50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Pelham

“The first pie I had from John at Fenice was the Detroit Red...which Tony picked up for me last week when i was at work...i finished the whole pie by just after midnight...but I had to go for the regular NY Cheese pie fresh from the oven. We scored one of the two tables there and were able to decide which of the other slices to bring home...it was like a pizza candy store. We didn't finish our pie so brought home two slices, and I wanted to try John's sicilian, I couldn't leave there without a Detroit Red slice and Tony wanted the multi cheese white pizza...every pizza we tried was perfect! something about the dough. The sauce. The cheese. The dough for the Sicilian and the Detroit Red was light and perfectly crunchy on the bottom. Flavor out of this world. We drove from White Plains just to try Pizza Fenice. worth the trip.“

“Great NY Pizza. We have fresh pie, Excellent“

“The service is always excellent here. The food did not disappoint. It was my first time having their pizza and it was delicious, had a magherita personal pie with arugula and wild mushrooms and the sauce to cheese ratio was perfect, the sauce was very good and the mushrooms and arugula were fresh. I completed my dinner with a glass of Malbec which complimented my meal. I will definitely return to try more of Marcello's menu.“

“Not only is it great Greek pie, it's great pie, period. Good enough to compete with the apizza in New Haven, I kid you not.“

“One word DIABLO !!!🙏❤️ Frost Beer was ice cold !!!“

“5 Stars - Highly recommend.“

“Loved this place! So good, very authentic“

“Great service the staff is so nice ! Food was fantastic . This is our first time here !“

“Mario's Metro Pizza is hands down the best pizzaria in New Rochelle; and I have tried them all as a New Ro long time resident. I am a pizza aficionado and their pizza has only the top ingredient. Their cheese and sauce is amazing.
Also, the owner is incredibly welcoming and kind. This guy is 1st class.
I highly recommend you give this pizzaria a try.“

“Figlia is hands-down my favorite local spot. From the first sip of the Purple Rain cocktail to the last bite of the cacio e pepperoni pizza, I’m completely obsessed. The salads & pastas are always fresh, flavorful, and made with so much care. And the staff? They treat us like family every time we come in. It’s one of those rare places that just gets it right—every single time. Love you guys!“

“The young lady helping me today was super attentive, I didn't get her name, but it's 12-13-2025 at 11AM .
I wanted to tip her, it's Holiday season, but she kindly said they don't accept tips.
I feel that the owners should leave that up to us whether we want to recognize an employee by tipping and not dictate it whatsoever.
That is my only complaint.
Sincerely.
Monica.“

“12/10!!! Great place! Awesome family owned restaurant and the pizza was amazing!! From Buffalo Ny!! We’ll be back !“

“Perfect crust. Perfect pie. Sauce just right!“

“Nice hole-in-the-wall place in the neighborhood. When that pizza is fresh, those slices are great. Usually I go towards the end of the night. Nick is always a good chat when I go in and see what's available. This place also is on Too Good To Go, so that helps. Zeppoles and garlic knots are both solid. Not a lot of downsides to this spot. Stop in if you walk by!“

“Great pizza and staff!! The gelato was great!“

“Absolutely loved our experience here tonight! I am unsure of the hostesses name but she was a doll and clearly had everything running so smoothly. As walk-ins we were even able to pick where we wanted to sit. Juan was our waiter who was such a gem, so attentive but also did not rush us at all. We got the baked clams, veal Marsala and the gnocchi special which were excellent. The manager also came over to say hello which felt very personable. We can’t wait to come back!“

“Came to this place by chance and I didn't not regret it! The staff is very welcoming and friendly. He gave me a garlic bread to try and took the time to explained the ingredients. I'm touched by Halal King Pizza's hospitality and service. The foods are great and warm (super fresh), 100/10 would recommend this spot for anyone who's looking for a quick and yummy bite!“

“The pizza is first class! The crust is perfect! It snaps instead of biting into a pillow of heavy dough. the sauce is just right, not tart where you’ll have instant heartburn & not sweet where it tastes like some garbage out of a jar! All their food is equally delicious! The restaurant is spotless & has a rustic beautiful welcoming look. The staff & owners are respectful, friendly & attentive! I highly recommend this establishment!“

“Best pizza in NYC! And their fried calzones are a must 😊“

“The best pizza and friendliest staff!!!“

“This is the pizza I’ve been searching for my whole life.“

“Back at Tufino after 2 years of Covid and the Pizza it’s EXCELLENT as usual. I’m originally from Napoli, IT and Tufinos pizza is just like back home.“

“I placed an order with Frankie’s today, and they were a little backed up because of all the orders they had. The management team was very accommodating and apologetic when my food came out late. I truly appreciate their professionalism and hospitality. The food was amazing, and I’ll definitely be back. Thank you for the great service!“

“Very kind guy running the place, super clean. We were starving and decided to come here because of the great reviews, best decision. Food was so fresh, crust nice and soft but also crunchy perfect texture. Pasta has amazing flavor, and perfect portions. Great place to come and dine is as the guy there was so nice and welcoming. Great food and hospitality! Will be back whenever we’re here in New York!“

“This pizzeria has been here for a long time and that says something. I’ve been coming here for over 20 years and it’s still fire. I don’t live close by anymore but every time I come back I always find myself here first. 8.3“

“im ivette rodriguez i know sal and his amazing one of a kind pizza,there best 100% garantee you be back for more .there original ,fresh made with love,not only his pizza his calzone patties sicillian,ices.so many things but most of all there clean enviorment.and the best part its a family place.full of love friendly and welcoming.can be all night saying all i experianced etc ...knowed them for 40 yests Greek up eating there and left to pr then orlando and never had one pizza like pugleys pizza.so much that i tell everyone in florida that goes to the bronx must make that stop and prove me wrong .hope one day they move to florida or im going back to the bronx just for there pizza 100% garantee.“

“excellent food! our go to spot. Food is always consistent, fresh and delicious. #1 on UES“

“Place is decent and above average for NYC pizza but got the special (2 for $5 and a coke) but they should put a little more cheese on the slices. Wasn’t docked real great and had bare spots. Much rather go a block away around the corner and eat Retro Pizza.“

“Good Pizza Great service Good Beer“

“It’s great place with very delicious pasta and artesanal pizza! 🍝🍕“

“We used to frequent the Astoria location which was always so great. The new Manhattan location is no different. Somewhat smaller, but just very cozy and very nice looking. Amazing food as always. The flavors and taste are just the best. No matter what you order you will not go wrong. The service is top notch and Rocco and his staff are just the best at what they do. Just go, you won't regret it.“

“This is awesome place to eat at very respectful very good atmosphere to eat at friendly if you want ice cream also they sell ice cream if you want to play a game they have the gaming area that you can play also it's just a very nice atmosphere with family friendly very very nice“

“Dine-in section is classy with an “old” Italian charm. The food is fantastic! Classic Italian dishes like lasagna, wood fire pizzas and pastas.

Take-out section is cash only, your pizza is ready in 10 minutes. The pizza guys are super busy and working fast so just pay and pick up once your order is called. Have cash in hand. The pizza’s are delicious no doubt about that, classic NYC thin crust. Try the vodka pizza sauce with fresh mozzarella and prosciutto.“

“Great meal tonight, pizza was perfect…. Wings were tasty !!“

“***** The best Caesar salad.“

“We had a great experience here! The food was absolutely delicious and the service was top notch from start to finish. Our waiter recommended the jalapeño poppers and they did not disappoint, truly a must order. Highly recommend this place!“

“We visited Luca’s Pizza for the second time today, and once again everything was amazing. Both times we ordered a large pizza and pasta, and the pasta was perfectly al dente each visit.

This time we also tried a cannoli that was filled fresh to order, and it was phenomenal. The staff is incredibly professional while still making the experience feel warm and personal. You can tell they truly care about their food and their customers. We will definitely be back in the summer for the tiramisu!“

“Every time i come to this Frank's Pizza shop. It always amazed me of the quality and freshness of the food. The service is always polite and always with a good vibe. My favorite entree to get here at this fabulous Pizza shop is the spaghetti and meatballs. For me is the best one!!!“

“One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had! Never tried the tomato pie until here and fell in love with it.“

“This is a charming neighborhood pizzeria with friendly, welcoming staff and a wide selection of menu items. The space is cozy, offering only limited counter seating and no tables, so it’s ideal for takeout or delivery. A great go-to spot for a quick and satisfying meal.“

“Bahn Mi at the pizzeria I grew up with? Seems the owners sold out to a Vietnamese restaurant owner and they kept the pizza alive but serve up some amazing Bahn Mi. Sad and happy at the same time. Next time I will try a slice and some Pho.“

“Want the best pizza in all of New York City. Sorry to break it to you but it won’t be downtown. This place is a gem in Inwood and hopefully will be here for generations to come! Def must check it out if you’re ever In the city.“

“I love this pizza 🍕 place . It’s like little Italy in the city❤️😊“

“Gino’s vs Unberto’s is like the Torchy Taco vs Taco Deli debate in Austin. They are both high-quality products, but I am more old school NY style pizza, and Gino’s edges out the “newcomer” by is more traditional NY slice style and sauce.“

“What a place this is, just bumped into it walking down the street, the staff were just amazing and the pizza just blew me away (gonna be back for sure), the pasta was tops, they have got everything right, nothing fancy, no frills, but their food, bang on.“

“After a long trip around the UK, the first thing I was craving was a classic NYC slice, and Amore Pizzeria delivered exactly that. There's a reason they've been around for over 50 years!
The pizza is everything great New York pizza should be—thin, crispy (with that perfect crack in the crust that true NYC pizza lovers know and appreciate), perfectly foldable, and topped with quality mozz.

The pizza alone is worth the visit, but the service made the experience even better. The woman working there (who I suspect may be the owner) was incredibly welcoming and friendly. She took the time to chat with us and even helped move our suitcases inside to a safe place while we ate our pie.

Fantastic NYC pizza, and great people. I highly recommend Amore Pizzeria to anyone looking for an authentic New York slice.

*just like all the good NYV pizza restaurants- they are cash only*“

“awesome food,great portions and prices wonderful owners go there you wont regret it“

“Service terrible and tomato soup tasted like it was watered down plus cold.Waitress was visiting with colleagues more than giving us service. We were the only ones in the restaurant during lunchtime. When it came to receiving our bill she put the wrong price down she said there was no manager to talk to which she lied to us. Overall Service and Food at the St.Albert location I would definitely not recommend on the other hand McGrath on the southside excellent for service food everything etc.“

“the food is phenomenal and the decor transports you out of the Bronx“

“Everyone was friendly and casual. The waitress and owner took time to speak with us. The Margherita pizza and meatballs appetizer were good. The tomato sauce was excellent.“