman Inn offers amazing food and excellent service. The chicken sandwich and chicken wings are a must-try, especially the pepper lemon wings. The meatballs and ricotta with garlic naan are delicious starters. It is BYOB and also offers catering services. The Italian cold cut sub is highly recommended, as well as the truffle fries. The place is clean, and the staff is friendly. A perfect spot for a delicious meal, whether for brunch or any other occasion.“

“Marcellino's Restaurant & Lounge offers delicious food, with the jerk chicken being a standout dish. The service is attentive, with servers clearing plates promptly. Despite some delays at the bar, the overall experience is enjoyable. The atmosphere is pleasant, making it a great place to dine. With validated parking available to avoid extra charges, it's a convenient choice. Customers praise the friendly and intimate setting, recommending dishes like money bags and margarita pizza. The restaurant also hosts various activities, including salsa nights with DJs on weekends.“

“Valtori Pizza Kitchen is a great place to visit, offering tasty pizzas with a thin crust and plenty of toppings. They also serve a delicious gluten-free crust pizza, making it a great option for those with dietary restrictions. The lunch specials are a highlight, with options like wraps and eggplant slices. The atmosphere is welcoming, and prices are reasonable. The restaurant's pizzas and salads are highly praised, with many customers enjoying the fresh and hot pies. Other popular dishes include baked clams and meatballs.“

“Four Bros Pizza in Westchester is a top choice for delicious, fresh pizza with fantastic crust and mouth-watering combinations. Customers love the cookie pie and appreciate the clean dine-in experience. The crispy crust, perfect amount of cheese, and friendly staff make this spot a must-visit in New Rochelle. Great for events and parties, with responsive service for special requests.“

“Pizza Palace is a long-standing restaurant, known for its delicious pizza and welcoming atmosphere. Located on a busy street in Manhattan, it is a popular spot for shoppers and locals alike. The restaurant offers large slices of pizza, known for their great taste. In addition to pizza, there are vegetarian options available. Despite its small size, with only a few seats, Pizza Palace is highly regarded for its cleanliness and good service. Many consider it to be the best pizza in New York City. It is a great spot for a quick, satisfying meal on the go.“

“Famosa Pizza offers exceptional pizza slices, including the notable combination of cheddar cheese, bacon, caramelized onion, and minced meat. The welcoming staff provide outstanding service, making customers feel valued. With accessible prices and delicious, well-made crust, this restaurant is a must-visit in Little Italy, Bronx.“

“A & V Pizzeria is a restaurant that offers delicious and affordable Italian-American food. The menu includes options like a large pepperoni pie for $16 and a chicken pamasan sandwich. The pizzeria, which is connected to a sit-down dining room, has a comfortable and unpretentious atmosphere. The pizza here has received high praise, with a perfectly balanced sauce, cheese, and dough. The service is prompt, attentive, and friendly. Overall, A & V Pizzeria is a great choice for those looking for delicious and affordable Italian-American food.“

“Dom & Vinnie's Pizzeria serves large, authentic Bronx/NYC-style slices with a wide variety to choose from. The atmosphere is welcoming, with friendly staff and a clean, wheelchair-accessible space. Prices are excellent, and the service is good, with staff speaking Spanish.“

“Pugsley Pizza is a welcoming old school pizzeria that caters to diverse tastes. The restaurant offers gluten-free and vegan options, including a gluten-free pizza. The service is excellent, with staff willing to go the extra mile, such as playing happy birthday on a saxophone. The menu features a range of options, including the popular chicken milanese and penne slice. Prices are reasonable, with two slices of pizza and a drink available for around $11. The atmosphere is eclectic, with interesting art on the walls, making it a great spot to visit with family or friends.“

“Famous Famiglia offers the best pizza in White Plains, along with delicious Lasagna and other selections. This welcoming restaurant provides an exceptional customer service experience, with friendly and humorous staff. The reasonable price range makes it a top recommendation for anyone craving high-quality food in a pleasant atmosphere.“

“Pizza Gourmet Restaurant is a local Italian eatery known for its delicious and reasonably priced dishes, as well as friendly and efficient service. The restaurant offers a wide selection of Italian-style meals, and takeout and delivery options are available. Customers have praised the knowledgeable and attentive service of staff members like Osbaldo, making it a great spot for both dining in and taking out. The restaurant has ample parking and a comfortable atmosphere, making it a popular choice for families and groups.“

“Chazz Palminteri Italian Restaurant White Plains offers a consistently excellent dining experience. Friendly and attentive servers, such as Elson and Tommasso, provide top-notch service. The food is outstanding, with delicious dishes like eggplant parm, risotto balls, buccatini, chicken marsala, shrimp dish, lasagna, and Chicken Pizzaola.“

“Roma Pizza is a must-visit spot in the Bronx, offering the best pizza in the area. With a welcoming atmosphere and delicious food, customers keep coming back for more. The slices are generous, with excellent crust and just the right cheese to sauce ratio. The menu includes mouth-watering options like the chicken parm slice, chicken and broccoli slice, and chicken roll. The sauce is a standout feature, setting Roma Pizza apart from other pizzerias. For a taste of authentic, top-quality pizza that feels like home, Roma Pizza is the place to be.“

“Nick's is a popular spot for families and friends to gather. The atmosphere is relaxed and welcoming, making it a great place to celebrate special occasions. The staff are patient and friendly, going above and beyond to ensure customers have a great experience. The menu offers a variety of options, including vegetarian choices and kid-friendly favorites like garlic knots and finger foods. The pizza is a standout, with one reviewer giving it a perfect 10 out of 10. Overall, Nick's is a reliable and enjoyable destination for a night out.“