27 Best Pizza Restaurants in New Rochelle

“First time being in New York, and I found this little place close to my hotel. You will not be disappointed! Mario and his father took good care of me, and the pizza was absolutely amazing. Perfect crunch, perfect flavor, and a small pizza is HUGE! 11/10! Highly recommend this spot if you’re in New Rochelle.“

“Great meal tonight, pizza was perfect…. Wings were tasty !!“

“Great pizza and a comfortable dining experience!“

“This place is awesome! Consistently good pizza. I’ve tried several different pies and they’ve been all good. Garlic knots are so good, wings are amazing, and the calzones are perfect. What’s even better is the staff, they’re all super friendly and care a lot about their product and customers.“

“Love Deanna’s! Great pizza and great people. They always help out out PTA and Girl Scout Troop parties with delicious, on time, discounted pies! Love a business that gives back to the community!“

“Great NY pizza with lots or little add ons.“

“Such a cool place! I was visiting and was craving some pizza, found this place online. Walked in and felt like I walked into cheers. The staff were super friendly. I got a pepperoni pizza and boy was that pepperoni pepperoniing. Yummy. Wish I lived here because I’d for sure be ordering here weekly. The owner, Gavin (if I remember correctly) was super cool and went out of his way to make sure my order was what I wanted.“

“When there last year, the manicotti was great.“

“Stopped in on my lunch break. I usually order for delivery and never actually went into the pizza shop. The place is very clean, well managed, and perfect for a quick bite. The spinach pinwheel, garlic knots and grandma slice was so fresh and made with the best quality. Cestras is for sure my #1 go to place“

“I just ordered on Uber eats because the reviews here said the staff was great and when they didn’t have the drink I wanted they called and the gentleman was so friendly! Great representation of the business! I know this food will be great, so 5 stars in advance!“

“Great pizza as well as dishes. My favorite is the cajun chicken pie and their chicken francese is excellent. Great owners and staff.. Sadly the owner past away but his son is a chip off the old block and is super appreciative of his customers. Highly recommend.“

“Thank you. Guys for showing great hospitality two Maine boys who came down for work. Your staff was very friendly and hospitable,food was great. Thank you too the Lady and Gentleman who served us and recommended our meals. You made our trip back to Bangor, ME better. Thank you for the dessert.“

“The Pizza is very very good, I must say.
The tables were dirty and when I asked for them to be wiped down, a dirty rag was used to do so.
The workers are pleasant enough, EXCEPT this one older man, who seems impatient and speaks to customers a bit harsh (very unnecessary)
They do have outside tables to dine at, and that's a big plus.“

“Afreakinmazing !!! Sal I freaking love y'all !! First we felt like family right when we came in . Second he instantly starts serving us . 3rd but probably #1 the food was insanely delicious . We had a slice each and a stuff something or other chicken Parmesan .. Then dessert was so good it was like inside of a cannoli but a zapple so good . Highly recommend“

“Cute little place the pizza was great and the garlic knots were soooooo amazing and garlicky. Would 100% go back prices are also a lot better than the surrounding area!

Vegetarian options: Pizzas, Pastas, Calzones, salads, wedge sandwiches

Kid-friendliness: It's Pizza what kid doesn't love pizza :)“

“The best eggplant parm I’ve ever had. Ugh it’s so good I’m obsessed with it. If I was dieing and got to pick my last meal it would be Prime Times eggplant parm!!I haven’t tried anything else there because I need the eggplant Parm hahaThe people in there are so nice too!“

“Fantastic food and service, with a varied menu! And very friendly and personable staff! I highly reccomend this place!“

“Friendly and helpful during this craziness“

“New owners, been coming here since the 90s. Loved helping Joe and Maria as a child especially making pizza,chicken rolls and bringing them home ? hopefully they keep the cooks or menu somewhat similar since a lot of seniors would always go. Best of luck“

“This is probably my favorite pizza place around Iona. Staff is always so nice and welcoming to me and my family. And the food is always so good. They have one of my fave white slices and the buffalo wings are amazing. The sandwiches are really good too!“

“The best in new Rochelle I love this place“

“I utilize the driver seat pickup service at this location a few times a month, mainly because I usually have my young children in the car. We usually have good, timely service. Today, the person who brought our order practically threw it in my son's lap. Based on the positive history, I'm going to give him the benefit of the doubt and say he was having a tough day and perhaps was under the pressure of the 2minute clock that starts when you press " I'm here" for a pickup. Restaurant business is NOT easy and people are often under a lot of pressure. The interaction also reminded that I've never given it a review. Having said that, this location, is doing a good job and I expect the usual service next time I go.“

“I want to clarify something to individuals who think they are ordering from the pizzeria but ordering from a third party who link themselves to any restaurant. They charge 3 dollars extra on each item. Then for delivery where most places it is free. I made this make. Most places don’t know until you address it with the owner. Order Direct Aboid the Issues ofVold Food with MultipleDeliveries.I was in the area returning a book we were hungry. I asked for two slices from a fresh pie. The pizza was delicious the crust was crispy not burnt or hard. The man and women were super friendly. And the atmosphere was clean and delightful watch some soccer while we eat definitely would recommend

Vegetarian options: They have several vegetarian platters as well as salad pizza

Parking: There is parking all over the place in back of cvs , on the street as well as several other parking place. Down the block from new Rochelle library“

“I’m a creature of habit and usually only get one of two things depending on when I go, but every time they are delicious! Ben is so great and friendly and knows what my “usual” is! Breakfast is a bacon, fried egg, and cheese on a plain bagel, toasted. Lunch is a club panini!“

“M&M Deli Cafe was fantastic! The food at M&M Deli Cafe was absolutely delicious, with each dish bursting with flavor and made with fresh ingredients. The portion sizes were generous, ensuring that you left feeling satisfied. Great atmosphere and staff, right in the middle of downtown New Rochelle—this is a must-try if you have the opportunity!“

“This is my favorite restaurant ever I’m so sad I graduated Iona because this was my go to place with my friends. Half off sangria Tuesdays and wine Wednesdays are great deals. The workers are extremely friendly and welcoming and I never had a bad experience here“

“I frequent this location. Whoever manages this, please cc whomever it may regard, you have an employee named Megan (not sure if spelt correctly) she is phenomenal, remembered my name since my first visit, knows my order, and works very hard from what i see and clearly deserves a raise. I don't generally leave reviews for chains but in this case figured it was worth the while“