7 Best Bakeries near New Hyde Park

Philly Pretzel Factory Pretzel Store • $
2105 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park

Customers` Favorites

Bottle - Super Hot Mustard
Bottle - Yellow Mustard
Pretzel Dog Specialty
Large Rivet Tray
10 Pretzels
Rivet Shaker

“Everything is super fresh and hot off the press literally! Just give yourself a lot of time to wait“

4.6 Superb79 Reviews
Italian Latin Bakery Bakery • $$
1586 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park

Customers` Favorites

Small Fresh Strawberry Cheesecake
Canoli Strawberry Shortcake
Almond Pinoli Rasberry Tart
Assorted Italian Cookie
Fry Sicilian Cassatina
Strawberry Oreon Cake
Pistachio Cream Puff
1 lb Small Cannoli
Glazed Croissant
Frutta Martorana

“My favorite bakery! Their rainbow cookies and pignolis are the best I have ever had hands down! Going to try and see if I can get these babies delivered to me today 😍I’m obsessed!“

4.2 Good35 Reviews
Gourmet Bake Shop Bakery • $
775 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park

Customers` Favorites

Creme Brulee Eclair and Fruit Tart
Birthday Cake
Cheese Puff

“Their product is good but their service is very bad. The sales girl in the early morning can't deal customer. They are very unproffessional. I recomend don't face that 2 sales girl when they are paired.“

3.8 Good44 Reviews
Hot Breads Bakery • $$
1608 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Tikka Sandwich
Eggless Mango Cake
Specialty Cakes
Paneer Panini
Puff Pasties
Paneer Wrap
Pastries
Bada Pav
Vada

“Takeout-only establishment. We love their version of 'Bombay Sandwich', made here in panini press; as against traditional method of using sandwich toaster with deep pocket heating plates. While this approach facilitates use of bigger slices, we have to contend with chopped ingredients falling off.
Flavor is always well managed and grill marks enhanced by use of margarine (against use of butter).
One hopes they'll be little more attentive to store upkeep.
They have a fair assortment of puff pastries & sweet pastries, including off-beat frosting flavors, which we've never tried. Maybe someday.“

3.7 Good29 Reviews
Polito Bakery Bakery • $
3365 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park

Customers` Favorites

Custard Filled
Birthday Cake

“Such amazing pastry, breads and cakes. Great service and kind and welcoming staff.“

3.7 Good26 Reviews
L & MUSA Bakery Equipment Inc Bakery • $$
3333 New Hyde Park Rd, New Hyde Park

“Their product is good but their service is very bad. The sales girl in the early morning can't deal customer. They are very unproffessional. I recomend don't face that 2 sales girl when they are paired.“

5 Superb1 Reviews
Bagel Boss Lake Success Bagels • $
1564 Union Tpke, New Hyde Park

Customers` Favorites

Bagel with Cream Cheese
Bagel with Butter
Gourmet Coffee
Salad
Tuna

“Delicious and fresh bagels. Staff are very helpful. Pricey for a bagel shop but worth it!“

3.1 Average72 Reviews