21 Best Italian Restaurants in Middletown

“Absolutely fantastic service and the food was amazing“

“They are friendly and accommodating, I called a little after six on Christmas eve and found out they closed at six, however they assured me it was ok and took my order and had it ready right away. They went above and beyond to make sure we were taken care of with hot delicious pizza and cookies! Thank you.“

“My husband and I went there today for lunch and omg sooo good we got pizza we got cake we got it alll lol all of it was delicious“

“Best pizza ever Frank is always smiling 😃“

“Always delicious! Taco Tuesday when they have 1$ tacos and special drink prices!“

“Ordered Maria’s Rice con Dondulos and Pegnil. Wow! Keep an eye on their Facebook page for this occasional special! It is primo Puerto Rican fare!“

“My first time here and it won’t be my last. I described a salad I was in the mood for and he the owners made exactly that. It was fresh and delicious. I recommend this restaurant and look forward to returning and trying different dishes.“

“Delicious food! Great service.“

“I had an amazing experience at this Olive Garden! The food was fresh, the service was quick, and the entire atmosphere felt warm and welcoming but what really made the visit exceptional was the manager, Peter. Peter is the kind of manager every restaurant needs. He was attentive, friendly, and genuinely cared about making sure guests were happy. You can tell he runs the place with pride because the staff was organized, the restaurant was spotless, and the overall vibe was fantastic. He checked on our table personally, made us feel valued, and handled everything with professionalism and kindness. Customer service like that is rare these days.“

“I had my wedding reception here on 11/22. The food was AMAZING, the loft looked gorgeous, the bar tenders and bus boys were so helpful and lovely. The bar tenders made sure my husband and I had plates of food so we remembered to eat. People kept complimenting the venue to me. Marie was amazing to deal with and I cannot think of a single thing that I would change or complain about.“

“best all around“

“muy buen servicio, la comida riquísima. la güerita es muy amable y lo mejor hacen delivery“

“A lot of reviews about Pizza. I would be remiss if I didn't mention this restaurant has the best baked pasta I have had and I ate everywhere in NYC for 20 years. Try the baked ziti. Also the bread is from another planet, nothing else like it anywhere.“

“We have been going here since we moved to Middletown in 2016. Hands down the best pizza place in Middletown. Donaldo and his team are awesome!“

“Caputo’s chicken cutlet gets a 6/10—mediocre when fresh, with a buffalo chicken taste that clashed with the veggies, but oddly better when cold. Their pizza’s solid, a go-to for me, but the rice and beans were bland yet still satisfying. Reliable spot, but not without its flaws.

I always get it delivered“

“Good job for driving and fast!!!And good pizza“

“We are in NY from CT and I cannot express how great our server was friendly and delivered our food fast and piping hot. Gratsi!“

“Best food, I hardly recommend this place!!!! Very friendly. LOVE IT 😍“

“absolutely lovely heart shapped pizza for Valentine's day 😍“

“Greatest Stromboli and pizza“

“Quality + Value + Customer Service. John’s has been my go-to pizza spot since I’ve moved to Middletown. Gourmet GIANT slice (think buffalo chicken, bbq chicken or white slice etc) for only $4.75. I’m always full after 1 slice. I’m from NYC so have eaten at more pizzerias than I can count. John’s gets 5 stars🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟for a no-frills local neighborhood pizza spot! (my photos don’t do it justice 😂)“