24 Best Pizza Restaurants in New Rochelle

“Mario’s Metro Pizza completely changed what I expected from a pizzeria. We came in for a full tasting and every single dish overdelivered. The chicken scarpariello was the standout, juicy chicken smothered in a sauce with real depth, sausage and thin cut potatoes mixed in, plated like something from a sit down Italian restaurant rather than handed over a counter. The vodka rigatoni with fresh burrata was another surprise, creamy, rich, and not something you expect to find at a pizza shop. The Philly cheesesteak pizza and hot honey pepperoni with vodka sauce were both excellent as well, and the hot honey and buffalo wings are made completely from scratch in house.

Beyond the food, the hospitality stood out. The owners, two brothers with over a decade of experience in kitchens across Westchester and New York City, took over a pizzeria that had been a neighborhood staple for decades and elevated it without losing that local feel. You can tell everything is made fresh and with real care.

If you are in New Rochelle and think you already know what a pizzeria can offer, this place will prove you wrong. Highly recommend.“

“awesome pizza, awesome crew“

“Great meal tonight, pizza was perfect…. Wings were tasty !!“

“Thank you. Guys for showing great hospitality two Maine boys who came down for work. Your staff was very friendly and hospitable,food was great. Thank you too the Lady and Gentleman who served us and recommended our meals. You made our trip back to Bangor, ME better. Thank you for the dessert.“

“Pizza was delicious! Pie size is great for just one person, and fries were great too! This is my first time trying this pizza shop and never knew this pizza joint even existed, now this will definitely be the spot to order some delicious pizza🍕😋😁“

“When there last year, the manicotti was great.“

“I never leave reveiws unless I'm genuinely 💯 percent satisfied! First I'm very picky and my pizza was executed the way I like it..Pizzas are usally hit and miss ! The pizza was mouthwatering delicious, quality ingredients and sauce they don't cut corners& the crust perfecto..The flavor was exceptional 👌 😋 I ordered a large I almost ate the whole thing lol,,I forgot I had to share😁..And there prices are excellent,,I will definitely order again this is real 🍕 pizza with great service..

Thanks Cestra's“

“Great NY pizza with lots or little add ons.“

“Love Deanna’s! Great pizza and great people. They always help out out PTA and Girl Scout Troop parties with delicious, on time, discounted pies! Love a business that gives back to the community!“

“I just ordered on Uber eats because the reviews here said the staff was great and when they didn’t have the drink I wanted they called and the gentleman was so friendly! Great representation of the business! I know this food will be great, so 5 stars in advance!“

“Afreakinmazing !!! Sal I freaking love y'all !! First we felt like family right when we came in . Second he instantly starts serving us . 3rd but probably #1 the food was insanely delicious . We had a slice each and a stuff something or other chicken Parmesan .. Then dessert was so good it was like inside of a cannoli but a zapple so good . Highly recommend“

“I have been coming to Prime Time since I was a child and it never disappoints. Even though I no longer live in the area, any chance I get when I’m back in town I always get a pie to bring home for the freezer. This is simply the best pizza in town. It’s always fresh and delicious.“

“I've ordered all kinds of weird pizza abominations from them and they've always done a good job and not judged me. 4 stars instead of 5 because one time my boyfriend ordered garlic on his pizza and they gave him SO much garlic on that pizza that it stank up our entire house and gave him garlic breath for 2 straight days. Just an inappropriate amount of garlic.“

“Friendly and helpful during this craziness“

“The best in new Rochelle I love this place“

“Excellent pizza. I didn’t plan to eat pizza with eggplant topping, but owner Nick asked me to try it, and now I’m hooked. I even took a large pie home. I also took a large regular pie home for my three grandsons, and they loved it. Just in case I bought an eggplant parmigiana sandwich home, and it was amazing. I’ll be back soon Nick!“

“Old reliable; my family has been eating/ordering from here since before they changed their location, so 10+ years. Yes there’s loyalty, but also damn if they don’t know how to make even a simple cheese pie taste good. And that’s what matters in my book, the pizza. Thanks you Alfredo’s.“

“Small extra cheese and Pepsi can $26 for 11pm amazing pizza (ask for slightly under baked) more then enough for fiancé and I plus a slice for a neighbor and leftovers for the morning. 💯 will definitely be making regular return trips 👏👏👏👏👏“

“Great breakfast stuff, sandwiches & of course 🍕!!!!“

“La comida 🍱 es deliciosa 😋 Súper recomendado para todos los latinos …“

“Saccone is amazing. I love the food. They definitely cook with love. I've tried a lot of the food, and everything is delicious 😋 thank you Saccone's for making my experience awesome. ❤️
I didn't get a chance to take any pictures, because I ate the food up. 😂😂 Yummy in my tummy goodness 😋🤤“

“The Gemelli team went above and beyond to cater our staff training. We ordered lunch for 8:

Half tray of cheese ravioli
Half tray of eggplant rigatoni
Half tray of arugula salad
Half tray of grilled veggies
1 tiramisu platter
2L Orange Crush
2L Brisk iced tea

Everything was delicious and very carefully packed. The delivery person kindly brought everything inside so it was easy to set up. The food quantities and temperature were perfect. Lunch was a hit!

We're a non-profit, and Gemelli honored our sales tax exemption right away. I highly recommend their team.“

“I just want to say how amazing the girls at this Starbucks are! They are always so sweet, friendly, and attentive. Every time I come in, they make me feel welcomed and taken care of.

The manager has such a warm and positive energy — you can truly feel the good vibes as soon as you walk in. It’s clear that she leads with kindness and that reflects in the whole team.

Thank you for always making my visits so pleasant! 💕“

“Is good customer service the food is fresh that's what you want excellent“