“The food at Pizzeria La Rosa is simply the best. From the mozzarella to the rigatoni alla vodka to the pizza to the ITALIAN DOUGHNUTS (best in my opinion) - you will not be disappointed. They’re always trying new things and some truly wonderful specials. Matt and the entire team always make you feel at home. If you haven’t checked this place out, you’re truly missing out on the best.“
“Neighborhood Pizza Shop Reborn!Loved coming here growing up in New Ro, it has only gotten better with the new owners! Mario and his brother are super friendly down to earth people! Service is always quick and friendly and they always have something tasty coming out of the oven whenever I walk in! My favorites are the Sicilian Slice, Meat Slice, Regular Slice, Chicken Francese and their desserts are amazing (try the Tiramisu or the Creme Brule Cheese Cake! They are sooo good!)“
“Deanna’s is the best Pizza and I love their thin crispy crust. I travel from the Bronx whenever I feel like a pie. What’s even better than the pizza is the staff. Everyone who works there is friendly and always greets you when you arrive. I love Deanna’s!“
“This cute and cozy wine bar has been opened for quite a while and I just decided to stop by a few weeks ago. I paired shrimp pizza with a glass of sauvignon blanc and it did not disappoint. The staff are very friendly and you'll always run into some neighborhood locals. Definitely a New Rochelle staple and you should stop by if you can. It's great for a low key date night for a cool vibe.“
“M&M Deli Cafe was fantastic! The food at M&M Deli Cafe was absolutely delicious, with each dish bursting with flavor and made with fresh ingredients. The portion sizes were generous, ensuring that you left feeling satisfied. Great atmosphere and staff, right in the middle of downtown New Rochelle—this is a must-try if you have the opportunity!“
“I can’t express how pleased I am with my experience at Patsy’s. Susie was incredible to work with and helped set up a very successful rehearsal dinner in the private room. The food was phenomenal and that was the same response every person who came said. All of the servers went above and beyond and truly made the night amazing. Thank you so much Patsy’s and I can’t highly recommend this place enough!!“
“I've been going to this place for over 20 years when they were across from Iona college and now on Huguenot street and I can tell you the food, the quality, the service is always amazing!!! We order at least once a week, my favorites are the Cajun chicken pizza, penne Gorgonzola with grilled chicken and mushrooms, the house salad with that delicious balsamic dressing but you really can't go wrong with anything there. I love all the guys who work there especially Pete and Steven! They are the best not just because of the delicious true Calabrian style food but because they treat you like family!“
“A New York style slice! This pizza place may sound underwhelming on the outside, but don't let the simplicity foul you. Consistently great pizza with variety of toppings and styles, including the bacon cheesy fries. Service is fast too.“
“I had some business to take care of in New Rochelle and decided to try a new pizza spot. This place had a old school, non modern look- which I liked. They then a at least 8-10 different toppings for their slice options. The slices were on point and I stop here frequently now when I come through this town. ⭐️⭐️⭐️?????“
“Great food. Ordered shrimp fra diavolo. I hope I spelled it right. Amazing! Just the the right amount of spice. A healthy amount of shrimp. Although there were only a couple they staff served us, although with paper and plastic utensils...lol! The place is nothing's fancy but the food was great. The smallest most obscure places tend to have the greatest food. I came back the next day and got a couple slices of pizza. That was good as well. Check this spot out. A hidden treasure.“
“The best eggplant parm I’ve ever had. Ugh it’s so good I’m obsessed with it. If I was dieing and got to pick my last meal it would be Prime Times eggplant parm!!I haven’t tried anything else there because I need the eggplant Parm hahaThe people in there are so nice too!“
“This is the go to place if you want cavatelli with broccoli rabe and sausage done the way it's supposed to be. The pasta is freshly made. It's so perfectly chewy and the sausage adds a little heat and the broccoli rabe negates all the calories. Ha! It's so delicious it's worth every single one. Tbh this dish is my go to comfort food and it's never disappointed.“
“I remember when they first opened after it had been Walkway pizza when I was a kid. I have been going here for years and the unique way which they make there pan pizza is still outstanding. And they still have one of the best burgers in New Rochelle. Its simple and cooked on the grill and you can taste that open flame flavor. My son now loves it to definitely a staple in that area.“
“Oh what a feeling in my Irene Cara voice! LOL! My sister and I came here for lunch on a Saturday. My first time. My nephew and sister raved about this restaurant. And I was not disappointed. The ambiance was family oriented. I felt right at home. I had the spinach salad with the white balsamic vinaigrette and shrimp. Their dressing is home made and omg it was so good I bought a batch to bring home. The service was attentive and friendly. Can I just mention the bread appetizer is addicting. It's so damn good. I will absolutely be back“
“My new go-to for pizza in New Rochelle. Buffalo chicken slice is legit and the garlic knots are very good. I’ve had the calzone as well which has a nice crispy bake to the outside. Have had fries and calamari as well - nothing has missed the mark yet.“
“Ordered catering for an anniversary party and Maestro's did not disappoint. Chicken Parm with Penne Alla Vodka was insanely delicious. The Chicken Maestro was superb and got rave reviews from all attendees. Owner treated us like family and always a pleasure. I love this restaurant and will continue ordering and dining here.“
“Have not fallen in love with a pie in a long time. Genius combination of crispy but not sharp dough that still somehow feels fluffy at the same time, just enough cheese that fills you but doesn’t make you feel bloated. Also, doesn’t feel oddly acidic like your mouth is getting cut up by the slice (like some other places in town). Hand to God some of the best sauce I’ve had in years. Lovers of pizza are always gonna have preferences and while I feel like on another day I may have preferred a tiny bit less sauce or a more even distribution of chicken across the pie, both the sauce and chicken are so perfect that it doesn’t matter whatsoever.VERY nice staff too. Genuine guys behind the counter. Called after like three bites to give compliments. I have NEVER done that when ordering out and they deserved it. Definitely going back.Please ignore the couple of embarrassing reviews that complain about microscopic things. If you have a problem, I would be shocked if they didn’t try to instantly accommodate you. Don’t leave a bad review unless it’s something serious. These are peoples’ livelihoods we’re dealing with.“
“Great local Pizza joint. Nothing fancy though I do like the sauce as a step up. Sal is on top of it and is always trying new offerings can't go wrong for quick bight or an entree.Wheelchair accessibility: Tight quarters but on sidewalk level.“
“Excellent Deli and very good pizza. I have been going here since 2002 when I moved next door. Their omelets, beef and Turkey burgers are great. Their breaded chicken cutlets are perfect and their sandwiches are tops because they use Boarshead cold cuts! They are not open on Sunday, but that is the only problem . Service is polite and good and the establishment is always spotless! I highly recommend Joe's!“
“I don't leave reviews too often, but AJ's deserves it. Excellent burgers, excellent sides and they have, by far, the coldest beer in New Rochelle. The owner is super friendly and welcoming. 5/5 stars. Come here, you won't regret it.“