33 Best Italian Restaurants in Yonkers

“Zuppa Restaurant offers a dining experience that exceeds expectations. From the attentive staff and superior service to the mouthwatering dishes, such as the lamb chops and flourless lava cake, the restaurant provides a delightful and indulgent atmosphere. The free valet parking and accommodating team ensure a seamless visit, making guests feel like long-time friends.“

“Via Veroli, previously known as Calabria Mia, has been impressing diners with its delicious meals. The fried calamari stands out for its freshness and crispiness, while the chicken parm and pasta dishes are also popular choices. The pork chop scarp and branzino are must-tries, thanks to the chef's excellent cooking. The service, led by Sal, Walter, and Sergio, is commendable, contributing to an overall enjoyable dining experience. The clean and welcoming ambiance makes it a great place for various occasions.“

“Tombolinos Ristorante is a welcoming restaurant with a comfortable atmosphere. The staff, including the owner, are friendly and great. The menu offers plenty of options, and the food is great, according to customers. Some dishes may take a few extra minutes to arrive, but the staff makes up for it with small gestures, such as offering rice balls. Parking can be limited, but street parking is available. The restaurant has a pleasant atmosphere and a good selection of music, making it a great place to have a relaxed dinner.“

“DeCosta's is a top-notch Italian restaurant that offers delicious dishes. The calamari and cheese ravioli are must-tries, along with the fruit cake for dessert. The restaurant provides fresh and tasty meals, like the Clams Casino and Clams Oreganato, and pasta dishes such as capellini with crabmeat and shrimp in a creamy tomato sauce. The Seafood Pescatore with linguine is also a hit, with tender and fresh seafood like mussels, clams, calamari, and shrimp. To top off the meal, the creme brulee with blackberries and dragonfruit offers a perfect mix of creaminess and crunch. Whether it's a special occasion or a casual dining experience, DeCosta's in Yonkers is the ideal spot for authentic Italian cuisine that will leave customers satisfied with every bite.“

“La Lanterna Restaurant Wine & Beer Garden offers outstanding food, with highly recommended dishes such as chicken parm, spicy lobster & shrimp with pasta, and grilled branzino. The decor is perfect for photos, and the outdoor space is very cozy. While service can be improved, they were accommodating when a reservation needed to be pushed back. The drinks are satisfactory. Overall, it's a nice dining experience.“

“Reno's Trattoria is a beloved spot for authentic Italian cuisine. Known for its remarkable service and fresh, delicious food, Reno's is a favorite among locals and visitors alike. The restaurant is famous for its red sauce classics, with popular dishes like Carbonara that are expertly prepared and served in generous portions. With a warm and welcoming atmosphere, Reno's is a great choice for any occasion.“

“J B & Son Ltd. is an old-style Italian Macaroni deli in Yonkers, offering fresh pasta like Ravioli and Gnocchi with assorted imported sauces. A Yonkers classic, known for its homemade pastas, it's a hidden gem worth visiting. With a friendly staff and a cash-only policy, this family-owned store is a must-try. Be sure to try the Cheese Ravioli and Stuffed Rigatoni for an authentic Italian experience.“

“Carlo's is a restaurant known for its excellent food, including a house salad with unique dressing and generously sized portions that often result in leftovers. The service is friendly, and the atmosphere is cozy and relaxing. However, there have been issues with reservations, resulting in long wait times. The steak, in particular, has been highly praised for its size and quality. While some side dishes may not be necessary due to the large portion of the steak, it is still recommended to try their Italian dishes.“

“Capis Pizza is a go-to pizzeria serving perfect slices with thick, crispy outside and soft inside crust. The pizza is cooked to perfection with the right combination of cheese and sauce. The ambiance is warm and friendly, and the staff, including the owner, treat customers like family. The menu offers plenty of options at an affordable price. The customer service is exceptional, with the staff, particularly the young lady at the counter, providing a welcoming and smiling presence, making everyone feel valued.“

“Gianna's is a local restaurant that has been in the neighborhood for some time. The food is generally excellent, with highlights including the Chicken Scarpariello, which is described as one of the best ever had, and delicious desserts like the lava cake with ice cream. The servings are substantial and filling. Parking can be a bit of a challenge, as the lot is shared with other stores, but it tends to open up after 7 pm when the other businesses close. However, there have been some issues with order accuracy, where the wrong items were delivered despite the customer's efforts to clarify the order. Additionally, one reviewer had a poor experience with the baked clams, finding the dish to be "vile" and "rotten and freezer burnt." Overall, Gianna's offers a good dining experience, with tasty food and a suitable atmosphere, but the service and consistency could use some improvement.“

“Louie & Johnnie's Ristorante Primavera offers generous portions and delicious food. Their take-out options are convenient, with hot and fresh orders ready for pickup. The restaurant serves a variety of dishes, including eggplant parmesan, spaghetti, and Grandma-style pizza, all made with flavorful ingredients. The staff is friendly and helpful, and the atmosphere is clean and welcoming. While occasionally, an order may be affected by a minor mistake, such as serving a cold dish, the restaurant's commitment to quality and customer satisfaction is evident.“

“San Martino Ristorante is a classic Italian eatery serving top-quality food at reasonable prices. Start with their spot-on fried calamari and complimentary fried zucchini. Popular dishes include the tremendous eggplant rollatini and muscles marinara. Friendly wait staff, like Rachel and Theresa, provide excellent service, making for a great dining experience.“

“La Bella is a cozy restaurant with a warm atmosphere, thanks to its comfortable setup and superhelpful staff. The owner makes every guest feel at home. The pizza is a highlight, with a fantastic crust and dough made fresh on-site. The crust is crispy on the bottom, and the sauce is slightly tangy. While the cheese may be just okay, the price is a great value, with slices costing less than $3. However, consistency in cooking the pizza can be an issue, but with a little request, the pizza can be cooked to perfection.“

“Raceway is a family-friendly restaurant with a cozy environment. The service is excellent, and the atmosphere is nice and quiet. Customers enjoyed delicious and amazing food, such as spaghetti and meatballs, ice cream, pizza, chicken parm, and chicken franchise. The owner is very friendly, and the restaurant and restroom are clean. A great place for a meal with the family, and customers are likely to return for more.“

“Marcellino's Restaurant & Lounge offers delicious food, with the jerk chicken being a standout dish. The service is attentive, with servers clearing plates promptly. Despite some delays at the bar, the overall experience is enjoyable. The atmosphere is pleasant, making it a great place to dine. With validated parking available to avoid extra charges, it's a convenient choice. Customers praise the friendly and intimate setting, recommending dishes like money bags and margarita pizza. The restaurant also hosts various activities, including salsa nights with DJs on weekends.“

“Olive Garden Italian Restaurant offers a pleasant dining experience. The service is generally good, with friendly and attentive servers. The food is consistently served hot, with great breadsticks and salads. While some dishes, such as the shrimp and chicken carbonara, may not meet expectations, the overall quality of the cuisine is good. The atmosphere is family-oriented and wheelchair accessible on the first floor.“

“Dom & Vinnies Restaurant is a beloved neighborhood institution serving authentic Italian cuisine. The cozy atmosphere and homemade bread make it a standout. The menu features flavorful pizzas, including the popular Sicilian option, and family-style dishes. The restaurant is a family-owned business, dedicated to providing exceptional service and timely delivery.“

“Luigi's Pizzeria & Restaurant Inc. offers a delightful dining experience with its great flavors of specialty pizza. The pizza is well-balanced, featuring a crispy crust, quality cheese, and savory sauce. Customers highly recommend the white slice. The restaurant also serves other tasty dishes, such as eggplant parmesan hero, chickpea salad, and Penne Broccoli Rabe, all of which have received positive reviews. The owner, Raymond, is described as a warm and welcoming host, making customers feel at home. While the restaurant is a modest, nondescript neighborhood joint, the food, service, and friendly atmosphere make it a great find.“

“The prices are great, the staff is really friendly. The food is amazing! And I don't eat just any Caribbean food. You'll love this place!“

“Catania's Pizzeria, a 50-year-old institution, serves exceptional pizza and must-try calzones, packed with meat and cheese fillings. The menu features standout dishes like Spaghetti and meatballs. While service can be hit-or-miss, the Old School Bronx ambiance is nostalgic and charming. The pizzeria is clean, reliable, and safe, with a focus on traditional Italian flavors.“

“Bella Rosa Pizzeria is a wonderful restaurant, known for its delicious food and welcoming atmosphere. The staff, led by Vinny and crew, provide exceptional service, making guests feel at home. The menu offers a variety of options, including pizza, salad, and wine, all of which are prepared to perfection. Standout dishes include hot, saucy, and cheesy pizzas, as well as specialty items like pizza bread and Grandma's pizza with pepperoni and honey. With its top-notch food and friendly service, Bella Rosa Pizzeria is a highly recommended destination.“

“Silvio's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria serves some of the best Italian food, with standout garlic knots. Located on Broadway in Yonkers downtown, this restaurant offers fantastic food, refined service, and a beautiful, relaxing ambiance. The friendly wait staff, nice atmosphere, and free parking make it a great spot to visit. The restaurant is kid-friendly, and the owner, Silvio, is accommodating to special requests. With reserved parking in a closed lot and wheelchair accessibility, Silvio's is a must-visit for a delicious and enjoyable dining experience.“

“Dunwoodie Pizzeria is a gem with a reputation for serving exceptional pizzas. The crust is often crunchy, although sometimes overcooked, but the garlic knots are a standout, soft and freshly made. The service is also impressive, with friendly and helpful staff. The pizzeria offers a range of dishes, including a popular spicy pasta that is "out of this world" and a "symphony of flavors". With its attention to detail and commitment to quality, Dunwoodie Pizzeria is a must-visit spot for a memorable dining experience.“

“Pizza Beat is a restaurant that has been around for over 40 years, with a change in ownership over the years. A customer who hadn't visited in 35 years was pleasantly surprised by the excellent food during their recent visit. The restaurant employs Roberto, a friendly server. The minestrone soup is made with fresh ingredients and not from a can, and the chicken and eggplant parmigiana entree is delicious with generous portions. The cannoli has a crunchy shell filled with ricotta cream, giving the impression that the shells are filled to order. The large cheese pizza pie is another popular choice, served hot and delicious. The restaurant has a party room, a bar area, and plenty of free parking. It is a great value and highly recommended.“

“Giovanni's Pizza in Yonkers is a must-visit spot for Italian food lovers. The ziti with sausage and BBQ wings are top-notch. The chicken marsala and pasta with chicken bolognese are delicious. The penne a la vodka is always perfectly seasoned, and the veal is incredibly tender. The fresh pasta gives a taste of dining in Rome. The owners are friendly and welcoming, making every visit a pleasant experience. Located near Downtown Yonkers by the Saw Mill River, the restaurant has a great vibe. Whether you're a local or from out of town, Giovanni's will make you feel right at home.“

“Gigi's Pizzeria & Restaurant is a beloved local favorite, known for its delicious pizza and friendly staff. The pizza guys have been there for years, and the pizza is consistently great. The restaurant is kid-friendly, with the staff being great with children. The Pizza and dishes are described as delicious, with the salad slice, Chicken Parm slice, and Chicken Bacon Ranch slice being standout menu items. While the parking can be a bit tight, the overall dining experience at Gigi's is highly recommended by both regular and new customers.“

“Singa's Famous Pizza & Grill Restaurant is a clean and kid-friendly spot with vegan options available. The pizza is a hit with some customers, who find it yummy, while others have mixed opinions. The restaurant is well-maintained, with staff taking care to clean tables thoroughly. However, parking can be a challenge, with limited street parking options available.“

“Midland Pizzeria and Restaurant has been a dining option for several years, known for its pizza and garlic knots. However, there have been recent changes in quality, with customers noting the need to request extra cheese and inconsistent additional ingredient amounts. The restaurant's service during busy times, such as Yankees games, is commendable, with accommodating staff. However, there are concerns about card information being shared on speakerphone in the waiting area, which may raise security issues. Overall, the personal pepperoni pie and garlic knots have received positive feedback for their taste.“

“They are amazing!!!!! I was calling everywhere for a Valentine’s Day pizza and no one would do it. I called Montebellos pizzeria and they did it with no problem. Same day delivery and all! They were so sweet and accommodating. Very professional and patient with me. They went above and beyond to make my special gift happen. The way to his heart is with pizza! I have a valentine now!! Thanks to Montebellos pizzeria!!! Thank you again… you guys were amazing. Happy Valentine’s Day!!! Oh yeah and btw the pizza itself was delicious too!!! :)“

“Public Pizza Italian Restaurant & Bar offers a comfortable and clean dining experience. The atmosphere is very nice, and the food, including the calamari appetizer and margarita pie, has potential but could use more flavor. While the service could be improved, with issues like not providing water refills or checking in on customers, the restaurant does offer decent vegetarian options. Overall, it may be worth giving the establishment another chance.“

“Pizza Pizza in Yonkers is a local favorite known for its top contender pizza. The owner, a friend of the community, offers unique slice choices and will make any pizza no matter how absurd. The sauce has improved, and the staff is friendly, ensuring the best value for your money. With vegetarian options like broccoli poppers and vegetable pizza, along with wheelchair accessibility, it's a must-try spot for a late-night bite with free street parking available.“

“Sophia's Pizza & Pasta is a beloved establishment in the Woodlawn/McClean Avenue area, known for its delicious Italian cuisine. They offer a variety of dishes, all made fresh to order, with delicious options like pizza with a great crust and lasagna. The service is always cheerful and welcoming, and they are known for their quick delivery and friendly staff. Their tres leche cake is a popular dessert choice. Sophia's has been a community staple for years, and is praised for its phenomenal food and service. The pizza is so highly regarded that it is a regular feature at work parties, with all employees being fans of the pizza.“

“Casa Mia is a cozy and elegant restaurant that offers delectable dining experiences. The manager and servers are accommodating, catering to special requests and dietary needs. The food is praised for its exceptional quality, particularly the seafood pasta in tomato sauce and the fresh bruschetta. While the take-out orders may have had some inconsistencies, the in-restaurant dining experience is highly recommended for both small gatherings and simple dinners. Overall, Casa Mia provides a satisfying culinary journey for its guests.“